arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1981 Beck and Fiala proved an upper bound for the discrepancy of a set system of degree d that is independent of the size of the ground set. In the intervening years the bound has been decreased from 2d-2 to 2d-4. We improve the bound to 2d-log* d.

We give the following extension of Barany's colorful Caratheodory theorem: Let M be an oriented matroid and N a matroid with rank function r, both defined on the same ground set V and satisfying rank(M) < rank(N). If every subset A of V with r(V - A) < rank (M) contains a positive circuit of M, then some independent set of N contains a positive circuit of M.

The pinched Veronese poset $V^*_n$ is the poset with ground set consisting of all non-negative integer vectors of length n such that the sum of their coordinates is divisible by $n$ with exception of the vector $(1,...,1)$. For two vectors $a$ and $b$ in $V^*_n$ we have $a \leq b$ if and only if $b - a$ belongs to the ground set of $V^*_n$. We show that every interval in $V^*_n$ is shellable for $n$ at least 4. In order to obtain the result, we develop a new method for showing that a poset is shellable. This method differs from classical lexicographic shellability. Shellability of intervals in $V^*_n$ has consequences in commutative algebra. As a corollary we obtain a combinatorial proof of the fact that the pinched Veronese ring is Koszul for $n \geq 4$. (This also follows from a result by Conca, Herzog, Trung and Valla.)

We prove that on the set of lattice paths with steps N=(0,1) and E=(1,0) that lie between two fixed boundaries T and B (which are themselves lattice paths), the statistics `number of E steps shared with B' and `number of E steps shared with T' have a symmetric joint distribution. To do so, we give an involution that switches these statistics, preserves additional parameters, and generalizes to paths that contain steps S=(0,-1) at prescribed x-coordinates. We also show that a similar equidistribution result for path statistics follows from the fact that the Tutte polynomial of a matroid is independent of the order of its ground set. We extend the two theorems to k-tuples of paths between two boundaries, and we give some applications to Dyck paths, generalizing a result of Deutsch, to watermelon configurations, to pattern-avoiding permutations, and to the generalized Tamari lattice. Finally, we prove a conjecture of Nicolás about the distribution of degrees of k consecutive vertices in k-triangulations of a convex n-gon. To achieve this goal, we provide a new statistic-preserving bijection between certain k-tuples of non-crossing paths and k-flagged semistandard Young tableaux, which is based on local moves reminiscent of jeu de taquin.

We define a partial ordering on the set Q = Q(M) of pairs of topes of an oriented matroid M, and show the geometric realization |Q| of the order complex of Q has the same homotopy type as the Salvetti complex of M. For any element e of the ground set, the complex |Qe| associated to the rank-one oriented matroid on {e} has the homotopy type of the circle. There is a natural free simplicial action of Z4 on |Q|, with orbit space isomorphic to the order complex of the poset Q(M,e) associated to the pointed (or affine) oriented matroid (M,e). If M is the oriented matroid of an arrangement A of linear hyperplanes in real space, the Z_4 action corresponds to the diagonal action of C* on the complement M of the complexification of A: |Q| is equivariantly homotopy-equivalent to M under the identification of Z_4 with {+1, i, -1, -i}, and |Q(M, e)| is homotopy-equivalent to the complement of the decone of A relative to the hyperplane corresponding to e. All constructions and arguments are carried out at the level of the underlying posets. If a group G acts on the set of topes of M preserving adjacency, then G acts simplicially on |Q|. We also show that the class of fundamental groups of such complexes is strictly larger than the class of fundamental groups of complements of complex hyperplane arrangements. Specifically, the group of the non-Pappus arrange- ment is not isomorphic to any realizable arrangement group.

Let $M$ be a representable matroid, and $Q, R, S, T$ subsets of the ground set. We prove that, if $M$ is sufficiently large, then there is an element $e$ such that deleting or contracting $e$ preserves both the $Q$-$R$ and the $S$-$T$ connectivities. For matroids representable over a finite field we prove a stronger result: we show that we can remove $e$ such that both a connectivity and a minor of $M$ are preserved.

If V(R) is the vertex sequence of a symmetric cycle R in the tope graph of a simple acyclic oriented matroid M on a t-element ground set, then the set min V(R) of minimal elements in the subposet V(R) of the tope poset of M, based at the positive tope, is a critical committee for M that votes for the base tope. We consider the sequence zR of poset ranks of the elements from the vertex sequence of R as a fragment of a signal with period 2t and relate the number of members of the committee min V(R) to the magnitudes of [t/2] components, with odd indices, of the discrete Fourier transform of the distance vector zR.

A coloring of a matroid is proper if elements of the same color form an independent set. For a loopless matroid M, its chromatic number χ(M) is the minimum number of colors that suffices to color properly the ground set E of M. In this note we study a game-theoretic variant of this parameter proposed by Grytczuk. Suppose that in each round of the game Alice indicates an uncolored yet element e of E, then Bob colors it using a color from a fixed set of colors C. The rule Bob has to obey is that it is a proper coloring. The game ends if the whole matroid has been colored or if Bob can not color e using any color of C. Alice wins in the first case, while Bob in the second. The minimum size of the set of colors C for which Alice has a winning strategy is called the indicated chromatic number of M, denoted by χ_i(M). We prove that χ_i(M)=χ(M).

A coloring of the ground set of a matroid is proper if elements of the same color form an independent set. For a loopless matroid $M$, its chromatic number $χ(M)$ is the minimum number of colors in a proper coloring. In this note we study a game-theoretic variant of this parameter. Suppose that Alice and Bob alternately properly color the ground set of a matroid $M$ using a fixed set of colors. The game ends when the whole matroid has been colored, or if they arrive to a partial coloring that cannot be further properly extended. Alice wins in the first case, while Bob in the second. The game chromatic number of $M$, denoted by $χ_{g}(M)$, is the minimum size of the set of colors for which Alice has a winning strategy. Clearly, $χ_{g}(M)\geqχ(M)$. We prove an upper bound $χ_{g}(M)\leq 2χ(M)$ for every matroid $M$. This improves and extends a result of Bartnicki, Grytczuk and Kierstead, who showed that $χ_{g}(M)\leq 3χ(M)$ holds for graphic matroids. Our bound is almost tight, as we construct a family of matroids $M_k$ (for $k\geq 3$) satisfying $χ(M_k)=k$ and $χ_{g}(M_k)=2k-1$.

Consider families of $k$-subsets (or blocks) on a ground set of size $v$. Recall that if all $t$-subsets occur with the same frequency $λ$, one obtains a $t$-design with index $λ$. On the other hand, if all $t$-subsets occur with different frequencies, such a family has been called (by Sarvate and others) a $t$-adesign. An elementary observation shows that such families always exist for $v > k \ge t$. Here, we study the smallest possible maximum frequency $μ=μ(t,k,v)$. The exact value of $μ$ is noted for $t=1$ and an upper bound (best possible up to a constant multiple) is obtained for $t=2$ using PBD closure. Weaker, yet still reasonable asymptotic bounds on $μ$ for higher $t$ follow from a probabilistic argument. Some connections are made with the famous Sidon problem of additive number theory.

We introduce the notion of a matroid M over a commutative ring R, assigning to every subset of the ground set an R-module according to some axioms. When R is a field, we recover matroids. When R=$\mathbb{Z}$, and when R is a DVR, we get (structures which contain all the data of) quasi-arithmetic matroids, and valuated matroids i.e. tropical linear spaces, respectively. More generally, whenever R is a Dedekind domain, we extend all the usual properties and operations holding for matroids (e.g., duality), and we explicitly describe the structure of the matroids over R. Furthermore, we compute the Tutte-Grothendieck ring of matroids over R. We also show that the Tutte quasi-polynomial of a matroid over $\mathbb{Z}$ can be obtained as an evaluation of the class of the matroid in the Tutte-Grothendieck ring.

A family $\cF\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ of sets is said to be $l$-trace $k$-Sperner if for any $l$-subset $L \subset [n]$ the family $\cF|_L=\{F|_L:F \in \cF\}=\{F \cap L: F \in \cF\}$ is $k$-Sperner, i.e. does not contain any chain of length $k+1$. The maximum size that an $l$-trace $k$-Sperner family $\cF \subseteq 2^{[n]}$ can have is denoted by $f(n,k,l)$. For pairs of integers $l<k$, if in a family $\cG$ every pair of sets satisfies $||G_1|-|G_2||<k-l$, then $\cG$ possesses the $(n-l)$-trace $k$-Sperner property. Among such families, the largest one is $\cF_0=\{F\in 2^{[n]}: \lfloor \frac{n-(k-l)}{2}\rfloor+1 \le |F| \le \lfloor \frac{n-(k-l)}{2}\rfloor +k-l\}$ and also $\cF'_0=\{F\in 2^{[n]}: \lfloor \frac{n-(k-l)}{2}\rfloor \le |F| \le \lfloor \frac{n-(k-l)}{2}\rfloor +k-l-1\}$ if $n-(k-l)$ is even. In an earlier paper, we proved that this is asymptotically optimal for all pair of integers $l<k$, i.e. $f(n,k,n-l)=(1+o(1))|\cF_0|$. In this paper we consider the case when $l=1$, $k\ge 2$, and prove that $f(n,k,n-1)=|\cF_0|$ provided $n$ is large enough. We also prove that the unique $(n-1)$-trace $k$-Sperner family with size $f(n,k,n-1)$ is $\cF_0$ and also $\cF'_0$ when $n+k$ is odd.

Let $\mathcal{F}=\{F_1,F_2, \ldots,F_n\}$ be a family of $n$ sets on a ground set $S$, such as a family of balls in $\mathbb{R}^d$. For every finite measure $μ$ on $S$, such that the sets of $\mathcal{F}$ are measurable, the classical inclusion-exclusion formula asserts that $μ(F_1\cup F_2\cup\cdots\cup F_n)=\sum_{I:\emptyset\ne I\subseteq[n]} (-1)^{|I|+1}μ\Bigl(\bigcap_{i\in I} F_i\Bigr)$; that is, the measure of the union is expressed using measures of various intersections. The number of terms in this formula is exponential in $n$, and a significant amount of research, originating in applied areas, has been devoted to constructing simpler formulas for particular families $\mathcal{F}$. We provide an upper bound valid for an arbitrary $\mathcal{F}$: we show that every system $\mathcal{F}$ of $n$ sets with $m$ nonempty fields in the Venn diagram admits an inclusion-exclusion formula with $m^{O(\log^2n)}$ terms and with $\pm1$ coefficients, and that such a formula can be computed in $m^{O(\log^2n)}$ expected time. For every $\varepsilon>0$ we also construct systems with Venn diagram of size $m$ for which every valid inclusion-exclusion formula has the sum of absolute values of the coefficients at least $Ω(m^{2-\varepsilon})$.

Bingo is played on a $5\times 5$ grid. Take the 25 squares to be the ground set of a closure system in which square $s$ is dependent on a set $S$ of squares iff $s$ completes a line - a row, column, or diagonal - with squares that are already in $S$. The closure of a set $S$ is obtained via an iterative process in which, at each stage, the squares dependent upon the current state are added. In this paper we establish for the $n \times n$ Bingo board the maximum number of steps required in this closure process.

A $k$-majority digraph is a directed graph created by combining $k$ individual rankings on the same ground set to form a consensus where edges point in the direction indicated by a strict majority of the rankings. The $k$-majority digraph is used to model voting scenarios, where the vertices correspond to options ranked by $k$ voters. When $k$ is odd, the resulting digraph is always a tournament, called $k$-majority tournament. Let $f_k(n)$ be the minimum, over all $k$-majority tournaments with $n$ vertices, of the maximum order of an induced transitive sub-tournament. Recently, Milans, Schreiber, and West proved that $\sqrt n \le f_3(n) \le 2 \sqrt n +1 $. In this paper, we improve the upper bound of $f_3(n)$ by showing that $f_3(n) < \sqrt {2n} +\frac 12 $.

A pair of families $(\cF,\cG)$ is said to be \emph{cross-Sperner} if there exists no pair of sets $F \in \cF, G \in \cG$ with $F \subseteq G$ or $G \subseteq F$. There are two ways to measure the size of the pair $(\cF,\cG)$: with the sum $|\cF|+|\cG|$ or with the product $|\cF|\cdot |\cG|$. We show that if $\cF, \cG \subseteq 2^{[n]}$, then $|\cF||\cG| \le 2^{2n-4}$ and $|\cF|+|\cG|$ is maximal if $\cF$ or $\cG$ consists of exactly one set of size $\lceil n/2 \rceil$ provided the size of the ground set $n$ is large enough and both $\cF$ and $\cG$ are non-empty.

Let $S$ be an orthogonal array $OA(d,k)$ and let $c$ be an $r$--coloring of its ground set $X$. We give a combinatorial identity which relates the number of vectors in $S$ with given color patterns under $c$ with the cardinalities of the color classes. Several applications of the identity are considered. Among them, we show that every equitable $r$--coloring of the integer interval $[1,n]$ has at least $1/2(n/r)^2+O(n)$ monochromatic Schur triples. We also show that in an orthogonal array $OA(d,d-1)$, the number of monochromatic vectors of each color depends only on the number of vectors which miss that color and the cardinality of the color class.

In 1986 Lovasz, Spencer, and Vesztergombi proved a lower bound for the hereditary a discrepancy of a set system F in terms of determinants of square submatrices of the incidence matrix of F. As shown by an example of Hoffman, this bound can differ from herdisc(F) by a multiplicative factor of order almost log n, where n is the size of the ground set of F. We prove that it never differs by more than O((log n)3/2), assuming |F| bounded by a polynomial in n. We also prove that if such an F is the union of t systems F_1, . . ., F_t, each of hereditary discrepancy at most D, then herdisc(F) \leq O(t^(1/2)(log n)^(3/2) D). For t = 2, this almost answers a question of Sos. The proof is based on a recent algorithmic result of Bansal, which computes low-discrepancy colorings using semidefinite programming.

The heterochromatic number hc(H) of a non-empty hypergraph H is the smallest integer k such that for every colouring of the vertices of H with exactly k colours, there is a hyperedge of H all of whose vertices have different colours. We denote by nu(H) the number of vertices of H and by tau(H) the size of the smallest set containing at least two vertices of each hyperedge of H. For a complete geometric graph G with n > 2 vertices let H = H(G) be the hypergraph whose vertices are the edges of G and whose hyperedges are the edge sets of plane spanning trees of G. We prove that if G has at most one interior vertex, then hc(H) = nu(H) - tau(H) + 2. We also show that hc(H) = nu(H) - tau(H) + 2 whenever H is a hypergraph with vertex set and hyperedge set given by the ground set and the bases of a matroid, respectively.

We provide evidence for five long-standing, basis-exchange conjectures for matroids by proving them for the enormous class of sparse paving matroids. We also explore the role that these matroids may play in the following problem: as a function of the size of the ground set, what is the greatest number of cyclic flats that a matroid can have?