arXiv++ Combinatorics

In his work on molecular spaces, Ivashchenko introduced the notion of an $\mathfrak{I}$-contractible transformation on a graph $G$, a family of addition/deletion operations on its vertices and edges. Chen, Yau, and Yeh used these operations to define the $\mathfrak{I}$-homotopy type of a graph, and showed that $\mathfrak{I}$-contractible transformations preserve the simple homotopy type of $C(G)$, the clique complex of $G$. In other work, Boulet, Fieux, and Jouve introduced the notion of $s$-homotopy of graphs to characterize the simple homotopy type of a flag simplicial complex. They proved that $s$-homotopy preserves $\mathfrak{I}$-homotopy, and asked whether the converse holds. In this note, we answer their question in the affirmative, concluding that graphs $G$ and $H$ are $\mathfrak{I}$-homotopy equivalent if and only if $C(G)$ and $C(H)$ are simple homotopy equivalent. We also show that a finite graph $G$ is $\mathfrak{I}$-contractible if and only if $C(G)$ is contractible, which answers a question posed by the first author, Espinoza, Frías-Armenta, and Hernández. We use these ideas to give a characterization of simple homotopy for arbitrary simplicial complexes in terms of links of vertices.

In 1864, J. C. Maxwell introduced a link between self-stressed frameworks in the plane and piecewise linear liftings to 3-space. This connection has found numerous applications in areas such as discrete geometry, control theory and structural engineering. While there are some generalisations of this theory to liftings of $d$-complexes in $d$-space, extensions for liftings of frameworks in $d$-space for $d\geq 3$ have been missing. In this paper, we introduce and study differential liftings on general graphs using differential forms associated with the elements of the homotopy groups of the complements to the frameworks. Such liftings play the role of integrands for the classical notion of liftings for planar frameworks. We show that these differential liftings have a natural extension to self-stressed frameworks in higher dimensions. As a result we generalise the notion of classical liftings to both graphs and multidimensional $k$-complexes in $d$-space ($k=2,\ldots, d$). Finally we discuss a natural representation of generalised liftings as real-valued functions on Grassmannians.

We show that the dominance complex $\mathcal{D}(G)$ of a graph $G$ coincides with the combinatorial Alexander dual of the neighborhood complex $\mathcal{N}(\overline{G})$ of the complement of $G$. Using this, we obtain a relation between the chromatic number $χ(G)$ of $G$ and the homology group of $\mathcal{D}(G)$. We also obtain several known results related to dominance complexes from well-known facts of neighborhood complexes. After that, we suggest a new method for computing the homology groups of the dominance complexes, using independence complexes of simple graphs. We show that several known computations of homology groups of dominance complexes can be reduced to known computations of independence complexes. Finally, we determine the homology group of $\mathcal{D}(P_n \times P_3)$ by determining the homotopy types of the independence complex of $P_n \times P_3 \times P_2$.

The last decade has seen the development of path homology and magnitude homology -- two homology theories of directed graphs, each satisfying classic properties such as Kunneth and Mayer-Vietoris theorems. Recent work of Asao has shown that magnitude homology and path homology are related, appearing in different pages of a certain spectral sequence. Here we study the target of that spectral sequence, which we call reachability homology. We prove that it satisfies appropriate homotopy invariance, Kunneth, excision, and Mayer-Vietoris theorems, these all being stronger than the corresponding properties for either magnitude or path homology.

$N_\infty$-operads are an equivariant generalization of $E_\infty$-operads introduced by Blumberg and Hill to study structural problems in equivariant stable homotopy theory. In the original paper introducing these objects, Blumberg and Hill raised the question of classifying $N_\infty$-operads that are weakly equivalent to a particularly nice kind of $N_\infty$-operad called a linear isometries operad. For some groups there is a known classification of linear isometries operads up to weak equivalence in terms of certain combinatorially defined objects called saturated transfer systems, but this classification is known to be invalid in general. Various authors have made incremental progress on understanding the domain of validity for this classification, but even among cyclic groups the validity is unknown in general. We determine essentially all the finite Abelian groups for which the classification is valid using techniques from algebra and extremal combinatorics.

We describe CW decompositions of complex Lagrangian Grassmannians, that contain as subcomplexes, CW decompositions of real Lagrangian Grassmannians by Schubert-Arnol'd cells. The degrees of attaching maps are explicitly computed in terms of quantities that can be read off from the corresponding shifted Young diagrams of mixed type. The signs are determined by a choice of lexicographical ordering on coordinates. As an immediate consequence, we obtain the homotopy extension property for real and complex Lagrangian Grassmannians. We also show some torsion classes in the integral homology of the real Lagrangian Grassmannian are contractible inside the complex Lagrangian Grassmannian.

We prove that Hill's characteristic function $χ$ for transfer systems on a lattice $P$ surjects onto interior operators for $P$. Moreover, the fibers of $χ$ have unique maxima which are exactly the saturated transfer systems. In order to apply this theorem in examples relevant to equivariant homotopy theory, we develop the theory of saturated transfer systems on modular lattices, ultimately producing a ``matchstick game'' that puts saturated transfer systems in bijection with certain structured subsets of covering relations. After an interlude developing a recursion for transfer systems on certain combinations of bounded posets, we apply these results to determine the full lattice of transfer systems for rank two elementary Abelian groups.

We introduce the poset of biflats of a matroid $M$, a Lagrangian analog of the lattice of flats of $M$, and study the topology of its order complex, which we call the biflats complex. This work continues the study of the Lagrangian combinatorics of matroids, which was recently initiated by work of Ardila, Denham and Huh. We show the biflats complex contains two distinguished subcomplexes: the conormal complex of $M$ and the simplicial join of the Bergman complexes of $M$ and $M^\perp$, the matroidal dual of $M$. Our main theorems give sequences of elementary collapses of the biflats complex onto the conormal complex and the join of the Bergman complexes of $M$ and $M^\perp$. These collapses give a combinatorial proof that the biflats complex, conormal complex and the join of the Bergman complexes of $M$ and $M^\perp$ are all simple homotopy equivalent. Although simple homotopy equivalent, these complexes have many different combinatorial properties. We collect and prove a list of such properties.

In this paper we study the nerves of two types of coverings of a sphere $S^{d-1}$: (1) coverings by open hemispheres; (2) antipodal coverings by closed hemispheres. In the first case, nerve theorem implies that the nerve is homotopy equivalent to $S^{d-1}$. In the second case, we prove that the nerve is homotopy equivalent to a wedge of $(2d-2)$-dimensional spheres. The number of wedge summands equals the Möbius invariant of the geometric lattice (or hyperplane arrangement) associated with the covering. This result explains some observed large-scale phenomena in topological data analysis. We review the particular case, when the coverings are centered in the root system $A_d$. In this case the nerve of the covering by open hemispheres is the space of directed acyclic graphs (DAGs), and the nerve of the covering by closed hemispheres is the space of non-strongly connected directed graphs. The homotopy types of these spaces were described by Björner and Welker, and the incarnation of these spaces appeared independently as "the poset of orders" and "the poset of preorders" respectively in the works of Bouc. We study the space of DAGs in terms of Gale and combinatorial Alexander dualities, and propose how this space can be applied in automated machine learning.

In this paper we study natural reconfiguration spaces associated to the problem of distributing a fixed number of resources to labeled nodes of a tree network, so that no node is left empty. These spaces turn out to be cubical complexes, which can be thought of as higher-dimensional geometric extensions of the combinatorial Stirling problem of partitioning a set of named objects into non-empty labeled parts. As our main result, we prove that these Stirling complexes are always homotopy equivalent to wedges of spheres of the same dimension. Furthermore, we provide several combinatorial formulae to count these spheres. Somewhat surprisingly, the homotopy type of the Stirling complexes turns out to depend only on the number of resources and the number of the labeled nodes, not on the actual structure of the tree network.

Let $D_n \subseteq Σ_n$ be the set of derangements in the symmetric group. We prove that the complex of injective words generated by $Σ_n \setminus D_n$ is contractible. This gives a conceptual explanation to the well known fact that the complex of injective words generated by $Σ_n$ is homotopy equivalent to the wedge sum $\underset{|D_n|}{\bigvee} S^{n-1}$.

We provide a systematic enumerative and combinatorial study of geometric cellular diagonals on the permutahedra. In the first part of the paper, we study the combinatorics of certain hyperplane arrangements obtained as the union of $\ell$ generically translated copies of the classical braid arrangement. Based on Zaslavsky's theory, we derive enumerative results on the faces of these arrangements involving combinatorial objects named partition forests and rainbow forests. This yields in particular nice formulas for the number of regions and bounded regions in terms of exponentials of generating functions of Fuss-Catalan numbers. By duality, the specialization of these results to the case $\ell = 2$ gives the enumeration of any geometric diagonal of the permutahedron. In the second part of the paper, we study diagonals which respect the operadic structure on the family of permutahedra. We show that there are exactly two such diagonals, which are moreover isomorphic. We describe their facets by a simple rule on paths in partition trees, and their vertices as pattern-avoiding pairs of permutations. We show that one of these diagonals is a topological enhancement of the Sanbeblidze-Umble diagonal, and unravel a natural lattice structure on their sets of facets. In the third part of the paper, we use the preceding results to show that there are precisely two isomorphic topological cellular operadic structures on the families of operahedra and multiplihedra, and exactly two infinity-isomorphic geometric universal tensor products of homotopy operads and A-infinity morphisms.

Recently there has been growing interest in discrete homotopies and homotopies of graphs beyond treating graphs as 1-dimensional simplicial spaces. One such type of homotopy is $\times$-homotopy. Recent work by Chih-Scull has developed a homotopy category, a fundamental group for graphs under this homotopy, and a way of computing covers of graphs that lift homotopy via this fundamental group. In this paper, we compute the fundamental groups of all Hamming graphs, show that they are direct products of cyclic groups, and use this result to describe some $\times$-homotopy covers of Hamming graphs.

We give a decomposition of the suspension of a polyhedral join in terms of the polyhedral smash product of the suspension of the family of pairs, and study some cases in which the formula can be desuspended, particularly for polyhedral joins over independence complexes of graphs. We also give some lower bounds for the connectivity of polyhedral joins. We use these results to study the homotopy type of the forest filtration for some lexicographic products of graphs.

Given a graph $G$, we define a filtration of simplicial complexes associated to $G$, $\mathcal{F}_0(G)\subseteq\mathcal{F}_1(G)\subseteq\cdots\subseteq\mathcal{F}_\infty(G)$ where the first complex is the independence complex and the last the complex is formed by the acyclic sets of vertices. We prove some properties of this filtration and we calculate the homotopy type for various families of graphs. We give an upper bound for the decycling number and generalizations of this parameter using the dimensions of the rational cohomology groups of these complexes. We also derive an upper bound for the Fibonacci numbers of ternary graphs.

It was conjectured by Goyal, Shukla and Singh that the independence complex of the categorical product $K_2\times K_3\times K_n$ has the homotopy type of a wedge of $(n-1)(3n-2)$ spheres of dimension $3$. Here we prove this conjecture by calculating the homotopy type of the independence complex of the graphs $C_{3r}\times K_n$ and $K_2\times K_m\times K_n$. For $C_m \times K_n$ when $m$ is not a multiple of $3$, we calculate the homotopy type for $m = 4, 5$ and show that for other values it has to have the homotopy type of a wedge of spheres of at most $2$ consecutive dimensions and maybe some Moore spaces.

Let $(Σ,\mathbb{M},\mathbb{P})$ be a surface with marked points $\mathbb{M}\subseteq \partialΣ\neq\varnothing$ and punctures $\mathbb{P}\subseteqΣ\setminus\partialΣ$. In this paper we show that for every curve $γ$ on $Σ\setminus\mathbb{P}$, the curve obtained by resolving the kinks of $γ$ in any order is uniquely determined, up to homotopy in $Σ\setminus\mathbb{P}$, by the $2$-orbifold homotopy class of $γ$, in which the punctures are interpreted to be orbifold points of order $2$. Our proof resorts to an application of the Diamond Lemma.

We show that the quasicategory defined as the localization of the category of (simple) graphs at the class of A-homotopy equivalences does not admit colimits. In particular, we settle in the negative the question of whether the A-homotopy equivalences in the category of graphs are part of a model structure.

Our main result has topological, combinatorial and computational flavor. It is motivated by a fundamental conjecture stating that computing Khovanov homology of a closed braid of fixed number of strands has polynomial time complexity. We show that the independence simplicial complex $I(w)$ associated to the 4-braid diagram $w$ (and therefore its Khovanov spectrum at extreme quantum degree) is contractible or homotopy equivalent to either a sphere, or a wedge of 2 spheres (possibly of different dimensions), or a wedge of 3 spheres (at least two of them of the same dimension), or a wedge of 4 spheres (at least three of them of the same dimension). On the algorithmic side we prove that finding the homotopy type of $I(w)$ can be done in polynomial time with respect to the number of crossings in $w$. In particular, we prove the wedge of spheres conjecture for circle graphs obtained from 4-braid diagrams. We also introduce the concept of Khovanov adequate diagram and discuss criteria for a link to have a Khovanov adequate braid diagram with at most 4 strands.

Robin Forman's highly influential 2002 paper A User's Guide to Discrete Morse Theory presents an overview of the subject in a very readable manner. As a proof of concept, the author determines the topology (homotopy type) of the abstract simplicial complex of disconnected graphs of order $n$ (which was previously done by Victor Vassiliev using classical topological methods) using discrete Morse theoretic techniques, which are purely combinatorial in nature. The techniques involve the construction (and verification) of a discrete gradient vector field on the complex. However, the verification part relies on a claim that doesn't seem to hold. In this note, we provide a couple of counterexamples against this specific claim. We also provide an alternative proof of the bigger claim that the constructed discrete vector field is indeed a gradient vector field. Our proof technique relies on a key observation which is not specific to the problem at hand, and thus is applicable while verifying a constructed discrete vector field is a gradient one in general.