arXiv++ Combinatorics

Henze and Malikiosis (2017) have shown that the Lonely Runner Conjecture (LRC) can be restated as a convex-geometric question on the so-called LR zonotopes, lattice zonotopes with one more generator than their dimension. This relation naturally suggests a more general statement, the shifted LRC, the zonotopal version of which concerns a classical parameter, the covering radius. In this paper we do two things: 1) We show explicit counterexamples to both the shifted Lonely Runner Conjecture (starting at $n=5$) and to the Lonely Vector Property of Malikiosis-Schymura-Santos (2025). 2) We push the analogies between the two versions of LRC and their zonotopal counterparts, in particular highlighting that the proofs of the finite-checking Theorems A and B in Malikiosis-Schymura-Santos (2025) are more transparent, and the statements more general, if regarded in terms of two quite general classes of lattice zonotopes: the coloopless zonotopes that we introduce here and the cosimple ones, already defined by them.

The classical Hadwiger-Nelson problem asks for the chromatic number of the unit distance graph of the Euclidean plane. Over the years, this problem has been considered for a variety of other normed spaces, with higher-dimensional Euclidean space $\mathbb{R}^d$ being perhaps the most natural and well-studied. Alon, Bucić, and Sauermann proved that, for a typical norm on $\mathbb{R}^d$, the chromatic number of the unit distance graph is at most $2^d$. We improve this exponential bound to a linear one by showing that the chromatic number of a typical norm on $\mathbb{R}^d$ is at most $2d$ and that this is tight. This shows a stark difference in the behavior compared to the Euclidean case, where there is an exponential lower bound. One of the key ingredients is a certain high-dimensional, matrix generalization of the Lonely runner conjecture, which also allows us to completely settle the so-called view-obstruction conjecture of Schoenberg from 1978 and a more recent covering-radius conjecture of Henze and Malikiosis.

We prove the Lonely Runner Conjecture for fourteen and fifteen runners. Our proof combines a stronger bound on the speed product in a primitive counterexample with exhaustive computations modulo primes. To obtain the bound, we work with a projected lattice basis and use cases of the conjecture with fewer runners to bound partial sums of its squared Gram-Schmidt lengths. For fifteen runners, the product bound derived from the work of Malikiosis, Santos, and Schymura gives a logarithmic threshold of about $810$; ours reduces this to about $415$, making the computation feasible. For fourteen runners, the new bound reduces the required number of primes from $111$ to $61$. The computations start with a complete two-branch covering search, followed by binary lifting. Since $14$ and $15$ are composite, the polynomial argument used in earlier work does not apply directly. We finish the fourteen-runner case by a direct search. For fifteen runners, we use the factorisation $15=3\cdot5$ and a shifting argument when all but a few speeds share a common divisor. The code and certificates are publicly archived.

We study the Lonely Runner Conjecture (LRC), conceived by Jörg M. Wills in the 1960's: Given positive integers $n_1, n_2, \dots, n_k$, there exists a positive real number $t$ such that for all $1 \le j \le k$ the distance of $t \,n_j$ to the nearest integer is at least $\frac{ 1 }{ k+1 }$. We prove that for any counterexample or tight instance $\mathbf{n}$ of LRC, $\mathbf{m} \cdot \mathbf{n} = 0$ for some $\mathbf{m} \in \mathbb{Z}^k$ with $0 < \| \mathbf{m} \|_1 \le \min(2k+3, \ \frac{ k+1 }{ k-1 } \mathrm{flt}(k))$ where $\mathrm{flt}(k)$ denotes Khinchin's (1948) flatness constant limiting the lattice width of a $k$-dimensional convex body without interior integer points. In other words, potential counterexamples to LRC lie on a finite set of hyperplanes in the parameter space. Our proofs use Fourier analysis and a geometric reformulation of LRC, and our results generalize to the situation of shifted lonely runners of varying measures of loneliness. Our results imply and generalize a theorem of Czerwiński (2012) that when we choose $\mathbf{n}$ at random then, with probability tending to 1, the measure of loneliness $\frac{1}{ k+1 }$ can be replaced by $\frac 1 2 - ε$.

The shifted lonely runner conjecture was recently disproved by Blanco, Criado and Santos. We give quantitative bounds on its failure as the number of runners grows. The loneliness of a configuration is the maximum, over time, of the distance from the origin to the nearest runner. We write $1/(n+1+E_n)$ for the infimum of loneliness over configurations of $n$ runners on the unit circle with distinct positive integer velocities and arbitrary initial shifts. We prove $E_n\ge\lfloor n/287\rfloor$, which together with the elementary bound $E_n\leq n-1$ implies that $E_n$ grows linearly in $n$. We also show that $E_n\geq1$ for every $n\geq95$.

For distinct positive integers v_1, ..., v_n let ML(v_1, ..., v_n) be the largest number L such that at some time t every t_vi is at distance at least L from the nearest integer; the Lonely Runner Conjecture asserts that ML >= 1/(n+1). Write ML = p/q in lowest terms. Kravitz conjectured that whenever ML < 1/n one has q = np + 1; Fan and Sun found counterexamples for n = 4, conjectured that q = np + k with 1 <= k <= n always holds, and observed that in their data for n = 6 only k = 1 and k = 3 occur. We explain this observation. For six speeds we show that all but finitely many tuples with ML < 1/6 satisfy ML = (P-1)/(6P) for an integer P congruent to 1 or 5 modulo 6; in particular k is 1 or 3 and the denominator q is odd. The proof determines the three infinite two-parameter families of tuples on which such values concentrate, computes ML exactly on each family, and describes exactly where k = 3 occurs. An exhaustive search over the 2 x 10^9 sextuples with speeds at most 110 finds no exception. For five speeds the same method, together with Chen's classification of the tuples attaining ML = 1/5, shows that all but finitely many tuples with ML < 1/5 satisfy Kravitz's original conjecture. The computations are exact and the code is provided.

For a set V of n-1 distinct positive integers write LR(V) = max_t min_{v in V} ||vt||, where ||x|| is the distance from x to the nearest integer; V is tight if LR(V) = 1/n, the value predicted by the Lonely Runner Conjecture. The baseline [n-1] = {1,...,n-1} is tight for every n, and Perarnau and Serra list the characterization of tight instances as Problem 1 of their survey, noting no further progress since Goddyn and Wong, who classified the multiple case and proved finiteness for each fixed deleted speed. We settle the one-entry case completely: ([n-1] minus {r}) union {w} with w > n-1 is tight if and only if either 2r > n-1, r divides w and the Goddyn-Wong gcd criterion holds, or (n,r,w) = (5,2,7) or (6,2,9). In particular no tight one-entry modification exists for 3 <= r <= (n-1)/2, and the only tight cases beyond the Goddyn-Wong multiples are the two sporadic sets of Wills, {1,3,4,7} and {1,3,4,5,9}. The proof is purely theoretical: the connected components of the uncovered region U(n,r) are determined exactly in both regimes 2r > n-1 and 2r <= n-1, yielding the effective bound w <= 4rI/(2s-I), with s = n-r and I the least integer of [s, n-1] coprime to r; a single inequality, proved via the Jacobsthal function, closes the mid-range without computation. Tight one-entry modifications also satisfy max V <= 0.60 n log n + 52 n unconditionally, with sharp leading constant 1/2 along n = p#+2 (p# the primorial), so no linear bound confines tight instances. We further isolate an explicit CRT doubling subfamily of the Goddyn-Wong multi-acceleration theorem and prove for two-speed replacements that no tight instance contains a removed speed q with 2 <= q <= n/10 when n >= max(40,10q), whatever the second removal and the inserted speeds. An exact census over all n <= 140, w <= 8n finds only two tight two-swaps, the Wills set {1,4,5,6,7,11,13} and the Goddyn-Wong doubling at n = 74.

Let $C_k(q)$ be the least cardinality of a family of nonzero polynomials over $\mathbb F_q$ whose associated codimension-$k$ partial-circulant kernels cover the full coefficient space. Chow and Rimani'c conjectured that $C_k(q)=1+q+\cdots+q^k$. We disprove the unrestricted conjecture by constructing thirteen monic polynomials over $\mathbb F_2$ whose $k=3$ kernels cover $\mathbb F_2^7$; in particular, $C_3(2)\le 13<15$. For a general covering family of size $N=q^k+S$ and $\mathbb F_q$-linear rank $d$, we prove $S\gg d^{2/3}\left(\frac{\log(2q)}{\log(eNq^k/S)}\right)^{2/3}$. Consequently, for every fixed $k\ge 2$ and all sufficiently large $q$, $C_k(q)\ge q^k+c_kq^{2/3}$. When $k=2$, an integer-multiplicity refinement of the second-moment covering argument yields $\liminf_{q\to\infty}(C_2(q)-q^2)/q\ge \widetilde c_2$, where $\widetilde c_2$ is an explicit one-variable variational constant with numerical value $\widetilde c_2=0.5829944375\ldots$. We also classify triples admitting two independent low-degree polynomial syzygies and prove a conditional packet-free lower bound of size $q^k+(1/2-o(1))q^{k-1}$.

Motivated by the celebrated Lonely Runner Conjecture, we study a variant in which the runners have time-dependent velocities. Let $n \geq 3$ runners start from the same point on the unit circle, where each runner $i\in[n]$ has a locally integrable velocity function $ν_i\in L^1_{\mathrm{loc}}(\mathbb{R}_{>0})$Assume that their velocities are strictly ordered almost everywhere and that the relative distance between every pair diverges. We prove that each of the slowest and fastest runners is at a distance strictly larger than $2^{-n+1}$ from every other runner at some time. Moreover, we show that the distance $2^{-n+1}$ is optimal. On the other hand, we construct examples in which every intermediate runner remains arbitrarily close to another runner at all times. As a consequence, we also obtain a sharp nonlinear analogue of a classical theorem of Schoenberg on billiard ball motion in the unit cube.

The Lonely Runner Conjecture states that if $k+1$ runners start at the same point on a unit-length circular track and run with distinct constant speeds, then each runner is at some time at least $1/(k+1)$-distant from every other runner. Equivalently, for every tuple of $k$ distinct positive integer speeds $s_1,\ldots,s_k$, there is a real number $t$ such that $\|s_i t\|\geq \frac{1}{k+1}$ for all $i$. We introduce and study a version of the conjecture in which the required distances may vary with $i$. For $\mathbf d=(d_1,\ldots,d_k)\in(0,1/2]^k$, let $\mathsf{MLPS}_k$ be the set of vectors such that, for every choice of distinct positive integer speeds $s_1,\ldots,s_k$, there is a real number $t$ with $\|s_i t\|\geq d_i$ for all $i$. We give an exact characterization of $\mathsf{MLPS}_2$. We also use Fourier series for distance-threshold indicator functions to obtain an arithmetic progression summation formula and an exact two-function integral formula for unequal thresholds.

Wills conjectured that, for any non-zero integers $u_1,\ldots,u_k$, there is a real number $t$ such that, for all $i=1,\ldots,k$, \[\lVert tu_i\rVert\geq\frac{1}{k+1},\] where $\lVert x\rVert$ is the distance from $x$ to the closest integer. This statement is known as the Lonely Runner Conjecture. A computational method developed by Rosenfeld and the second author verified the conjecture for $k\leq9$. We further refine this method with new sieving techniques and employ a polynomial method argument to show that any $(u_1,\ldots,u_k)\equiv(1,2,\ldots,k)\pmod{p}$ with $\gcd(u_1,\ldots,u_k)=1$ satisfies the conjecture when $k+1$ and $p > k^2+k$ are both odd primes. Ultimately, we provide a computer-assisted proof of the Lonely Runner Conjecture for $k\in\{10,11,12\}$.

We prove that the lonely runner conjecture holds for nine runners. Our proof is based on a couple of improvements of the method we used to prove the conjecture for eight runners.

The Lonely Runner Conjecture of Wills and Cusick states that if $k+1$ runners start running at distinct constant speeds around a unit-length circular track, then for each runner there is a time when he/she is at least $1/(k+1)$ away from all other runners. Rosenfeld recently obtained a computer-assisted proof of the conjecture for $8$ runners. By refining his approach with a sieve, we obtain proofs (also computer-assisted) for $9$ and $10$ runners.

The lonely runner conjecture of Wills and Cusick asserts that if $n$ runners with distinct constant speeds run around a a circular unit length track, starting at a common time and place, then each runner will at some time be separated by a distance of at least $\frac{1}{n}$ from all other runners. A weaker lower bound of $\frac{1}{2n-2}$ follows from the so-called trivial union bound, and subsequent work upgraded this to bounds of the form $\frac{1}{2n}+\frac{c}{n^2}$ for various constants $c>0$. Tao strengthened this to $\frac{1}{2n}+\frac{(\log n)^{1-o(1)}}{n^2}$. In this paper, we obtain a polynomial improvement of the form $$\frac{1}{2n}+\frac{1}{n^{5/3+o(1)}}.$$

We prove that the lonely runner conjecture holds for eight runners. Our proof relies on a computer verification and on recent results that allow bounding the size of a minimal counterexample. We note that our approach also applies to the known cases with 4, 5, 6, and 7 runners. We expect that minor improvements to our approach could be enough to solve the cases of 9 or 10 runners.

We show that the shifted Lonely Runner Conjecture (sLRC) holds for 5 runners. We also determine that there are exactly 3 primitive tight instances of the conjecture, only two of which are tight for the non-shifted conjecture (LRC). Our proof is computational, relying on a rephrasing of the sLRC in terms of covering radii of certain zonotopes (Henze and Malikiosis, 2017), and on an upper bound for the (integer) velocities to be checked (Malikiosis, Santos and Schymura, 2024+). As a tool for the proof, we devise an algorithm for bounding the covering radius of rational lattice polytopes, based on constructing dyadic fundamental domains.

For a subtorus $T \subseteq (\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^n$, let $D(T)$ denote the $L^\infty$-distance from $T$ to the point $(1/2, \ldots, 1/2)$. For a subtorus $U \subseteq (\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^n$, define $\mathcal{S}_1(U)$, the Lonely Runner spectrum relative to $U$, to be the set of all values of $D(T)$ as $T$ ranges over the $1$-dimensional subtori of $U$ not contained in the union of the coordinate hyperplanes of $(\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^n$. The relative spectrum $\mathcal{S}_1((\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^n)$ is the ordinary Lonely Runner spectrum that has been studied previously. Giri and the second author recently showed that the relative spectra $\mathcal{S}_1(U)$ for $2$-dimensional subtori $U \subseteq (\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^n$ essentially govern the accumulation points of the Lonely Runner spectrum $\mathcal{S}_1((\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z})^n)$. In the present work, we prove that such relative spectra $\mathcal{S}_1(U)$ have a very rigid arithmetic structure, and that one can explicitly find a complete characterization of each such relative spectrum with a finite calculation; carrying out this calculation for a few specific examples sheds light on previous constructions in the literature on the Lonely Runner Problem.

Tao (2018) showed that in order to prove the Lonely Runner Conjecture (LRC) up to $n+1$ runners it suffices to consider positive integer velocities in the order of $n^{O(n^2)}$. Using the zonotopal reinterpretation of the conjecture due to the first and third authors (2017) we here drastically improve this result, showing that velocities up to $\binom{n+1}{2}^{n-1} \le n^{2n}$ are enough. We prove the same finite-checking result, with the same bound, for the more general \emph{shifted} Lonely Runner Conjecture (sLRC), except in this case our result depends on the solution of a question, that we dub the \emph{Lonely Vector Problem} (LVP), about sumsets of $n$ rational vectors in dimension two. We also prove the same finite-checking bound for a further generalization of sLRC that concerns cosimple zonotopes with $n$ generators, a class of lattice zonotopes that we introduce. In the last sections we look at dimensions two and three. In dimension two we prove our generalized version of sLRC (hence we reprove the sLRC for four runners), and in dimension three we show that to prove sLRC for five runners it suffices to look at velocities adding up to $195$.

The Lonely Runner Conjecture originated in Diophantine approximation is turning 60. Even if the conjecture is still widely open, the flow of partial results, innovative tools and connections to different problems and applications has been steady on its long life. This survey attempts to give a panoramic view of the status of the problem, trying to highlight the contributions of the many papers that it has originated.

Let $||x||$ be the absolute distance from $x$ to the nearest integer. For a set of distinct positive integral speeds $v_1, \ldots, v_n$, we define its maximum loneliness, also known as the gap $δ$, to be $$ML(v_1,\ldots,v_n) = \max_{t \in \mathbb{R}}\min_{1 \leq i \leq n} || tv_i||.$$ The Loneliness Spectrum Conjecture, recently proposed by Kravitz (2021), asserts that $$\exists s \in \mathbb{N}, \text{ML}(v_1,\ldots,v_n) = \frac{s} {sn + 1} \text{ or } \text{ML}(v_1,\ldots,v_n) \geq \frac{1}{n}. $$ We disprove the Loneliness Spectrum Conjecture for $n = 4$ with an infinite family of counterexamples and propose an alternative conjecture. We confirm the amended conjecture for $n = 4$ whenever there exists a pair of speeds with a common factor of at least $3$ and also prove some related results.