arXiv++ Combinatorics

Browse math.CO papers from arXiv

math.CO ↗ arXiv

7121 papers in this category
2026-10-05
A Morris recursion rule for values of the spin characters of wreath products
The classical Murnaghan-Nakayama rule is a recursive formula for computing the values of complex irreducible characters of the symmetric group $S_n$. Alun Morris proved a recursive formula for evaluating the values of irreducible spin characters of $\widetilde{S}_n$, where $\widetilde{S}_n$ is one of the Schur covers of $S_n$ defined by $\widetilde{S}_n:=\langle t_1,t_2,\cdots,t_{n-1},z\ |\ z^2=1,\ t_i^2=z,\ (t_it_{i+1})^3=z, \ t_it_j=zt_jt_i\ \text{if}\ |i-j|>1\rangle$. A recursive formula for evaluating the values of complex irreducible characters of the wreath product $G\wr S_n$, where $G$ is a finite group, was proved by J. Stembridge. In this article, we state and prove a recursive formula to compute the values of the irreducible spin characters of the wreath product $G\wr \widetilde{S}_n$. For the convenience of implementing these recursive formulas, we extend the notion of 0-1 boundary sequence of a Young diagram to shifted Young diagrams.
2026-10-05
The Bounded-Linear Dichotomy Holds for all 4 Point Posets
Given a finite poset $\mathcal P$, its induced saturation number, $\text{sat}^*(n,\mathcal P)$ is the smallest size a family of subsets of $[n]$ can have such that it does not contain an induced copy of $\mathcal P$, but adding any other set to it creates one. The saturation numbers already show a sharp dichotomy -- Freschi, Piga, Sharifzadeh and Treglown showed that for any given poset its saturation number is either bounded or at least $2\sqrt n$. The dominant conjecture is that in fact, the saturation numbers are either bounded, or exactly linear. In this paper we show that this dichotomy is true for all posets on at most 4 points. Most of these posets, most notably the butterfly and the diamond, had individually long resisted analysis, and the missing piece which this paper tackles is the poset comprised of a $\mathcal V$ and an isolated point, denoted by $\widehat{\mathcal V}$, for which we show linear saturation. The architecture of the proof uncovers the structure of an arbitrary $\widehat{\mathcal V}$- saturated family, namely an antichain with at most two chains above it, and an upside-down forest below it. Moreover, we anticipate that, at least partially, this structure is relevant to the wider class of posets that contain an isolated point.
2026-10-05
Random independent sets in triangle-free and linear Berge-$C_4$-free hypergraphs
We study probability distributions on independent sets of uniform hypergraphs with local constraints. For a positive vertex-weight function $w$ on an $(r+1)$-uniform hypergraph, define the weighted degree of vertex $v$ by \[ d_w(v):= \sum_{e\ni v} \left( \prod_{u\in e\setminus\{v\}}\dfrac{w(u)}{w(v)} \right)^{1/r}. \] For each fixed $r\geq1$, our first result gives, in every triangle-free $(r+1)$-uniform hypergraph (without a linearity assumption), a random independent set $I$ satisfying \[ \mathbb P(v\in I)\geq \left( \frac{r}{r+1}(r(r+1))^{-1/r}+o_r(1) \right) \left(\frac{\log d_w(v)}{d_w(v)}\right)^{1/r}, \qquad d_w(v)\to+\infty. \] The same result also implies that every $d$-degenerate triangle-free $(r+1)$-uniform hypergraph satisfies \[ χ_f(G)\leq \left( \dfrac{r+1}{r}(r(r+1))^{1/r}+o_r(1) \right) \left(\dfrac{d}{\log d}\right)^{1/r}, \qquad d\to+\infty. \] Our second result concerns linear Berge-$C_4$-free hypergraphs which allow Berge triangles. In this setting, for every sufficiently large threshold $D$, there exists a random independent set $I$ such that, uniformly over all vertices with $d_w(v)\geq D$, \[ \mathbb P(v\in I)\geq (1-o_r(1)) \left(\frac{\log d_w(v)}{r\,d_w(v)}\right)^{1/r}, \qquad D\to+\infty. \] It also yields \[ χ_f(G)\leq (1+o_r(1)) \left(\frac{rd}{\log d}\right)^{1/r} \] for $d$-degenerate linear Berge-$C_4$-free $(r+1)$-uniform hypergraphs. Both results are based on the ordered random pick process originated from Martinsson and Steiner. By choosing different selection functions and iteration, we prove the output of the random process gives the required random independent set.
2026-10-05
Deciding lettericity is NP-complete, even for four-colorable comparability graphs
We prove that deciding whether a graph has lettericity at most k is NP-complete, even for four-colorable comparability graphs. Our reduction maps a bipartite graph G to the graph obtained from its incidence graph by inflating each vertex by a clique or an independent set of three vertices. The lettericity of this graph is determined by the numbers of vertices and edges of G and the greatest number of edge-disjoint paths on four vertices in G. Teypaz and Rapine showed that deciding whether the edges of a bipartite graph can be partitioned into paths on four vertices is NP-complete.
2026-10-05
Counting zero-sum subspaces for the multiplicative inverse function
Let $q=2^n$ with $n\ge6$, and let $\mathbb{F}_q$ be the finite field with $q$ elements. For a subspace $E$ of $\mathbb{F}_q$, define \[ S(E)=\sum_{x\in E\setminus\{0\}}x^{-1}.\] Let $N_{n,k}$ denote the number of $k$-dimensional $\mathbb{F}_2$-subspaces $E$ for which $S(E)=0$. We prove that, if $k\ge3$ and $n\ge2k+1$, then \[ \left|\frac{2^nN_{n,k}}{\genfrac{[}{]}{0pt}{}{n}{k}_{2}}-1\right|<2^{r^2+r}2^{n(1-r/2)},\] where $r=\lfloor\frac{k-1}{2}\rfloor$, and $\genfrac{[}{]}{0pt}{}{n}{k}_{2}$ is the Gaussian binomial coefficient. In particular, \[ N_{n,k}\sim2^{-n}\genfrac{[}{]}{0pt}{}{n}{k}_{2}\quad (n\to\infty)\] uniformly for $n/3<k\le(n-1)/2$. Combined with the known low-dimensional cases and the symmetry between dimensions $k$ and $n-k$, and the elementary middle-dimensional subfield construction, this proves a conjecture of Carlet: for every $3\le k\le n-3$, there exists a $k$-dimensional $\mathbb{F}_2$-subspace $E$ such that $S(E)=0$.
2026-10-05
Descartes' rule of signs for arbitrary fewnomial systems
We consider systems of $n$ real polynomial equations in $n$ variables with $n+k+1$ monomials. By the Gale duality of Bihan and Sottile, their positive solutions correspond to the solutions of a system of $k$ equations $\prod_ip_i^{B_{ij}}=1$ in a polyhedron $Δ\subset\mathbb{R}^k$, where the $p_i$ are affine functions, and a Khovanskii--Rolle argument bounds their number by the number of common zeros in $Δ$ of iterated Jacobians $Γ_k,\dots,Γ_1$ plus the number of noncompact branches of certain curves. We bound the first term by the Bézout number minus the numbers of zeros in the other chambers of the arrangement $\{p_i=0\}$, which we bound from below by boundary degrees given by a facet-count formula. The branches of the curves end at zeros of the Jacobians on faces of $Δ$, which we count on the flats of the arrangement through explicit reduced systems. The resulting recursion over all flats and chambers starts on lines with Descartes' rule of signs for circuits. We obtain upper bounds for the number of positive solutions which only depend on the oriented matroid of the coefficient matrix and on the oriented matroids of the exponent matrix and of its liftings.
2026-10-05
Magic positivity for polar duals of pseudo-symmetric smooth Fano polytopes
Motivated by Gal's conjecture, Ferroni and Higashitani conjectured that the $h^*$-polynomial of any Gorenstein lattice polytope admitting a quadratic triangulation is $γ$-positive. Together with conjectures predicting quadratic properties of toric ideals of smooth lattice polytopes, this suggests that smooth Gorenstein lattice polytopes should have $γ$-positive $h^*$-polynomials. In this paper, we prove that the Ehrhart polynomial of the polar dual of every pseudo-symmetric simplicial reflexive polytope is magic positive. For pseudo-symmetric smooth Fano polytopes, we prove the stronger statement that all magic coefficients are strictly positive. Consequently, for every pseudo-symmetric simplicial reflexive polytope, its polar dual is Ehrhart positive and has a real-rooted and $γ$-positive $h^*$-polynomial. We also prove that the Ehrhart polynomial of the polar dual of the symmetric edge polytope of every cycle is magic positive. This gives an affirmative answer to a question of Konoike, who had previously proved partial positivity results for this family.
Explicit Nonlinear Functions beyond the Fourier bound
We study the problem of constructing highly nonlinear vectorial maps $F: \mathbb F_2^n \to \mathbb F_2^m$. Concretely, we want an $F$ and an $A = A(m,n)> 0$ as small as possible, so that for every affine map $L: \mathbb F_2^n \to \mathbb F_2^m$ (of the form $L(x) = M x + b $) we have: $$\mathrm{agree}(F, L) := |\{ x \in \mathbb F_2^n \mid F(x) = L(x) \}| \leq A.$$ Such questions have been studied by Nyberg (1991,1993), Carlet and Ding (2004,2007), Liu, Mesnager and Chen (2017), Nagy (2025), and Biryukov, Turecek, and Udovenko (2026). There is a classical method of constructing such functions from bent-functions and Fourier analytic ideas; the best bound achievable by this method is: $$ A(m,n) = Θ(2^{n-m} + 2^{n/2}),$$ and in particular, is never smaller than $2^{n/2}$. In this work, we show how to construct highly nonlinear functions beyond this Fourier bound. Concretely, we show how to construct for every $γ>0$, a function $F: \mathbb F_2^n \to \mathbb F_2^m$ with $m = O_γ(n)$, achieving $$ A(m,n) \leq (1 + γ)^n.$$ Surprisingly, we even achieve the same quantitative behavior for the much harder question of having low agreement with $m$-tuples of degree $d$ polynomials $Q: \mathbb F_2^n \to \mathbb F_2^m$, with $m = O_{γ, d}(n)$. Here the previously best bounds were of the form $A(m,n) = O( 2^{-\frac{n}{2^{d+1}}} \cdot 2^n )$ of Ben-Sasson and Kopparty (2010), based on Gowers-norm-type arguments. All our results generalize to all finite fields $\mathbb F_q$ in place of $\mathbb F_2$. Our methods are based on a new connection to classical results on counting solutions to systems of polynomial equations via algebraic methods. This connection brings us to basic questions in combinatorics, about graphs and hypergraphs with simultaneously a small number of edges and independent sets.
2026-10-05
Geometric Realizations with Strong Self-Duality Part II: Diameter Graphs, Reuleaux Polyhedra, and Thrackles
In this paper we construct new examples of diameter graphs and Reuleaux polyhedra in $\mathbb{R}^3$, obtaining a full characterization of their combinatorial structure. For a finite set of points $X\subset\mathbb{R}^d$, its diameter graph is the graph on vertex set $X$ where pairs forming a diameter pair are connected by an edge. Grünbaum, Heppes and Straszewicz independently proved that the diameter graph of $X\subset \mathbb{R}^3$ has at most $2|X|-2$ edges, answering a question of Vázsonyi. Their proof relied on ball polytopes. The ball polytope $\mathcal{B}(X)$ is the intersection of the unit balls centered at the points of $X$. We call a ball polytope a Reuleaux polyhedron if the centers form a family with $2|X|-2$ diameter pairs. Kupitz, Martini and Perles showed that the skeleton of a Reuleaux polyhedron must be a 2-connected strongly involutive self-dual graph. They conjectured that in the simple 3-connected case this is also sufficient. We not only confirm this conjecture, but we show that any 2-connected (not necessarily simple) strongly involutive self-dual graph arises as the skeleton of a Reuleaux polyhedron. To construct the new Reuleaux polyhedra we construct new diameter graphs. It was known that any 3-dimensional diameter graph is a subgraph of a non-bipartite quadrangulation of the projective plane. We show that the reverse holds. That is, for any such graph we construct a diameter realization. This also confirms and strengthens a conjecture of Montejano, Pauli, Raggi, Roldán-Pensado on metric embeddings of strongly involutive self-dual graphs. The construction relies on ideas from rigidity theory. We also discuss a number of applications of these results, such as the construction of bodies of constant width and connections to Steinitz's theorem and Borsuk's conjecture.
2026-10-05
Ehrhart Properties under Operations on Lattice Polytopes
This paper investigates the preservation of three classes of Ehrhart properties under various operations on lattice polytopes. These operations include Cartesian products, lattice joins, lattice pyramids, free sums, Minkowski sums, Cayley sums, reflexive polarity, and integral dilations. Specifically, we consider the following properties frequently studied in Ehrhart theory: (i): Positivity of Ehrhart coefficients, including Ehrhart positivity and magic positivity. In particular, we present lattice point counting formulas for the polytopes generated by these operations. (ii): Coefficient properties of the $h^*$-polynomial, including symmetry, unimodality, log-concavity, ultra log-concavity, real-rootedness, and $γ$-positivity. (iii): Geometric properties, including the spanning property, the integer decomposition property, very ampleness, and the existence of unimodular triangulation, regular unimodular triangulation, and quadratic triangulation. We determine which properties are preserved under these eight operations, establishing preservation theorems or constructing explicit counterexamples. Furthermore, when a property is not preserved in general, we investigate sufficient or equivalent conditions for its preservation.
2026-10-05
Geometric Realizations with Strong Self-Duality Part I: Non-Bipartite Quadrangulations of the Projective Plane and Strongly Involutive Self-Dual Graphs
In this series of articles, we study two graph classes and their various geometric representations. The first class consists of strongly involutive self-dual graphs (SISD graphs); the second consists of non-bipartite quadrangulations of the projective plane (NBQP graphs). These classes naturally arise in many geometric problems. For example, NBQP graphs are connected to diameter graphs in $\mathbb{R}^3$, tangency graphs of families of pairwise intersecting circles and pseudocircles, generalized thrackles, and graphs formed by the main diagonals of negatively self-polar polytopes. On the other hand, SISD graphs correspond to the skeletons of negatively self-polar polytopes, self-dual cones, and extremal ball-polytopes. In Part I we show a natural one-to-one correspondence between non-bipartite quadrangulations of the projective plane and 2-connected strongly involutive self-dual maps. In particular, we show that the reduced vertex-face incidence structure of a 2-connected strongly involutive self-dual map is a non-bipartite quadrangulation of the projective plane, and every non-bipartite quadrangulation of the projective plane arises that way. This allows us to translate natural properties from one class to the other. These results lay the foundation for later parts of the series.
2026-10-05
A Conjecture on Circular Permutations over Finite Fields
Let \(\mathbb{F}_q\) be a finite field with \(q>7\). Zhi-Wei Sun conjectured that for every \(a_0\in\mathbb{F}_q\), there is a circular permutation \((a_1,\dots,a_{q-1})\) of non-zero elements of \(\mathbb{F}_q\) such that \(a_0+a_i a_{i+1}\) is primitive for \(1\le i\le q-1\), where \(a_q=a_1\). In this paper, we confirm this conjecture for \(q>18\,888\,871\). For \(a_0=0\), the conclusion holds for all \(q>4\). For \(a_0\ne0\), we apply the Chvátal--Erdős theorem to obtain a Hamilton cycle.
2026-10-05
Combinatorial twisted bialgebras and combinatorial twisted double bialgebras
We provide in this text a new framework for a family of combinatorial Hopf algebras. We adopt for this the language of species and twisted bialgebras (also known as Hopf monoids). We define the category of combinatorial twisted bialgebras (briefly, CTBs), a class of twisted bialgebras satisfying strong combinatorial conditions of compatibilities of the product and the coproduct with the underlying combinatorial structure. The considered morphisms also have to respect the combinatorial structure, in some sense. Many classical examples fit into this framework, including Hopf algebras of graphs, rooted trees, posets, hypergraphs, symmetric functions, boolean maps, etc. Most of known combinatorial Hopf algebras can be obtained from a CTB by application of a Fock functor, or by duality. A central result is the introduction of a universal CTB denoted by $\mathbf{Exch}$, built from collections of compositions satisfying a certain exchange condition. It has a special character $ε$, such that the pair $(\mathbf{Exch},ε)$ plays a role analogous to that of quasi-symmetric functions for graded and connected Hopf algebras: it is the terminal object in the category of CTBs equipped with combinatorial characters. This leads to universal morphisms that encode important information about the combinatorial structure of coproducts. The natural order on the set of compositions on a fixed set is used to define three important sub-objects $\mathbf{Exch}\_-$, $\mathbf{Exch}\_+$ and $\mathbf{Exch}\_{+\hspace{-2mm}+}$ of $\mathbf{Exch}$. We also studies polynomial invariants associated with CTBs. It establishes a correspondence between characters and polynomial invariants. Well-known invariants such as the chromatic polynomial of graphs and the Ehrhart polynomials of posets arise naturally within this framework. We show that, for a given degree, only finitely many polynomial invariants can occur. We show that these universal polynomial invariants can be used to give cancellation-free formulas for the antipode or the Eulerian idempotent, under conditions on the CTB, and use this for an example based on rooted trees, coming from a Hopf algebra used in linguistics. Results are also obtained for families of polynomial invariants with the alternating sign condition, or satisfying a reciprocity principle. We also extend the theory to combinatorial twisted double bialgebras (briefly, CTDBs), which involve two interacting coproduct structures. These generalize previously known examples arising from graphs, posets, hypergraphs, and rooted trees. The twisted approach preserves the combinatorial richness of these structures while providing a unified algebraic framework. We show that not any CTB can be made a CTDB, leading to the introduction of the notion of quasi-cocommutativity. In particular, we show that $\mathbf{Exch}\_+$ is not a CTDB, and construct a sub-object which is, in a unique way, and maximal for the inclusion. In the cocommutative case, simplifications naturally occur, and we show that in this case, a CTB of hypergraphs plays a central role, especially two sub-objects based on connectedness systems and antichain covers. We also show that, in the cocommutative case, the universal polynomial invariants are always chromatic polynomials of hypergraphs, no matter which CTB is considered. Finally, forgetting the combinatorial underlying structure, we study the algebraic structure of $\mathrm{Exch}$, with the help of a twisted version of Loday and Ronco's rigidity theorem for infinitesimal bialgebras.
On rigidity properties of unit-distance graphs
A unit-distance graph is a graph which admits a realisation in Euclidean space in which every edge has unit length. Imposing further geometric conditions on the non-edges gives a family of natural subclasses. Requiring that no two vertices lie at distance less than one gives penny and marble graphs: the contact graphs of collections of equal radii $d$-dimensional spheres with non-overlapping interiors for $d=2,3$. Requiring instead that the straight-line drawing in the plane be non-crossing gives matchstick graphs. Since any motion of a realisation must preserve these extra conditions, the rigidity and flexibility properties of the resulting frameworks differ from those of classical bar-joint rigidity theory. In this note we analyse various rigidity problems for penny and marble graphs, matchstick graphs and unit-distance graphs. In particular we answer a recent open problem on penny and marble graph rigidity and establish a link between penny graphs and the concept of NAC-colourings.
2026-10-05
Refinements on the Restriction and Kakeya problems range in $\mathbb{R}^4$
We obtain improved Fourier restriction and Kakeya maximal estimates in $\mathbb R^4$. More precisely, by proving the two-ends incidence estimates $\mathbf{TE}\left(\frac{133}{44},\frac{177}{88},\frac34\right)$ and $\mathbf{TE}\left(\frac{386453}{125988},\frac{386453}{125988},\frac{358951}{377964}\right)$, we extend the restriction range to $p>2+ \frac{176}{221}$ and the Kakeya maximal estimate up to dimension $3.06737$. The implications to the known lower-bounds for the Hausdorff dimension of Kakeya sets in $\mathbb{R}^4$ and the Bochner--Riesz conjecture are also studied.
2026-10-05
Exactness of weighted exponential systems with a defect
Let $w \colon (0,1) \to \mathbb{R}_{+}$ be a weight. We prove that for an arbitrary Schauder basis $\{e^{i λ_n t}\}_{n \in \mathbb{Z}}$ in $L^2(0,1)$ and an arbitrary lacunary defect set $A \subset \mathbb{Z}$ the system $\{w(t) r_n(t)\}_{n \in \mathbb{Z} \setminus A}$ is always complete and never minimal for any weight $w$ satisfying a natural decay condition, which is sharp on the exponential scale. Moreover, we establish a simple combinatorial criterion for systems of the form $ \{ w(t) e^{2πi n t} \}_{n \in \mathbb{Z} \setminus A} $ to be complete and minimal in $L^2(0,1)$ for an arbitrary weight $w$ and a finite defect set $A \subset \mathbb{Z}$.
2026-10-05
The separator-based derivations for arrangements of monomial groups
We investigate derivation modules of hyperplane arrangements associated with the monomial groups $G(r,p,\ell)$. Motivated by Mühlherr's separator-based construction for graphic arrangements, we extend this approach by combining separators with integral expressions. For a subarrangement $\mathcal{A}_G$ defined by a graph $G$, we show that, when $p<r$, the derivation module $\mathcal{D}(\mathcal{A}_G)$ is generated by the standard derivations $η_0,\dots,η_{κ(G)}$ together with a finite set of separator-based derivations. This result generalizes the complete graph case and provides new evidence toward the broader applicability of separator methods in the study of hyperplane arrangements.
2026-10-05
Polynomial families of incident flags and explicit off-diagonal Ramsey graphs
We construct explicit off-diagonal Ramsey graphs from polynomial families of incident point--hyperplane flags. Universal interpolation translates the exact dimension of ordered clique configurations into a bound on their coefficient--label incidence. At the critical dimension, a polynomial separates the forbidden-pair image from its diagonal; deleting the corresponding edges preserves a triangular rank certificate. Restriction of scalars realizes the rational endpoint without rounding loss. The resulting fixed-$s$ exponent has leading scale $s/(2\log_2s)$, and short Frobenius relations give the explicit example $R(16,t)\geΩ(t^{2.0539221767\ldots})$. A finite-fiber construction gives the range $s^2(\log s)^2=o(\log t)$. For fixed parameters, algebraic preprocessing terminates and field initialization, vertex decoding and adjacency take deterministic time polynomial in the extension degree. We also retain an elimination-free variant and formulate the filtering argument for general forbidden configurations with a distinguished edge.
2026-10-05
Optimal spectral supersaturation for cliques and odd cycles
Let $Y_{n,r,q}$ be the graph obtained from the Turán graph $T_{n,r}$ by adding $q$ pairwise disjoint edges inside a largest part, and let $c(n,F)$ be the minimum number of copies of $F$ created by adding a single edge to $T_{n,r}$. Fang, Li, Lin and Ma proved that for every color-critical graph $F$ with $χ(F)=r+1$, there exists a constant $δ_F>0$ such that for all sufficiently large $n$ and all $1\le q\le δ_F \sqrt{n}$, the condition $λ(G)\geλ(Y_{n,r,q})$ forces at least $q\, c(n,F)$ copies of $F$. The bound $q=O(\sqrt{n}\,)$ is tight up to a constant factor, in contrast to the linear order $n$ of the edge setting of Mubayi, Pikhurko and Yilma, but the exact constant $δ_F$ remained unknown for any $F$. In this paper, building on a structural result of Fang, Li, Lin and Ma, we determine the threshold $δ_F$ when $F$ is a clique and an odd cycle. For every $r\ge2$, we denote $δ_r :=(1-\tfrac1r)\sqrt2$ and prove that for every $\varepsilon>0$, if $n$ is sufficiently large and $1\le q\le(δ_r-\varepsilon)\sqrt n$, then every $n$-vertex graph $G$ with $λ(G)\geλ(Y_{n,r,q})$ contains at least $q\,c(n,K_{r+1})$ copies of $K_{r+1}$, and $δ_r$ is best possible. For odd cycles, the threshold is $1/\sqrt2$. For every $k\ge1$ and $\varepsilon>0$, if $n$ is sufficiently large and $1\le q\le(1/\sqrt2-\varepsilon)\sqrt n$, then every $n$-vertex graph $G$ with $λ(G)\geλ(Y_{n,2,q})$ contains at least $q\,c(n,C_{2k+1})$ copies of $C_{2k+1}$, and $1/\sqrt2$ is best possible. Our results determine both the exact count of copies and the optimal range of $q$. The behavior in the spectral setting differs from the classical edge setting, in which the range of $q$ is of order $n$ and the threshold is $1/r$ for cliques by Lovász and Simonovits, and $1/2$ for odd cycles by Pikhurko and Yilma.
2026-10-05
A counterexample to the circuit-cocircuit intersection conjecture
Oxley conjectured that a matroid with a circuit-cocircuit intersection of size $k\geq 4$ has one of size $k-2$. Using the standard polynomial representation of the classical extended binary Golay code, we construct an identically self-dual binary matroid of rank $12$ on $24$ elements. Its circuit-cocircuit intersection sizes are exactly $0,2,4,6,8$, and $12$, disproving the conjecture for $k=12$. The proof is self-contained and does not rely on the full weight distribution of the code or on an enumeration of all circuits.