arXiv++ Combinatorics

We resolve an open question posed by the authors of arXiv:1501.06925v2 in 2015 concerning a Gröbner theoretic approach for the noetherianity of the twisted commutative algebra ${\rm Sym}({\rm Sym}^2(\mathbf{C}^\infty))$. We provide a negative answer to their question by producing an explicit antichain. In doing so, we establish a connection to well studied posets of graphs under the subgraph and induced subgraph relation. We then analyze this connection to suggest future paths of investigation, for example a deeper study of initial ideals in twisted commutative algebras.

Extending a classical theorem of Sperner, we characterize the integers $m$ such that there exists a maximal antichain of size $m$ in the Boolean lattice $B_n$, that is, the power set of $[n]:=\{1,2,\dots,n\}$, ordered by inclusion. As an important ingredient in the proof, we initiate the study of an extension of the Kruskal-Katona theorem which is of independent interest. For given positive integers $t$ and $k$, we ask which integers $s$ have the property that there exists a family $\mathcal F$ of $k$-sets with $\lvert\mathcal F\rvert=t$ such that the shadow of $\mathcal F$ has size $s$, where the shadow of $\mathcal F$ is the collection of $(k-1)$-sets that are contained in at least one member of $\mathcal F$. We provide a complete answer for $t\leqslant k+1$. Moreover, we prove that the largest integer which is not the shadow size of any family of $k$-sets is $\sqrt 2k^{3/2}+\sqrt[4]{8}k^{5/4}+O(k)$.

This is the second in a sequence of three papers investigating the question for which positive integers $m$ there exists a maximal antichain of size $m$ in the Boolean lattice $B_n$ (the power set of $[n]:=\{1,2,\dots,n\}$, ordered by inclusion). In the previous paper we characterized those $m$ between $\binom{n}{\lceil n/2\rceil}-\lceil n/2\rceil^2$ and the maximum size $\binom{n}{\lceil n/2 \rceil}$ that are not sizes of maximal antichains. In this paper we show that all smaller $m$ are sizes of maximal antichains.

Let $X$ be a finite set, $Z \subseteq X$ and $y \notin X$. Marcel Erné showed in 1981, that the number of posets on $X$ containing $Z$ as an antichain equals the number of posets $R$ on $X \cup \{ y \}$ in which the points of $Z \cup \{ y \}$ are exactly the maximal points of $R$. We prove the following generalization: For every poset $Q$ with carrier $Z$, the number of posets on $X$ containing $Q$ as an induced sub-poset equals the number of posets $R$ on $X \cup \{ y \}$ which contain $Q^d + A_y$ as an induced sub-poset and in which the maximal points of $Q^d + A_y$ are exactly the maximal points of $R$. Here, $Q^d$ is the dual of $Q$, $A_y$ is the singleton-poset on $y$, and $Q^d + A_y$ denotes the direct sum of $Q^d$ and $A_y$.

We define several sorts of mappings on a poset like monotone, strictly monotone, upper cone preserving and variants of these. Our aim is to characterize posets in which some of these mappings coincide. We define special mappings determined by two elements and investigate when these are strictly monotone or upper cone preserving. If the considered poset is a semilattice then its monotone mappings coincide with semilattice homomorphisms if and only if the poset is a chain. Similarly, we study posets which need not be semilattices but whose upper cones have a minimal element. We extend this investigation to posets that are direct products of chains or an ordinal sum of an antichain and a finite chain. We characterize equivalence relations induced by strongly monotone mappings and show that the quotient set of a poset by such an equivalence relation is a poset again.

Let $\mathcal{F}$ be an antichain of finite subsets of $\mathbb{N}$. How quickly can the quantities $|\mathcal{F}\cap 2^{[n]}|$ grow as $n\to\infty$? We show that for any sequence $(f_n)_{n\ge n_0}$ of positive integers satisfying $\sum_{n=n_0}^\infty f_n/2^n \le 1/4$, $f_{n_0}=1$ and $f_n\le f_{n+1}\le 2f_n$, there exists an infinite antichain $\mathcal{F}$ of finite subsets of $\mathbb{N}$ such that $|\mathcal{F}\cap 2^{[n]}| \geq f_n$ for all $n\ge n_0$. It follows that for any $\varepsilon>0$ there exists an antichain $\mathcal{F}\subseteq 2^\mathbb{N}$ such that $$\liminf_{n \to \infty} |\mathcal{F}\cap 2^{[n]}| \cdot \left(\frac{2^n}{n\log^{1+\varepsilon} n}\right)^{-1} > 0.$$ This resolves a problem of Sudakov, Tomon and Wagner in a strong form, and is essentially tight.

For a Weyl group $W$ of rank $r$, the $W$-Catalan number is the number of antichains of the poset of positive roots, and the $W$-Narayana numbers refine the $W$-Catalan number by keeping track of the cardinalities of these antichains. The $W$-Narayana numbers are symmetric, i.e., the number of antichains of cardinality $k$ is the same as the number of cardinality $r-k$. However, this symmetry is far from obvious. Panyushev posed the problem of defining an involution on root poset antichains that exhibits the symmetry of the $W$-Narayana numbers. Rowmotion and rowvacuation are two related operators, defined as compositions of "toggles," that give a dihedral action on the set of antichains of any ranked poset. Rowmotion acting on root posets has been the subject of a significant amount of research in the recent past. We prove that for the root posets of classical types, rowvacuation is Panyushev's desired involution.

The Lalanne-Kreweras involution is an involution on the set of Dyck paths which combinatorially exhibits the symmetry of the number of valleys and major index statistics. We define piecewise-linear and birational extensions of the Lalanne-Kreweras involution. Actually, we show that the Lalanne-Kreweras involution is a special case of a more general operator, called rowvacuation, which acts on the antichains of any graded poset. Rowvacuation, like the closely related and more studied rowmotion operator, is a composition of toggles. We obtain the piecewise-linear and birational lifts of the Lalanne-Kreweras involution by using the piecewise-linear and birational toggles of Einstein and Propp. We show that the symmetry properties of the Lalanne-Kreweras involution extend to these piecewise-linear and birational lifts.

The age $\mathcal{A}(G)$ of a graph $G$ (undirected and without loops) is the collection of finite induced subgraphs of $G$, considered up to isomorphy and ordered by embeddability. It is well-quasi-ordered (wqo) for this order if it contains no infinite antichain. A graph is \emph{path-minimal} if it contains finite induced paths of unbounded length and every induced subgraph $G'$ with this property embeds $G$. We construct $2^{\aleph_0}$ path-minimal graphs whose ages are pairwise incomparable with set inclusion and which are wqo. Our construction is based on uniformly recurrent sequences and lexicographical sums of labelled graphs.

In set theory without the Axiom of Choice (AC), we observe new relations of the following statements with weak choice principles. 1. Every locally finite connected graph has a maximal independent set. 2. Every locally countable connected graph has a maximal independent set. 3. If in a partially ordered set all antichains are finite and all chains have size $\aleph_α$, then the set has size $\aleph_α$ if $\aleph_α$ is regular. 4. Every partially ordered set has a cofinal well-founded subset. 5. If $G=(V_{G},E_{G})$ is a connected locally finite chordal graph, then there is an ordering $<$ of $V_{G}$ such that $\{w < v : \{w,v\} \in E_{G}\}$ is a clique for each $v\in V_{G}$.

One of the most classical results in extremal set theory is Sperner's theorem, which says that the largest antichain in the Boolean lattice $2^{[n]}$ has size $Θ\big(\frac{2^n}{\sqrt{n}}\big)$. Motivated by an old problem of Erdős on the growth of infinite Sidon sequences, in this note we study the growth rate of maximum infinite antichains. Using the well known Kraft's inequality for prefix codes, it is not difficult to show that infinite antichains should be "thinner" than the corresponding finite ones. More precisely, if $\mathcal{F}\subset 2^{\mathbb{N}}$ is an antichain, then $$\liminf_{n\rightarrow \infty}\big|\mathcal{F} \cap 2^{[n]}\big|\left(\frac{2^n}{n\log n}\right)^{-1}=0.$$ Our main result shows that this bound is essentially tight, that is, we construct an antichain $\mathcal{F}$ such that $$\liminf_{n\rightarrow \infty}\big|\mathcal{F} \cap 2^{[n]}\big|\left(\frac{2^n}{n\log^{C} n}\right)^{-1}>0$$ holds for some absolute constant $C>0$.

Nash-Williams' Strong Immersion Conjecture states that graphs are well-quasi-ordered by the strong immersion relation. That is, given infinitely many graphs, one graph contains another graph as a strong immersion. In this paper we study the analogous problem for directed graphs. It is known that digraphs are not well-quasi-ordered by the strong immersion relation, but for all known such infinite antichains, paths that change direction arbitrarily many times can be found. This paper proves that the converse statement is true: for every positive integer $k$, the digraphs that do not contain a path that changes direction $k$ times are well-quasi-ordered by the strong immersion relation, even when vertices are labelled by a well-quasi-order. This result is optimal for classes of digraphs closed under taking subgraphs since paths that change direction arbitrarily many times with vertex-labels form an infinite antichain with respect to the strong immersion relation.

We prove some properties of the Kruskal-Katona function, and apply to the following variation of cross-intersecting antichains. Let $n\ge 4$ be an even integer and $\mathscr{A}$ and $\mathscr{B}$ be two cross-intersecting antichains of $\mathbb{N}_n$ with at most $k$ disjoint pairs, i.e. for all $A_i\in \mathscr{A}$, $B_j\in\mathscr{B}$, $A_i\cap B_j=\emptyset$ only if $i=j\le k$. We prove a best possible upper bound on $|\mathscr{A}|+|\mathscr{B}|$. Furthermore, we show that the extremal families contain only $\frac{n}{2}$ and $(\frac{n}{2}+1)$-sets.

Contrary to the expectation arising from the tanglegram Kuratowski theorem of É. Czabarka, L.A. Székely and S. Wagner [SIAM J. Discrete Math. 31(3): 1732--1750, (2017)], we construct an infinite antichain of planar tanglegrams with respect to the induced subtanglegram partial order. R.E. Tarjan, R. Laver, D.A. Spielman and M. Bóna, and possibly others, showed that the partially ordered set of finite permutations ordered by deletion of entries contains an infinite antichain, i.e. there exists an infinite collection of permutations, such that none of them contains another as a pattern. Our construction adds a twist to the construction of Spielman and Bóna [Electr. J. Comb, Vol. 7. N2.]

Let $n>3$ be a natural number. By a 1975 result of H. Strietz, the lattice Part$(n)$ of all partitions of an $n$-element set has a four-element generating set. In 1983, L. Zádori gave a new proof of this fact with a particularly elegant construction. Based on his construction from 1983, the present paper gives a lower bound on the number $ν(n)$ of four-element generating sets of Part$(n)$. We also present a computer assisted statistical approach to $ν(n)$ for small values of $n$. In his 1983 paper, L. Zádori also proved that for $n\geq 7$, the lattice Part$(n)$ has a four element generating set that is not an antichain. He left the problem whether such a generating set for $n\in\{5,6\}$ exists open. Here we solve this problem in negative for $n=5$ and in affirmative for $n=6$. Finally, the main theorem asserts that the direct product of some powers of partition lattices is four-generated. In particular, by the first part of this theorem, Part$(n_1)\times$ Part$(n_2)$ is four-generated for any two distinct integers $n_1$ and $n_2$ that are at least 5. The second part of the theorem is technical but it has two corollaries that are easy to understand. Namely, the direct product Part$(n)$ $\times$ Part$(n+1)$ $\times\dots\times$ Part$(3n-14)$ is four-generated for each integer $n\geq 9$. Also, for every positive integer $u$, the $u$-th the direct power of the direct product Part$(n)$ $\times$ Part$(n+1)$ $\times\dots\times$ Part$(n+u-1)$ is four-generated for all but finitely many $n$. If we do not insist on too many direct factors, then the exponent can be quite large. For example, our theorem implies that the $10^{127}$-th direct power of Part$(1011)$ $\times$ Part$(1012)$ $\times \dots \times$ Part$(2020)$ is four-generated.

Let $n>s>0$ be integers, $X$ an $n$-element set and $\mathscr{A}, \mathscr{B}\subset 2^X$ two families. If $|A\cup B|\le s$ for all $A\in\mathscr{A}, B\in \mathscr{B}$, then $\mathscr{A}$ and $\mathscr{B}$ are called cross $s$-union. Assuming that neither $\mathscr{A}$ nor $\mathscr{B}$ is empty, we prove several best possible bounds. In particular, we show that $|\mathscr{A}|+|\mathscr{B}|\le 1+\sum\limits_{0\le i\le s}{{n}\choose{i}}$. Supposing $n\ge 2s$ and $\mathscr{A},\mathscr{B}$ are antichains, we show that $|\mathscr{A}|+|\mathscr{B}|\le {{n}\choose{1}}+{{n}\choose{s-1}}$ unless $\mathscr{A}=\{\emptyset\}$ or $\mathscr{B}=\{\emptyset\}$. An analogous result for three families is established as well.

Robertson and Seymour's celebrated Graph Minor Theorem states that graphs are well-quasi-ordered by the minor relation. Unlike the minor relation, the topological minor relation does not well-quasi-order graphs in general. Among all known infinite antichains with respect to the topological containment, subdivisions of a graph obtained from an arbitrarily long path by duplicating each edge can be found. In the 1980's Robertson conjectured that this is the only obstruction. Formally, he conjectured that for every positive integer $k$, graphs that do not contain the graph obtained from a path of length $k$ by duplicating each edge as a topological minor are well-quasi-ordered by the topological minor relation. The case $k=1$ implies Kruskal's Tree Theorem, and the case $k=2$ implies a conjecture of Vázsonyi on subcubic graphs. This series of papers dedicates a proof of Robertson's conjecture. We prove Robertson's conjecture for graphs of bounded tree-width in this paper. It is an essential step toward the complete proof of Robertson's conjecture, and the machinery developed in this paper will be applied in future papers of the series. This bounded tree-width case proved in this paper implies all known results about well-quasi-ordering graphs by the topological minor relation that can be proved without using the Graph Minor Theorem, and our proof in this paper is self-contained.

A simplified construction is presented for Komjáth's result that for every uncountable cardinal $κ$, there are $2^κ$ graphs of size $κ$ none of them being a minor of another.

For an integer $n\geq 5$, H. Strietz (1975) and L. Zádori (1986) proved that the lattice Part$(n)$ of all partitions of $\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ is four-generated. Developing L. Zádori's particularly elegant construction further, we prove that even the $k$-th direct power Part$(n)^k$ of Part$(n)$ is four-generated for many but only finitely many exponents $k$. E.g., Part$(n)^k$ is four-generated for every $k\leq 3\cdot 10^{89}$, and it has a four element generating set that is not an antichain for every $k\leq 1.4\cdot 10^{34}$. In connection with these results, we outline a protocol how to use these lattices in authentication and secret key cryptography.

We generalize Kada's definable strengthening of Dilworth's characterization of the class of quasi-orders admitting an antichain of a given finite cardinality.