arXiv++ Combinatorics

For some positive integer $m$, a real polynomial $P(x)=\sum\limits_{k=0}^ma_kx^k$ with $a_k\geqslant 0$ is called log-concave (resp. ultra log-concave) if $a_k^2\geqslant a_{k-1}a_{k+1}$ (resp. $a_k^2\geqslant \left(1+\frac{1}{k}\right)\left(1+\frac{1}{m-k}\right)\cdot$ $a_{k-1}a_{k+1}$) for all $1\leqslant k\leqslant m-1$. If $P(x)$ has only real roots, then it is called real-rooted. It is well-known that the conditions of log-concavity, ultra log-concavity and real-rootedness are ever-stronger. For a graph $G$, a dependent set is a set of vertices which is not independent, i.e., the set of vertices whose induced subgraph contains at least one edge. The dependence polynomial of $G$ is defined as $D(G, x):=\sum\limits_{k\geqslant 0}d_k(G)x^k$, where $d_k(G)$ is the number of dependent sets of size $k$ in $G$. Horrocks proved that $D(G, x)$ is log-concave for every graph $G$ [J. Combin. Theory, Ser. B, 84 (2002) 180--185]. In the present paper, we prove that, for a graph $G$, $D(G, x)$ is ultra log-concave if $G$ is $(K_2\cup 2K_1)$-free or contains an independent set of size $|V(G)|-2$, and give the characterization of graphs whose dependence polynomials are real-rooted. Finally, we focus more attention to the problems of log-concavity about independence systems and pose several conjectures closely related the famous Mason's Conjecture.

We characterize compatible families of real-rooted polynomials, allowing both positive and negative leading coefficients. Our characterization naturally generalizes the same-sign characterization used by Chudnovsky and Seymour in their famous 2007 paper proving the real-rootedness of independence polynomials of claw-free graphs, thus fully settling a question left open in their paper. Our methods are generally speaking elementary, utilizing mainly linear algebra and the established theory of interlacing polynomials, with a bit of invariant theory.

The concept of a fully interlacing matrix of formal power series with real coefficients is introduced. This concept extends and strengthens that of an interlacing sequence of real-rooted polynomials with nonnegative coefficients, in the special case of row and column matrices. The fully interlacing property is shown to be preserved under matrix products, flips across the reverse diagonal and Veronese sections of the power series involved. These results and their corollaries generalize, unify and simplify several results which have previously appeared in the literature. An application to the theory of uniform triangulations of simplicial complexes is included.

The local $h$-polynomial was introduced by Stanley as a fundamental enumerative invariant of a triangulation $Δ$ of a simplex. This polynomial is known to have nonnegative and symmetric coefficients and is conjectured to be $γ$-positive when $Δ$ is flag. This paper shows that the local $h$-polynomial has the stronger property of being real-rooted when $Δ$ is the barycentric subdivision of an arbitrary geometric triangulation $Γ$ of the simplex. An analogous result for edgewise subdivisions is proven. The proofs are based on a new combinatorial formula for the local $h$-polynomial of $Δ$, which is valid when $Δ$ is any uniform triangulation of $Γ$. A combinatorial interpretation of the local $h$-polynomial of the second barycentric subdivision of the simplex is deduced.

Given permutations $π\in S_n$ and $σ\in S_k$, let $N_σ(π)$ denote the number of occurrences of $σ$ in $π$. While pattern avoidance and the distribution of pattern occurrences in permutations have been extensively studied, their interactions with the group structure on $S_n$ are still poorly understood. Gaetz and Ryba showed that the expected value of $χ^{λ[n]}(π)N_σ(π)$ for $π\in S_n$ is given by a polynomial $a_σ^λ(n)$. More recently, Gaetz and Pierson derived explicit formulas for $a_{\mathrm{id}_k}^λ(n)$ when $\lvertλ\rvert \le 2$, which led them to conjecture that the polynomials $a_{\mathrm{id}_k}^λ(n)$ are real-rooted and nonnegative for $n \ge k$. We show that for all partitions $λ$, the polynomials $a_{\mathrm{id}_k}^λ(n)$ admit explicit closed forms in $n$ and $k$. These formulas allow us to exhibit counterexamples to Gaetz and Pierson's real-rootedness conjecture as well as to prove special cases of their nonnegativity conjecture. Lastly, we note that our results imply that the expected value of $f \cdot N_{\mathrm{id}_k}$ on $S_n$ admits a closed form whenever $f$ is a permutation statistic expressible as a polynomial in the functions $m_j \colon \bigsqcup_{n \ge 0} S_n \to \mathbb{Z}$ which count $j$-cycles in their inputs.

We introduce a family of polynomials, which arise in three distinct ways: in the large $N$ expansion of a matrix integral, as a weighted enumeration of factorisations of permutations, and via the topological recursion. More explicitly, we interpret the complex Grassmannian $\mathrm{Gr}(M,N)$ as the space of $N \times N$ idempotent Hermitian matrices of rank $M$ and develop a Weingarten calculus to integrate products of matrix elements over it. In the regime of large $N$ and fixed ratio $\frac{M}{N}$, such integrals have expansions whose coefficients count factorisations of permutations into monotone sequences of transpositions, with each sequence weighted by a monomial in $t = 1 - \frac{N}{M}$. This gives rise to the desired polynomials, which specialise to the monotone Hurwitz numbers when $t = 1$. These so-called deformed monotone Hurwitz numbers satisfy a cut-and-join recursion, a one-point recursion, and the topological recursion. Furthermore, we conjecture on the basis of overwhelming empirical evidence that the deformed monotone Hurwitz numbers are real-rooted polynomials whose roots satisfy remarkable interlacing phenomena. An outcome of our work is the viewpoint that the topological recursion can be used to "topologise" sequences of polynomials, and we claim that the resulting families of polynomials may possess interesting properties. As a further case study, we consider a weighted enumeration of dessins d'enfant and conjecture that the resulting polynomials are also real-rooted and satisfy analogous interlacing properties.

The coefficients of the chain polynomial of a finite poset enumerate chains in the poset by their number of elements. It has been a challenging open problem to determine which posets have real-rooted chain polynomials. Two new classes of posets, namely those of all rank-selected subposets of Cohen-Macaulay simplicial posets and all noncrossing partition lattices associated to finite Coxeter groups, are shown to have this property. The first result generalizes one of Brenti and Welker. As a special case, the descent enumerator of permutations of the set $\{1, 2,\dots,n\}$ which have ascents at specified positions is shown to be real-rooted, hence log-concave and unimodal, and a good estimate for the location of the peak is deduced.

Given a (finite) simplicial complex, we define its $i$-th Laplacian polytope as the convex hull of the columns of its $i$-th Laplacian matrix. This extends Laplacian simplices of finite simple graphs, as introduced by Braun and Meyer. After studying basic properties of these polytopes, we focus on the $d$-th Laplacian polytope of the boundary of a $(d+1)$-simplex $\partial(σ_{d+1})$. If $d$ is odd, then as for graphs, the $d$-th Laplacian polytope turns out to be a $(d+1)$-simplex in this case. If $d$ is even, we show that the $d$-th Laplacian polytope of $\partial(σ_{d+1})$ is combinatorially equivalent to a $d$-dimensional cyclic polytope on $d+2$ vertices. Moreover, we provide an explicit regular unimodular triangulation for the $d$-th Laplacian polytope of $\partial(σ_{d+1})$. This enables us to to compute the normalized volume and to show that the $h^\ast$-polynomial is real-rooted and unimodal, if $d$ is odd and even, respectively.

We study the Hilbert series of four objects arising in the Chow-theoretic and Kazhdan-Lusztig framework of matroids. These are, respectively, the Hilbert series of the Chow ring, the augmented Chow ring, the intersection cohomology module, and its stalk at the empty flat. We develop a parallelism between the Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomial of a matroid and the Hilbert series of its Chow ring. This extends to a parallelism between the $Z$-polynomial of a matroid and the Hilbert series of its augmented Chow ring. This suggests to bring ideas from one framework to the other. Our two main motivations are the real-rootedness conjecture for all of these polynomials, and the problem of computing them. We provide several intrinsic definitions of these invariants; also, by leveraging that they are valuations under matroid polytope subdivisions, we deduce a fast way for computing them for a large class of matroids. Uniform matroids are a case of combinatorial interest; we link the resulting polynomials with certain real-rooted families such as the (binomial) Eulerian polynomials, and we settle a conjecture of Hameister, Rao, and Simpson. Furthermore, we prove the real-rootedness of the Hilbert series of the augmented Chow rings of uniform matroids via a result of Haglund and Zhang; and in addition, we prove a version of a conjecture of Gedeon in the Chow setting: uniform matroids maximize coefficient-wisely these polynomials for matroids with fixed rank and size. By relying on the nonnegativity of the Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials and the semi-small decompositions of Braden, Huh, Matherne, Proudfoot, and Wang, we strengthen the unimodality of the Hilbert series of Chow rings, augmented Chow rings, and intersection cohomologies to $γ$-positivity, a property for palindromic polynomials that lies between unimodality and real-rootedness; this settles a conjecture of Ferroni, Nasr, and Vecchi.

The coefficients of the chain polynomial of a finite poset enumerate chains in the poset by their number of elements. The chain polynomials of the partition lattices and their standard type $B$ analogues are shown to have only real roots. The real-rootedness of the chain polynomial is conjectured for all geometric lattices and is shown to be preserved by the pyramid and the prism operations on Cohen--Macaulay posets. As a result, new families of convex polytopes whose face lattices have real-rooted chain polynomials are presented. An application to the face enumeration of the second barycentric subdivision of the boundary complex of the simplex is also included.

Let $N_σ(π)$ denote the number of occurrences of a permutation pattern $σ\in S_k$ in a permutation $π\in S_n$. Gaetz and Ryba (2021) showed using partition algebras that the $d$-th moment $M_{σ,d,n}(π)$ of $N_σ$ on the conjugacy class of $π$ is given by a polynomial in $n,m_1,\dots,m_{dk}$, where $m_i$ denotes the number of $i$-cycles of $π$. They also showed that the coefficient $\langle χ^{λ[n]}, M_{σ,d,n}\rangle$ agrees with a polynomial $a_{σ,d}^λ(n)$ in $n$. This work is motivated by the conjecture that when $σ=\text{id}_k$ is the identity permutation, all of these coefficients are nonnegative. We directly compute closed forms for the polynomials $a_{\text{id}_k}^λ(n)$ in the cases $λ=(1),(1,1),$ and $(2)$, and use this to verify the positivity conjecture for those cases by showing that the polynomials are real-rooted with all roots less than $k$. We also study the case $a_σ^{(1)}(n)$, for which we give a formula for the polynomials and their leading coefficients.

Over a decade ago De Loera, Haws and Köppe conjectured that Ehrhart polynomials of matroid polytopes have only positive coefficients and that the coefficients of the corresponding $h^*$-polynomials form a unimodal sequence. The first of these intensively studied conjectures has recently been disproved by the first author who gave counterexamples in all ranks greater or equal to three. In this article we complete the picture by showing that Ehrhart polynomials of matroids of lower rank have indeed only positive coefficients. Moreover, we show that they are coefficient-wise bounded by the Ehrhart polynomials of minimal and uniform matroids. We furthermore address the second conjecture by proving that $h^*$-polynomials of matroid polytopes of sparse paving matroids of rank two are real-rooted and therefore have log-concave and unimodal coefficients. In particular, this shows that the $h^*$-polynomial of the second hypersimplex is real-rooted thereby strengthening a result of De Loera, Haws and Köppe.

Polynomials which afford nonnegative, real-rooted symmetric decompositions have been investigated recently in algebraic, enumerative and geometric combinatorics. Brändén and Solus have given sufficient conditions under which the image of a polynomial under a certain operator associated to barycentric subdivision has such a decomposition. This paper gives a new proof of their result which generalizes to subdivision operators in the setting of uniform triangulations of simplicial complexes, introduced by the first named author. Sufficient conditions under which these decompositions are also interlacing are described. Applications yield new classes of polynomials in geometric combinatorics which afford nonnegative, real-rooted symmetric decompositions. Some interesting questions in $f$-vector theory arise from this work.

We introduce tools from discrete convexity theory and polyhedral geometry into the theory of West's stack-sorting map $s$. Associated to each permutation $π$ is a particular set $\mathcal V(π)$ of integer compositions that appears in a formula for the fertility of $π$, which is defined to be $|s^{-1}(π)|$. These compositions also feature prominently in more general formulas involving families of colored binary plane trees called troupes and in a formula that converts from free to classical cumulants in noncommutative probability theory. We show that $\mathcal V(π)$ is a transversal discrete polymatroid when it is nonempty. We define the fertilitope of $π$ to be the convex hull of $\mathcal V(π)$, and we prove a surprisingly simple characterization of fertilitopes as nestohedra arising from full binary plane trees. Using known facts about nestohedra, we provide a procedure for describing the structure of the fertilitope of $π$ directly from $π$ using Bousquet-Mélou's notion of the canonical tree of $π$. As a byproduct, we obtain a new combinatorial cumulant conversion formula in terms of generalizations of canonical trees that we call quasicanonical trees. We also apply our results on fertilitopes to study combinatorial properties of the stack-sorting map. In particular, we show that the set of fertility numbers has density $1$, and we determine all infertility numbers of size at most $126$. Finally, we reformulate the conjecture that $\sum_{σ\in s^{-1}(π)}x^{\text{des}(σ)+1}$ is always real-rooted in terms of nestohedra, and we propose natural ways in which this new version of the conjecture could be extended.

It is well known that the coefficients of the matching polynomial are unimodal. Unimodality of the coefficients (or their absolute values) of other graph polynomials have been studied as well. One way to prove unimodality is to prove real-rootedness.` Recently I. Beaton and J. Brown (2020) proved the for almost all graphs the coefficients of the domination polynomial form a unimodal sequence, and C. Barton, J. Brown and D. Pike (2020) proved that the forest polynomial (aka acyclic polynomial) is real-rooted iff $G$ is a forest. Let $\mathcal{A}$ be a graph property, and let $a_i(G)$ be the number of induced subgraphs of order $i$ of a graph $G$ which are in $\mathcal{A}$. Inspired by their results we prove: {\bf Theorem:} If $\mathcal{A}$ is the complement of a hereditary property, then for almost all graphs in $G(n,p)$ the sequence $a_i(G)$ is unimodal. {\bf Theorem:} If $\mathcal{A}$ is a hereditary property which contains a graph which is not a clique or the complement of a clique, then the graph polynomial $P_{\mathcal{A}}(G;x) = \sum_i a_i(G) x^i$ is real-rooted iff $G \in \mathcal{A}$.

In this paper, we prove that if $f(x)=\sum_{k=0}^n{n\choose k}a_kx^k$ is a polynomial with real zeros only, then the sequence $\{a_k\}_{k=0}^n$ satisfies the following inequalities $a_{k+1}^2(1-\sqrt{1-c_k})^2/a_k^2 \leq(a_{k+1}^2-a_ka_{k+2})/(a_k^2-a_{k-1}a_{k+1}) \leq a_{k+1}^2(1+\sqrt{1-c_k})^2/a_k^2$, where $c_k=a_ka_{k+2}/a_{k+1}^2$. This inequality holds for the coefficients of the Riemann $ξ$-function, the ultraspherical, Laguerre and Hermite polynomials, and the partition function. Moreover, as a corollary, for the partition function $p(n)$, we prove that $p(n)^2-p(n-1)p(n+1)$ is increasing for $n\geq 55$. We also find that for a positive and log-concave sequence $\{a_k\}_{k\geq 0}$, the inequality $a_{k+2}/a_k\leq (a_{k+1}^2-a_ka_{k+2})/(a_k^2-a_{k-1}a_{k+1}) \leq a_{k+1}/a_{k-1}$ is the sufficient condition for both the $2$-log-concavity and the higher order Tur{á}n inequalities of $\{a_k\}_{k\geq 0}$. It is easy to verify that if $a_k^2\geq ra_{k+1}a_{k-1}$, where $r\geq 2$, then the sequence $\{a_k\}_{k\geq 0}$ satisfies this inequality.

Symmetric edge polytopes $\mathcal{A}_G$ of type A are lattice polytopes arising from the root system $A_n$ and finite simple graphs $G$. There is a connection between $\mathcal{A}_G$ and the Kuramoto synchronization model in physics. In particular, the normalized volume of $\mathcal {A}_G$ plays a central role. In the present paper, we focus on a particular class of graphs. In fact, for any cactus graph $G$, we give a formula for the $h^*$-polynomial of $\mathcal{A}_{\widehat{G}}$ by using matching generating polynomials, where $\widehat{G}$ is the suspension of $G$. This gives also a formula for the normalized volume of $\mathcal{A}_{\widehat{G}}$. Moreover, via the chemical graph theory, we show that for any cactus graph $G$, the $h^*$-polynomial of $\mathcal{A}_{\widehat{G}}$ is real-rooted. Finally, we extend the discussion to symmetric edge polytopes of type $B$, which are lattice polytopes arising from the root system $B_n$ and finite simple graphs.

The harmonic polytope and the bipermutahedron are two related polytopes which arose in Ardila, Denham, and Huh's work on the Lagrangian geometry of matroids. We study the bipermutahedron. We show that its faces are in bijection with the vertex-labeled and edge-labeled multigraphs with no isolated vertices; the generating function for its f-vector is a simple evaluation of the three variable Rogers--Ramanujan function. We show that the h-polynomial of the bipermutahedral fan is the biEulerian polynomial, which counts bipermutations according to their number of descents. We construct a unimodular triangulation of the product of n triangles that is combinatorially equivalent to (the triple cone over) the nth bipermutahedral fan. Ehrhart theory then gives us a formula for the biEulerian polynomial, which we use to show that this polynomial is real-rooted and that the h-vector of the bipermutahedral fan is log-concave and unimodal. We describe all the deformations of the bipermutahedron; that is, the ample cone of the bipermutahedral toric variety. We prove that among all polytopes in this family, the bipermutahedron has the largest possible symmetry group. Finally, we show that the Minkowski quotient of the bipermutahedron and the harmonic polytope equals 2.

The antiprism triangulation provides a natural way to subdivide a simplicial complex $Δ$, similar to barycentric subdivision, which appeared independently in combinatorial algebraic topology and computer science. It can be defined as the simplicial complex of chains of multi-pointed faces of $Δ$, from a combinatorial point of view, and by successively applying the antiprism construction, or balanced stellar subdivisions, on the faces of $Δ$, from a geometric point of view. This paper studies enumerative invariants associated to this triangulation, such as the transformation of the $h$-vector of $Δ$ under antiprism triangulation, and algebraic properties of its Stanley--Reisner ring. Among other results, it is shown that the $h$-polynomial of the antiprism triangulation of a simplex is real-rooted and that the antiprism triangulation of $Δ$ has the almost strong Lefschetz property over ${\mathbb R}$ for every shellable complex $Δ$. Several related open problems are discussed.

Given an Eulerian digraph, we consider the genus distribution of its face-oriented embeddings. We prove that such distribution is log-concave for two families of Eulerian digraphs, thus giving a positive answer for these families to a question asked in Bonnington, Conder, Morton and McKenna (2002). Our proof uses real-rooted polynomials and the representation theory of the symmetric group $\mathbb{S}_n$. The result is also extended to some factorizations of the identity in $\mathbb{S}_n$ that are rotation systems of some families of one-face constellations.