arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove a variational formula for the logarithmic asymptotics of a non-existence probability in a broad class of combinatorial problems such as avoiding cliques in random graphs and $k$-term arithmetic progressions in random subsets of integers. These results follow from a formula for the probability that a binomial random subset of the vertices of a locally sparse hypergraph is an independent set. The formula holds throughout the critical regime, interpolating between the regimes in which Janson's inequality and the method of hypergraph containers give the respective asymptotics. The formula is the replica-symmetric Bethe free energy formula from statistical physics applied to a hypergraph hardcore model. The proof uses two new techniques. The first, for the upper bound, involves revealing a small `window' of a random independent set and then applying entropy methods. The second, for the lower bound, involves the analysis of a random greedy algorithm guided by a Belief Propagation fixed point. In the case of avoiding cliques in random graphs, the variational formula can be expressed as an optimization problem over graphons. Moreover, typical random graphs conditioned on not containing $K_r$, when suitably normalized, approach the set of optimizing graphons in cut distance.

We give negative answers to Kolmogorov's rearrangement problem and Garsia's conjecture. We construct a complete uniformly bounded orthonormal system for which every rearrangement admits a square-summable series divergent almost everywhere. The finite construction uses two copies of the trigonometric system in different orderings. The main ingredient is a combinatorial lemma which guarantees a prescribed ordering along an arithmetic progression in at least one of two related permutations. Its proof uses Szemerédi's theorem and a counting argument. A Walsh variant gives $N$-term $\{\pm1\}$-valued systems with $L^2$ maximal norm at least $c\log\log N$ in every ordering, matching Bourgain's upper bound.

We establish discorrelation estimates between the Piatetski-Shapiro prime set \[ \mathcal{P}_γ := \{p \text{ is prime and } p = \lfloor n^{1/γ} \rfloor \text{ for some } n \in \mathbb{N}\} \] and arbitrary nilsequences when $γ\in (0,1)$ is sufficiently close to $1$. This extends earlier works which treated linear or polynomial exponential phase functions. As an application, we establish an asymptotic formula for the number of solutions in $\mathcal{P}_γ$ to any ``finite-complexity" system of linear equations, including for the number of $k$-term arithmetic progressions in $\mathcal{P}_γ$ up to a threshold $N$ for any given $k \geq 3$. Furthermore, we show that there exists an absolute constant $C>0$ such that if \[ 1 - 2^{-Ck} < γ< 1, \] then the Piatetski-Shapiro primes $\mathcal{P}_γ$ contain infinitely many non-trivial $k$-term arithmetic progressions. This significantly improves upon the previous range of $γ$ obtained by Li and Pan, which is of triple exponential type.

Benjamini asked whether every configuration of points on the real line that is in equilibrium under the inverse-square repulsive force must be an arithmetic progression. Georgakopoulos and Kolountzakis proved this when some gap between consecutive points has maximal or minimal length, and described the general (aperiodic) case as open. We show that the answer is yes. More generally, let $1<s\le2$, and let $X\subset\mathbb{R}$ be a locally finite set with at least two points such that, for every $x\in X$, the total force $\sum_{y\in X\setminus\{x\}}|y-x|^{-s}$ is finite and the net force $\sum_{y\in X\setminus\{x\}}\operatorname{sgn}(y-x)\,|y-x|^{-s}$ is zero. Then $X$ is an arithmetic progression. No a priori assumption on the gaps is needed. Subtracting the equilibrium equations of two consecutive points shows that the gaps $g_n$ form a positive harmonic function for an explicit reversible random walk on $\mathbb{Z}$ with long-range jumps. Equilibrium also bounds the ratio of consecutive gaps, by $1.5386\ldots$ when $s=2$. With this bound, an energy estimate shows that the Doob transform of the walk by $g$ is recurrent. Since $1/g$ is a positive harmonic function of the transformed walk, it is constant.

A $k$-configuration is a collection of $k$ distinct integers $x_1,\ldots,x_k$ together with their pairwise arithmetic means $\frac{x_i+x_j}{2}$ for $1 \leq i < j \leq k$. Building on recent work of Filmus, Hatami, Hosseini and Kelman on binary systems of linear forms and of Kelley and Meka on Roth's theorem on arithmetic progressions, we show that, for $N \geq \exp((k\log(2/α))^{O(1)})$, any subset $A \subseteq [N]$ of density at least $α$ contains a $k$-configuration. This improves on the previously best known bound $N \geq \exp((2/α)^{O(k^2)})$, due to Shao. As a consequence, it follows that any finite non-empty set $A \subseteq \mathbb{Z}$ contains a subset $B \subseteq A$ of size at least $(\log|A|)^{1+Ω(1)}$ such that $b_1+b_2 \not\in A$ for any distinct $b_1,b_2 \in B$. This provides a new proof of a lower bound for the Erdős--Moser sum-free set problem of the same shape as the best known bound, established by Sanders.

Given $m \in \mathbb{N}$ and a $p$-random subset $A \subseteq \mathbb{N}$, we asymptotically determine $\log \Pr(|\mathbb{N} \setminus (A + A)| \ge m)$ for $p$ above the threshold for this property. As an application, we show that a uniformly at random chosen subset $A \subseteq \{1, \ldots, n\}$ of size $k$ such that $|A + A| \le λk$, for $λ= o(k^{1/4} / \log^{1/2} n)$, with high probability belongs to an arithmetic progression of length $λk / 2 + o(λk)$. Both proofs are based on a bespoke container argument, exploiting the additive robustness of the considered sets.

In this paper, we derive thresholds and fluctuations for arithmetic progressions with prescribed color patterns in sparse random colorings of $[n]:=\{1, 2, \ldots, n\}$, where each element of $[n]$ is colored independently according to a given probability vector. For any admissible ordered palette of colors, we determine the full multi-parameter threshold region for the appearance of a colorful arithmetic progression. The threshold is governed by two competing mechanisms: a global first-moment condition and a local color-availability condition, resulting in a polyhedral satisfiability region, with a piecewise-polyhedral threshold surface. In the satisfiability region we establish asymptotic normality for the number of colorful arithmetic progressions of a given length, with an explicit rate of convergence in Wasserstein distance. On the threshold surface, we identify three distinct asymptotic regimes: Poisson, compound Poisson with mixed Poisson jumps, and compound Poisson with uniform jumps, after an appropriate normalization. These results provide a complete description of the threshold and fluctuation behavior of general colored arithmetic progressions under sparse random colorings, in a unified framework that interpolates between classical uncolored/monochromatic progressions in binomial random subsets and multicolored, including rainbow, arithmetic progressions.

Let $u=(u_n)_{n\ge0}$ be a binary sequence, and define \[ X_0=1,\qquad X_{n+1}=2X_n+u_n \qquad(n\ge0). \] Let $A_u$ be the set of all nonempty finite subset sums of the sequence $(X_n)$, and let $L_u(N)$ denote the maximum length of an arithmetic progression contained in $A_u\cap[1,N]$. We prove that there are absolute constants $c>0$ and $N_0\geq 1$ such that, for every binary sequence $u$, \[ L_u(N)\ge \exp\!\left(c\sqrt{\frac{\log N}{\log\log N}}\right) \] for all $N\geq N_0$. Moreover, if the random variables $u_n$ are independent and uniformly distributed on $\{0,1\}$, then, almost surely, \[ L_u(N)\ll_u N^{2/3}\exp\!\left(C\sqrt{\log N\log\log N}\right), \] where $C>0$ is an absolute constant. Furthermore, every eventually periodic binary sequence satisfies $L_u(N)\gg_u N^{1/2}$.

For an integer $k\ge 3$, let $w(3,k)$ be the least $n$ such that every red-blue coloring of $[n]$ contains either a nontrivial three-term arithmetic progression in blue or a nontrivial $k$-term arithmetic progression in red. A recent breakthrough of Green proved that $w(3,k)\ge k^{Ω\left(\left(\frac{\log k}{\log\log k}\right)^{1/3}\right)}$ when $k$ is large, and Hunter later improved the bound to $w(3,k)\ge k^{Ω\left(\frac{\log k}{\log\log k}\right)}$. On the other hand, Green remarked that it is reasonable to believe that $w(3,k)\le k^{O(\log k)}$. We prove that $w(3,k)\ge k^{Ω(\log k)}$, which perhaps gives some evidence that $k^{Θ(\log k)}$ is the correct order of magnitude.

We develop a Ramsey theory for leaf-generated subsets of finite products of trees. Our starting point is a Theorem of Furstenberg and Weiss which states that for every $k\geq 1$ and $α>0$, if $A$ is a subset of the leaves of $T_n$, where $T_n$ is the complete binary tree of height $n$, with size $|A|\geq 2^{αn}$, then for $n$ sufficiently large the ancestor closed sub-tree $T_A\subset T_n$ generated by $A$ must contain a copy of $T_k$ such that (1) all vertices in the same level of $T_k$ are mapped into vertices at the same level of $T_A$, (2) if a non-leaf vertex $x\in T_k$ is mapped into a vertex $y \in T_A$, then the two children of $x$ are mapped into descendants of the two children of $y$, and (3) the levels of $T_A$ occupied by the copy of $T_k$ form an arithmetic progression. For the product $T_n \times T_n$ of two binary trees, we show that for every $k\geq 1$ and $α> 1$, for $n$ sufficiently large, every subset $A$ of the leaves of $T_n\times T_n$ of size at least $2^{αn}$ has that its ancestor closure $Γ_A\subset T_n \times T_n$ contains similarly structured arithmetic copies of the height $k$ four-ary tree, where the four children of every non-leaf vertex in the source tree are required to map below the four distinct \textit{diagonal children} of the image vertex, where a diagonal child of a vertex $(x,y) \in T_n \times T_n$ is obtained by moving one level down each in each component. Our results generalise to product of $d$-many finite $b$-ary trees with a sharp critical exponent of \[ α_{\text{crit}}(d,b) =d-1 + \log_b(b-1).\] Geometrically, our results imply that any set $E\subset [0,1)^d$ of upper Minkowski dimension greater than $α_{\text{crit}}(d,b)$ contains arithmetic $b$-adic branching patterns of arbitrary finite order.

A family $\mathcal F$ of finite subsets of $\mathbb Z$ is packed into $[N]$ if suitable integer translates of its members are pairwise disjoint subsets of $[N]$. We study two prescribed-difference packing problems of Alon, Dębski, Grytczuk and Przybyło for the arithmetic progressions $A_d=\{d,2d,\ldots,\lfloor n/d\rfloor d\}$ and $B_d=\{d,2d,\ldots,nd\}$. Let $m(n)$ and $M(n)$ denote the corresponding minimum packing lengths, with subscripts indicating restrictions on the admissible differences, and let $\mathcal P(x)$ denote the set of primes at most $x$. The key ingredient is a residue-class selection scheme that encodes pairwise intersection constraints by cyclic intervals. A lattice-covering argument yields a simultaneous admissible choice, permitting substantial overlap of the containing intervals and providing the sharp upper bounds needed for the bounded-diameter family and the prime-difference equal-cardinality family. For the bounded-diameter family, we prove $m(n)\sim m_{\mathcal P(\sqrt n)}(n)\sim 4n^{3/2}/(3\log n)$. For the equal-cardinality family with prime differences, we prove $M_{\mathcal P(n)}(n)\sim n^3/(6\log n)$. For the full equal-cardinality family, we show $M(n)\ge \left(\frac{19}{108}-o(1)\right)n^3/\log n$. Together with corresponding estimates for restricted ranges of differences, these results prove several conjectures of Alon--Dębski--Grytczuk--Przybyło and disprove others.

The slice rank method gives exponential bounds for sets with no three-term arithmetic progression in finite vector spaces of odd characteristic and for three-sunflower-free families of subsets of a fixed ground set. We show that for $k\ge4$, every tensor that is nonzero exactly on the $k$-term arithmetic progression relation or the $k$-sunflower relation has maximal slice rank over every coefficient field. When the support is prescribed only on pairwise distinct inputs, we obtain comparable lower bounds, which likewise rule out exponential savings.

Let $r,t\ge 3$ be integers and $L=\{\ell_1,\ell_2,\ldots,\ell_s\}\subseteq [0,r-1]$ a fixed set of integers with $|L|\neq r$ and $\ell_1<\ell_2<\cdots<\ell_s$. For each integer $n$, let $Ψ_{r}(n,L,t)$ be the maximum number of $r$-cliques in an $n$-vertex graph whose $r$-cliques, viewed as a family of $r$-subsets of the vertex set, form a $t$-wise $L$-intersecting family. In this paper, we prove that $Ψ_{r}(n,L,t)=o(n^{|L|})$ when the sequence $\ell_1,\ell_2,\ldots,\ell_s,r$ does not form an arithmetic progression, and we give an asymptotic formula for $Ψ_{r}(n,L,t)$ when this sequence does form an arithmetic progression. When $t=2$, our results are exactly Helliar and Liu's results.

In this note we connect Sobolev estimates in the context of polynomial averages e.g.\ \begin{align}\label{e:savings} \| \int_0^1 \prod_{k=1}^m f_k(x-t^k) \|_{1} \leq \text{Const} \cdot 2^{-\text{const} \cdot l} \prod_{i=1}^m \| f_k \|_m \end{align} whenever some $f_i$ vanishes on $\{ |ξ| \leq 2^l \}$ to the existence of polynomial progressions inside of sets of sufficiently large Hausdorff dimension, in analogy with work of Peluse in the discrete context. Our strongest results builds off work of Becker-Krause and is as follows: suppose that $\mathcal{P} = \{a_{d_1} t^{d_1}, a_{d_2} t^{d_2},\dots, a_{d_k} t^{d_k}\}$ vanish at the origin at different rates, and that $E \subset [0,1]$ has sufficiently large Hausdorff dimension, \[ 1 - \text{const}(\mathcal{P}) < \text{dim}_H(E) < 1 \] and Hausdorff content bounded away from zero, sufficiently large in terms of its dimension. Then $E$ contains a non-trivial polynomial progression of the form \begin{align} \{ x , x - a_{d_1} t^{d_1}, x - a_{d_2} t^{d_2}, \dots, x - a_{d_k} t^{d_k} \} \subset E, \; \; \; t \neq 0. \end{align} Also, using the Fourier spectrum, we provide a short proof that whenever $E$ supports a measure with both positive Fourier dimension and a sufficiently large Frostman condition, it necessarily contains a non-trivial generalized three-term arithmetic progression of the form \[ \{ x, x - γ_1 t, x- γ_2 t\} \subset E, \; \; \; γ_i \in \mathbb{Q},\ t \neq 0.\]

In recent work, Hirschhorn and the second author defined $a_k(n)$ to be the number of partitions of $n$ wherein the even parts come in only one color, while the odd parts may be ``colored'' with one of $k$ colors for fixed $k\geq 1$. This function generalizes the classical partition function and has been of significant interest because it satisfies a number of congruences. Although prior work studying $a_k(n)$ has resulted in congruences in arithmetic progressions in a somewhat ad hoc manner, this work gives a uniform framework for studying congruences modulo 3. This allows us to prove an infinite family of infinite families of non-nested congruences modulo 3.

A family $F$ of subsets of $[n]$ is 3AP-intersecting if every two members have intersection containing a non-trivial three-term arithmetic progression. We prove that there is an absolute constant $c>0$ such that any such $F$ has size at most $(\tfrac12 - c)2^n$. This is the first non-trivial progress towards a conjecture of Simonovits and Sós that the maximum possible size is $2^{n-3}$. More generally, we show the same bound for $H$-intersecting families whenever $H$ is a $3$-graph on $[n]$ with bounded codegrees. A clique shows that this is sharp, in that the bounded codegree assumption cannot be removed.

Let $p$ be an odd prime, and write $A\RS B=\{a+b:a\in A,\ b\in B,\ a\ne b\}$. We classify all pairs $A,B\subseteq\Fp$ satisfying $|A|+|B|=p$, $|A|>|B|=\ell\ge1$, and $|A\RS B|=p-2$. After normalizing the two missing sums to $\{0,1\}$, we obtain exactly $\ell+1$ explicit models. The classification forces $B\subseteq A$ and yields, for fixed $p,\ell$, exactly $\binom p2(\ell+1)$ ordered pairs and $1+\lfloor\ell/2\rfloor$ equivalence classes under simultaneous affine transformations. We determine when either set is an arithmetic progression and compute exact difference-set cardinalities. For $\ell\ge3$ and $p\ge4\ell-5$, the cardinality $|B-B|$ determines the equivalence class at fixed $p,\ell$. The proof uses punctured translates and cyclic component counting. We also exhibit a critical pair in $\mathbb F_{13}$, with size gap three and $|A|+|B|=p-2$, that contradicts a proposed inverse statement below the boundary.

For every finite set $A\subset\mathbb{Z}$, we construct a bijection $p:\mathbb{N}_0\to\mathbb{Z}$ beginning with $0,1$ that contains no four-term arithmetic progression, in occurrence order, whose first value belongs to $A$. More generally, for each $n\ge2$ the enumeration can begin with $0,1,3,\ldots,2^{n-1}-1$ and simultaneously avoid every such progression starting in $A$ or among these first $n$ entries. The construction uses finitely branching prerequisite relations and an explicit bounded integer potential. This proves finite prerequisite closure and gives an exhaustive enumeration, rather than merely a total order. We also give an extension theorem for finite prefixes with compatible binary-tail constraints. These results do not determine whether every enumeration of the integers contains an ordered four-term arithmetic progression.

We construct a permutation of the positive integers containing no four-term arithmetic progression as a subsequence.

Let $F$ be a function field over an algebraically closed field $K$ and $S$ a finite dimensional $K$-subspace of $F$. The square of $S$ is spanned by all products of pairs of elements in $S$. We conjecture that if $\dim S^2 \leq 3 \dim S - 4$, then $S^2$ must contain a Riemann--Roch space of dimension at least $2 \dim S - 1 + g$, where $g$ is the genus of $F$. This generalizes a theorem of Freiman from additive combinatorics, stating that small sumsets must contain long arithmetic progressions. We prove our conjecture in the case that $S$ is contained in a Riemann--Roch space of dimension at most $3/2\dim S + 1$. For the proof we study the annihilator of $S$ and introduce the notion of weight for linear forms.