arXiv++ Combinatorics

We consider systems of $n$ real polynomial equations in $n$ variables with $n+k+1$ monomials. By the Gale duality of Bihan and Sottile, their positive solutions correspond to the solutions of a system of $k$ equations $\prod_ip_i^{B_{ij}}=1$ in a polyhedron $Δ\subset\mathbb{R}^k$, where the $p_i$ are affine functions, and a Khovanskii--Rolle argument bounds their number by the number of common zeros in $Δ$ of iterated Jacobians $Γ_k,\dots,Γ_1$ plus the number of noncompact branches of certain curves. We bound the first term by the Bézout number minus the numbers of zeros in the other chambers of the arrangement $\{p_i=0\}$, which we bound from below by boundary degrees given by a facet-count formula. The branches of the curves end at zeros of the Jacobians on faces of $Δ$, which we count on the flats of the arrangement through explicit reduced systems. The resulting recursion over all flats and chambers starts on lines with Descartes' rule of signs for circuits. We obtain upper bounds for the number of positive solutions which only depend on the oriented matroid of the coefficient matrix and on the oriented matroids of the exponent matrix and of its liftings.

We show that, up to isometry, there is exactly one compact hyperbolic Coxeter 6-polytope with 10 facets, the polytope $P_{6,10}$ attributed to Bugaenko. Together with results of Felikson-Tumarkin ($d \ge 7$) and of Burcroff and Ma-Zheng ($d = 4, 5$), this completes the classification of compact hyperbolic Coxeter $d$-polytopes with $d+4$ facets. The proof is computer assisted. Affine Gale duality applied to the complete database of order types on 10 points yields 387 combinatorial types, of which Lannér's classification excludes 83. For the remaining 304, an exhaustive search over Coxeter labellings, with no a priori bound on the dihedral angles, leaves a single realizable Gram matrix. Every rejection is certified in exact arithmetic, and completeness of the search is certified independently by DRAT proofs checked by drat-trim. The same code reproduces the known censuses in dimensions 4 and 5. Code, data and certificates are publicly available.

We consider the integer version of Alkan--Gale's model on stability in a two-sided market, called the stable generalized allocation one. It is given by a triple $(G,b,C)$, where $G=(V,E)$ is a finite bipartite graph with nonnegative integer capacities $b(e)\in{\mathbb Z}_+$ of edges $e\in E$, and for each vertex (``agent'') $v\in V$, the preferences on the set $E_v$ of its incident edges depend on a choice function $C_v$. The latter acts on the set of vectors in ${\mathbb Z}_+^{E_v}$ bounded by the capacities and obeys the standard axioms of substitutability and size monotonicity. Alkan--Gale's prominent theorem implies that the stability problem in this case always has a stable solution $x\in{\mathbb Z}_+^E$ and, moreover, the set ${\cal S}_{G,b,C}$ of these solutions (``stable generalized allocations'') forms a distributive lattice. However, this lattice is rather intricate to construct and work with, and we wonder whether it can be represented via a ``simpler'' stability model. Answering this issue, we arrange a sort of splitting techniques to embed ${\cal S}_{G,b,C}$, as a sublattice, in the lattice of stable matchings and, more compactly, in the lattice of stable allocations (as in Baiou--Balinski's stability model). This generalizes Fleiner's result on a detachment in the special case with all-unit capacities. Keywords: stable marriage, stable allocation, choice function, rotation, distributive lattice, poset representation

We prove that every equal-weight spherical $4$-design on $\mathbb{S}^2$ has at least twelve points. Since the regular icosahedron is a spherical $5$-design, this determines the exact minimum$$N_4(\mathbb{S}^2)=12;$$equivalently, no such design has $9$, $10$ or $11$ points.The proof is part of a finite-defect theory. If a spherical $2m$-design has corank $c=N-\dim P_m$, its Naimark complement consists of unit vectors $u_x\in\mathbb{S}^{c-1}$ forming a spherical $2$-design and satisfying the exact coupling$$u_x\cdot u_y=-\frac{K_m^{(d)}(x\cdot y)}{c}\qquad(x\ne y).$$This gives a pairwise kernel bound, an antipodal lower bound, Cayley-Bacharach information, and uniform lower bounds for multiplicative-relation spaces. In corank one the design splits into two equal spherical $m$-designs. We derive a residue formula for its signed Schoenberg coefficients; the coefficient of degree $m+3$ is negative exactly when $3\le d\le m+1$, excluding corank one throughout that range. At strengths four and six the only examples in any dimension are the regular hexagon and octagon, respectively.In corank two the complement is a circle Gale frame. Multiplication by its phase forces at least $d-1$ linear-quadratic aliases and yields exact norm and socle identities in every dimension. For eleven nodes on $\mathbb{S}^2$, two aliases produce a real harmonic cubic and a Hermitian quartic matrix. A matrix-valued Cayley-Bacharach argument eliminates the generic branch; the exceptional branch reduces to a Pauli normal form and contradicts the second moments. In dimensions $d\ge4$ the corank-two problem remains open; we identify a forced quadratic socle as the obstruction to extending the present argument.

We study near alternating sign matrices with prescribed row and column weights. After recalling the basic definitions and the necessary conditions coming from the Gale--Ryser theorem, we give a graph-theoretic characterization of the existence problem. More precisely, we show that a near alternating sign matrix with prescribed row and column weight sequences exists if and only if there exists a binary array with the same weights whose associated adjacency graph is bipartite. This reformulation shows that the Gale--Ryser conditions are not sufficient in general. We then formulate a natural conjecture up to permutations of the row and column weight sequences, and present some positive results, based on convex binary arrays and composition constructions.

We study the action of the Fourier transform on the Stokes data of irregular connections on the complex affine line with symmetric irregular classes at infinity, both from the point of view of Stokes filtered local systems and of Stokes local systems, and we show that it is governed by a rich combinatorial structure: (1) Observing that, in this setup, a Stokes filtration is fully determined by the data of either its recessive or subdominant solution spaces, and making the link with results of T. Mochizuki, we show that the Fourier transform amounts to exchanging recessive and subdominant solutions via the Gale transform of configurations of points in projective spaces. (2) We show that the equivalence between recessive solutions and Stokes local systems is deeply connected with the triality relating point configurations, superperiodic linear difference equations and frieze patterns obtained by Morier-Genoud-Ovsienko-Schwartz-Tabachnikov: Up to signs, the coefficients of the difference equations and friezes coincide with the nontrivial Stokes matrix entries. It follows from this Stokes-frieze correspondence that the Fourier transform of Stokes representations is given by their combinatorial Gale transform, leading to explicit closed formulas.

Chomp was introduced by Gale in 1974. In the same paper, Gale reported that the 3 x n games had been completely analyzed for n <= 100, with a unique winning first move in every case, and asked whether winning first moves are unique in general. Although the general uniqueness statement is false, we prove that the three-row uniqueness phenomenon suggested by Gale's computations holds for all n: every 3 x n Chomp rectangle has exactly one winning opening move. This settles the three-row case of Gale's 52-year-old first-move uniqueness question. The proof is carried out in the two-variable recurrence introduced by Brouwer, Horvath, Molnar-Saska, and Szabo for the function f(q,r) whose values encode the P-positions. The main local ingredient is a rightmost-hole principle: if a value p is absent from the set C(q,r) but belongs to all corresponding sets C(t,r) for q < t < p, then all intermediate values q+1,...,p-1 are forced to belong to C(q,r). This separates the diagonal values from the starts of constant rows, and yields a partition of the positive integers into the two possible types of winning opening moves.

Given lattice polytopes $P_1, \ldots, P_k$ contained in a $k$-dimensional subspace $U \subseteq \mathbb{R}^d$ and a $d$-dimensional lattice polytope $Q \subset \mathbb{R}^d$, we compute the Hodge vector of the Cayley polytope $P_1 * \cdots * P_k * Q$, and show that it equals the mixed volume of $P_1, \ldots, P_k$ times the Hodge vector of the projection of $Q$ along $U$. Here, the Hodge vector of a lattice polytope is its local $h^*$-vector with leading and trailing zeroes removed. This result allows finding infinitely many high-dimensional lattice polytopes with the same Hodge vector that are not free joins. The proof relies on a closed formula for the Hodge-Deligne polynomial of generic complete intersections in the torus in terms of the bivariate/mixed $h^*$-polynomial. A special case of our construction is what we call Lawrence twists: extending the Gale transform by centrally-symmetric pairs of vectors. As applications, we can produce many new thin polytopes answering a question by Borger, Kretschmer and the second author, and we provide an alternative explanation of the thinness of $B_k$-polytopes answering a question of Selyanin.

Assume that $n = 2k$ potential roommates each have an ordered preference of the $n-1$ others. A stable matching is a perfect matching of the $n$ roommates in which no two unmatched people prefer each other to their matched partners. In their seminal 1962 stable marriage paper, Gale and Shapley noted that not every instance of the stable roommates problem admits a stable matching. In the case when the preferences are chosen uniformly at random, Gusfield and Irving predicted in 1989 that there is no stable matching with high probability for large $n$. We prove this conjecture and show that for $n$ sufficiently large, the probability there is a stable matching is at most $n^{-1/17}$.

We study the \emph{Bipartite Degree Realization} (BDR) problem: given a graphic degree sequence $D$, decide whether it admits a realization as a bipartite graph. While bipartite realizability for a fixed vertex partition can be decided in polynomial time via the Gale--Ryser theorem, the computational complexity of BDR without a prescribed partition remains unresolved. We address this question through a parameterized analysis. For constants $0 \le c_1 \le c_2 \le 1$, we define $\mathrm{BDR}_{c_1,c_2}$ as the restriction of BDR to degree sequences of length $n$ whose degrees lie in the interval $[c_1 n, c_2 n]$. Our main result shows that $\mathrm{BDR}_{c_1,c_2}$ is solvable in polynomial time whenever $0 \le c_1 \le c_2 \le \frac{\sqrt{c_1(c_1+4)}-c_1}{2}$, as well as for all $c_1 > \tfrac12$. The proof relies on a reduction to extremal \emph{least balanced degree sequences} and a detailed verification of the critical Gale--Ryser inequalities, combined with a bounded subset-sum formulation. We further show that, assuming the NP-completeness of unrestricted BDR, the problem $\mathrm{BDR}_{c_1,c_2}$ remains NP-complete for all $0 < c_2 < \frac{1}{2}$ and $c_1 < 1 - c_2 - \sqrt{1-2c_2}$. % This establishes a sharp conditional boundary between tractable and intractable parameter regimes. Our results clarify the algorithmic landscape of bipartite degree realization and contribute to the broader study of potentially bipartite graphic degree sequences.

Generalizing a variety of earlier problems on stable contracts in two-sided markets, Alkan and Gale introduced in 2003 a general stability model on a bipartite graph $G=(V,E)$ in which the vertices are interpreted as ``agents'', and the edges as possible ``contract'' between pairs of ``agents''. The edges are endowed with nonnegative capacities $b$ giving upper bounds on ``contract intensities'', and the preferencies of each ``agent'' $v\in V$ depend on a \emph{choice function} (CFs) that acts on the set of ``contracts'' involving $v$, obeying three well motivated axioms of \it{consistence}, \it{substitutability} and \it{cardinal monotonicity}. In their model, the capacities and choice functions can take reals or discrete values and, extending well-known earlier results on particular cases, they proved that systems of \it{stable} contracts always exist and, moreover, their set $\cal S$ constitutes a distributive lattice under a natural comparison relation $\prec$. In this paper, we study Alkan--Gale's model when all capacities and choice functions take integer values. We characterize the set of rotations -- augmenting cycles linking neighboring stable assignments in the lattice $(\cal S,\prec)$, explain how to construct the rotations efficiently, and devise a weighted poset in which the lattice of closed functions is isomorphic to $(\cal S,\prec)$, thus obtaining an explicit representation for the latter. We show that in general the size of the poset is at most $b^{\rm max}|E|$, where $b^{\rm max}$ is the maximal capacity, and the poset can be constructed in pseudo polynomial time. Then we explain that by imposing an additional condition on CFs, the size of the poset becomes polynomial in $|V|$, and the total time reduces to a polynomial in $|V|,\log b^{\rm max}$.

A polytope is called indecomposable if it cannot be expressed (non-trivially) as a Minkowski sum of other polytopes. Since the concept was introduced by Gale in 1954, several increasingly strong criteria have been developed to characterize indecomposability. In this paper, we introduce a new indecomposability criterion that unifies and generalizes most existing approaches. The key new ingredient is the graph of (implicit) edge dependencies, which records proportionalities between edge lengths across deformations and has broader applications in the study of deformation cones of polytopes, beyond indecomposability. As a main application, we construct new indecomposable deformed permutahedra that are not matroid polytopes. In 1970, Edmonds posed the problem of characterizing the extreme rays of the submodular cone, equivalently, indecomposable deformed permutahedra. Matroid polytopes from connected matroids form a well-known family of such examples. We exhibit a new infinite family of indecomposable deformations of the permutahedron, disjoint from matroid polytopes, obtained by suitable truncations of vertices of certain graphical zonotopes. We further demonstrate the scope of our methods through several additional applications. In particular, we refute a conjecture by Smilansky (1987) asserting that indecomposable polytopes must have relatively few vertices compared to their number of facets. We also obtain new bounds on the dimensions of deformation cones and characterize certain of their extreme rays, introduce parallelogramic Minkowski sums whose deformation cones factor as products, and provide new constructions of indecomposable polytopes via truncations and stackings.

In 1962, Gale and Shapley \cite{GS} introduced the concept of stable marriages and proved their existence. Since then, the statement of the stability problem has been highly generalized. And a lot of proofs has emerged for the existence in these more general statements. It's time to review them and identify the similarities and differences. First, we will briefly discuss the classical case, because the existence proofs in the general case grew out of it. Or rather, from the idea of "deferred acceptance". When the best of the proposed contracts is temporarily retained until a better offer is received.

Zonotopal algebras, introduced by Postnikov--Shapiro--Shapiro, Ardila--Postnikov, and Holtz--Ron, show up in many different contexts, including approximation theory, representation theory, Donaldson--Thomas theory, and hypertoric geometry. In the first half of this paper, we construct a perfect pairing between the internal zonotopal algebra of a linear space and the reduced Orlik--Terao algebra of the Gale dual linear space. As an application, we prove a conjecture of Moseley--Proudfoot--Young that relates the reduced Orlik--Terao algebra of a graph to the cohomology of a certain configuration space. In the second half of the paper, we interpret the Macaulay inverse system of a zonotopal algebra as the space of sections of a sheaf on the Schubert variety of a linear space. As an application of this, we use an equivariant resolution of the structure sheaf of the Schubert variety inside of a product of projective lines to produce an exact sequence relating internal and external zonotopal algebras.

We study linear relations between face numbers of levels in arrangements. Let $V = \{ v_1, \ldots, v_n \} \subset \mathbf{R}^{r}$ be a vector configuration in general position, and let $\mathcal{A}(V)$ be polar dual arrangement of hemispheres in the $d$-dimensional unit sphere $S^d$, where $d=r-1$. For $0\leq s \leq d$ and $0 \leq t \leq n$, let $f_{s,t}(V)$ denote the number of faces of \emph{level} $t$ and dimension $d-s$ in the arrangement $\mathcal{A}(V)$ (these correspond to partitions $V=V_-\sqcup V_0 \sqcup V_+$ by linear hyperplanes with $|V_0|=s$ and $|V_-|=t$). We call the matrix $f(V):=[f_{s,t}(V)]$ the \emph{$f$-matrix} of $V$. Completing a long line of research on linear relations between face numbers of levels in arrangements, we determine, for every $n\geq r \geq 1$, the affine space $\mathfrak{F}_{n,r}$ spanned by the $f$-matrices of configurations of $n$ vectors in general position in $\mathbf{R}^r$; moreover, we determine the subspace $\mathfrak{F}^0_{n,r} \subset \mathfrak{F}_{n,r}$ spanned by all \emph{pointed} vector configurations (i.e., such that $V$ is contained in some open linear halfspace), which correspond to point sets in $\mathbf{R}^d$. This generalizes the classical fact that the Dehn--Sommerville relations generate all linear relations between the face numbers of simple polytopes (the faces at level $0$) and answers a question posed by Andrzejak and Welzl in 2003. The key notion for the statements and the proofs of our results is the $g$-matrix of a vector configuration, which determines the $f$-matrix and generalizes the classical $g$-vector of a polytope. By Gale duality, we also obtain analogous results for partitions of vector configurations by sign patterns of nontrivial linear dependencies, and for \emph{Radon partitions} of point sets in $\mathbf{R}^d$.

Levels and sublevels in arrangements -- and, dually, $k$-sets and $(\leq k)$-sets -- are fundamental notions in discrete and computational geometry and natural generalizations of convex polytopes, which correspond to the $0$-level. A long-standing conjecture of Eckhoff, Linhart, and Welzl, which would generalize McMullen's Upper Bound Theorem for polytopes and provide an exact refinement of asymptotic bounds by Clarkson, asserts that for all $k\leq \lfloor \frac{n-d-2}{2}\rfloor$, the number of $(\leq k)$-sets of a set $S$ of $n$ points in $\mathbf{R}^d$ is maximized if $S$ is the vertex set of a neighborly polytope. As a new tool for studying this conjecture and related problems, we introduce the $g$-matrix, which generalizes both the $g$-vector of a simple polytope and a Gale dual version of the $g$-vector studied by Lee and Welzl. Our main result is that the $g$-matrix of every vector configuration in $\mathbf{R}^3$ is non-negative, which implies the Eckhoff--Linhart--Welzl conjecture in the case where $d=n-4$. As a corollary, we obtain the following result about crossing numbers: Consider a configuration $V\subset S^2 \subset \mathbf{R}^3$ of $n$ unit vectors, and connect every pair of vectors by the unique shortest geodesic arc between them in the unit sphere $S^2$. This yields a drawing of the complete graph $K_n$ in $S^2$, which we call a spherical arc drawing. Complementing previous results for rectilinear drawings, we show that the number of crossings in any spherical arc drawing of $K_n$ is at least $\frac{1}{4}\lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor \lfloor \frac{n-1}{2}\rfloor \lfloor \frac{n-2}{2}\rfloor \lfloor \frac{n-3}{2}\rfloor$, which equals the conjectured value of the crossing number of $K_n$. Moreover, the lower bound is attained if $V$ is coneighborly, i.e., if every open linear halfspace contains at least $\lfloor (n-2)/2 \rfloor$ of the vectors in $V$.

The problem of realizing a given degree sequence by a multigraph can be thought of as a relaxation of the classical degree realization problem (where the realizing graph is simple). This paper concerns the case where the realizing multigraph is required to be bipartite. The problem of characterizing sequences that can be realized by a bipartite graph has two variants. In the simpler one, termed BDR$^P$, the partition of the sequence into two sides is given as part of the input. A complete characterization for realizability in this variant was given by Gale and Ryser over sixty years ago. However, the variant where the partition is not given, termed BDR, is still open. For bipartite multigraph realizations, there are also two variants. For BDR$^P$, where the partition is given as part of the input, a characterization was known for determining whether there is a multigraph realization whose underlying graph is bipartite, such that the maximum number of copies of an edge is at most $r$. We present a characterization for determining if there is a bipartite multigraph realization such that the total number of excess edges is at most $t$. We show that optimizing these two measures may lead to different realizations, and that optimizing by one measure may increase the other substantially. As for the variant BDR, where the partition is not given, we show that determining whether a given (single) sequence admits a bipartite multigraph realization is NP-hard. Moreover, we show that this hardness result extends to any graph family which is a sub-family of bipartite graphs and a super-family of paths. On the positive side, we provide an algorithm that computes optimal realizations for the case where the number of balanced partitions is polynomial, and present sufficient conditions for the existence of bipartite multigraph realizations that depend only on the largest degree of the sequence.

The Gale-Berlekamp switching game is played on the following device: $G_n=\{1,2,\ldots,n\} \times \{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ is an $n \times n$ array of lights is controlled by $2n$ switches, one for each row or column. Given an (arbitrary) initial configuration of the board, the objective is to have as many lights on as possible. Denoting the maximum difference (discrepancy) between the number of lights that are on minus the number of lights that are off by $F(n)$, it is known (Brown and Spencer, 1971) that $F(n)= Θ(n^{3/2})$, and more precisely, that $F(n) \geq \left( 1+ o(1) \right) \sqrt{\frac{2}π} n^{3/2} \approx 0.797 \ldots n^{3/2}$. Here we extend the game to other playing boards. For example: (i)~For any constant $c>1$, if $c n$ switches are conveniently chosen, then the maximum discrepancy for the square board is $Ω(n^{3/2})$. From the other direction, suppose we fix any set of $a$ column switches, $b$ row switches, where $a \geq b$ and $a+b=n$. Then the maximum discrepancy is at most $-b (n-b)$. (ii) A board $H \subset \{1,\ldots,n\}^2$, with area $A=|H|$, is \emph{dense} if $A \geq c (u+v)^2$, for some constant $c>0$, where $u= |\{x \colon (x,y) \in H\}|$ and $v=|\{y \colon (x,y) \in H\}|$. For a dense board of area $A$, we show that the maximum discrepancy is $Θ(A^{3/4})$. This result is a generalization of the Brown and Spencer result for the original game. (iii) If $H$ consists of the elements of $G_n$ below the hyperbola $xy=n$, then its maximum discrepancy is $Ω(n)$ and $O(n (\log n)^{1/2})$.

This article introduces the theory of Veronese polytopes, a broad generalisation of cyclic polytopes. These arise as convex hulls of points on curves with one or more connected components, obtained as the image of the rational normal curve in affine charts. We describe their facial structure by extending Gale's evenness condition, and provide a further combinatorial characterisation of facets via $σ$-parity alternating sequences. Notably, we establish a bijective correspondence between combinatorial types of Veronese polytopes and partitions of finite sets equipped with a cyclic order, called circular compositions. We show that, although the only Veronese $3$-polytopes are the cyclic $3$-polytopes and the octahedron, in general dimension they form a rich and diverse class including all combinatorial types of simplicial $d$-polytopes with at most $d+3$ vertices, the cross-polytope and particular stacked polytopes. In addition, we characterise which curves defining Veronese polytopes are $d$-order curves, and provide a closed formula for the number of facets of any Veronese polytope.

Equipartition theory, beginning with the classical ham sandwich theorem, seeks the fair division of finite point sets in $\mathbb{R}^d$ by the full-dimensional regions determined by a prescribed geometric dissection of $\mathbb{R}^d$. Here we examine $\textit{equidistributions}$ of finite point sets in $\mathbb{R}^d$ by prescribed $\textit{low dimensional}$ subsets. Our main result states that if $r\geq 3$ is a prime power, then for any $m$-coloring of a sufficiently small point set $X$ in $\mathbb{R}^d$, there exists an $r$-fan in $\mathbb{R}^d$ -- that is, the union of $r$ ``half-flats'' of codimension $r-2$ centered about a common $(r-1)$-codimensional affine subspace -- which captures all the points of $X$ in such a way that each half-flat contains at most an $r$-th of the points from each color class. The number of points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ we require for this is essentially tight when $m\geq 2$. Additionally, we extend our equidistribution results to ''piercing'' distributions in a similar fashion to Dolnikov's hyperplane transversal generalization of the ham sandwich theorem. By analogy with recent work of Frick et al., our results are obtained by applying Gale duality to linear cases of topological Tverberg-type theorems. Finally, we extend our distribution results to multiple $r$-fans after establishing a multiple intersection version of a topological Tverberg-type theorem due to Sarkaria.