arXiv++ Combinatorics

We solve two long standing open problems, one from probability theory formulated by Malyshev in 1970 and another one from a crossroad of geometry and dynamics, of Darboux from 1879. The Malyshev problem is of finding effective, explicit necessary and sufficient conditions in the closed form to characterize all random walks in the quarter plane with the finite group of random walk of order $2n$, for all $n\ge 2$, where the underlining biquadratic is an elliptic curve. Until now, the results were known only for $n=2, 3, 4$, obtained using ad-hoc methods developed separately for each of the three cases. We provide a method that solves the problem for all $n$ and in a unified way. Explicit examples of random walks with the groups of orders higher than 10 are presented here for the first time, including orders 12, 14, 16. The same method applies to any higher order. We consider cases with singular biquadratics in a systematic manner. We establish a new two-way relationship between diagonal random walks and $4$-bar links. We describe all $n$-periodic Darboux transformations for $4$-bar links for all $n\ge 2$, thus completely solving the Darboux problem: after $n$ iterations, a polygonal configuration maps to a congruent one of the same orientation, that he solved for $n=2$, which was recently extended to $n=3$. We also study $k$-semi-periodicity as a natural type of periodicity of the Darboux transformations, where after $k$ iterations of the Darboux transformation, a polygonal configuration maps to a congruent one, but of opposite orientation. By introducing a new object, the secondary $(2,2)$ correspondence, and the related secondary cubic of the centrally-symmetric biquadratics, we provide necessary and sufficient conditions for $k$-semi-periodicity for $4$-bar links for all $k\ge 2$ in an explicit closed form, while the case $k=2$ was solved recently.

We use sign-reversing involutions to solve two computational problems that arise naturally in the geometry of moduli spaces of curves. In particular, we give an explicit combinatorial formula for arbitrary $ψ$ class intersection products on the genus zero multicolored spaces $\overline{M}_{0,[r_1,\ldots,r_m]}$ using a novel sign reversing involution on decorated diagrams. As an application, we give a necessary and sufficient condition for when these intersection products are nonzero in terms of matchings on graphs. We also calculate the analog of the tropical Euler characteristic for the graphical moduli spaces $\overline{M}_{0,Γ}$ for graphs with two dominant vertices $P, Q$, by constructing two new sign-reversing involutions to simplify the sum. We show that (up to sign) it is the number of acyclic orientations of $Γ\smallsetminus \{P, Q\}$.

In 2021, motivated by graph limit theory Lovász extended most of the theory of flows to a measure theoretic setting. Using this framework, the first author constructed $d$-regular treeings that are measurably bipartite, and have no nonzero measurable circulations, that is, flows without sources or sinks. In particular, these treeings do not admit a measurable perfect matching. In this paper, we develop tools to build $d$-regular treeings where the space of circulations is exactly $k$-dimensional for any positive integer $k$. As applications, we construct 1) a treeing with a single balanced orientation, but no Schreier decoration; 2) a treeing with a single Schreier decoration; 3) and a treeing with a proper edge $d$-coloring, but no further perfect matchings. The first answers a question raised by Lovász, as this particular balanced orientation does not decompose as a linear combination of finite cycles and infinite paths.

The class of word-representable graphs, introduced in connection with the study of the Perkins semigroup by Kitaev and Seif, has attracted significant attention in combinatorics and theoretical computer science due to its deep connections with graph orientations and combinatorics on words. A graph is word-representable if and only if it admits a semi-transitive orientation, which is an acyclic orientation such that for any directed path $v_0 \rightarrow v_1 \rightarrow \cdots \rightarrow v_m$ with $m \ge 2$, either there is no arc between $v_0$ and $v_m$, or, for all $1 \le i < j \le m$, there exists an arc from $v_i$ to $v_j$. Split graphs, whose vertex set can be partitioned into a clique and an independent set, constitute a natural yet nontrivial subclass for studying word-representability. However, not all split graphs are semi-transitive, and the characterization of minimal forbidden induced subgraphs for semi-transitive split graphs remains an open problem. In this paper, we introduce a new matrix property called the $I$-circular property, which is closely related to the well-known $D$-circular property introduced by Safe. The $I$-circular property requires that both the rows of a matrix and the pairwise intersections of rows form circular intervals under some linear ordering of the columns. Using this property, we establish a direct connection between the structure of semi-transitive split graphs and the matrix representation of their adjacency relationships. Our main result is a complete forbidden submatrix characterization of the $I$-circular property, which in turn provides a characterization for semi-transitive split graphs in terms of minimal forbidden induced subgraphs.

A graph $G$ with vertex set $V(G)$ and edge set $E(G)$ is said to be word-representable if there exists a word $w$ over the alphabet $V(G)$ such that, for any two distinct letters $x,y \in V(G)$, the letters $x$ and $y$ alternate in $w$ if and only if $(x,y) \in E(G)$. Equivalently, a graph is word-representable if and only if it admits a semi-transitive orientation, that is, an acyclic orientation in which, for every directed path $v_0 \rightarrow v_1 \rightarrow \cdots \rightarrow v_m$ with $m \ge 2$, either there is no arc between $v_0$ and $v_m$, or, for all $1 \le i < j \le m$, there exists an arc from $v_i$ to $v_j$. In this work, we provide a comprehensive structural and algorithmic characterization of word-representable co-bipartite graphs, a class of graphs whose vertex set can be partitioned into two cliques. This work unifies graph-theoretic and matrix-theoretic perspectives. We first establish that a co-bipartite graph is a circle graph if and only if it is a permutation graph, thereby deriving a minimal forbidden induced subgraph characterization for co-bipartite circle graphs. The central contribution then connects semi-transitivity with the circularly compatible ones property of binary matrices. In addition to the structural characterization, the paper introduces a linear-time recognition algorithm for semi-transitive co-bipartite graphs, utilizing Safe's matrix recognition framework.

As a directed analog of Sidorenko's conjecture in extremal graph theory, Fox, Himwich, Zhou, and the second author defined an oriented graph $H$ to be tournament Sidorenko (anti-Sidorenko) if the random tournament asymptotically minimizes (maximizes) the number of copies of $H$ among all tournaments. We prove new inequalities of this form for oriented trees and cycles, considering both local and global notions of the Sidorenko property. We make progress on a conjecture of the aforementioned authors that every tree has an anti-Sidorenko direction, and give a characterization of short paths. For long paths we show that orientations are split symmetrically between being locally Sidorenko and anti-Sidorenko, yet almost all orientations are not globally Sidorenko. Finally, we give algorithms characterizing the local Sidorenko status of paths and cycles when the number of vertices is not divisible by four.

Given an oriented graph $D$, the inversion of a subset $X$ of vertices consists in reversing the orientation of all arcs with both endpoints in $X$. When the subset $X$ is of size $p$ (resp. at most $p$), this operation is called an $(=p)$-inversion (resp. $(\leq p)$-inversion). Then, an oriented graph is $(=p)$-invertible if it can be made acyclic by a sequence of $p$-inversions. We observe that, for $n=|V(D)|$, deciding whether $D$ is $(=n-1)$-invertible is equivalent to deciding whether $D$ is acyclically pushable, and thus NP-complete. In all other cases, when $p \neq n-1$, we construct a polynomial-time algorithm to decide $(=p)$-invertibility. We then consider the $(= p)$-inversion number, $\text{inv}^{= p}(D)$ (resp. $(\leq p)$-inversion number, $\text{inv}^{\leq p}(D)$), defined as the minimum number of $(=p)$-inversions (resp. $(\leq p)$-inversions) rendering $D$ acyclic. We show that every $(=p)$-invertible digraph $D$ satisfies $\text{inv}^{= p}(D) \leq |A(D)|$ for every integer $p\geq 2$. When $p$ is even, we bound $\text{inv}^{= p}$ by a (linear) function of the feedback arc set number, and rule out the existence of any bounding function for odd $p$. Finally, we study the complexity of deciding whether the $(= p)$-inversion number, or the $(\leq p)$-inversion number, of a given oriented graph is at most a given integer $k$. For any fixed positive integer $p \geq 2$, when $k$ is part of the input, we show that both problems are NP-hard even in tournaments. In general oriented graphs, we prove $W[1]$-hardness for both problems when parameterized by $p$, even for $k=1$. In contrast, we exhibit polynomial kernels in $p + k$ for both problems in tournaments.

We introduce a spoke-arc decomposition of non-crossing annular pair partitions $NC_2(p,q)$ that records spoke type and orientation, isolates spoke-level contributions, and factorizes the dependence on the ellipticity parameter $γ$ into a spoke factor and arc weights. This yields closed-form descriptions of the limiting covariance of Gaussian elliptic matrices. As a corollary, we show that an independent family of Gaussian elliptic random matrices is asymptotically second-order free.

We develop a new bijective framework for the enumeration of bipartite planar maps with control on the degree distribution of black and white vertices. Our approach builds on the blossoming-tree paradigm, introducing a family of orientations on bipartite maps that extends Eulerian and quasi-Eulerian orientations and connects the bijection of Bousquet-Mélou and Schaeffer to the general scheme of Albenque and Poulalhon. This enables us to generalize the Bousquet-Mélou and Schaeffer's bijection to several families of bipartite maps. As an application, we also derive a rational and Lagrangian parametrization with positive integer coefficients for the generating series of quartic maps equipped with an Ising model, which is key to the probabilistic study of these maps.

Let the grid graph $G_{M\times N}$ denote the Cartesian product $K_M \square K_N$. For a fixed subgraph $H$ of a grid, we study the off-diagonal Ramsey number $\operatorname{gr}(H, K_k)$, which is the smallest $N$ such that any red/blue edge coloring of $G_{N\times N}$ contains either a red copy of $H$ (a copy must preserve each edge's horizontal/vertical orientation), or a blue copy of $K_k$ contained inside a single row or column. Conlon, Fox, Mubayi, Suk, Verstraëte, and the first author recently showed that such grid Ramsey numbers are closely related to off-diagonal Ramsey numbers of bipartite $3$-uniform hypergraphs, and proved that $2^{Ω(\log ^2 k)} \le \operatorname{gr}(G_{2\times 2}, K_k) \le 2^{O(k^{2/3}\log k)}$. We prove that the square $G_{2\times 2}$ is exceptional in this regard, by showing that $\operatorname{gr}(C,K_k) = k^{O_C(1)}$ for any cycle $C \ne G_{2\times 2}$. We also obtain that a larger class of grid subgraphs $H$ obtained via a recursive blowup procedure satisfies $\operatorname{gr}(H,K_k) = k^{O_H(1)}$. Finally, we show that conditional on the multicolor Erdős-Hajnal conjecture, $\operatorname{gr}(H,K_k) = k^{O_H(1)}$ for any $H$ with two rows that does not contain $G_{2\times 2}$.

We investigate a combinatorial reconfiguration problem on oriented graphs, where a reconfiguration step (edge-flip) is the inversion of the orientation of a single edge. A recently published conjecture that is relevant to the correctness of a Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampler for directed flag complexes states that any simple oriented graph admits a flip sequence that monotonically decreases the number of directed 3-cycles to zero, and is known to be true for complete oriented graphs. We show that, in general, this conjecture does not hold. As main tool for disproving the conjecture, we introduce the concept of FBD-graphs (fully blocked digraphs). An FBD-graph is a directed graph that does not contain any directed 1-, 2-, or 3-cycles, and for which any edge-flip creates a directed 3-cycle. We prove that the non-existence of FBD-graphs is a necessary condition for the conjecture to hold and succeed in constructing FBD-graphs. On the other hand, we show that complete graphs, as well as graphs in which every edge is incident to at most two triangles, cannot be fully blocked. In addition to being relevant for determining in which cases the above mentioned sampling process is correct, the concept of FBD-graphs might also be useful for other problems and yields interesting questions for further study.

Webs are a kind of planar, directed, edge-labeled graph that encode invariant vectors for quantum representations of $\mathfrak{sl}_n$. The theory of webs developed organically for $\mathfrak{sl}_2$, where they are also known as noncrossing matchings and the Temperley-Lieb algebra, before being formalized by Kuperberg for $\mathfrak{sl}_2$ and $\mathfrak{sl}_3$ as the morphisms in a diagrammatic categorification of quantum representations called the spider category. Various models extend webs to $n \geq 4$. Only Cautis-Kamnitzer-Morrison prove a full set of relations for their webs, though Fontaine's webs are better adapted to computations, more graph-theoretically natural, and directly generalize webs for $n=2$ and $n=3$. This paper formalizes the theory of Fontaine's webs, proving the existence of a deep and powerful global structure on these webs called strandings. We do three key things: 1) give a state-sum formula to construct ($U_q(\mathfrak{sl}_n)$-invariant) web vectors from the orientation of strandings on Fontaine's webs; 2) list and prove a complete set of relations, connecting strandings to the local data of binary labelings that are well-established in the literature; and 3) provide applications and examples of how strandings facilitate computations.

A famous conjecture by Thomassen from 1983 asserts that for any given $k,g\in \mathbb{N}$ there exists some $d=d(k,g)\in \mathbb{N}$ such that every graph of minimum degree at least $d$ contains a subgraph of minimum degree at least $k$ and girth at least $g$. In this paper, we initiate the systematic study of the directed analogs of Thomassen's conjecture one obtains when replacing minimum degree by minimum out-degree. Concretely, we study which digraphs $F$ are avoidable in the sense that there exists $d_F:\mathbb{N}\rightarrow \mathbb{N}$ such that every digraph of minimum out-degree at least $d_F(k)$ contains an $F$-free subdigraph of minimum out-degree at least $k$. Among our main results, we show that all orientations of $C_3$ and $C_5$ are avoidable, while one-directed orientations of complete bipartite graphs and all oriented trees are not avoidable. This, in particular, shows that the most direct extension of Thomassen's conjecture to digraphs is false. We also fully characterize which digraphs are avoidable when restricting the setting to regular host digraphs. Finally, we raise numerous attractive open problems in the hope of sparking further progress.

An orientation of a given static graph is called transitive if for any three vertices $a,b,c$, the presence of arcs $(a,b)$ and $(b,c)$ forces the presence of the arc $(a,c)$. If only the presence of an arc between $a$ and $c$ is required, but its orientation is unconstrained, the orientation is called quasi-transitive. A fundamental result presented by Ghouila-Houri guarantees that any static graph admitting a quasi-transitive orientation also admits a transitive orientation. In a seminal work, Mertzios et al. introduced the notion of temporal transitivity in order to model information flows in simple temporal networks. We revisit the model introduced by Mertzios et al. and propose an analogous to Ghouila-Houri's characterization for the temporal scenario. We present a structure theorem that will allow us to express by a 2-SAT formula all the constraints imposed by temporal transitive orientations. The latter produces an efficient recognition algorithm for graphs admitting such orientations. Additionally, we extend the temporal transitivity model to temporal graphs having multiple time-labels associated to their edges and claim that the previous results hold in the multilabel setting. Finally, we propose a characterization of temporal comparability graphs via forbidden temporal ordered patterns.

We prove that every 2k-edge-connected graph with countably many edge-ends admits a k-arc-connected orientation, extending the previous result by Assem, Koloschin and Pitz that also assumed the hypothesis of the graph being locally finite. We prove that, if every locally finite graph has a well-balanced orientation, so does every graph. Lastly, we explore an alternative to the Nash-Williams Orientation Conjecture via topological paths, and prove that it is true for every finitely separated graph.

Kauffman's clock theorem provides a distributive lattice structure on the set of states of a four-valent graph in the plane. We prove two distinct generalisations of this theorem, for four-valent graphs embedded in more general compact oriented surfaces. The proofs use results of Propp providing distributive lattice structures on matchings on bipartite plane graphs, and orientations of graphs with fixed circulation.

In 1935, Pauling proposed an estimate for the number of Eulerian orientations of a graph in the context of the theoretical behaviour of water ice. The logarithm of the number of Eulerian orientations, normalised by the number of vertices, is called the residual entropy. In an earlier paper, we conjectured that the residual entropy of a sequence of regular graphs of increasing degree was asymptotically equal to Pauling's estimate. Here we prove the conjecture under constraints on the number of short circuits. These constraints hold under weak eigenvalue conditions and apply to sequences of increasing girth and repeated Cartesian products such as hypercubes.

Petrie symmetric functions $G(k,n)$, also known as truncated homogeneous symmetric functions or modular complete symmetric functions, form a class of symmetric functions interpolating between the elementary symmetric functions $e_n$ and the homogeneous symmetric functions $h_n$. Analogous to the Pieri rule for $s_μh_n$ and the dual Pieri rule for $s_μe_n$, Grinberg showed that the Schur coefficients for the ``Pieri rule'' of $s_μG(k,n)$ can be determined by the determinant $\pet_k(λ,μ)$ of Petrie matrices. Cheng, Chou, Eu, Fu, and Yao provided a ribbon tiling interpretation for the coefficient $\pet_k(λ,\varnothing)$, which was later generalized by Jin, Jing, and Liu to $\pet_k(λ,μ)$ in the case where $λ/μ$ is connected. The goal of this paper is to offer a more transparent combinatorial perspective on the structure and behavior of Petrie symmetric functions. First, we provide a refined combinatorial formula for the determinant of a Petrie matrix in terms of certain orientations of the associated graph derived from the matrix. We then generalize the result of JJL to arbitrary skew shapes using purely combinatorial proofs. In addition, we investigate the generating function of these orientations with respect to certain statistics. As an application of our method, we present a combinatorial proof of the plethystic Pieri rule.

For an oriented graph $D$, the inversion of $X\subseteq V(D)$ in $D$ is the graph obtained by reversing the orientation of all arcs with both ends in $X$. The inversion number $\mathrm{inv}(D)$ is the minimum number of inversions needed to obtain an acyclic oriented graph. We show that the dijoin conjecture of Bang-Jensen, da Silva and Havet, that $\mathrm{inv}(D_1\rightarrow D_2)=\mathrm{inv}(D_1)+\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$, is true in the case where $\mathrm{inv}(D_1)=2$ and $\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$ is even. We also characterise the cases $\mathrm{inv}(D_1)=2$ and $\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$ odd, for which the conjecture does and does not hold. We then go on to show a similar result for n-joins, in doing so we prove a conjecture of Alon, Powierski, Savery, Scott and Wilmer. Our proofs build on the idea of tournament minimum rank, introduced by Behague, Johnston, Morrison and Ogden.

An $S_k$-set in a group $Γ$ is a set $A\subseteqΓ$ such that $α_1\cdotsα_k=β_1\cdotsβ_k$ with $α_i,β_i\in A$ implies $(α_1,\ldots,α_k)=(β_1,\ldots,β_k)$. An $S_k'$-set is a set such that $α_1β_1^{-1}\cdotsα_kβ_k^{-1}=1$ implies that there exists $i$ such that $α_i=β_i\text{ or }β_i=α_{i+1}$. We give explicit constructions of large $S_k$-sets in the group $S_n$ and $S_2$-sets in $S_n\times S_n$ and $A_n\times A_n$. We give probabilistic constructions for `nice' groups which obtain large $S_2$-sets in $A_n$ and $S_2'$-sets in $S_n$. We also give upper bounds on the size of $S_k$-sets in certain groups, improving the trivial bound by a constant multiplicative factor. We describe some connections between $S_k$-sets and extremal graph theory. In particular, we determine up to a constant factor the minimum outdegree of a digraph which guarantees even cycles with certain orientations. As applications, we improve the upper bound on Hamilton paths which pairwise create a two-part cycle of given length, and we show that a directed version of the Erdős-Simonovits compactness conjecture is false.