arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove the following conjecture of Leighton and Moitra. Let $T$ be a tournament on $[n]$ and $S_n$ the set of permutations of $[n]$. For an arc $uv$ of $T$, let $A_{uv}=\{σ\in S_n \, : \, σ(u)<σ(v) \}$. $\textbf{Theorem.}$ For a fixed $\varepsilon>0$, if $\mathbb{P}$ is a probability distribution on $S_n$ such that $\mathbb{P}(A_{uv})>1/2+\varepsilon$ for every arc $uv$ of $T$, then the binary entropy of $\mathbb{P}$ is at most $(1-\vartheta_{\varepsilon})\log_2 n!$ for some (fixed) positive $\vartheta_\varepsilon$. When $T$ is transitive the theorem is due to Leighton and Moitra; for this case we give a short proof with a better $\vartheta_\varepsilon$.

Fox--Grinshpun--Pach showed that every $3$-coloring of the complete graph on $n$ vertices without a rainbow triangle contains a clique of size $Ω\left(n^{1/3}\log^2 n\right)$ which uses at most two colors, and this bound is tight up to the constant factor. We show that if instead of looking for large cliques one only tries to find subgraphs of large chromatic number, one can do much better. We show that every such coloring contains a $2$-colored subgraph with chromatic number at least $n^{2/3}$, and this is best possible. We further show that for fixed positive integers $s,r$ with $s\leq r$, every $r$-coloring of the edges of the complete graph on $n$ vertices without a rainbow triangle contains a subgraph that uses at most $s$ colors and has chromatic number at least $n^{s/r}$, and this is best possible. Fox--Grinshpun--Pach previously showed a clique version of this result. As a direct corollary of our result we obtain a generalisation of the celebrated theorem of Erdős-Szekeres, which states that any sequence of $n$ numbers contains a monotone subsequence of length at least $\sqrt{n}$. We prove that if an $r$-coloring of the edges of an $n$-vertex tournament does not contain a rainbow triangle then there is an $s$-colored directed path on $n^{s/r}$ vertices, which is best possible. This gives a partial answer to a question of Loh.

Motivated by known results for finite tournaments, we define and study the score functions of tournament kernels and the degree distributions of tournament limits. Our main theorem completely characterises those distributions that appear as the degree distribution of some tournament limit and those functions that appear as the score function of some tournament kernel. We also show that only the uniform distribution can be realised as the outdegree distribution of a unique tournament limit. Finally we define self-converse tournament limits and kernels and characterise their degree distributions and score functions.

We study some problems pertaining to the tournament equilibrium set (TEQ for short). A tournament $H$ is a TEQ-retentive tournament if there is a tournament $T$ which has a minimal TEQ-retentive set $R$ such that $T[R]$ is isomorphic to $H$. We study TEQ-retentive tournaments and achieve many significant results. In particular, we prove that there are no TEQ-retentive tournaments of size 4, only 2 non-isomorphic TEQ-retentive tournaments of sizes 5 and 6, respectively, and 26 non-isomorphic TEQ-retentive tournaments of size 7. For three tournaments $H_1, H_2$ and $T$, we say $T$ is a $(H_1,H_2)$-TEQ-retentive tournament if $T$ has two minimal TEQ-retentive sets $R_1$ and $R_2$ such that $T[R_1]$ and $T[R_2]$ are isomorphic to $H_1$ and $H_2$, respectively. We show that there are no $(H_1,H_2)$-retentive tournaments for $H_1$ and $H_2$ being small tournaments. Our results imply that Schwartz's Conjecture holds in all tournaments of size at most 14. Finally, we study Schwartz's Conjecture in several classes of tournaments. To achieve these results, we study the relation between (directed) domination graphs of tournaments and TEQ-retentive sets, and derive a number of properties on minimal TEQ-retentive sets.

A $\overrightarrow{P_{3}}$-decomposition of a directed graph $D$ is a partition of the arcs of $D$ into directed paths of length $2$. In this paper, we give a characterization for a tournament and a bipartite digraph admitting a $\overrightarrow{P_{3}}$-decomposition. This solves a problem posed by Diwan ($\overrightarrow{P_{3}}$-decomposition of directed graphs, Discrete Appl. Math., http:// dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.dam.2016.01.039.).

In this paper, we study $(1,2)$-step competition graphs of bipartite tournaments. A bipartite tournament means an orientation of a complete bipartite graph. We show that the $(1,2)$-step competition graph of a bipartite tournament has at most one non-trivial component or consists of exactly two complete components of size at least three and, especially in the former, the diameter of the nontrivial component is at most three if it exists. Based on this result, we show that, among the connected non-complete graphs which are triangle-free or the cycles of which are edge-disjoint, $K_{1,4}$ is the only graph that can be represented as the $(1,2)$-step competition graph of a bipartite tournament. We also completely characterize a complete graph and the disjoint union of two complete graphs, respectively, which can be represented as the $(1,2)$-step competition graph of a bipartite tournament. Finally we present the maximum number of edges and the minimum number of edges which the $(1,2)$-step competition graph of a bipartite tournament might have.

In this paper we consider the question of well quasi-order for classes defined by a single obstruction within the classes of all graphs, digraphs and tournaments, under the homomorphic image ordering (in both its standard and strong forms). The homomorphic image ordering was introduced by the authors in a previous paper and corresponds to the existence of a surjective homomorphism between two structures. We obtain complete characterizations in all cases except for graphs under the strong ordering, where some open questions remain.

In this paper, we give a direct construction for a set of dice realizing any given tournament $T$. The construction for a tournament with $n$ vertices requires a number of sides on the order of $n$, which appears to be the best general construction to date. Our construction relies only on a standard theorem from graph theory.

In 1985, Mader conjectured the existence of a function $f$ such that every digraph with minimum out-degree at least $f(k)$ contains a subdivision of the transitive tournament of order $k$. This conjecture is still completely open, as the existence of $f(5)$ remains unknown. In this paper, we show that if $D$ is an oriented path, or an in-arborescence (i.e., a tree with all edges oriented towards the root) or the union of two directed paths from $x$ to $y$ and a directed path from $y$ to $x$, then every digraph with minimum out-degree large enough contains a subdivision of $D$. Additionally, we study Mader's conjecture considering another graph parameter. The dichromatic number of a digraph $D$ is the smallest integer $k$ such that $D$ can be partitioned into $k$ acyclic subdigraphs. We show that any digraph with dichromatic number greater than $4^m (n-1)$ contains every digraph with $n$ vertices and $m$ arcs as a subdivision.

A Hamilton cycle in a directed graph $G$ is a cycle that passes through every vertex of $G$. A Hamiltonian decomposition of $G$ is a partition of its edge set into disjoint Hamilton cycles. In the late $60$s Kelly conjectured that every regular tournament has a Hamilton decomposition. This conjecture was recently settled by Kühn and Osthus, who proved more generally that every $r$-regular $n$-vertex oriented graph $G$ (without antiparallel edges) with $r=cn$ for some fixed $c>3/8$ has a Hamiltonian decomposition, provided $n=n(c)$ is sufficiently large. In this paper we address the natural question of estimating the number of such decompositions of $G$ and show that this number is $n^{(1-o(1))cn^2}$. In addition, we also obtain a new and much simpler proof for the approximate version of Kelly's conjecture.

We provide an algorithm with constant running time that given a weighted tournament $T$, distinguishes with high probability of success between the cases that $T$ can be represented by a Bradley--Terry model, or cannot even be approximated by one. The same algorithm tests whether the corresponding Markov chain is reversible.

An oriented tree $T$ on $n$ vertices is unavoidable if every tournament on $n$ vertices contains a copy of $T$. In this paper we give a sufficient condition for $T$ to be unavoidable, and use this to prove that almost all labelled oriented trees are unavoidable, verifying a conjecture of Bender and Wormald. We additionally prove that every tournament on $n + o(n)$ vertices contains a copy of every oriented tree $T$ on $n$ vertices with polylogarithmic maximum degree, improving a result of Kühn, Mycroft and Osthus.

We discuss two approaches to a recent question of Loh: must a 3-colored transitive tournament on $N$ vertices have a 1-color-\emph{avoiding} path of vertex-length at least $N^{2/3}$? This question generalizes the Erdős--Szekeres theorem on monotone subsequences. First, we define three canonical transformations on these tournaments called Color, Record, and Dual. We use these to establish a reduction to special tournaments with natural geometric and combinatorial properties. In many cases (including all known tight examples), these tournaments have recursive Gallai decompositions. Not all relevant tournaments have Gallai decompositions, but those that do satisfy the desired $N^{2/3}$ bound by recent work of Wagner, roughly analogous to earlier work of Fox, Grinshpun, and Pach on a similar \emph{undirected} problem. Second, we consider the related geometric problem of bounding \emph{slice-increasing} sets $S\subseteq [n]^3$, which---under an additional ordering hypothesis on $S$---was shown by Loh to be equivalent to the original question. In particular, we establish a rigorous connection from a problem of Szabó and Tardos, raise a stronger $L^2$-question on slice-counts, and mention a surprising overlap with the joints problem.

We introduce the $(j,k)$-Kemeny rule -- a generalization of Kemeny's voting rule that aggregates $j$-chotomous weak orders into a $k$-chotomous weak order. Special cases of $(j,k)$-Kemeny include approval voting, the mean rule and Borda mean rule, as well as the Borda count and plurality voting. Why, then, is the winner problem computationally tractable for each of these other rules, but intractable for Kemeny? We show that intractability of winner determination for the $(j,k)$-Kemeny rule first appears at the $j=3$, $k=3$ level. The proof rests on a reduction of max cut to a related problem on weighted tournaments, and reveals that computational complexity arises from the cyclic part in the fundamental decomposition of a weighted tournament into cyclic and cocyclic components. Thus the existence of majority cycles -- the engine driving both Arrow's impossibility theorem and the Gibbard-Satterthwaite theorem -- also serves as a source of computational complexity in social choice.

In recent breakthrough results, Saxton--Thomason and Balogh--Morris--Samotij have developed powerful theories of hypergraph containers. These theories have led to a large number of new results on transference, and on counting and characterising typical graphs in hereditary properties. In a different direction, Hatami--Janson--Szegedy proved results on the entropy of graph limits which count and characterise graphs in dense hereditary properties. In this paper, we make a threefold contribution to this area of research: 1) We generalise results of Saxton--Thomason to obtain container theorems for general, dense hereditary properties of multicoloured graphs. Our main tool is the adoption of an entropy-based framework. As corollaries, we obtain general counting, characterization and transference results. We further extend our results to cover a variety of combinatorial structures: directed graphs, oriented graphs, tournaments, multipartite graphs, multi-graphs, hypercubes and hypergraphs. 2) We generalise the results of Hatami--Janson--Szegedy on the entropy of graph limits to the setting of decorated graph limits. In particular we define a cut norm for decorated graph limits and prove compactness of the space of decorated graph limits under that norm. 3) We explore a weak equivalence between the container and graph limit approaches to counting and characterising graphs in hereditary properties. In one direction, we show how our multicolour container results may be used to recover decorated versions of the results of Hatami--Janson--Szegedy. In the other direction, we show that our decorated extensions of Hatami--Janson--Szegedy's results on graph limits imply counting and characterization applications. Similar container results were recently obtained independently by Terry.

For a $k$-uniform hypergraph $F$ let $\textrm{ex}(n,F)$ be the maximum number of edges of a $k$-uniform $n$-vertex hypergraph $H$ which contains no copy of $F$. Determining or estimating $\textrm{ex}(n,F)$ is a classical and central problem in extremal combinatorics. While for $k=2$ this problem is well understood, due to the work of Turán and of Erdős and Stone, only very little is known for $k$-uniform hypergraphs for $k>2$. We focus on the case when $F$ is a $k$-uniform hypergraph with three edges on $k+1$ vertices. Already this very innocent (and maybe somewhat particular looking) problem is still wide open even for $k=3$. We consider a variant of the problem where the large hypergraph $H$ enjoys additional hereditary density conditions. Questions of this type were suggested by Erd\H os and Sós about 30 years ago. We show that every $k$-uniform hypergraph $H$ with density $>2^{1-k}$ with respect to every large collections of $k$-cliques induced by sets of $(k-2)$-tuples contains a copy of $F$. The required density $2^{1-k}$ is best possible as higher order tournament constructions show. Our result can be viewed as a common generalisation of the first extremal result in graph theory due to Mantel (when $k=2$ and the hereditary density condition reduces to a normal density condition) and a recent result of Glebov, Král', and Volec (when $k=3$ and large subsets of vertices of $H$ induce a subhypergraph of density $>1/4$). Our proof for arbitrary $k\geq 2$ utilises the regularity method for hypergraphs.

The converse of a tournament is obtained by reversing all arcs. If a tournament is isomorphic to its converse, it is called self--converse. Eplett provided a necessary and sufficient condition for a sequence of integers to be realisable as the score sequence of a self--converse tournament. In this paper we extend this result to generalised tournaments.

Landau \cite{Landau1953} showed that a sequence $(d_i)_{i=1}^n$ of integers is the score sequence of some tournament if and only if $\sum_{i\in J}d_i \geq \binom{|J|}{2}$ for all $J\subseteq \{1,2,\dots, n\}$, with equality if $|J|=n$. Moon \cite{Moon63} extended this result to generalised tournaments. We show how Moon's result can be derived from Landau's result.

In this paper, we consider upper bounds on the size of transitive subtournaments in a digraph. In particular, we give an analogy of Hoffman's bound for the size of cocliques in a regular graph. Furthermore, we partially improve the Hoffman type bound for doubly regular tournaments by using the technique of Greaves and Soicher for strongly regular graphs [4], which gives a new application of block intersection polynomials.

The theory of tournament limits and tournament kernels (often called graphons) is developed by extending common notions for finite tournaments to this setting; in particular we study transitivity and irreducibility of limits and kernels. We prove that each tournament kernel and each tournament limit can be decomposed into a direct sum of irreducible components, with transitive components interlaced. We also show that this decomposition is essentially unique.