arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $G$ be a locally finite multigraph that is bipartite and "unbalanced," meaning that it has a nontrivial bipartition $(A,B)$ with $°(x) > °(y)$ for all $x \in A$ and $y \in B$. We explore matchings in such graphs through the lens of descriptive set theory. In particular, we show that when $G$ is Borel and $μ$ is a Borel probability measure on its vertex set, there is a Borel matching in $G$ that covers $μ$-almost every vertex in $A$. This was previously known only under the assumption that $μ$ is $G$-invariant, which we eliminate using a novel probabilistic approach. We also describe various extra conditions that imply the existence of a Borel matching covering every vertex in $A$. Along the way, we confirm a conjecture of the first and third named authors concerning the existence of Borel independent complete sections in Borel graphs of finite asymptotic separation index. In addition to their intrinsic interest, our results have applications to various other topics, such as edge-colorings, balanced orientations, and equidecomposition theory for group actions. For example, we show that the measurable edge-chromatic number of every Borel multigraph with finite maximum degree $Δ$ is at most $\lfloor\frac{3Δ}{2}\rfloor$, matching Shannon's optimal bound for finite multigraphs. Another example is that paradoxical Borel group actions with finite asymptotic separation index admit paradoxical decompositions with Borel pieces. This refines a result of Marks and Unger.

We study $\mathbb{Z}$-Ramsey ultrafilters, ultrafilters containing witnesses to every shift-invariant instance of Ramsey's theorem. We prove that it is consistent that there are no $\mathbb Z$-Ramsey ultrafilters. We also prove that every $(\mathbb{Z},3)$-Ramsey ultrafilter, as well as every $\mathbb{Z}$-Ramsey P-point, is selective. Further, we exhibit a generic extension -- using quotient algebras of the form \(\mathcal{P}(\mathbb{Z})/\mathcal{I}\) for certain \(F_{σ}\)-ideals -- that contains P-points that are not \(\mathbb{Z}\)-Ramsey ultrafilters, thereby addressing open questions raised by Petrenko and Protasov.

We consider some extremal combinatorial questions for bipartite graphs definable in stable one-based (and related) structures. We show that they satisfy both strong Erdős-Hajnal property and linear Zarankiewicz. We also show that the same is true for both collapsed and uncollapsed Hrushovski's ``ab initio'' constructions, and discuss some connections to Zilber's trichotomy principle. For strong Erdős-Hajnal, we show that in fact it holds in a more general class of $1$-semi-equational theories.

We show that for any uncountable cardinal $κ$, there is a coloring $c: [κ]^2\to ω$ such that $c''A \otimes B = ω$ for any $A, B\subseteq κ$ of order type $ω_1$ that are stationary in their common supremum. In particular, the stationary version of Erdős-Rado theorem and the higher dimensional Friedman's property are both inconsistent. We demonstrate that the theorem is optimal in various ways.

We investigate infinite-exponent partition relations on arbitrary relational structures, with a focus on linear orders and graphs. Any such relation contradicts the Axiom of Choice. We show that there are some such relations which are consistent with ZF which imply the failure not just of Choice but also of the Kinna-Wagner Selection Principle KWP$_1$ and the Ordering Principle O.

An infinite structure has the finite length property (over a given field) if, for each of its finite powers, chains of equivariant subspaces in the corresponding free vector space are bounded in length. Prior work showed that the countable pure set and the countable dense linear order without endpoints have this property. We generalise these results to (a) any structure approximated by finite substructures with few orbits, provided the field is of characteristic zero, and (b) any Fraïssé limit with free amalgamation in a finite vocabulary consisting of unary and binary relations, possibly expanded with a generic total order. As a special case, we deduce the finite length property of the Rado graph using both methods. We also describe some connections with function spaces, weighted register automata, and orbit-finite systems of linear equations.

We investigate the class of FHP theories, i.e. theories of structures in which all definable families of sets satisfy the Fractional Helly Property (and its variants) from combinatorics. FHP theories generalize NIP and form a new subclass of low NTP$_2$ theories. We give many new examples (including ultraproducts of finite fields and of the $p$-adics) and establish some results about forking and $f$-generics for amenable groups definable in FHP theories. We make several conjectures about finitary combinatorial properties of forking in NTP$_2$ theories and establish some partial results, as well as investigate related two-cardinal type counting functions addressing a question of Adler.

In their classical paper \emph{On the stopping time Banach space}, Bang and Odell, among a plethora of results concerning the dyadic stopping time space and its dual, presented the first non-trivial example of the \emph{duality phenomenon} between combinatorial Banach spaces. We give a full characterization of such pairs $(\mc{F}_0, \mc{F}_1)$ of families of finite sets: This duality holds iff there is a perfect graph $G$ on $\NN$ such that $\mc{F}_0$ consists of all finite cliques of $G$ and $\mc{F}_1$ consists of all finite anti-cliques of $G$. As it turns out, Lovász' famous perfect graph theorem is an immediate corollary of this result. Among the many examples of such pairs of families, we investigate a particularly interesting one, when $G$ is the Sierpiński graph, and study general methods of embedding combinatorial and classical sequence spaces in the generated space, including the Schreier and $\ell_p$ spaces.

We describe a general method for constructing representations of finite integral symmetric relation algebras from distance-regular graphs. Given a distance-regular graph of diameter $d$, the distances between vertices induces a coloring of the complete graph with $d$ colors, and we show that this coloring yields a representation of finite integral symmetric relation algebra on $d+1$ atoms. We then introduce a necessary and sufficient condition for when such a representation is algebraic, proving that this occurs if and only if the distance-regular graph is also distance-transitive. We study the diameter-3 case of this method in detail, and we express a condition for the representation's mandatory cycles in terms of the distance-regular graph's intersection array. We apply this result to give a positive answer to an open question of Roger Maddux; namely, whether the relation algebra $30_{65}$ has a representation on a finite set. The representation is given on 42 points, and arises from the second subconstituent of the Hoffman-Singleton graph. We further use this method to describe an infinite class of finite representations of $26_{65}$ and the smallest possible representation of $31_{65}$.

We study test sets: subfamilies of sequences converging to a point P that still suffice to detect every discontinuity of real-valued functions at P. Ordered by inclusion, these test sets form a poset. Under natural hypotheses at P, we prove that this poset has a minimal element. We also analyze its maximal chains, showing that some have a least element, while others do not. Finally, on the sequential fan we give a concrete realization in which the minimal test set produced by our construction has strictly smaller cardinality than the full family of convergent sequences.

We study Keisler measures in strongly n-distal NIP theories, generalizing some results of Simon and Chernikov-Starchenko for distal theories and addressing some questions of Walker. In particular, we establish a hypergraph version of the distal regularity lemma, compact domination for definable fsg groups, and demonstrate that the strong n-distality hierarchy is strict among stable theories using a connection to Poizat's total triviality of forking. We also show that infinite strongly n-distal NIP fields have characteristic 0 using a discrepancy result of Babai-Hayes-Kimmel from multiparty communication complexity.

We present a number of results concerning infinite-exponent partition relations on linear orders of the form $\langle {}^α2,<_{\text{lex}}\rangle$ for $α$ an ordinal, generalising the setting of the real line, working throughout in ZF without the Axiom of Choice. As a particular consequence of our results, we obtain a full classification of the relation $\langle {}^α2,<_{\text{lex}}\rangle \rightarrow (τ)^τ$ for $τ$ countable.

We study stability theory in Hilbert spaces quantitatively. We prove that the inner product on the unit ball is $(k,ε)$-stable for all $k\ge \exp(π/ε)$, and it is not $(k,ε)$-stable for $k\le \exp(\log 2/ε)$, showing that the growth is necessarily exponential in $1/ε$. We then analyze how stability scales under nonlinear connectives applied to the inner product. In particular, for power-type predicates $f(x,y)=\langle x,y\rangle_+^β$ with $β<1$ we obtain upper and lower bounds of the form $\exp(Cε^{-1/β})$, and for $β>1$ and integer powers $\langle x,y\rangle^d$ we retain the bilinear scale $\exp(C/ε)$.

This paper is a contribution to the investigation of closed partition relations for pairs of countable ordinals. As our main result, we prove that \[ω^4 \cdot (n-2)+1 < R^{cl}(ω\cdot n+1,3)<ω^5\] for every integer $n \geq 3$. This result significantly improves the existing upper and lower bounds for these closed Ramsey numbers. In addition, we prove that \[ω^θ\nrightarrow_{cl} (ω^α,3)^2\] whenever $1 \leq α\leq θ<ω_1$ satisfy $θ< R(α,3)$. This result asymptotically improves the existing lower bounds for $R^{cl}(ω^n,3)$ and slightly strengthens the existing necessary condition for being a topological partition ordinal.

We prove that the existence of finite combinatorial objects such as affine planes, mutually orthogonal Latin squares, and resolvable balanced incomplete block designs can be reformulated as the existence of certain algorithmic reductions between problems related to the pigeonhole principle. We then study the latter using counting arguments and computability theory. In particular, we demonstrate that computability theoretic techniques can be used to refine and prove new results in finite combinatorics.

Given a positive integer $n$, an $n$-ladder is a lower finite lattice whose elements have at most $n$ lower covers. In 1984, Ditor proved that every $n$-ladder has cardinality at most $\aleph_{n-1}$ and asked whether this bound is sharp, i.e., whether for each $n$ there is an $n$-ladder of cardinality $\aleph_{n-1}$. We isolate the notion of maximal $n$-ladder and use it to study Ditor's problem and related questions. We show that $\text{Add}(ω, ω_ω)$ forces every maximal $n$-ladder to have cardinality $\aleph_{n-1}$, and hence forces a positive answer to Ditor's question for every $n$. In particular, it is consistent that there are no maximal $3$-ladders of cardinality $\aleph_1$. However, we show that the existence of such a ladder follows from $\mathfrak{d}=\aleph_1$. Under $\clubsuit$, we construct a maximal $3$-ladder of breadth $2$. Finally, we prove that, consistently (under $\diamondsuit$), there exists a maximal $3$-ladder that is destructible by forcing with a Suslin tree.

By a [$K$-]approximate subring of a ring we mean an additively symmetric subset $X$ such that $X \cdot X \cup (X + X)$ is covered by finitely many [resp.\ $K$] additive translates of $X$. We prove a structure theorem for finite approximate subrings. Our aim is to develop a general framework for the sum-product phenomenon that applies uniformly across arbitrary rings. The main result identifies nilpotent quotients as the fundamental obstruction to growth under both addition and multiplication. Another application of the main structure theorem is a ring-theoretic counterpart of Gromov's theorem on groups of polynomial growth. The principal tool in the proof is the existence of definable locally compact models for arbitrary approximate subrings from [Kru24]. This existence theorem extends beyond the finite (and pseudofinite) setting. To illustrate the scope of the method, we also establish a structure theorem for uniformly discrete approximate subrings of semi-simple real algebras, generalizing a classical sum-product result of Meyer.

We show the simplicity of the automorphism groups of the generic $n$-hypertournament and the semigeneric tournament, and determine the normal subgroups of the automorphism groups of several other ultrahomogeneous oriented graphs. We also give a new proof of the simplicity of the automorphism group of the dense $\frac{2π}{n}$-local order $\mathbb{S}(n)$ for $n \geq 2$ (a result due to Droste, Giraudet and Macpherson). Previous techniques of Li, Macpherson, Tent and Ziegler involving stationary weak independence relations (SWIRs) cannot be applied directly to these structures; our approach involves applying these techniques to a certain expansion of each structure, where the expansion has a SWIR and its automorphism group is isomorphic to a stabiliser subgroup of the automorphism group of the original structure.

We investigate Hindman- and Owings-type Ramsey-theoretic statements in Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory without the Axiom of Choice, with some occasional extra assumptions (such as the Axiom of Dependent Choice and/or the Axiom of Determinacy). We study several variations of Hindman's theorem on $\mathbb Q$-vector spaces; notably, we show that the uncountable analog of Hindman's theorem fails for the additive group of $\mathbb R$ (under ZF), and for $\mathbb Q$-vector spaces of uncountable dimension (under DC if such dimension is not well-orderable), among other results. In contrast, for Owings-type configurations, we obtain several positive results, especially when assuming AD. These results highlight the interaction between determinacy, algebraic structure, and dimension in the study of infinite Ramsey theory without the Axiom of Choice.

Tree-ordered weakly sparse models have recently emerged as a robust framework for representing structures in an ``almost sparse'' way, while allowing the structure to be reconstructed through a simple first-order interpretation. A prominent example is given by twin-models, which are bounded twin-width tree-ordered weakly sparse representations of structures with bounded twin-width derived from contraction sequences. In this paper, we develop this perspective further. First, we show that twin-models can be chosen such that they preserve linear clique-width or clique-width up to a constant factor. Then, we introduce \emph{merge-models}, a natural analog of twin-models for merge-width. Merge-models represent binary relational structures by tree-ordered weakly sparse structures. The original structures can then be recovered by a fixed first-order interpretation. A merge-model can be constructed from a merge sequence. Then, its radius-$r$ merge-width will be, up to a constant factor, bounded by the radius-$r$ width of the merge sequence from which it is derived. Finally, we show that twin-models arise naturally as special cases of merge-models, and that binary structures with bounded twin-width are exactly those having a loopless merge-model with bounded radius-$r_0$ merge-width (for some sufficiently large constant $r_0$).