arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study the complementary version of Hedetniemi's problem for infinite graphs. We prove that if a graph $G$ and its complement $\overline{G}$ are both uncountably chromatic while their categorical product is countably chromatic, then $|V(G)|=ω_1$. Assuming $\diamondsuit$, we construct a graph $G$ on $ω_1$ such that $χ(G)=χ(\overline{G})=ω_1$ and $χ(G\times\overline{G})=ω$; the construction uses two suitably chosen minimal Countryman lines. We also define a c.c.c. forcing of cardinality $ω_1$ that adds a graph with the same properties. It remains open whether ZFC alone proves the existence of such a graph.

We use stationary common-neighborhood properties to study highly connected Ramsey relations and partition hypotheses. For weakly compact $κ$, $\operatorname{Coll}(ω_1,{<}κ)$ forces $ω_2\to_{\mathrm{hc},<5}(ω_2)^2_ω$ and $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_2)$. If $κ$ is $T^{κ^+}_{ω_1}$-Ramsey, the same collapse forces that every countable coloring of $[ω_2]^2$ has a stationary set $X\subseteqω_2$ and a color $i$ such that every finite subset of $X$ has stationarily many color-$i$ common neighbors in $X$. From one weakly compact cardinal, we obtain a model of the ${<}5$-edge relation at $ω_3$ and $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_3)$, in which $\check H^2(ω_3,A_d)\ne0$ for every nontrivial abelian group $A$. This separates $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_3)$ from $\operatorname{PH}_2(ω_3)$, with the exact consistency strength of one weakly compact cardinal. We also show that $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_2\timesω_5)$ is equiconsistent with two weakly compact cardinals.

In this note, we prove a stronger version of the Kővári-Sós-Turán theorem for partition-wise $k$-stable $r$-hypergraphs. More precisely, we show that for every $k,r\in\mathbb{N}_{\geq 2}$ there is $η=η(r,k)>0$ such that if $H=(V;E)$ is a partition-wise $k$-stable $r$-uniform $K^{(r)}_{t,\ldots,t}$-free hypergraph with $|V|=n$, then $|E| = O_{r,k,t}(n^{r-η})$. Crucially, $η$ is independent of $t$. The proof follows the pseudofinite regime used by Chernikov and Starchenko to prove an analogous version of Erdős-Hajnal for stable hypergraphs.

We study the well-quasi-order (wqo) consisting of the set of finite trees with leaf labels coming from an arbitrary wqo $Q$, ordered by tree homomorphisms which respect the order on the labels. This is a variant of the usual Kruskal tree ordering without infima preservation. We calculate the precise maximal order types of this class of wqos as a function of the maximal order type of the labels $Q$. In the process, we sharpen some recent results of Friedman and Weiermann. Furthermore, we show a correspondence with indecomposable transfinite sequences with finite range, over elements of the wqo $Q$, of length less than $ω^ω$. Nash-Williams proved that arbitrary transfinite sequences with finite range are also well-quasi-ordered, but there are no known methods to extract bounds on the maximal order type from the proof. More concrete proofs for sequences of length less than $α$ for some $α< ω^ω$ were given by Erdős and Rado. Using the correspondence, we obtain precise bounds for the entire collection of transfinite sequences with finite range of length less than $ω^ω$.

Motivated by the EPPA problem for finite tournaments,we consider various extension properties for partial permutations. We show that for any set $Π$ of prime numbers, the $Π$-extension property is equivalent to the $Π$-LERF. As a consequence of known results, the odd-extension property is then equivalent to the EPPA for finite tournaments. To study the $Π$-extension property, we reformate the property using the concepts of EP problems and $Π$-solutions. We then show that the existence of a $Π$-solution for an EP problem depends entirely on its fundamental group. In particular, when the fundamental group is trivial or cyclic, the EP problem has a $Π$-solution for any $Π$. These extend some known results of Huang, Pawliuk, Sabok and Wise [HPSW19]. We give examples of EP problems without nilpotent-solutions; they witness that the $p$-extension property and the $p$-LERF fail for any prime $p$. Then we consider a special kind of EP problems whose fundamental groups have two generators. We show that any 1-weakly wandering problem has a $Π$-solution for any $Π$. For 2-weakly wandering problems, we show that they all have odd-solutions and we completely characterize those without nilpotent-solutions.

Green's arithmetic regularity lemma over ${\bf F}_2^n$ has tower-type lower bounds. We show that the large order properties in the Hosseini--Lovett--Moshkovitz--Shapira (HLM) construction survive sparse edits. If $d$ is the top block dimension, then changing at most $|G|/16$ points of the top HLM set $A_s$ still leaves a half-graph of height $d/8$. For a suitable choice of the HLM maps, changing at most $ε|G|$ points of a super-level set of the averaged witness still leaves a half-graph of height $d/(8\sqrt{s})\ge {\rm twr}(s-2)$. The proofs use the binary code formed by the top-level row traces and Sauer's lemma.

For every fixed integer $d\geq2$, we prove that the finite graphs receiving a continuous homomorphism from the standard Schreier graph $F(2^{\mathbb Z^d})$ form a $Σ^0_1$-complete set. This extends a theorem of Gao, Jackson, Krohne and Seward when $d=2$. For the positive part of the reduction, we show that if a graph $H$ satisfies a certain property then there is a continuous graph homomorphism from $F(2^{\mathbb Z^d})$ to $H$, in particular, the complete graph $K_4$ satisfies this property. This extends a theorem of Gao and Jackson. We also prove that $\big (\mathcal H_d\big )$ is a strictly decreasing sequence.

Let $Σ_{1} = \mathbb{N}^*$ and $Σ_{k+1} = \overline{\mathbb{N}^* + Σ_{k}}$ be the cumulative depth filtration of $β\mathbb{N}$, the analogue for $(\mathbb{N},+)$ of a chain of closed ideals that Protasov and Protasova studied for discrete groups, where strict descent follows from a theorem of Lutsenko and Protasov. For every $k$ we give an explicit set whose closure meets $Σ_{k}$ but not $Σ_{k+1}$. Fix the doubly exponential sequence $e_{n} = 2^{2^{n}}$, partition it into $k$ subsequences $E_{0}, \dots, E_{k-1}$ by the residue of the index modulo $k$, and set $A_{k} = E_{0} + \cdots + E_{k-1}$. We prove that any sum $q_{0} + \cdots + q_{k-1}$ of free ultrafilters with $E_{t} \in q_{t}$ lies in $Σ_{k} \setminus Σ_{k+1}$. The engine is a master lemma, proved by induction on $j$: if a sum $F_{1} + \cdots + F_{j}$ of subsequences of $\{e_{n}\}$ with pairwise disjoint index sets belongs to a free ultrafilter $s$, then $s \notin Σ_{j+1}$. The proof rests on a single rigidity of the doubly exponential sequence: a fixed difference forces the largest index in any shift-intersection, once it is large, to cancel within its own subsequence, which makes every shift-intersection descend by at least one level. The same witnesses lie in the gaps of the pure filtration.

We prove the equivalence of Hindman's finite sums theorem with a natural extension of Ramsey's theorem.

A class of graphs is monadically dependent if one cannot encode all graphs in coloured graphs from the class using a fixed first-order formula, and monadically stable if one cannot even encode arbitrarily long linear orders. Bonnet et al. (ICALP 2025) characterised monadic dependence by flip-separability: for every vertex weighting, boundedly many flips - complementations of the adjacency relation within a vertex subset - make every ball of radius $r$ carry at most an $\varepsilon$-fraction of the weight, so that every set carrying an $\varepsilon$-fraction has two elements pulled apart. We introduce flip-packability: boundedly many graphs, each obtained from the input by boundedly many flips and all determined by the weighting before any set is presented, such that every set carrying an $\varepsilon$-fraction of the weight has $m$ elements pairwise far apart in one of them. The number of flips producing each graph depends on the radius alone; only the number of graphs depends on $\varepsilon$ and $m$. We prove that a class of graphs is flip-packable if and only if it is monadically stable, and $2$-flip-packable, that is, flip-packable with $m=2$, if and only if it is monadically dependent. The passage from two scattered elements to $m$ is thus exactly what separates the two notions. For monadically stable classes we show that the flipped graphs can be computed from the weighting in cubic time. Varying the three parameters of the definition - the sparsifying operation, the radius, and the number $m$ of elements scattered - produces eight known characterisations of sparse and dense graph classes from the same template. In each case $m$ separates a depth-like notion from its width-like relaxation: treedepth from treewidth, shrubdepth from cliquewidth, and monadic stability from monadic dependence.

We show that one of the main cases of the stable forking conjecture, stability of the forking relation over a base in a finite-rank supersimple theory, is determined by finitely many pregeometries in each rank. This case of the stable forking conjecture has long had an implicitly well-known pregeometric interpretation: there is a set of matroids $\mathcal{G}_{n}$ such that the forking instability in rank $n$ is equivalent to the pregeometry on some rank-one partial type (over a finite set) embedding a matroid in $\mathcal{G}_{n}$. Our contribution is to show that this set of matroids $\mathcal{G}_{n}$, determining based forking stability in rank $n$, can be chosen to be finite. The main part of our proof was already accomplished in rank $3$ by Peretz, but does not extend as stated to higher ranks (and may or may not directly extend in a weaker sense to higher ranks, by shrinking terms). However, we obtain a sufficient substitute for Peretz's work in ranks $n > 3$: we turn Peretz's original universal result into an existence theorem. The rest of our proof refines an argument from multi-experiment parameter definability, originating from work in applied model theory by Li, Meshkat, Ovchinnikov, Pillay, Pogudin and Scanlon.

We show that the percolation components on a square grid can be $5$-colored as a factor of iid so that neighboring components get different colors. Above the critical probability, we observe that these regions can be 4-colored. Along the way, we extend the classical correspondence between fiid process and measurable labellings of the Bernoulli shift to this quotient setting, prove a general coloring result about hyperfinite pmp planar graphs, and clarify some foundational issues about how to define planarity for Borel graphs.

In this paper, we provide a combinatorial characterization of the elements of Schur ultrafilters on countable commutative groups. Using this characterization, we construct a Schur ultrafilter on $\mathbb Z$ that is not infinitary Schur. Moreover, assuming the Continuum Hypothesis, we establish the existence of Schur P-points in $β(\mathbb Z)$. On the other hand, it is consistent with ZFC that there exist P-points in $β(\mathbb Z)$, but none of them are Schur. Also, we extend the result of Fernández-Bretón, Navarro-Castillo, and Soria-Rojas by showing that no Schur ultrafilter on $\mathbb Z$ is a Q-point.

We introduce several Ramsey-theoretic properties of 0-dimensional ambits and obtain their dynamical characterizations. In consequence, we obtain Ramsey-theoretic criteria for triviality and for profiniteness of some important invariants (in particular, of the Ellis groups) of the ambits in question. This yields a criterion for the structural property that each distal minimal factor of the given ambit is a profinite flow. Another result is a criterion for metrizability of the minimal left ideals in the Ellis semigroup. Then we study three specializations of the above abstract context: to first order theories, to definable groups, and to the classical Kechris-Pestov-Todorčević theory, recovering known and obtaining new results in each of these contexts.

In this paper, we determine the precise asymptotics of the number of parts of stable regularity equipartitions in terms of the Littlestone dimension: every graph $G$ of Littlestone dimension $\operatorname{Lit}(G)\leq\ell$ has a regular equipartition into excellent sets with $(1 + o_{ε\to 0,\ell}(1))\cdotε^{-\ell-1}$ parts and in the other direction, for every $\ell\in\mathbb{N}_+$, there is an infinite family of graphs, all of Littlestone dimension $\ell$, whose equipartitions into good sets must have size at least $(1 + o_{ε\to 0,\ell}(1))\cdotε^{-\ell-1}$. Dropping the equitability condition, we determine the asymptotics of non-equitable partitions up to a multiplicative $\log(1/ε)$: every graph $G$ with $\operatorname{Lit}(G)\leq\ell$ has a regular partition into excellent sets with $(1 + o_{ε\to 0,\ell}(1))\cdotε^{-\ell}\cdot\ln(1/ε)$ parts and in the other direction, for every $\ell\in\mathbb{N}_+$, there is an infinite family of graphs, all of Littlestone dimension $\ell$, whose partitions into good sets must have size at least $(1 + o_{ε\to 0,\ell}(1))\cdotε^{-\ell}$. We also show that such partition can be obtained algorithmically efficiently in an approximation scheme fashion: replacing the $o_{ε\to 0,\ell}(1)$ term above by a constant $c > 0$, we obtain randomized $O_{c,ε,\ell}(n\cdot\log(n))$-time algorithms for partitions/equipartitions into good sets, a deterministic $O_{c,ε,\ell}(n^2)$-time algorithm for partitions into good sets, a deterministic $O_{c,ε,\ell}(n^6)$-time algorithm for equipartitions into good sets, a deterministic $O_{c,\ell,ε}(1)\cdot n^{O(\ell\cdot 2^{2\cdot\ell+4})}$-time algorithm for partitions/equipartitions into excellent sets, and $O_{c,ε,\ell}(\log(n+1))$-space algorithms for partitions/equipartitions into good/excellent sets.

We study conditions for a countable group acting on a connected locally finite hyperbolic graph to induce a hyperfinite orbit equivalence relation on the Gromov boundary of the graph in terms of tree-decompositions of the graph. We prove that for a connected locally finite hyperbolic graph $X$ equipped with an action of a countable group $G$, if $(T, β)$ is a $G$-invariant tree-decomposition of $X$ such that each bag induces a connected subgraph $X_t$ of $X$ for each $t \in V(T)$, each adhesion set is finite and such that there are only finitely many $G$-orbits of edges of $T$, then the orbit equivalence relation of $G$ acting on the Gromov boundary $\partial X$ is hyperfinite provided the orbit equivalence relation of $G$ acting on $\partial T$ is hyperfinite and the orbit equivalence relations of the bag stabilizers acting on $\partial X_t$ are all hyperfinite. We show that the converse also holds if $(T, β)$ satisfies the additional property that each adhesion set distinguishes at least two ends of $X$.

Let $G$ be a Borel digraph with maximum out-degree $d \in \mathbb{N}$. We show that $G$ admits a random Borel $(2d+1)$-coloring for which every edge is almost surely not monochromatic. This gives a simpler proof of a recent result of Pelayo-Gómez: such a graph $G$ admits a measurable proper $(2d+1)$-coloring with respect to any Borel probability measure on $V(G)$. Our proof is an adaptation of Pelayo-Gómez's proof to the randomized Borel setting.

We develop some model theory of multilinear forms, generalizing Granger's work in the bilinear case. In particular, after proving a quantifier elimination result, we show that for an NIP field $K$, the theory of infinite-dimensional non-degenerate alternating $n$-linear spaces over $K$ is strictly $n$-dependent, and is NSOP$_1$ if $K$ is. These results rely on a new Composition Lemma for functions of arbitrary arity and NIP relations (which in turn relies on certain higher-arity generalizations of the Sauer--Shelah lemma). We also study the invariant connected components $G^{\infty}$ in $n$-dependent groups, demonstrating their relative absoluteness.

We give direct combinatorial proofs that 1-semi-equational theories satisfy two combinatorial properties that imply the non-interpretability of certain fields. Our main result is that Boolean combinations of 1-semi-equations have almost linear Zarankiewicz bounds, and hence no infinite field is interpretable in a 1-semi-equational theory; this answers a question of Chernikov--Mennen and Chernikov--Starchenko, who had respectively established almost linear Zarankiewicz bounds for Boolean combinations of $(2,1)$-semi-equations and Boolean combinations of weakly normal relations. (This was recently and independently established by Gou, Mirabi, Mittal, Tran, and Yang, using different techniques and producing different bounds.) We also show that $(k,1)$-semi-equations satisfy the $δ$-strong Erdős--Hajnal property with $δ=1/6^{k-1}$; this had previously been established by Chernikov--Starchenko for an ineffective constant $δ>0$.

The Borel distinguishing number $D_B(\mathcal{G})$ of a Borel graph $\mathcal{G}$, recently introduced by Bilge and Kaya, is the minimum number of colors required to break the symmetry of $\mathcal{G}$ in a Borel way. In this paper, we investigate the Borel distinguishing number of Schreier graphs induced by the free part of the shift action $Γ\curvearrowright n^Γ$. We prove that $D_B(\mathcal{G})\le n+1$ for $Γ=\mathbb{Z}^d$ equipped with the standard generators. Moreover, we show that $D_B(\mathcal{G})\ge n+1$ if $ Γ$ is amenable and $ \{γ\in \mathrm{Aut}(\mathrm{Cay}(Γ,S)) \mid γ(e) = e \}$ is non-trivial. We also show that $D_B(\mathcal{G})$ is finite if $Γ$ is finitely generated, and give some applications of our results. These results answer some questions raised by Bilge and Kaya.