arXiv++ Combinatorics

A connected graph G is 3-flow-critical if G does not have a nowhere-zero 3-flow, but every proper contraction of G does. We prove that every n-vertex 3-flow-critical graph other than K_2 and K_4 has at least 5n/3 edges. This bound is tight up to lower-order terms, answering a question of Li et al. (2022). It also generalizes the result of Koester (1991) on the maximum average degree of 4-critical planar graphs.

A subset $S$ of vertices in a planar graph $G$ is a free set if, for every set $P$ of $|S|$ points in the plane, there exists a straight-line crossing-free drawing of $G$ in which vertices of $S$ are mapped to distinct points in $P$. In this survey, we review - several equivalent definitions of free sets, - results on the existence of large free sets in planar graphs and subclasses of planar graphs, - and applications of free sets in graph drawing. The survey concludes with a list of open problems in this still very active research area.

A total coloring of a graph colors all its elements, vertices and edges, with no adjacency conflicts. The Total Coloring Conjecture (TCC) is a sixty year old challenge, says that every graph admits a total coloring with at most maximum degree plus two colors, and many graph parameters have been studied in connection with its validity. If a graph admits a total coloring with maximum degree plus one colors, then it is Type 1, whereas it is Type 2, in case it does not admit a total coloring with maximum degree plus one colors but it does satisfy the TCC. Cavicchioli, Murgolo and Ruini proposed in 2003 the hunting for a Type 2 snark with girth at least 5. Brinkmann, Preissmann and Sasaki in 2015 conjectured that there is no Type 2 cubic graph with girth at least 5. We investigate the total coloring of fullerene nanodiscs, a class of cubic planar graphs with girth 5 arising in Chemistry. We prove that the central layer of an arbitrary fullerene nanodisc is 4-total colorable, a necessary condition for the nanodisc to be Type 1. We extend the obtained 4-total coloring to a 4-total coloring of the whole nanodisc, when the radius satisfies r = 5 + 3k, providing an infinite family of Type 1 nanodiscs.

A vertex coloring of a graph $G$ is called a $2$-distance coloring if any two vertices at a distance at most $2$ from each other receive different colors. Recently, Bousquet et al. (Discrete Mathematics, 346(4), 113288, 2023) proved that $2Δ+7$ colors are sufficient for the $2$-distance coloring of planar graphs with maximum degree $Δ\geq 9$. In this paper, we strengthen their result by removing the maximum degree constraint and show that all planar graphs admit a 2-distance $(2Δ+7)$-coloring. This particularly improves the result of Van den Heuvel and McGuinness (Journal of Graph Theory, 42(2), 110-124, 2003).

Let $\mathcal {F}$ be a given family of graphs. A graph $G$ is $\mathcal {F}$-free if it does not contain any member of $\mathcal {F}$ as a subgraph. Let $C_{l, l}$ be a graph obtained from $2C_l$ such that the two cycles share a common vertex, where $l\geqslant3 $. A $\mathrm{Theta}$ graph is obtained from a cycle $C_k$ by adding an additional edge between two non-consecutive vertices on $C_k$, where $k\geqslant 4$. Let $Θ_k$ be the set of $\mathrm{Theta}$ graphs on $k$ vertices, where $k \geqslant 4$. For sufficiently large $n $, the unique extremal planar graph with the maximum spectral radius among $C_{l, l}$-free planar graphs on $n$ vertices and among $Θ_k$-free planar graphs on $n$ vertices are characterized respectively, where $l \geqslant 3$ and $k \geqslant 4$.

The arboricity $Γ(G)$ of an undirected graph $G =(V,E)$ is the minimal number $k$ such that $E$ can be partitioned into $k$ forests on $V$. Nash-Williams' formula states that $k = \lceil γ(G) \rceil$, where $γ(G)$ is the maximum of $\frac{|E_{H}|}{|V_{H}|-1}$ over all subgraphs $(V_H , E_H )$ of $G$ with $|V_H | \geq 2$. The Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture states that if $γ(G) \leq k + \frac{d}{d+k+1}$ for $k, d \in \mathbb{N}$, then there is a partition of the edge set of $G$ into $k + 1$ forests on $V$ such that one forest has at most $d$ edges in each connected component. Here we prove the Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture when $d \leq 2(k +1)$, which is a new result for all $(k, d)$ such that $d > k + 1$. In fact, we prove a stronger theorem. We prove that a weaker sparsity notion, called $(k, d)$-sparseness, suffices to give the decomposition, under the assumption that the graph decomposes into $k+1$ forests. This is a new result for all $(k, d)$ where $d > 1$, and improves upon the recent resolution of the Overfull Nine Dragon Tree Theorem for all $(k, d)$ when $d \leq 2(k +1)$. As a corollary, we obtain that planar graphs of girth five decompose into a forest and a forest where every component has at most four edges, and by duality, we obtain that $5$-edge-connected planar graphs have a $\frac{4}{5}$-thin tree, improving a result of the authors that $5$-edge-connected planar graphs have a $\frac{5}{6}$-thin tree

This paper concerns $(r,c)$-constant graphs, which are $r$-regular graphs in which the subgraph induced by the open neighbourhood of every vertex has precisely $c$ edges. The family of $(r,c)$-graphs contains vertex-transitive graphs (and in particular Cayley graphs), graphs with constant link (sometimes called locally isomorphic graphs), $(r,b)$-regular graphs, strongly regular graphs, and much more. This family was recently introduced in [arXiv:2312.08777] serving as important tool in constructing flip graphs [arXiv:2312.08777, arXiv:2401.02315]. In this paper we shall mainly deal with the following: i. Existence and non-existence of $(r, c)$-planar graphs. We completely determine the cases of existence and non-existence of such graphs and supply the smallest order in the case when they exist. ii. We consider the existence of $(r, c)$-circulant graphs. We prove that for $c \equiv 2 \ (\mathrm{mod} \ 3)$ no $(r,c)$-circulant graph exists and that for $c \equiv 0, 1 \ (\mathrm{mod} \ 3)$, $c > 0$ and $r \geq 6 + \sqrt{\frac{8c - 5}{3}}$ there exists $(r,c)$-circulant graphs. Moreover for $c = 0$ and $r \geq 1$, $(r, 0)$-circulants exist. iii. We consider the existence and non-existence of small $(r,c)$-constant graphs, supplying a complete table of the smallest order of graphs we found for $0 \leq c \leq \binom{r}{2}$ and $r \leq 6$. We shall also determine all the cases in this range for which $(r,c)$-constant graphs don't exist. We establish a public database of $(r,c)$-constant graphs for varying $r$, $c$ and order.

A dominating set of a graph $G$ is a subset $S$ of its vertices such that each vertex of $G$ not in $S$ has a neighbor in $S$. A face-hitting set of a plane graph $G$ is a set $T$ of vertices in $G$ such that every face of $G$ contains at least one vertex of $T$. We show that the vertex-set of every plane (multi-)graph without isolated vertices, self-loops or $2$-faces can be partitioned into two disjoint sets so that both the sets are dominating and face-hitting. We also show that all the three assumptions above are necessary for the conclusion. As a corollary, we show that every $n$-vertex simple plane triangulation has a dominating set of size at most $(1 - α)n/2$, where $αn$ is the maximum size of an independent set in the triangulation. Matheson and Tarjan [European J. Combin., 1996] conjectured that every plane triangulation with a sufficiently large number of vertices $n$ has a dominating set of size at most $n / 4$. Currently, the best known general bound for this is by Christiansen, Rotenberg and Rutschmann [SODA, 2024] who showed that every plane triangulation on $n > 10$ vertices has a dominating set of size at most $2n/7$. Our corollary improves their bound for $n$-vertex plane triangulations which contain a maximal independent set of size either less than $2n/7$ or more than $3n/7$.

In this work, we study how far one can deviate from optimal behavior when embedding a planar graph. For a planar graph $G$, we say that a plane subgraph $H\subseteq G$ is a \textit{plane-saturated subgraph} if adding any edge (possibly with new vertices) to $H$ would either violate planarity or make the resulting graph no longer a subgraph of $G$. For a planar graph $G$, we define the \textit{plane-saturation ratio}, $\psr(G)$, as the minimum value of $\frac{e(H)}{e(G)}$ for a plane-saturated subgraph $H$ of $G$ and investigate how small $\psr(G)$ can be. While there exist planar graphs where $\psr(G)$ is arbitrarily close to $0$, we show that for all twin-free planar graphs, $\psr(G)>1/16$, and that there exist twin-free planar graphs where $\psr(G)$ is arbitrarily close to $1/16$. In fact, we study a broader category of planar graphs, focusing on classes characterized by a bounded number of degree $1$ and degree $2$ twin vertices. We offer solutions for some instances of bounds while positing conjectures for the remaining ones.

Given a graph $G$, two edges $e_{1},e_{2}\in E(G)$ are said to have a common edge $e$ if $e$ joins an endvertex of $e_{1}$ to an endvertex of $e_{2}$. A subset $B\subseteq E(G)$ is an edge open packing set in $G$ if no two edges of $B$ have a common edge in $G$, and the maximum cardinality of such a set in $G$ is called the edge open packing number, $ρ_{e}^{o}(G)$, of $G$. In this paper, we prove that the decision version of the edge open packing number is NP-complete even when restricted to graphs with universal vertices, Eulerian bipartite graphs, and planar graphs with maximum degree $4$, respectively. In contrast, we present a linear-time algorithm that computes the edge open packing number of a tree. We also resolve two problems posed in the seminal paper [Edge open packing sets in graphs, RAIRO-Oper.\ Res.\ 56 (2022) 3765--3776]. Notably, we characterize the graphs $G$ that attain the upper bound $ρ_e^o(G)\le |E(G)|/δ(G)$, and provide lower and upper bounds for the edge-deleted subgraph of a graph and establish the corresponding realization result.

One of the fundamental results in graph minor theory is that for every planar graph $H$, there is a minimum integer $f(H)$ such that graphs with no minor isomorphic to $H$ have treewidth at most $f(H)$. A lower bound for ${f(H)}$ can be obtained by considering the maximum integer $k$ such that $H$ contains $k$ vertex-disjoint cycles. There exists a graph of treewidth ${Ω(k\log k)}$ which does not contain $k$ vertex-disjoint cycles, from which it follows that ${f(H) = Ω(k\log k)}$. In particular, if ${f(H)}$ is linear in ${\lvert{V(H)}\rvert}$ for graphs $H$ from a subclass of planar graphs, it is necessary that $n$-vertex graphs from the class contain at most ${O(n/\log(n))}$ vertex-disjoint cycles. We ask whether this is also a sufficient condition, and demonstrate that this is true for classes of planar graphs with bounded component size. For an $n$-vertex graph $H$ which is a disjoint union of $r$ cycles, we show that ${f(H) \leq 3n/2 + O(r^2 \log r)}$, and improve this to ${f(H) \leq n + O(\sqrt{n})}$ when ${r = 2}$. In particular this bound is linear when ${r=O(\sqrt{n}/\log(n))}$. We present a linear bound for ${f(H)}$ when $H$ is a subdivision of an $r$-edge planar graph for any constant $r$. We also improve the best known bounds for ${f(H)}$ when $H$ is the wheel graph or the ${4 \times 4}$ grid, obtaining a bound of $160$ for the latter.

The spectral extremal problem of planar graphs has aroused a lot of interest over the past three decades. In 1991, Boots and Royle [Geogr. Anal. 23(3) (1991) 276--282] (and Cao and Vince [Linear Algebra Appl. 187 (1993) 251--257] independently) conjectured that $K_2 + P_{n-2}$ is the unique graph attaining the maximum spectral radius among all planar graphs on $n$ vertices, where $K_2 + P_{n-2}$ is the graph obtained from $K_2\cup P_{n-2}$ by adding all possible edges between $K_2$ and $P_{n-2}$. In 2017, Tait and Tobin [J. Combin. Theory Ser. B 126 (2017) 137--161] confirmed this conjecture for all sufficiently large $n$. In this paper, we consider the spectral extremal problem for planar graphs without specified subgraphs. For a fixed graph $F$, let $\mathrm{SPEX}_{\mathcal{P}}(n,F)$ denote the set of graphs attaining the maximum spectral radius among all $F$-free planar graphs on $n$ vertices. We describe a rough sturcture for the connected extremal graphs in $\mathrm{SPEX}_{\mathcal{P}}(n,F)$ when $F$ is a planar graph not contained in $K_{2,n-2}$. As applications, we determine the extremal graphs in $\mathrm{SPEX}_{\mathcal{P}}(n,W_k)$, $\mathrm{SPEX}_{\mathcal{P}}(n,F_k)$ and $\mathrm{SPEX}_{\mathcal{P}}(n,(k+1)K_2)$ for all sufficiently large $n$, where $W_k$, $F_k$ and $(k+1)K_2$ are the wheel graph of order $k$, the friendship graph of order $2k+1$ and the disjoint union of $k+1$ copies of $K_2$, respectively.

The crossing number of a graph $G$ is the minimum number of crossings in a drawing of $G$ in the plane. A rectilinear drawing of a graph $G$ represents vertices of $G$ by a set of points in the plane and represents each edge of $G$ by a straight-line segment connecting its two endpoints. The rectilinear crossing number of $G$ is the minimum number of crossings in a rectilinear drawing of $G$. By the crossing lemma, the crossing number of an $n$-vertex graph $G$ can be $O(n)$ only if $|E(G)|\in O(n)$. Graphs of bounded genus and bounded degree (Böröczky, Pach and Tóth, 2006) and in fact all bounded degree proper minor-closed families (Wood and Telle, 2007) have been shown to admit linear crossing number, with tight $Θ(Δn)$ bound shown by Dujmović, Kawarabayashi, Mohar and Wood, 2008. Much less is known about rectilinear crossing number. It is not bounded by any function of the crossing number. We prove that graphs that exclude a single-crossing graph as a minor have the rectilinear crossing number $O(Δn)$. This dependence on $n$ and $Δ$ is best possible. A single-crossing graph is a graph whose crossing number is at most one. Thus the result applies to $K_5$-minor-free graphs, for example. It also applies to bounded treewidth graphs, since each family of bounded treewidth graphs excludes some fixed planar graph as a minor. Prior to our work, the only bounded degree minor-closed families known to have linear rectilinear crossing number were bounded degree graphs of bounded treewidth (Wood and Telle, 2007), as well as, bounded degree $K_{3,3}$-minor-free graphs (Dujmović, Kawarabayashi, Mohar and Wood, 2008). In the case of bounded treewidth graphs, our $O(Δn)$ result is again tight and improves on the previous best known bound of $O(Δ^2 n)$ by Wood and Telle, 2007 (obtained for convex geometric drawings).

The process of drawing electoral district boundaries is known as political redistricting. Within this context, gerrymandering is the practice of drawing these boundaries such that they unfairly favor a particular political party, often leading to unequal representation and skewed electoral outcomes. One of the few ways to detect gerrymandering is by algorithmically sampling redistricting plans. Previous methods mainly focus on sampling from some neighborhood of ``realistic' districting plans, rather than a uniform sample of the entire space. We present a deterministic subexponential time algorithm to uniformly sample from the space of all possible $ k $-partitions of a bounded degree planar graph, and with this construct a sample of the entire space of redistricting plans. We also give a way to restrict this sample space to plans that match certain compactness and population constraints at the cost of added complexity. The algorithm runs in $ 2^{O(\sqrt{n}\log n)} $ time, although we only give a heuristic implementation. Our method generalizes an algorithm to count self-avoiding walks on a square to count paths that split general planar graphs into $ k $ regions, and uses this to sample from the space of all $ k $-partitions of a planar graph.

Motivated by recent developments regarding the product structure of planar graphs, we study relationships between treewidth, grid minors, and graph products. We show that the Cartesian product of any two connected $n$-vertex graphs contains an $Ω(\sqrt{n})\timesΩ(\sqrt{n})$ grid minor. This result is tight: The lexicographic product (which includes the Cartesian product as a subgraph) of a star and any $n$-vertex tree has no $ω(\sqrt{n})\timesω(\sqrt{n})$ grid minor.

Given a graph $G$ and $k \in \mathbb{N}$, we introduce the following game played in $G$. Each round, Alice colours an uncoloured vertex of $G$ red, and then Bob colours one blue (if any remain). Once every vertex is coloured, Alice wins if there is a connected red component of order at least $k$, and otherwise, Bob wins. This is a Maker-Breaker version of the Largest Connected Subgraph game introduced in [Bensmail et al. The Largest Connected Subgraph Game. {\it Algorithmica}, 84(9):2533--2555, 2022]. We want to compute $c_g(G)$, which is the maximum $k$ such that Alice wins in $G$, regardless of Bob's strategy. Given a graph $G$ and $k\in \mathbb{N}$, we prove that deciding whether $c_g(G)\geq k$ is PSPACE-complete, even if $G$ is a bipartite, split, or planar graph. To better understand the Largest Connected Subgraph game, we then focus on {\it A-perfect} graphs, which are the graphs $G$ for which $c_g(G)=\lceil|V(G)|/2\rceil$, {\it i.e.}, those in which Alice can ensure that the red subgraph is connected. We give sufficient conditions, in terms of the minimum and maximum degrees or the number of edges, for a graph to be A-perfect. Also, we show that, for any $d \geq 4$, there are arbitrarily large A-perfect $d$-regular graphs, but no cubic graph with order at least $18$ is A-perfect. Lastly, we show that $c_g(G)$ is computable in linear time when $G$ is a $P_4$-sparse graph (a superclass of cographs).

We investigate how small the Randić index of a graph can be in terms of its matching number, and prove several results. We give best-possible linear bounds for graphs of small excess and for subcubic graphs; in the former case the size of excess we permit is qualitatively the best possible. We show that a linear bound holds for any sparse hereditary graph class (such as planar graphs). In general, however, we show that it can be much smaller than linear. We determine the asymptotic growth rate of the minimum Randić index for graphs with a near perfect matching, and conjecture that the same bounds hold for all graphs.

A maximal double Roman dominating function (MDRDF) on a graph $G=(V,E)$ is a function $f:V(G)\rightarrow \{0,1,2,3\}$ such that \textrm{(i) }every vertex $v$ with $f(v)=0$ is adjacent to least two vertices { assigned $2$ or to at least one vertex assigned $3,$} \textrm{(ii) }every vertex $v$ with $f(v)=1$ is adjacent to at least one { vertex assigned $2$ or $3$} and \textrm{(iii) }the set $\{w\in V|~f(w)=0\}$ is not a dominating set of $G $. The weight of a MDRDF is the sum of its function values over all vertices, and the maximal double Roman domination number $γ_{dR}^{m}(G) $ is the minimum weight of an MDRDF on $G$. {In this paper, we initiate the study of maximal double Roman domination. We first show that the problem of determining }$γ_{dR}^{m}(G)$ {is NP-complete for bipartite, chordal and planar graphs. But it is solvable in linear time for bounded clique-width graphs including trees, cographs and distance-hereditary graphs. Moreover, we establish various relationships relating }$γ_{dR}^{m}(G)$ to some domination parameters. {For the class of trees, we show that for every tree }$T$ {of order }$n\geq 4,$ $γ_{dR}^{m}(T)\leq \frac{5}{4}n$ {and we characterize all trees attaining the bound. Finally, the exact values of }$γ_{dR}^{m}(G) $ {are given for paths and cycles.

Given a spanning tree $T$ of a planar graph $G$, the co-tree of $T$ is the spanning tree of the dual graph $G^*$ with edge set $(E(G)-E(T))^*$. Grünbaum conjectured in 1970 that every planar 3-connected graph $G$ contains a spanning tree $T$ such that both $T$ and its co-tree have maximum degree at most 3. While Grünbaum's conjecture remains open, Biedl proved that there is a spanning tree $T$ such that $T$ and its co-tree have maximum degree at most 5. By using new structural insights into Schnyder woods, we prove that there is a spanning tree $T$ such that $T$ and its co-tree have maximum degree at most 4.

We study the problem of finding homomorphisms into odd cycles from planar graphs with high odd-girth. The Jaeger-Zhang conjecture states that every planar graph of odd-girth at least $4k+1$ admits a homomorphism to the odd cycle $C_{2k+1}$. The $k=1$ case is the well-known Grötzsch's $3$-coloring theorem. For general $k$, in 2013 Lovász, Thomassen, Wu, and Zhang showed that it suffices to have odd-girth at least $6k+1$. Improvements are known for $C_5$ and $C_7$ in [Combinatorica 2017, SIDMA 2020, Combinatorica 2022]. For $C_9$ we improve this hypothesis by showing that it suffices to have odd-girth 23. Our main tool is a variation on the potential method applied to modular orientations. This allows more flexibility when seeking reducible configurations. The same techniques also prove some results on circular coloring of signed planar graphs.