arXiv++ Combinatorics

The tournament isomorphism problem is one of the two fundamental bottlenecks to designing better algorithms for the graph isomorphism problem. Though the problem has been investigated for more than five decades, compared to graphs, there are only very few results on the isomorphism problem of tournaments. For most classes of tournaments neither hardness nor polynomial-time solvability is known. Tournaments of bounded VC dimension are such a class for which no results are available, even though the VC dimension is arguably one of the most robust and central notions of combinatorial tameness. Resolving an open problem of Neuen and Grohe, we show that the isomorphism problem for tournaments of VC dimension $d$ can be decided in time $n^{O(d\log d)}$. Consequently, automorphism groups of tournaments of bounded VC dimension can be computed in polynomial time. To this end, we develop a new method to isomorphism-invariantly decompose tournaments. To facilitate recursion, we introduce the notion of a patched tournament and analyze bounded VC dimension in patched tournaments. We design a recursive algorithm that balances the size of the decomposed pieces against their number and makes use of the structure of near twins. In an orthogonal direction, it is known that a hereditary class of tournaments has unbounded VC dimension if and only if it contains all 2-colorable tournaments. As a second result, we show that also this class does not form an obstruction towards polynomial-time isomorphism testing and indeed show that isomorphism of tournaments of bounded chromatic number is polynomial-time decidable.

Seymour's second neighborhood conjecture asserts that every finite oriented graph has a vertex with at least as many exact second outneighbors as outneighbors. Established cases include tournaments, proved by Fisher (1996), and oriented graphs of minimum outdegree at most six, proved by Kaneko and Locke (2001); a recent preprint of Sadhukhan, Sandeep, and Sen (2026) treats minimum outdegree seven. For dense incomplete graphs, Fidler and Yuster (2007) proved the conjecture when the missing edges form a matching, a star, or a clique, Ghazal (2012) extended this direction to generalized stars, and Dara, Francis, Jacob, and Narayanan (2022) proved it when the missing edges can be partitioned into a matching and a star. We give a short counting proof of the conjecture for every oriented graph of order $n=2δ+2$, where $δ$ is the minimum outdegree, with no prescribed structure on the missing edges. Together with Fisher's tournament theorem, this implies the conjecture for every oriented graph satisfying $n\le2δ+2$. Combined with the known minimum-outdegree results, this raises the best lower bound known to us on the order of a counterexample from $16$ to $17$ and, conditional on the preprint of Sadhukhan, Sandeep, and Sen (2026), from $18$ to $19$.

Jackson and Thomassen conjectured that every $2k$-strong digraph admits a spanning $k$-strong oriented subdigraph [Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 555 (1989) 402-412]. The conjecture holds for $k=1$ but other than some partial results that have been obtained for general $k$ in some special families of digraphs, including symmetric digraphs, the conjecture remains wide open in general. Even the existence of an integer $K$ such that every $K$-strong digraph has a 2-strong spanning oriented subdigraph is open. As a natural optimization counterpart, the minimum spanning $k$-strong subdigraph (MSSS$_k$) problem, is to find the minimum number of arcs in a spanning $k$-strong subdigraph of a $k$-strong digraph. This problem is NP-hard already for $k=1$ as it generalizes the hamiltonian cycle problem. In this paper, we address both problems simultaneously for the class of split digraphs, by constructing sparse spanning $k$-strong oriented subdigraphs. Specifically, we prove that every $k$-strong split digraph $D = (V_1, V_2; A)$ with minimum semi-degree {$δ^0(D)\geq 26k+15$} contains a spanning $k$-strong oriented subdigraph with no more than $kn+k|V_1|+98k^2+38k+3$ arcs, where $kn + k|V_1|$ is tight and the $k^{2}$ term is tight up to a constant factor. For the class of $k$-strong tournaments with minimum semi-degree at least $26k+15$ our results improve the bound obtained by Kang in [Combin. Probab. Comput., 27:892-907, 2018].

Sumner's universal tournament conjecture asserts that every tournament on $2n-2$ vertices contains every oriented tree on $n$ vertices. Let $f(n)$ be the least integer $N$ such that every tournament on $N$ vertices contains every oriented tree on $n$ vertices. Havet and Thomassé proved that $f(n)\le \lceil(7n-5)/2\rceil$, El Sahili improved this to $f(n)\le3n-3$, and Dross and Havet subsequently obtained $f(n)\le\lceil21n/8-47/16\rceil$. We refine their median-order method. More precisely, every non-bi-arborescence on $n$ vertices with $k$ leaves is $(4n-2k-4)$-unavoidable, which strictly improves their many-leaf estimate; bi-arborescences satisfy the stronger bound $2n-2$. Combining this refinement with their few-leaf bound gives $f(n)\le\lceil(18n-23)/7\rceil$ for every $n\ge2$. Thus the coefficient in the previously best general bound valid uniformly for all $n$ is reduced from $21/8$ to $18/7$.

Let $r\ge2$, let $T_r$ denote the transitive tournament on $r$ vertices, and write $d_G^*(v):=\max\{d_G^+(v),d_G^-(v)\}$. We prove that if $r\mid n$ and an $n$-vertex digraph $G$ satisfies $d_G^*(x)+d_G^*(y)\ge 2(1-1/r)n-1$ for every $x\ne y \in V(G)$ with $xy \notin E(G)$, then $G$ has a $T_r$-factor, and the bound is best possible. Furthermore, by applying our main theorem, we settle Treglown's conjecture on the dominant degree $d^*_G(x) \ge (1-1/r)n$ and answer Molla and Treglown's problem of determining the exact Ore-type threshold $2(1-1/r)n - 1$, and we obtain stronger versions of the theorems of Czygrinow, DeBiasio, Kierstead and Molla.

Given a tournament $T$, Aboulker, Aubian, Charbit, and Lopes (2023) defined its clique number $\vecω(T)$ as the minimum clique number of a backedge graph of $T$, and raised the question: Which classes of tournaments are polynomially $\vecχ$-bounded? Aboulker, Duron, Jacob, Kimbrough, Thomassé, and this work's authors (2026) showed that this holds for classes of tournaments whose arc sets may be written as the union of a bounded number of comparability digraphs. What about classes of tournaments that do not admit such a decomposition? The crossing tournaments of Nguyen, Scott, and Seymour (2025) are an example of such a class, as shown in the aforementioned 2026 work; we show that nonetheless crossing tournaments are polynomially $\vecχ$-bounded by adapting a method of Davies and McCarty (2021) and Davies (2022). We additionally show that we cannot extend this result for crossing tournaments to tournaments with chordal graphs as backedge graphs.

Alon introduced $d(s)$ as the largest integer $d$ such that every digraph on $2n$ vertices with minimum out-degree at least $s$ contains a subdigraph on $n$ vertices with minimum out-degree at least $d$. He proved that $s/2-d(s)=O(\sqrt{s\log s})$, and further asked whether this deficit can be bounded by an absolute constant. Steiner answered this question in the negative by constructing suitable tournaments, and showed that $s/2-d(s)=Ω(\log s)$. Using a different construction, we show that the deficit grows at least on the square-root scale, rather than merely logarithmically, improving the best known lower bound due to Steiner from $Ω(\log s)$ to $Ω(\sqrt{s})$ and leaving only a factor of $\sqrt{\log s}$ between the lower and upper bounds. This also completely settles a question raised by Steiner for tournament hosts. More generally, in the broader setting considered by Alon, our construction applies whenever the prescribed subdigraphs contain any fixed positive proportion of the vertices of the host digraph rather than specifically one half.

Let $u(n)$ be the largest integer $d$ such that every $n$-vertex claw with at most $d$ branches occurs in every tournament on $n$ vertices, and let $c_{\mathrm{claw}}=\limsup_{n\to\infty}u(n)/n$. In 1998, Lu, Wang and Wong proved that $19/50\le c_{\mathrm{claw}}\le11/23$, and these have remained the best bounds known. We improve them to $2/5\le c_{\mathrm{claw}}\le10/21$. We also isolate two parameters $θ$ and $σ$ which place the lower- and upper-bound arguments in a common framework: we show $σ\leθ$ and $1/21\leσ\leθ\le1/5$, our two bounds being the images of the endpoints under $α\mapsto\frac12-\fracα{2}$, and $σ=θ$ would force $\lim u(n)/n$ to exist.

Determining the combinatorial structures that maximize the number of prescribed substructures is a central theme in extremal combinatorics. Grzesik, Král', Lovász and Volec showed that when $\ell$ is not divisible by $4$, the random tournament contains asymptotically the most directed cycles of length $\ell$ among all $n$-vertex tournaments. In the paper, we resolve the remaining cases where $\ell$ is divisible by $4$. We show that, in this regime, the so-called carousel tournament asymptotically maximizes the number of directed $\ell$-cycles among all $n$-vertex tournaments, and in particular contains strictly more such cycles than the random tournament. This confirms the conjecture of Bartley and Day.

The spectral sensitivity $λ(f)$ of a Boolean function is the largest eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of its sensitivity graph. It lower-bounds every standard measure of query complexity, and Aaronson, Ben-David, Kothari, Rao and Tal, who introduced it, asked whether block sensitivity is at most quadratic in it: is $bs(f)=O(λ(f)^{2})$? We show that it is not. We construct a total Boolean function on $2017584$ variables with $bs(f)\ge 14011$ and $λ(f)\le 89.0162$, so that $bs(f)\geλ(f)^{2.127}$, and hence by composition a family with $λ(f_n)\to\infty$ and $bs(f_n)=Ω(λ(f_n)^{2.127})$. The function is the indicator of a union of $k$ subcubes indexed by the vertices of a doubly regular tournament, and the freedom left in the construction is fixed by the Lovász local lemma. The main result has been formally verified in Lean. We also give numerical evidence that a member of the same family on $1255$ variables reaches an exponent near $2.20$, and exhibit a member on $30$ variables whose exponent already exceeds $2$ and whose spectral sensitivity can be computed exactly.

The Kemeny rule aggregates rankings by minimizing their total Kendall-tau distance from an aggregate order. We prove that Kemeny Score is NP-complete for exactly three unweighted rankings, even when every candidate pair is split $2$-to-$1$. On the same profiles, the winner, unique-winner, and possible- and necessary-precedence problems are $Θ_2^p$-complete, while recognizing a Kemeny-optimal or uniquely Kemeny-optimal aggregate is coNP-complete. The hard instances induce tournaments of majority dimension exactly $3$. The reduction also determines the exact maximum-cut value from the optimal Kemeny score and recovers a maximum cut from any Kemeny-optimal aggregate. For every fixed $q\geq3$ and $\lceil q/2\rceil\leq s\leq q$, minimum pairwise support $s$ yields a sharp dichotomy: the score problem is NP-complete, the winner and precedence problems are $Θ_2^p$-complete, and the recognition problems are coNP-complete when $3s\leq2q$; for $3s>2q$, the majority tournament is transitive and its unique topological order is the unique Kemeny-optimal aggregate. Exact support $s$ suffices in the hard case when $s>q/2$, and supports in ${s,s+1}$ suffice when $s=q/2$. These results give complete fixed-profile-size classifications and transfer to Slater orders, permutation medians, and maximum-likelihood central rankings in the Mallows model. Finally, a six-copy construction proves NP-completeness of both Kemeny Score and Kendall--Tau Center for three pairwise-equidistant rankings that still split every pair $2$-to-$1$. For $N$ output candidates, their common distance is $\frac23\binom N2$, the largest possible for an equidistant triple. The construction gives affine formulas for both optimal values, characterizes all Kemeny-optimal output orders, and shows that the output has a unique Kemeny-optimal order and a unique center exactly when the input has a unique Kemeny-optimal order.

A $k$-majority tournament on a finite vertex set is defined by $2k-1$ linear orders, with $u\to v$ when $u$ lies above $v$ in at least $k$ of the orders. Let $F(k)$ be the maximum, over all $k$-majority tournaments, of the size of a minimum dominating set. Alon, Brightwell, Kierstead, Kostochka, and Winkler proved that $C_1k/\log k \leq F(k) \leq C_2k\log k$ for suitable positive constants $C_1$ and $C_2$. In this paper, we prove the linear lower bound $F(k)\ge \left\lfloor\frac{k+1}{2}\right\rfloor $ for $k\ge 3$.

In an incomplete round robin tournament, teams play against different sets of opponents. Given varying strengths of the teams, this raises a fairness issue. We establish the complexity of determining whether a fair draw exists under various scenarios involving the presence of pots (i.e., strength based groups of teams), teams coming from the same association, connectivity requirements, and others. We also show experimentally how fair incomplete round robin tournaments can be generated.

Results by Jackson and Frank imply that every 2k-arc-strong digraph D contains a spanning k-arc-strong oriented subdigraph. This is best possible, even for very dense digraphs. A digraph is semicomplete if at least one of the arcs xy,yx is present for every pair of distinct vertices x,y. A tournament has exactly one of xy,yx for every such pair. Clearly every semicomplete digraph D contains a spanning tournament T which is obtained by deleting one arc from every 2-cycle of D. We prove that every (2k-1)-arc-strong semicomplete digraph on at least 2k+1 vertices contains a spanning k-arc-strong tournament. Both bounds 2k-1 and 2k+1 are best possible. The proof uses Frank's general orientation theorem for graphs as well as counting arguments based on the semicomplete structure.

Let $k$ be a positive integer. Jackson and Thomassen conjectured in 1989 that there exists an integer function $f(k)$ such that every $f(k)$-strong digraph admits a spanning $k$-strong oriented subdigraph. They even conjectured that one can take $f(k)=2k$ [Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 555 (1989) 402-412]. Already the existence of $f(2)$ is open for general digraphs. Thomassen proved that $f(2)=4$ for symmetric digraphs. For general $k$, the existence of $f(k)$ was only known for locally semicomplete digraphs and quasi-transitive digraphs. Guo proved that every ${(3k-2)}$-strong locally semicomplete digraph contains a spanning $k$-strong local tournament [Discrete Appl. Math. 79 (1997) 119--125]. One can deduce from Guo's result that we have $f(k)\leq 3k-2$ for quasi-transitive digraphs. In this paper, we prove the existence of $f(k)$ for two subclasses of the semicomplete multipartite digraphs, namely extended semicomplete digraphs and semicomplete split digraphs. We prove that every $(4k+1)$-strong extended semicomplete digraph contains a spanning $k$-strong oriented subdigraph and every $5k$-strong semicomplete split digraph contains a spanning $k$-strong oriented subdigraph. The first result implies that for the large class of digraphs which can be obtained from some semicomplete digraph $S$ on at least 3 vertices by substituting arbitrary digraphs for each vertex of $S$ we also have $f(k)\leq 4k+1$.

The acyclic dichromatic number of an oriented graph is the minimum size of a vertex-partition such that the digraphs induced by any single part are acyclic, and the oriented bipartite graphs between any two parts are acyclic too. We characterize the subtournaments that must appear in every tournament with sufficiently large acyclic dichromatic number, thereby confirming a conjecture of Bang-Jensen, Picasarri-Arrieta, and Yeo and prove that acyclic dichromatic number satisfies a local to global property.

We study the $b$-biased Oriented-cycle game where two players, OMaker and OBreaker, take turns directing the edges of $K_n$ (the complete graph on $n$ vertices). In each round, OMaker directs one previously undirected edge followed by OBreaker directing between one and $b$ previously undirected edges. The game ends once all edges have been directed, and OMaker wins if and only if the resulting tournament contains a directed cycle. Bollobás and Szabó asked the following question: what is the largest value of the bias $b$ for which OMaker has a winning strategy? Ben-Eliezer, Krivelevich and Sudakov proved that OMaker has a winning strategy for $b \leq n/2 - 2$. In the other direction, Clemens and Liebenau proved that OBreaker has a winning strategy for $b \geq 5n/6+2$. Inspired by their approach, we propose a significantly stronger strategy for OBreaker which we prove to be winning for $b \geq 0.7841n + O(1)$.

Let $D$ be a tournament and let $X\subseteq V(D)$. The inversion of $X$ reverses all arcs whose both endpoints lie in $X$ and leaves every other arc unchanged. A family of inversions is a decycling family if applying all of them produces an acyclic, equivalently transitive, tournament. The inversion number $\inv(D)$ is the minimum size of such a family. Let $Q_n$ be the tournament on $[n]$ obtained from the natural transitive tournament by reversing precisely the consecutive pairs $12,23,\ldots,(n-1)n$. Belkhechine, Bouaziz, Boudabbous, and Pouzet conjectured in their unpublished manuscript that a natural path-reversed family has inversion number exactly $\left\lfloor(n-1)/2\right\rfloor$. The same problem was later recorded by Bang-Jensen, da Silva, and Havet and by Alon, Powierski, Savery, Scott, and Wilmer. In this paper we resolve this conjecture.

A homogeneous set in a graph is a clique or a stable set. The Erdős--Hajnal conjecture states that, for every graph $H$, there exists $c>0$ such that every $H$-free graph on $n$ vertices has a homogeneous set of size at least $n^c$. Nguyen, Scott and Seymour proved that for every $d>0$, graphs of VC-dimension at most $d$ have the Erdős--Hajnal property, confirming a conjecture of Fox, Pach and Suk. In particular, they showed that every such $n$-vertex graph contains a homogeneous set of size at least $n^{η_d}$ for some $η_d\ge 2^{-2^{O(d)}}$. In this paper, we give a sharper quantitative bound on the homogeneous sets in graphs of VC-dimension at most $d$, showing that one may take $ η_d\ge (Cd)^{-d}, $ where $C$ is an absolute constant. Equivalently, every graph $G$ of VC-dimension at most $d$ satisfies \[ \max\{ω(G),α(G)\}\ge |G|^{(Cd)^{-d}}. \] Our proof refines the iterative sparsification method of Nguyen, Scott and Seymour. The main enhancement is to apply the VC-dimension assumption directly, which gives a more efficient induction and thus improves the dependence on $d$. We also derive quantitative consequences for polynomial Rödl subgraphs, hypergraph Ramsey bounds under bounded VC-dimension, induced-free and viral formulations, tournaments, NIP and semi-algebraic graphs, Boolean combinations of relations of bounded VC-dimension, graphs whose adjacency matrices have bounded rank, graphs of bounded sign-rank, and graphs defined by dot-product threshold representations.

We investigate metric dimension and the localization game for several families of directed analogues of strongly regular graphs and their generalizations, adapting a probabilistic method of Babai (1980) for bounding the size of resolving sets in undirected strongly regular graphs. We derive upper bounds on the localization number and metric dimension depending on the order of the graph and the maximum number of common out-neighbours for a pair of vertices. We consider normally regular digraphs, so-called "ordinary graphs", classes of Deza digraphs, divisible design digraphs, nearly doubly regular tournaments, and certain doubly regular team tournaments. In particular, for asymmetric normally regular digraphs on $n$ vertices, we show that these invariants are bounded above by $O(\sqrt{n} \log n)$, and improve this to $O(\log n)$ for a class of doubly regular team tournaments.