arXiv++ Combinatorics

A graph property is monotone if it is closed under removal of vertices and edges. In this paper we consider the following edge-deletion problem; given a monotone property P and a graph G, compute the smallest number of edge deletions that are needed in order to turn G into a graph satisfying P. We denote this quantity by E_P(G). Our first result states that for any monotone graph property P, any ε>0 and n-vertex input graph G one can approximate E_P(G) up to an additive error of εn^2 Our second main result shows that such approximation is essentially best possible and for most properties, it is NP-hard to approximate E_P(G) up to an additive error of n^{2-δ}, for any fixed positive δ. The proof requires several new combinatorial ideas and involves tools from Extremal Graph Theory together with spectral techniques. Interestingly, prior to this work it was not even known that computing E_P(G) precisely for dense monotone properties is NP-hard. We thus answer (in a strong form) a question of Yannakakis raised in 1981.

In this article, we study the problem of finding the longest common separable pattern between several permutations. We give a polynomial-time algorithm when the number of input permutations is fixed and show that the problem is NP-hard for an arbitrary number of input permutations even if these permutations are separable. On the other hand, we show that the NP-hard problem of finding the longest common pattern between two permutations cannot be approximated better than within a ratio of $sqrt{Opt}$ (where $Opt$ is the size of an optimal solution) when taking common patterns belonging to pattern-avoiding classes of permutations.

The (two) core of a hypergraph is the maximal collection of hyperedges within which no vertex appears only once. It is of importance in tasks such as efficiently solving a large linear system over GF[2], or iterative decoding of low-density parity-check codes used over the binary erasure channel. Similar structures emerge in a variety of NP-hard combinatorial optimization and decision problems, from vertex cover to satisfiability. For a uniformly chosen random hypergraph of $m=nρ$ vertices and $n$ hyperedges, each consisting of the same fixed number $l\geq3$ of vertices, the size of the core exhibits for large $n$ a first-order phase transition, changing from $o(n)$ for $ρ>ρ_{\mathrm{c}}$ to a positive fraction of $n$ for $ρ<ρ_{\mathrm{c}}$, with a transition window size $Θ(n^{-1/2})$ around $ρ_{\mathrm{c}}>0$. Analyzing the corresponding ``leaf removal'' algorithm, we determine the associated finite-size scaling behavior. In particular, if $ρ$ is inside the scaling window (more precisely, $ρ=ρ_{\mathrm{c}}+rn^{-1/2}$), the probability of having a core of size $Θ(n)$ has a limit strictly between 0 and 1, and a leading correction of order $Θ(n^{-1/6})$. The correction admits a sharp characterization in terms of the distribution of a Brownian motion with quadratic shift, from which it inherits the scaling with $n$. This behavior is expected to be universal for a wide collection of combinatorial problems.

We consider local Markov chain Monte-Carlo algorithms for sampling from the weighted distribution of independent sets with activity $ł$, where the weight of an independent set $I$ is $ł^{|I|}$. A recent result has established that Gibbs sampling is rapidly mixing in sampling the distribution for graphs of maximum degree $d$ and $ł<ł_c(d)$, where $ł_c(d)$ is the critical activity for uniqueness of the Gibbs measure (i.e., for decay of correlations with distance in the weighted distribution over independent sets) on the $d$-regular infinite tree. We show that for $d \geq 3$, $ł$ just above $ł_c(d)$ with high probability over $d$-regular bipartite graphs, any local Markov chain Monte-Carlo algorithm takes exponential time before getting close to the stationary distribution. Our results provide a rigorous justification for ``replica'' method heuristics. These heuristics were invented in theoretical physics and are used in order to derive predictions on Gibbs measures on random graphs in terms of Gibbs measures on trees. We conjecture that $ł_c$ is in fact the exact threshold for this computational problem, i.e., that for $ł>ł_c$ it is NP-hard to approximate the above weighted sum overindependent sets to within a factor polynomial in the size of the graph.

We show that reconstructing a tree from order information on triples is NP-hard. This is in contrast to the case for ultra-metrics and for subtree information on quadruples which are both known to allow polynomial time reconstruction.

Given a permutation pi, the application of prefix reversal f^(i) to pi reverses the order of the first i elements of pi. The problem of Sorting By Prefix Reversals (also known as pancake flipping), made famous by Gates and Papadimitriou (Bounds for sorting by prefix reversal, Discrete Mathematics 27, pp. 47-57), asks for the minimum number of prefix reversals required to sort the elements of a given permutation. In this paper we study a variant of this problem where the prefix reversals act not on permutations but on strings over a fixed size alphabet. We determine the minimum number of prefix reversals required to sort binary and ternary strings, with polynomial-time algorithms for these sorting problems as a result; demonstrate that computing the minimum prefix reversal distance between two binary strings is NP-hard; give an exact expression for the prefix reversal diameter of binary strings, and give bounds on the prefix reversal diameter of ternary strings. We also consider a weaker form of sorting called grouping (of identical symbols) and give polynomial-time algorithms for optimally grouping binary and ternary strings. A number of intriguing open problems are also discussed.

Let $N \geq2$ and let $1 < a_1 < ... < a_N$ be relatively prime integers. Frobenius number of this $N$-tuple is defined to be the largest positive integer that cannot be expressed as $\sum_{i=1}^N a_i x_i$ where $x_1,...,x_N$ are non-negative integers. The condition that $gcd(a_1,...,a_N)=1$ implies that such number exists. The general problem of determining the Frobenius number given $N$ and $a_1,...,a_N$ is NP-hard, but there has been a number of different bounds on the Frobenius number produced by various authors. We use techniques from the geometry of numbers to produce a new bound, relating Frobenius number to the covering radius of the null-lattice of this $N$-tuple. Our bound is particularly interesting in the case when this lattice has equal successive minima, which, as we prove, happens infinitely often.

This paper discusses the complexity of graph pebbling, dealing with both traditional pebbling and the recently introduced game of cover pebbling. Determining whether a configuration is solvable according to either the traditional definition or the cover pebbling definition is shown to be NP-complete. The problem of determining the cover pebbling number for an arbitrary demand configuration is shown to be NP-hard.

We show that determining Kapranov rank of tropical matrices is not only NP-hard over any infinite field but also if solving Diophantine equations over the rational numbers is undecidable, then determining Kapranov rank over the rational numbers is undecidable. We prove that Kapranov rank of tropical matrices is not bounded in terms of tropical rank, answering a question of Develin, Santos, and Sturmfels.

We show factorization of polynomials in one variable over the tropical semiring is in general NP-complete, either if all coefficients are finite, or if all are either 0 or infinity (Boolean case). We give algorithms for the factorization problem which are not polynomial time in the degree, but are polynomial time for polynomials of fixed degree. For two-variable polynomials we derive an irreducibility criterion which is almost always satisfied, even for fixed degree, and is polynomial time in the degree. We prove there are unique least common multiples of tropical polynomials, but not unique greatest common divisors. We show that if two polynomials in one variable have a common tropical factor, then their eliminant matrix is singular in the tropical sense. We prove the problem of determining tropical rank is NP-hard.

Morse matchings capture the essential structural information of discrete Morse functions. We show that computing optimal Morse matchings is NP-hard and give an integer programming formulation for the problem. Then we present polyhedral results for the corresponding polytope and report on computational results.

Can the vertices of a graph $G$ be partitioned into $A \cup B$, so that $G[A]$ is a line-graph and $G[B]$ is a forest? Can $G$ be partitioned into a planar graph and a perfect graph? The NP-completeness of these problems are just special cases of our result: if ${\cal P}$ and ${\cal Q}$ are additive induced-hereditary graph properties, then $({\cal P}, {\cal Q})$-colouring is NP-hard, with the sole exception of graph 2-colouring (the case where both $\cal P$ and $\cal Q$ are the set ${\cal O}$ of finite edgeless graphs). Moreover, $({\cal P}, {\cal Q})$-colouring is NP-complete iff ${\cal P}$- and ${\cal Q}$-recognition are both in NP. This proves a conjecture of Kratochvíl and Schiermeyer.

For graph classes $P_1,...,P_k$, Generalized Graph Coloring is the problem of deciding whether the vertex set of a given graph $G$ can be partitioned into subsets $V_1,...,V_k$ so that $V_j$ induces a graph in the class $P_j$ $(j=1,2,...,k)$. If $P_1 = ... = P_k$ is the class of edgeless graphs, then this problem coincides with the standard vertex $k$-{\sc colorability}, which is known to be NP-complete for any $k\ge 3$. Recently, this result has been generalized by showing that if all $P_i$'s are additive induced-hereditary, then generalized graph coloring is NP-hard, with the only exception of recognising bipartite graphs. Clearly, a similar result follows when all the $P_i$'s are co-additive. In this paper, we study the problem where we have a mixture of additive and co-additive classes, presenting several new results dealing both with NP-hard and polynomial-time solvable instances of the problem.

Maximum satisfiability is a canonical NP-hard optimization problem that appears empirically hard for random instances. Let us say that a Conjunctive normal form (CNF) formula consisting of $k$-clauses is $p$-satisfiable if there exists a truth assignment satisfying $1-2^{-k}+p 2^{-k}$ of all clauses (observe that every $k$-CNF is 0-satisfiable). Also, let $F_k(n,m)$ denote a random $k$-CNF on $n$ variables formed by selecting uniformly and independently $m$ out of all possible $k$-clauses. It is easy to prove that for every $k>1$ and every $p$ in $(0,1]$, there is $R_k(p)$ such that if $r >R_k(p)$, then the probability that $F_k(n,rn)$ is $p$-satisfiable tends to 0 as $n$ tends to infinity. We prove that there exists a sequence $δ_k \to 0$ such that if $r <(1-δ_k) R_k(p)$ then the probability that $F_k(n,rn)$is $p$-satisfiable tends to 1 as $n$ tends to infinity. The sequence $δ_k$ tends to 0 exponentially fast in $k$.

We consider a class of multivariate recurrences frequently arising in the worst case analysis of Davis-Putnam-style exponential time backtracking algorithms for NP-hard problems. We describe a technique for proving asymptotic upper bounds on these recurrences, by using a suitable weight function to reduce the problem to that of solving univariate linear recurrences; show how to use quasiconvex programming to determine the weight function yielding the smallest upper bound; and prove that the resulting upper bounds are within a polynomial factor of the true asymptotics of the recurrence. We develop and implement a multiple-gradient descent algorithm for the resulting quasiconvex programs, using a real-number arithmetic package for guaranteed accuracy of the computed worst case time bounds.

We propose a novel algorithm for enumerating and listing all minimal cutsets of a given graph. It is known that this problem is NP-hard. We use connectivity properties of a given graph to develop an algorithm with reduced complexity for finding all its cutsets. We use breadth first search (BFS) method in conjunction with edge contraction to develop the algorithm. We introduce the concepts of a pivot vertex and absorbable clusters and use them to develop an enhanced recursive contraction algorithm. The complexity of the proposed algorithm is proportionate to the number of cutsets. We present simulation results to compare the performance of our proposed algorithm with those of existing methods.

We consider a problem of optimizing convex functionals over matroid bases. It is richly expressive and captures certain quadratic assignment and clustering problems. While generally NP-hard, we show it is polynomial time solvable when a suitable parameter is restricted.

The well-studied local postage stamp problem (LPSP) is the following: given a positive integer k, a set of postive integers 1 = a1 < a2 < ... < ak and an integer h >= 1, what is the smallest positive integer which cannot be represented as a linear combination x1 a1 + ... + xk ak where x1 + ... + xk <= h and each xi is a non-negative integer? In this note we prove that LPSP is NP-hard under Turing reductions, but can be solved in polynomial time if k is fixed.

The problem of finding a triangulation of a convex three-dimensional polytope with few tetrahedra is proved to be NP-hard. We discuss other related complexity results.

Let $μ$ be a metric on a set T, and let c be a nonnegative function on the unordered pairs of elements of a superset $V\supseteq T$. We consider the problem of minimizing the inner product $c\cdot m$ over all semimetrics m on V such that m coincides with $μ$ within T and each element of V is at zero distance from T (a variant of the {\em multifacility location problem}). In particular, this generalizes the well-known multiterminal multiway) cut problem. Two cases of metrics $μ$ have been known for which the problem can be solved in polynomial time: (a) $μ$ is a modular metric whose underlying graph $H(μ)$ is hereditary modular and orientable (in a certain sense); and (b) $μ$ is a median metric. In the latter case an optimal solution can be found by use of a cut uncrossing method. \Xcomment{We give a common generalization for both cases by proving that the problem is in P for any modular metric $μ$ whose all orbit graphs are hereditary modular and orientable. To this aim, we show the existence of a retraction of the Cartesian product of the orbit graphs to $H(μ)$, which enables us to elaborate an analog of the cut uncrossing method for such metrics $μ$.} In this paper we generalize the idea of cut uncrossing to show the polynomial solvability for a wider class of metrics $μ$, which includes the median metrics as a special case. The metric uncrossing method that we develop relies on the existence of retractions of certain modular graphs. On the negative side, we prove that for $μ$ fixed, the problem is NP-hard if $μ$ is non-modular or $H(μ)$ is non-orientable.