arXiv++ Combinatorics

The paper suggests a family of paired comparison-based scoring procedures for ranking the participants of a Swiss system chess team tournament. We present the challenges of ranking in Swiss system, the features of individual and team competitions as well as the failures of the official rankings based on lexicographical order. The tournament is represented as a ranking problem such that the linearly-solvable row sum (score), generalized row sum, and least squares methods have favourable axiomatic properties. Two chess team European championships are analysed as case studies. Final rankings are compared by their distances and visualized with multidimensional scaling (MDS). Differences to the official ranking are revealed by the decomposition of the least squares method. Rankings are evaluated by prediction power, retrodictive performance, and stability. The paper argues for the use of least squares method with a results matrix favouring match points on the basis of its relative insensitivity to the choice between match and board points, retrodictive accuracy, and robustness.

Ladder tournaments are widely used to rank individuals in real-world organizations and games. Their mathematical properties however are still poorly understood. We formalize the ranking rule generated by a ladder tournament, and we show that it is neither complete nor transitive in general. If it is complete, then it is transitive and its asymmetric component is a finite union of transitive tournaments. We also study the relationship between an individual's rank and his performance as measured by the frequency at which he is pivotal. We show an individual's pivotability is a weakly increasing function of his rank.

We propose a purely combinatorial quadratic time algorithm that for any $n$-vertex $P_{k}$-free tournament $T$, where $P_{k}$ is a directed path of length $k$, finds in $T$ a transitive subset of order $n^{\frac{c}{k\log(k)^{2}}}$. As a byproduct of our method, we obtain subcubic $O(n^{1-\frac{c}{k\log(k)^{2}}})$-approximation algorithm for the optimal acyclic coloring problem on $P_{k}$-free tournaments. Our results are tight up to the $\log(k)$-factor in the following sense: there exist infinite families of $P_{k}$-free tournaments with largest transitive subsets of order at most $n^{\frac{c\log(k)}{k}}$. As a corollary, we give tight asymptotic results regarding the so-called \textit{Erdős-Hajnal coefficients} of directed paths. These are some of the first asymptotic results on these coefficients for infinite families of prime graphs.

We prove that the proof of existence of weighted local median order of weighted tournaments is wrong and that the proof of the correct statement which asserts that every digraph obtained from a tournament by deleting a set of arcs incident to the same vertex contains a mistake, in the paper entitled "Remarks on the second neighborhood problem". We introduce correct proofs of each.

Moser asked for a construction of explicit tournaments on $n$ vertices having at least $(\frac{n}{3e})^n$ Hamilton cycles. We show that he could have asked for rather more.

Starting from an innocent Ramsey-theoretic question regarding directed paths in tournaments, we discover a series of rich and surprising connections that lead into the theory around a fundamental problem in Combinatorics: the Ruzsa-Szemerédi induced matching problem. Using these relationships, we prove that every coloring of the edges of the transitive $n$-vertex tournament using three colors contains a directed path of length at least $\sqrt{n} \cdot e^{\log^* n}$ which entirely avoids some color. We also expose connections to a family of constructions for Ramsey tournaments, and introduce and resolve some natural generalizations of the Ruzsa-Szemerédi problem which we encounter through our investigation.

We study the density of fixed strongly connected subtournaments on 5 vertices in large tournaments. We determine the maximum density asymptotically for five tournaments as well as unique extremal sequences for each tournament. As a byproduct we also characterize tournaments that are recursive blow-ups of a 3-cycle as tournaments that avoid three specific tournaments of size 5.

An arc-coloured digraph $D$ is said to be \emph{rainbow connected} if for every two vertices $u$ and $v$ there is an $uv$-path all whose arcs have different colours. The minimun number of colours required to make the digraph rainbow connected is called the \emph{rainbow connection number} of $D$, denoted $\stackrel{\rightarrow}{rc}(D)$. In \cite{Dorbec} it was showed that if $T$ is a strong tournament with $n\geq 5$ vertices, then $2\leq \stackrel{\rightarrow}{rc}(T)\leq n-1$; and that for every $n$ and $k$ such that $3\leq k\leq n-1$, there exists a tournament $T$ on $n$ vertices such that $\stackrel{\rightarrow}{rc}(T)=k$. In this note it is showed that for any $n\ge6$, there is a tournament $T$ of $n$ vertices such that $\stackrel{\rightarrow}{rc}(T)=2$.

Coloring graphs is an important algorithmic problem in combinatorics with many applications in computer science. In this paper we study coloring tournaments. A chromatic number of a random tournament is of order $Ω(\frac{n}{\log(n)})$. The question arises whether the chromatic number can be proven to be smaller for more structured nontrivial classes of tournaments. We analyze the class of tournaments defined by a forbidden subtournament $H$. This paper gives a first quasi-polynomial algorithm running in time $e^{O(\log(n)^{2})}$ that constructs colorings of $H$-free tournaments using only $O(n^{1-ε(H)}\log(n))$ colors, where $ε(H) \geq 2^{-2^{50|H|^{2}+1}}$ for many forbidden tournaments $H$. To the best of our knowledge all previously known related results required at least sub-exponential time and relied on the regularity lemma. Since we do not use the regularity lemma, we obtain the first known lower bounds on $ε(H)$ that can be given by a closed-form expression. As a corollary, we give a constructive proof of the celebrated open Erdős-Hajnal conjecture with explicitly given lower bounds on the EH coefficients for all classes of prime tournaments for which the conjecture is known. Such a constractive proof was not known before. Thus we significantly reduce the gap between best lower and upper bounds on the EH coefficients from the conjecture for all known prime tournaments that satisfy it. We also briefly explain how our methods may be used for coloring $H$-free tournaments under the following conditions: $H$ is any tournament with $\leq 5$ vertices or: $H$ is any but one tournament of six vertices.

A tournament is called locally transitive if the outneighbourhood and the inneighbourhood of every vertex are transitive. Equivalently, a tournament is locally transitive if it avoids the tournaments $W_4$ and $L_4$, which are the only tournaments up to isomorphism on four vertices containing a unique $3$-cycle. On the other hand, a sequence of tournaments $(T_n)_{n\in\mathbb{N}}$ with $|V(T_n)| = n$ is called almost balanced if all but $o(n)$ vertices of $T_n$ have outdegree $(1/2 + o(1))n$. In the same spirit of quasi-random properties, we present several characterizations of tournament sequences that are both almost balanced and asymptotically locally transitive in the sense that the density of $W_4$ and $L_4$ in $T_n$ goes to zero as $n$ goes to infinity.

We study the Maker-Breaker tournament game played on the edge set of a given graph $G$. Two players, Maker and Breaker claim unclaimed edges of $G$ in turns, and Maker wins if by the end of the game she claims all the edges of a pre-defined goal tournament. Given a tournament $T_k$ on $k$ vertices, we determine the threshold bias for the $(1:b)$ $T_k$-tournament game on $K_n$. We also look at the $(1:1)$ $T_k$-tournament game played on the edge set of a random graph ${\mathcal{G}_{n,p}}$ and determine the threshold probability for Maker's win. We compare these games with the clique game and discuss whether a random graph intuition is satisfied.

A finite set $X$ in a complex sphere is called a complex spherical $2$-code if the number of inner products between two distinct vectors in $X$ is equal to $2$. In this paper, we characterize the tight complex spherical $2$-codes by doubly regular tournaments, or skew Hadamard matrices. We also give certain maximal 2-codes relating to skew-symmetric $D$-optimal designs. To prove them, we show the smallest embedding dimension of a tournament into a complex sphere by the multiplicity of the smallest or second-smallest eigenvalue of the Seidel matrix.

We describe a round robin scheduling problem for a competition played in two divisions, motivated by a scheduling problem brought to the second author by a local sports organisation. The first division has teams from 2n clubs, and is played in a double round robin in which the draw for the second round robin is identical to the first. The second division has teams from two additional clubs, and is played as a single round robin during the first 2n+1 rounds of the first division. We will say that two clubs have a **common fixture** if their teams in division one and two are scheduled to play each other in the same round, and show that for n>1 the maximum possible number of common fixtures is 2n^2 - 3n + 4. Our construction of draws achieving this maximum is based on a bipyramidal one-factorisation of K_{2n}, which represents the draw in division one. Moreover, if we additionally require the home and away status of common fixtures to be the same in both divisions, we show that the draw can be chosen to be balanced in all three round robins.

Let $D_k$ denote the tournament on $3k$ vertices consisting of three disjoint vertex classes $V_1, V_2$ and $V_3$ of size $k$, each of which is oriented as a transitive subtournament, and with edges directed from $V_1$ to $V_2$, from $V_2$ to $V_3$ and from $V_3$ to $V_1$. Fox and Sudakov proved that given a natural number $k$ and $ε> 0$ there is $n_0(k,ε)$ such that every tournament of order $n_0(k,ε)$ which is $ε$-far from being transitive contains $D_k$ as a subtournament. Their proof showed that $n_0(k,ε) \leq ε^{-O(k/ε^2)}$ and they conjectured that this could be reduced to $n_0(k,ε) \leq ε^{-O(k)}$. Here we prove this conjecture.

Seymour's distance two conjecture states that in any digraph there exists a vertex (a "Seymour vertex") that has at least as many neighbors at distance two as it does at distance one. We explore the validity of probabilistic statements along lines suggested by Seymour's conjecture, proving that almost surely there are a "large" number of Seymour vertices in random tournaments and "even more" in general random digraphs.

We consider the following Turán-type problem: given a fixed tournament $H$, what is the least integer $t=t(n,H)$ so that adding $t$ edges to any $n$-vertex tournament, results in a digraph containing a copy of $H$. Similarly, what is the least integer $t=t(T_n,H)$ so that adding $t$ edges to the $n$-vertex transitive tournament, results in a digraph containing a copy of $H$. Besides proving several results on these problems, our main contributions are the following: (1) Pach and Tardos conjectured that if $M$ is an acyclic $0/1$ matrix, then any $n \times n$ matrix with $n(\log n)^{O(1)}$ entries equal to $1$ contains the pattern $M$. We show that this conjecture is equivalent to the assertion that $t(T_n,H)=n(\log n)^{O(1)}$ if and only if $H$ belongs to a certain (natural) family of tournaments. (2) We propose an approach for determining if $t(n,H)=n(\log n)^{O(1)}$. This approach combines expansion in sparse graphs, together with certain structural characterizations of $H$-free tournaments. Our result opens the door for using structural graph theoretic tools in order to settle the Pach-Tardos conjecture.

We give several results showing that different discrete structures typically gain certain spanning substructures (in particular, Hamilton cycles) after a modest random perturbation. First, we prove that adding linearly many random edges to a dense k-uniform hypergraph ensures the (asymptotically almost sure) existence of a perfect matching or a loose Hamilton cycle. The proof involves an interesting application of Szemerédi's Regularity Lemma, which might be independently useful. We next prove that digraphs with certain strong expansion properties are pancyclic, and use this to show that adding a linear number of random edges typically makes a dense digraph pancyclic. Finally, we prove that perturbing a certain (minimum-degree-dependent) number of random edges in a tournament typically ensures the existence of multiple edge-disjoint Hamilton cycles. All our results are tight.

We prove that for every fixed $k$, the number of occurrences of the transitive tournament $Tr_k$ of order $k$ in a tournament $T_n$ on $n$ vertices is asymptotically minimized when $T_n$ is random. In the opposite direction, we show that any sequence of tournaments $\{T_n\}$ achieving this minimum for any fixed $k\geq 4$ is necessarily quasi-random. We present several other characterizations of quasi-random tournaments nicely complementing previously known results and relatively easily following from our proof techniques.

We say that a graph $G$ has a perfect $H$-packing if there exists a set of vertex-disjoint copies of $H$ which cover all the vertices in $G$. The seminal Hajnal--Szemerédi theorem characterises the minimum degree that ensures a graph $G$ contains a perfect $K_r$-packing. Balogh, Kostochka and Treglown proposed a degree sequence version of the Hajnal--Szemerédi theorem which, if true, gives a strengthening of the Hajnal--Szemerédi theorem. In this paper we prove this conjecture asymptotically. Another fundamental result in the area is the Alon--Yuster theorem which gives a minimum degree condition that ensures a graph contains a perfect $H$-packing for an \emph{arbitrary} graph $H$. We give a wide-reaching generalisation of this result by answering another conjecture of Balogh, Kostochka and Treglown on the degree sequence of a graph that forces a perfect $H$-packing. We also prove a degree sequence result concerning perfect transitive tournament packings in directed graphs. The proofs blend together the regularity and absorbing methods.

We study the class of 1-perfectly orientable graphs, that is, graphs having an orientation in which every out-neighborhood induces a tournament. 1-perfectly orientable graphs form a common generalization of chordal graphs and circular arc graphs. Even though they can be recognized in polynomial time, little is known about their structure. In this paper, we develop several results on 1-perfectly orientable graphs. In particular, we: (i) give a characterization of 1-perfectly orientable graphs in terms of edge clique covers, (ii) identify several graph transformations preserving the class of 1-perfectly orientable graphs, (iii) exhibit an infinite family of minimal forbidden induced minors for the class of 1-perfectly orientable graphs, and (iv) characterize the class of 1-perfectly orientable graphs within the classes of cographs and of cobipartite graphs. The class of 1-perfectly orientable co-bipartite graphs coincides with the class of co-bipartite circular arc graphs.