arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove a degree-four Sum-of-Squares lower bound for the standard vector-coordinate formulations of mutually unbiased bases. For every dimension $d$ and every proposed number $m$ of bases, we construct a degree-four pseudoexpectation satisfying the orthonormality constraints and the cross-unbiasedness constraints in the quartic equality formulation. The construction is expectation over $m$ independent Haar-random orthonormal bases. We also prove that the same pseudoexpectation satisfies the degree-four localizing constraints for the natural $2\times 2$ Hermitian semidefinite formulation of the cross-coherence inequalities. Consequently, degree-four vector-coordinate SoS cannot refute the existence of $m$ mutually unbiased bases, even when $m>d+1$. In particular, under the two vector-coordinate encodings explicitly described in Randomstrasse101 Open Problem 23, degree-four SoS cannot prove that seven mutually unbiased bases do not exist in $\mathbb C^6$. We contrast this with a centered projector-coordinate Gram formulation, where degree-four SoS already recovers the elementary upper bound $m\le d+1$, giving a simple separation between vector-coordinate and projector-coordinate degree-four relaxations.

We obtain an optimal proximity bound for integer linear programs in standard form max{cx: Ax=b, x nonnegative integer}, where A is an integer mxn matrix of rank m<n and b is an integer vector. Specifically, we show that the Euclidean distance from any optimal vertex solution of the LP relaxation to a nearest optimal integer solution is bounded by $\sqrt{\det(AA^t)}-1$ and that this estimate is asymptotically tight. We also derive bounds for the optimal integer solutions involving the product function $\prod_{i=1}^{n}(x_i+1)$ and discuss their applications in the knapsack setting.

For a set $X$ of integer points, the relaxation complexity $\operatorname{rc}(X)$ is the smallest number of facets of any polyhedron $P$ such that $P \cap \mathbb{Z}^d = X$. In this paper, we focus on the case where $X$ is the discrete standard simplex $Δ_d = \{\mathbf{0}, \mathbf{e}_1, \dots, \mathbf{e}_d\}$. We show that $\operatorname{rc}(Δ_d) = O(\log d)$ by an explicit, elementary construction. This improves upon the previously best-known upper bound $\operatorname{rc}(Δ_d) = O(d / \sqrt{\log d})$ due to Aprile, Averkov, Di Summa, and Hojny (2024) and matches an asymptotic lower bound by Averkov and Schymura (2022).

The Graph Burning Problem (GBP) is a NP-Hard combinatorial optimization problem that models the propagation of influence or contagion in a network. The propagation is represented through the metaphor of a fire spreading through the vertices of a graph. A burning process takes place in a series of discrete time-steps. At each time step, the burning process is characterized by a propagation (where burned nodes spread the fire to their neighbors), and an ignition (where one additional unburned node is chosen to become burned). The minimum number of steps required to burn all vertices of a graph defines its burning number. Literature provides integer linear programming formulations to solve the problem, but with no surprise, such approaches struggle to converge as the graph size increases. Therefore, reducing the search space explored by these formulations becomes a key point to improve performances. In this work, we study the similarities of the Graph Burning Problem with the well-known Dominating Set Problem. We propose a new formulation based on this study and apply dominance rules and symmetry-breaking techniques to reduce the search space and consequently speed up resolution time. We also introduce a perturbation of the proposed objective function, as well as a pruning rule for the perturbed model in order to further accelerate its resolution.

The 2026 disproof of Erdős's unit-distance conjecture and Sawin's subsequent explicit quantitative refinement show that the maximum number $u(n)$ of unit distances among $n$ planar points can exceed $n^{1+\varepsilon}$ for a fixed positive $\varepsilon$. Sawin's explicit bound gives more than $n^{1.014}$ unit distances for arbitrarily large $n$ and exposes integer parameters whose choice is not fully optimized. This report starts from Sawin's nonlinear integer optimization problem and develops an open-source Python verification pipeline. The pipeline is first validated by reproducing Sawin's published parameter choice and is then applied to computationally improved certificates. We optimize and verify certificates involving sets of primes $T$ and $S_Q$, integer multiplicities $k(p)$, and a rationally encoded real parameter $R$. The implementation is deliberately lean, so that all results can be replicated on standard hardware and the procedures can be extended. We compare a deterministic greedy heuristic, a tailored integer evolution strategy with two-sided geometric, or discrete-Laplace, integer mutation and repair operators for number-theoretic feasibility, and a two-parent discrete-recombination variant. Four certificate levels are reported: Sawin's published example with $δ=0.0141144286784982\ldots$, a greedy certificate with $δ=0.0151718056372133\ldots$, a tailored integer evolution strategy certificate with $R=6672416/100000$ and $δ=0.0152616610684193\ldots$, and a recombination variant with the same $R$ and $δ=0.0152628688170072\ldots$. Consequently, the best current certificate supports the cautious statement $u(n)>n^{1.0152}$ for arbitrarily large $n$. Beyond this unit-distance application, the work illustrates how randomized optimization heuristics can improve explicit certificates in pure mathematics and combinatorial geometry.

The Membership Problem for Pedigree Polytope (M3P) asks, given $X\in\mathbb{Q}^{\binom{n}{3}}$, whether $X\in\mathrm{conv}(P_n)$, where $P_n$ is the set of all pedigrees. A pedigree is a structured encoding of a Hamiltonian cycle construction in $K_n$. We establish that M3P is solvable in strongly polynomial time via a recursively constructed layered network $(N_k, R_k, μ)$ and a multicommodity flow problem MCF$(k)$. The necessary and sufficient condition for membership established is that the optimal total flow in MCF$(n-1)$ equals the maximum possible flow $z_{\max}$. The complexity analysis, grounded in Tardos's strongly polynomial algorithm for combinatorial linear programs (1986), shows that this condition can be checked in strongly polynomial time in the dimension of the matrix involved. By sufficiency, this implies M3P~$\in$~P. Since the Symmetric Travelling Salesman Problem (STSP) reduces to M3P via the Multistage Insertion (MI) formulation (Arthanari 1983), STSP is solvable in polynomial time, and the P vs.NP question is resolved. The proofs leading to this result are fully machine-verified in Lean~4/Mathlib4, with zero unresolved \texttt{sorry}s in the main proof chain. The main contribution is the Lean~4 machine verification of all proofs in the main chain, resulting in \texttt{theorem p\_equals\_np}: P = NP. The Lean~4 formal verification covers the sufficiency of MCF(n-1) for membership in $\mathrm{conv}(P_n)$, and the P = NP chain via Maurras (2002), Grötschel--Lovász--Schrijver (1988), Cook (1971), and Karp (1972). The complete lean project (36 Lean~4 files, 2968/2968 build targets clean) is available at https://github.com/TiruArt/Pedigree-Polytopes-Lean4.

We introduce a diffusion-based uncertainty model for robust optimization on directed graphs, in which perturbations of edge weights propagate along adjacent edges and satisfy conservation constraints at nodes. This topology-aware structure is natural in networked systems where uncertainty is induced by flows and local interactions, including transportation, logistics, communication, and energy networks. We analyze how such diffusive uncertainty reshapes the computational landscape of robust graph optimization. For convex network problems, such as minimum-cost flow and maximum flow, the resulting formulations remain convex and admit polynomial-time solution methods across all diffusion regimes considered. For combinatorial problems, the effect is more delicate. We focus on two canonical combinatorial graph problems, shortest path and the traveling salesman problem (TSP), which provide complementary benchmarks: shortest path is polynomial-time solvable in the nominal setting, whereas TSP is already NP-hard. We show that, for shortest path, propagation depth induces a sharp transition between tractable and intractable robust counterparts. For the traveling salesman problem, robustness often adds no computational complexity beyond ordinary TSP, because the structure of Hamiltonian cycles makes the fixed-tour adversarial problem collapse to explicit formulas. Together, these results show that topology-aware uncertainty can fundamentally change robust combinatorial optimization, with tractability governed by the interaction between propagation, budget geometry, and the structure of feasible solutions.

For integers \(r\ge 2\), \(t\ge 1\) and a real number \(a\in(3/2,2]\), we study the typical structure of oriented graphs and digraphs that do not contain a blow-up \(T_{r+1}^t\) of a transitive tournament. We prove that almost every \(T_{r+1}^t\)-free oriented graph on n vertices admits an r-partition \(V_1\cup\cdots\cup V_r\) such that each induced subgraph \(G[V_i]\) is \(T_2^t\)-free, and the same holds for almost every \(T_{r+1}^t\)-free digraph.Consequently, the number \(f(n,T_{r+1}^t)\) of labelled \(T_{r+1}^t\)-free oriented graphs satisfies \(f(n,T_{r+1}^t)=|\mathcal{P}_{n,r,t}|(1+o(1))\), where \(\mathcal{P}_{n,r,t}\) is the family of oriented graphs admitting such an r-partition with each part \(T_2^t\)-free; an analogous statement holds for digraphs.When \(t=1\) this recovers the result of K"uhn, Osthus, Townsend and Zhao (2017) that almost all \(T_{r+1}\)-free oriented graphs (resp. digraphs) are r-partite, thereby confirming a generalised form of Cherlin's conjecture. Our proof combines the hypergraph container method, a weighted Erdős-Stone theorem, and a stability analysis for near-extremal \(T_{r+1}^t\)-free digraphs.

A connected undirected graph $G = (V,E)$ is lower conformally rigid if uniform edge weights maximize the second smallest Laplacian eigenvalue $λ_2(w)$ over all normalized edge weights $w$, and upper conformally rigid if uniform edge weights minimize the largest eigenvalue $λ_n(w)$ over all normalized edge weights; $G$ is conformally rigid if it is lower or upper conformally rigid. This paper establishes a new framework for conformal rigidity through the language of subdifferentials, unifying the variational perspective on eigenvalue optimization with the geometry of edge-isometric spectral embeddings, which are known to characterize conformal rigidity. This subdifferential framework lends itself naturally to techniques of symmetry reduction that motivate the notion of an orbit-isometric embedding - a weaker condition than edge-isometry that accounts for the symmetries of $G$ while remaining sufficient for conformal rigidity. The notion opens the door to tools from representation theory: for a large class of graphs, including all vertex-transitive ones, we show that conformal rigidity is certified by a single eigenvector, resolving an open question and explaining the conformal rigidity of previously unexplained graphs. This extra structure enables a new, algebraically exact certification method for conformal rigidity, bypassing the numerical difficulties of prior approaches. In many cases, the problem reduces to a check of linear feasibility, and in general, to solving a system of quadratic equations via Gröbner bases.

The regular set tolerance is an important term in sensitivity analysis. For combinatorial sum problems, e.g., the Traveling Salesman Problem, Shortest Path Problem and Minimum Spanning Tree Problem, it determines how much the sum of the costs of the elements of a set can be increased while ensuring that all current optimal solutions remain optimal. The regular set lower tolerance determines how much the sum of the costs of the elements of a set can be decreased while ensuring that the objective value of the optimal solution is not changed. We investigate a general method for computing regular (upper and lower) set tolerances in combinatorial sum problems. For the upper tolerance, we present a linear programming approach, and for the lower tolerances, three linear programming approaches, where the last two are novel and lead to recursive procedures for computation of the lower tolerances of all subsets of the given ground set. Furthermore, we give new upper bounds for set lower tolerances. For both upper and lower tolerances, we give an exact formula for sets of cardinality 2 and 3. Finally, we consider the computation of tolerances for the Minimum Spanning Tree Problem, give a formula for single tolerances, a lower bound for regular set upper tolerances and an exact formula for regular set lower tolerances.

Classroom dynamics depend on various elements that influence teaching performance and learning activities. A key challenge is to determine the most effective seating plan, where students will seat in a specific classroom setting to achieve the best learning environment. This paper introduces the Student Seat Allocation Problem (SSAP) for strategically organizing student seating in traditional classrooms to minimize interpersonal conflicts. We propose a mathematical model and an Iterated Local Search (ILS) heuristic to solve the SSAP. Computational experiments demonstrated that ILS outperformed in more complex scenarios when compared to the results obtained by a commercial solver on the introduced mathematical model. ILS was particularly efficient in real and artificial instances that exhibited a higher number of conflicts.

A variant of the flatness problem from integer programming is studied, in which one considers convex bodies in $\mathbb{R}^d$ with at most $k$ interior lattice points. The maximum lattice width of such a body is denoted by Flt(d,k) and it is related to the classical flatness constant as well as a conjectural dual version of Minkowski's convex body theorem due to Makai. Moreover, it is shown that Flt(2, 1) = 3, i.e., any planar convex body with at most one interior point has lattice width at most three. This leads to an isominwidth inequality for the lattice point enumerator of planar convex bodies.

We analyze the asymptotic behavior and scaling limits of large random matrices rescaled via the Sinkhorn algorithm to match prescribed row and column margins. For a random matrix with independent sub-exponential entries, we show that its Sinkhorn rescaling concentrates around the rescaling of its mean matrix, both at the level of the Schrödinger potentials and as random measures on the unit square, with explicit non-asymptotic rates. As the dimensions grow, the rescaled random matrix converges to the continuous static Schrödinger bridge (SSB) determined by the limiting margins and reference density. Around this scaling limit we develop a fluctuation theory: bulk rigidity for the empirical spectral distribution of the associated sample covariance matrix, and a central limit theorem for the empirical Schrödinger potentials of the rescaled empirical mean. Our analysis is driven by a new quantitative stability theory for the SSB, developed in three forms: Lipschitz continuity in the Hellinger distance under perturbations of the reference measure (kernel stability); Hölder-$1/2$ continuity in the Hellinger distance under $L^1$ perturbations of the margins (margin stability); and $L^\infty$ stability of the discrete Schrödinger potentials under margin perturbation (potential stability). Translated to the discrete random-matrix setting, these bounds yield the concentration and scaling-limit results, while a local law for random Gram matrices with a non-uniform variance profile drives the bulk rigidity. Our SSB stability theory may be of independent interest.

In this paper, we present the Electric Mobility Dial-a-Ride Problem (EM-DARP), which extends the Electric Vehicle Dial-a-Ride Problem (EV-DARP) to better accommodate human-focused mobility services. The problem involves utilizing a fleet of heterogeneous Electric Vehicles (EVs) to fulfill a set of customer requests with DARP and mobility-related specifications, while incorporating visits to charging stations amid requests. The problem is formulated as a Mixed-Integer Linear Program (MILP) and subsequently solved for a number of curated evaluation scenarios to demonstrate its practical applicability.

We describe a conjectural approach to obtaining canonical bases of the Hecke algebra at $q=1$ via continuous quadratic optimization. We focus on Specht modules $S^λ$ and proper cones inside $S^λ$ that are invariant under the action of $1+s$ for all simple reflections $s\in S$. We show that there are unique minimal and maximal cones invariant under all $1+s$. For hook shapes, two-column shapes, and partitions of the form $(n-2,2)$, we prove that the Kazhdan--Lusztig basis spans this maximal cone. More generally, we define an optimization problem over bases that are unitriangular with respect to the polytabloid basis, subject to the constraint that the operators $1+s$ act non-negatively. We prove that the feasible region forms a compact semialgebraic set, and interpret it in terms of a hierarchy of invariant cones under all $1+s$. We demonstrate that minimizing the trace of the Gram matrix uniquely recovers Young's seminormal basis. Furthermore, we verify computationally that maximization uniquely recovers the Kazhdan--Lusztig basis for all partitions of $n\leq 7$. In higher ranks, the optimization detects deviations from the Kazhdan--Lusztig basis and may favour other natural positive bases, such as the Springer basis or $p$-canonical bases. Finally, we extend this framework to irreducible representations of $\mathfrak{sl}_n$. We observe that the Gelfand--Tsetlin basis corresponds to the unique minimizer, and we conjecture that the canonical basis corresponds to the maximum in small ranks.

We study additive mixtures of Markov kernels of the form $A_α= αP + (1-α)G$, where $α\in [0,1]$, $P$ is a baseline sampler and $G$ is a Gibbs kernel induced by a partition of the state space. We first motivate the study of $A_α$, which can be interpreted as the projection of a lifted Markov chain. We then consider the minimisation of distance to stationarity under two objectives: the squared Frobenius norm and the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence. For the Frobenius objective, we derive explicit trace formulas and identify a Cheeger-type functional that characterises optimal two-block partitions. This yields a structured combinatorial optimisation problem admitting a difference-of-submodular decomposition, enabling efficient approximation via majorisation-minimisation. We also obtain geometric decay rates governed by the absolute spectral gap of $P$. For the KL divergence, we establish convexity-based bounds showing that the divergence of $A_α$ is controlled by those of both $P$ and $G$, thereby reducing partition selection to the Gibbs component. Numerical experiments on the Curie-Weiss model demonstrate that suitable choice of both the partition and the parameter $α$ can significantly accelerate convergence in total variation distance. We observe a consistent trade-off between local exploration and global averaging, with intermediate values of $α$ achieving the best performance across regimes.

Randomstrasse101 is a blog dedicated to Open Problems in Mathematics, with a focus on Probability Theory, Computation, Combinatorics, Statistics, and related topics. This manuscript serves as a stable record of the Open Problems posted in 2025, with the goal of easing academic referencing. The blog can currently be accessed at randomstrasse101.math.ethz.ch

We consider a realistic decentralized setup with bandwidth-constrained communication and derive optimal time complexities for non-convex stochastic parallel and asynchronous optimization (up to logarithmic factors). We develop the corresponding methods, Grace SGD and Leon SGD, for both homogeneous and heterogeneous settings. Unlike previous work, our optimal bounds are characterized in terms of min-cut/max-flow quantities and rely on tools from Gomory-Hu trees and Steiner Tree Packing problems, providing tighter and more practical complexities.

Random walks are fundamental tools for analyzing complex networked systems, including social networks, biological systems, and communication infrastructures. While classical random walks focus on pairwise interactions, many real-world systems exhibit higher-order interactions naturally modeled by hypergraphs. Existing random walk models on hypergraphs often focus on undirected structures or do not incorporate entropy-based inference, limiting their ability to capture directional flows, uncertainty, or information diffusion in complex systems. In this article, we develop a maximum-entropy random walk framework on directed hypergraphs with two interaction mechanisms: broadcasting where a pivot node activates multiple receiver nodes and merging where multiple pivot nodes jointly influence a receiver node. We infer a transition kernel via a Kullback--Leibler divergence projection onto constraints enforcing stochasticity and stationarity. The resulting optimality conditions yield a multiplicative scaling form, implemented using Sinkhorn--Schrödinger-type iterations with tensor contractions. We further analyze ergodicity, including projected linear kernels for broadcasting and tensor spectral criteria for polynomial dynamics in merging. The effectiveness of our framework is demonstrated with both synthetic and real-world examples.

We study the problem of selecting optimal two-block partitions to accelerate the mixing of finite Markov chains under group-averaging transformations. The main objectives considered are the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence and the Frobenius distance to stationarity. We establish explicit connections between these objectives and the induced projection chain. In the case of the KL divergence, this reduction yields explicit decay rates in terms of the log-Sobolev constant. For the Frobenius distance, we identify a Cheeger-type functional that characterises optimal cuts. This formulation recasts two-block selection as a structured combinatorial optimisation problem admitting difference-of-submodular decompositions. We further propose several algorithmic approximations, including majorisation-minimisation and coordinate descent schemes, as computationally feasible alternatives to exhaustive combinatorial search. Our numerical experiments reveal that optimal cuts under the two objectives can substantially reduce total variation distance to stationarity and demonstrate the practical effectiveness of the proposed approximation algorithms.