arXiv++ Combinatorics

We take the first step toward the study of set-theoretic principles below the axiom of choice $\mathsf{AC}$ and the axiom of foundation $\mathsf{AF}$ by studying Frucht's theorem, an ordinary mathematical theorem which is provable with either $\mathsf{AC}$ or $\mathsf{AF}$ but not provable without both, and its variants. Specifically, we propose a number of such principles, study the relations between these principles and the standard axioms, and prove provability and unprovability results using (infinite) graph-theoretic constructions and permutation models, which draw a preliminary map of this new area of set theory.

The rearrangement number $\mathfrak{rr}$ is the least cardinality of a collection of permutations of $ω$ such that every conditionally convergent real series is disrupted by some permutation in the collection. Blass, Brendle, Brian, Hamkins, Hardy, and Larson proved that $\max\{\operatorname{cov}(\mathcal N),\mathfrak b\}\leq\mathfrak{rr}\leq\operatorname{non}(\mathcal M)$ and asked whether $\mathfrak{rr}<\mathrm{non}(\mathcal M)$ is consistent. We prove that $\mathfrak{rr}<\operatorname{non}(\mathcal M)$ is consistent with ZFC. We also prove, in a different forcing extension, that $\max\{\operatorname{cov}(\mathcal N),\mathfrak b\}<\mathfrak{rr}$. We further derive consequences for the subseries number $\mathfrak{s}_{\mathrm{sub}}$ and the splitting number $\mathfrak s$.

We prove that $(k+1)$-uniform hypergraphs definable in an NIP strongly $k$-distal structure satisfy a homogeneous regularity lemma -- they can be partitioned into a bounded number of simplicial complexes, most of which are homogeneous (meaning that the restriction of the hypergraph to the simplicial complex is either complete or empty). Furthermore, the parts of the partition can be chosen uniformly definably, and the size of the partition is polynomial in the reciprocal of the error parameter. This extends the homogeneous regularity lemma proven by Chernikov and Starchenko for hypergraphs definable in a distal structure. We prove this by introducing $k$-strong honest definitions and showing that an NIP structure is strongly $k$-distal if and only if every formula $\varphi(x_1, ..., x_k; y)$ has a $k$-strong honest definition. This extends the theory of strong honest definitions in distal structures to the higher-arity setting.

We prove that for every non-arithmetic set~$C$ and every arithmetic finite coloring of~$\mathbb{N}$, there is an infinite set $H \subseteq \mathbb{N}$ whose non-empty finite sums of distinct elements is monochromatic, and $C$ is not $H$-computable. We also study restrictions of Hindman's theorem to simple colorings.

We establish absolute and relative almost-linear Zarankiewicz bounds for semilinear relations in valued vector spaces. For every fixed arity and description complexity, a $K_{t,\ldots,t}$-free semilinear $r$-partite hypergraph has at most \[ O\!\left(n^{r-1}(\log n)^c\right) \] edges, where $c$ depends only on the arity and the number of valuative literals. In the bipartite case a separate arbitrary-trace argument gives the explicit bound $O(n(\log n)^{2s})$ for description complexity $(ρ,s)$. We also prove a relative extension theorem: intersecting any relation with a hereditary almost-linear profile by $s$ affine moving-radius comparisons increases the logarithmic exponent by at most $2s$. For the additive affine-valuative structures on $\mathbb Q_p$ and $\mathbb C_p$, quantifier elimination converts these semilinear results into bounds for all definable relations. Finally, over every valued field with infinite value group, we construct $K_{2,2}$-free semilinear point--box graphs of description complexity $(1,4)$ with $Ω(n\log n/\log\log n)$ edges.

We prove that the recognition problem for algebraic matroids is undecidable. Explicitly, this means that there is no algorithm that takes as input a finite set $S$ and a function $r\colon\mathcal{P}(S) \to \mathbb{Z}_{\ge 0}$ (where $\mathcal{P}(S)$ is the power set) and decides whether there exists a pair of fields $F \subset K$, and a function $f\colon S \to K$, such that for all $A \subseteq S$: $\mathrm{tr.deg}_{K/F}(f(A)) = r(A)$. This problem is known to be decidable if the characteristic of the fields involved is constrained to be zero. We prove that it is undecidable if the characteristic is either left unspecified (in which case a realization over any characteristic is accepted) or fixed to be a prime $p$. The proof relies on Hrushovski--Zilber's Group Configuration Theorem and on the work of Evans and Hrushovski on "Projective Planes in Algebraically Closed Fields". We relate two different such projective planes, and eventually construct a reduction from the solvability of Diophantine equations over $\mathbb{F}_p(x)$ ($p$ prime) to algebraicity of matroids. Solvability of Diophantine equations over $\mathbb{F}_p(x)$ was proved to be undecidable by Pheidas for all $p > 2$, and later by Videla for $p=2$. A central part of our proof is a variant of the so-called Field Configuration Theorem.

We prove an $\mathrm{MSO}_2$ zero-one law for a very sparse Erdős-Rényi graph after pruning by component order. Let $p_n=c_n/n$, where $c_n\to0$, and delete every component of order less than $f(n)$, where $f(n)\to\infty$. If \[ f(n)\bigl(\log f(n)+\log(1/c_n)\bigr)=o(\log n), \] then the resulting graph satisfies a zero-one law for $\mathrm{MSO}_2$, with quantification over sets of vertices and sets of edges. The proof combines uniform component counts, an MSO Feferman-Vaught decomposition for disjoint unions, and semilinearity of the order spectra of MSO-definable classes of finite trees. We also show that the term $f(n)\log f(n)$ cannot simply be omitted: star components can occur at first-order-visible Poisson thresholds. We further establish first-order limit laws for bond percolation on the discrete torus $T_L^d$. In the two-sided subpolynomial regime, pruning below a sufficiently slow threshold yields a zero-one law. For the unpruned model in either one-sided polynomial regime, the reciprocal exponents $α=1/k$ are precisely the critical scales. At such a scale, an extended limit of $N p_N^k$ or $N q_N^k$ equal to $0$ or $\infty$ gives a zero-one law; a positive finite limit gives a convergence law but not a zero-one law; and the absence of an extended limit gives failure of convergence. Finally, $\mathrm{MSO}_1$ already detects the parity of the torus side length through bipartiteness, producing a natural obstruction to monadic convergence in a near-deterministic regime.

We provide a combinatorial characterization for pairs of order-theoretic trees with homeomorphic ray spaces, answering an open problem proposed by Kurkofka ad Pitz. This solution is inspired by the introduction of a transfinite topological game, which allows us to characterize not only ray spaces through the existence of winning strategies for one of the players, but also their homeomorphic classes. As applications of these results, we obtain a new topological characterization for graph-theoretic end spaces (thus obtaining yet another solution to a recently solved problem of Diestel), as well as for edge-end spaces and completely ultrametrizable spaces. We also introduce a generalization of the class of ray spaces (which is strict, as witnessed by the Sorgenfrey line). Furthermore, we establish that, for subspaces with cardinality less than continuum of end spaces, the scattered property is equivalent to the property of being, itself, an end space. At last, we determine that ray spaces in a couple of classes fail to have their product with any non-discrete space as a ray space.

The theory of $q$-series and basic hypergeometric series plays a crucial role at the intersection of combinatorics, number theory, and representation theory. From the classical partition identities of Euler and Jacobi to modern developments in class field theory, vertex operator algebras, and the Monstrous Moonshine conjecture, $q$-series provide the analytic framework for a wide range of profound applications. In this paper, we discuss the formalization of this theory in the Lean proof assistant, a process that requires careful design of scalable and versatile structures to reconcile formal algebraic identities with analytic convergence properties. We address these foundational challenges by focusing on the construction of $q$-Pochhammer symbols, $q$-binomial coefficients, Bailey's Lemma and similar primitives. To demonstrate the utility of this work, we provide fully verified proofs of the Jacobi Triple Product formula and the celebrated Rogers-Ramanujan identities, which serve as both historical and technical benchmarks for the field. This work establishes a rigorous computational foundation for the future formalization of mock theta functions, modular forms, and the diverse algebraic structures that underpin their applications across mathematics and physics.

Let \(\vec F(2^{\mathbb Z^2})\) be the directed Schreier graph on the free part of the Bernoulli shift \(\mathbb Z^2\curvearrowright 2^{\mathbb Z^2}\), with arcs in the two coordinate directions. We prove that the continuous oriented chromatic number of it is 7, that is, there is a tournament on 7 vertices receiving a continuous graph homomorphism from $\vec F(2^{\mathbb Z^2})$ and there is no continuous graph homomorphism from $\vec F(2^{\mathbb Z^2})$ to any tournament on 6 vertices.

Let $\mathbb{H}_{n+1}$ denote a computable copy of the $(n+1)$-clique free universal homogeneous Henson graph, $G$ denote a finite subgraph of $\mathbb{H}_{n+1}$, and $k(G,n)$ denote the big Ramsey degree of $G$ in $\mathbb{H}_{n+1}$. We prove that for any computable coloring $χ$ of the copies of $G$ in $\mathbb{H}_{n+1}$, there is a copy $\mathbb{H}'$ of $\mathbb{H}_{n+1}$ that is computable from $0^{(2δ(G,n)-1)}$ in which $χ$ takes no more than $k(G,n)$ colors, where $δ(G,n)$ denotes the maximum number of levels of a diary for $G$ in $\mathbb{H}_{n+1}$ (this is a finite number). It follows that the statement, ``Henson graphs have finite big Ramsey degrees," is provable in ACA$_0'$. Combining this with a recent result of Cholak, Dobrinen, and McCoy \cite{CDM} yields the equivalence of the statement with ACA$_0'$ over RCA$_0$.

We settle the long-standing open question whether there exists a $3$-ladder of cardinality $\aleph_2$. Given a positive integer $n$, an $n$-ladder is a lower finite lattice whose elements have at most $n$ lower covers. In 1984, Ditor proved that every $n$-ladder has cardinality at most $\aleph_{n-1}$, and that this cardinal bound is sharp for $n = 1,2$. He then raised the question of whether the bound is attained for $n\ge 3$ as well. An affirmative answer is known to be consistent with $\mathsf{ZFC}$. We prove, relative to the consistency of a Mahlo cardinal, that the question is independent of $\mathsf{ZFC}$. More precisely, we show that the nonexistence of a $3$-ladder of cardinality $\aleph_2$ is equiconsistent with a Mahlo cardinal.

This theoretical note studies the finite axiomatizability of strict majority reasoning in finite social decision frames. Moss and Pedersen (2026) <doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2606.23853> introduce a coherence criterion that characterizes exactly when qualitative majority judgments are representable by a finitely additive measure. The question addressed here is whether that coherence criterion can be replaced, in the finite setting, by any bounded finite fragment. We prove that it cannot. For every $k\ge 1$, we construct a maximal standard frame whose shortest coherence violation has length exactly $2k+2$. Hence there is no uniform finite bound on the incoherence index of social decision frames, resolving Conjecture 5.7 stated by Moss and Pedersen (2026). The construction is geometric, in the sense that it proceeds via orthogonality and dimension in rational vector spaces, and self-contained: it isolates a symmetric family of half-sized voting blocs and extends it to a maximal frame in which every shorter balanced obstruction is excluded. Along the explicit infinite sequence of universe sizes obtained in the construction, this also establishes the middle-layer family predicted by Conjecture B.25 by Moss and Pedersen (2026). Together with the soundness and completeness theorem for the Moss-Pedersen minimal logic for strict majorities, this establishes that measurable social decision frames are not finitely axiomatizable in that language.

We define a combinatorial property of a projective Fraisse category which we call the \emph{approximate Ramsey property}. Let $F$ be a continuum, $G$ a closed subgroup of the homeomorphism group of $F$, and $\mathbb{F}$ the limit of projective Fraisse category $\mathcal{F}$ such that $\textrm{Aut}(\mathbb{F})$ is dense in $G$. We prove that $\mathcal{F}$ has the approximate Ramsey property if and only if $G$ is extremely amenable. We prove that the group of homeomorphisms of the universal pseudo-solenoid has non-metrizable universal minimal flow.

We study monadic dependence of binary relational structures including at least one antisymmetric relation. Our cornerstone result gives sufficient conditions for proving that a structure is monadically dependent by only considering some of its reducts, assuming they are structurally well-behaved and compatible enough. As an application, we consider some reorientation rules preserving monadic dependence of binary structures, as well as replacement of one antisymmetric relation with bounded independence number by another. Then, we apply our main (technical) result to the study of twin-width in two ways. First, generalizing the fact that twin-width boundedness is equivalent to being expandable by a linear order into a monadically dependent class, we prove that it is also equivalent to being expandable by an oriented graph with bounded independence number (for instance by a poset with bounded width or by a tournament), and that FO-model checking is fixed-parameter tractable on such an expansion. Second, we show delineation by twin-width for some new classes of oriented graphs, including oriented split graphs and local tournaments. In all these cases, we also obtain fixed-parameter tractability of FO-model checking.

In 1921, Kuratowski gave the now-standard definition of ordered pair in the context of set theory. This paper studies the problem of defining ordered tuples as sets in the hierarchy of simple types, of which Kuratowski's construction is a special case.

The end space of an infinite graph arises naturally in many contexts as an important invariant and an interesting construction. It compactifies a locally finite graph and Diestel shows how to extend the end space to a larger space, called the tangle space, which is able to compactify any infinite graph. In both ends and tangles, it is the vertex-connectivity structure of the graph that is being studied. If we switch our attention to edge-connectivity, we can analogously define edge-ends. There is a space known as the edge-direction space which turns out to play an analogous role as the tangle space in its relationship with the end space: the edge-direction space provides a larger compact space in which the not necessarily compact space of edge-ends lives in. In this paper, we make this analogy precise, providing a natural edge analogue definition of tangles and proving they result in exactly the edge-directions. We also describe a combinatorial construction of certain Boolean algebras which give rise, via Stone duality, to the tangle and the edge-direction spaces. Finally, we pursue functorial definitions of the combinatorial constructions used in the paper, inspired by the famously functorial nature of Stone duality and by previous work by one of the authors and colleagues on trying to functorialize the end space construction. We hope our work will provide foundation and inspiration for further work on infinite graph theory that makes ample use of category theory and powerful algebraic constructions such as Boolean algebras and Stone duality.

We prove the existence of clopen strong marker sets in $F(2^{\mathbb{Z}^n})$ for arbitrary finite generating sets. Specifically, for any positive integers $n, d_0\geq 1$ and any finite generating set $S\subseteq \mathbb{Z}^n$, we construct a clopen set $M\subseteq F(2^{\mathbb{Z}^n})$ and a positive integer $Δ$ such that (1) for any distinct $x,y\in M$ in the same orbit, $ρ(x,y)\geq d_0$; (2) for any $v\in S$ and any $x\in F(2^{\mathbb{Z}^n})$, there are non-negative integers $a,b\leq Δ$ such that $av\cdot x\in M$ and $-bv\cdot x\in M$. Here $ρ$ denotes the Euclidean metric. The same result then holds for the standard supremum-norm metric $ρ_\infty$ (with an adjusted constant), by the equivalence of norms on $\mathbb{Z}^n$. The proof introduces polyhedral packages in $\mathbb{R}^n$ as a generalization of the rectangular packages used in earlier work, enabling the construction to handle generating vectors with arbitrary coordinate patterns. As an application, we obtain a continuous proper edge $(2|S|+1)$-coloring of the Schreier graph on $F(2^{\mathbb{Z}^n})$ with generating set $S$, recovering a result of Gao--Wang--Wang.

Sunflowerability, or the infinite sunflower property, was introduced and studied by Ackerman, Karker and Mirabi as a structural generalization of the well-known Δ-system lemma for sets. It turns out that for relational Fra\''issé limits with strong amalgamation, this property is equivalent to the so-called galah property, which was introduced by Sullivan and Winkel as an asymmetric variation of indivisibility. This paper is about these two properties and is divided into three parts. In the first part, we show that the conjecture proposed by Ackerman, Karker and Mirabi about the infinite sunflower property in higher dimensions is far from being true by proving that no infinite structure has the infinite n-sunflower property in dimension k for any n, k \geq 2. In the second part, we give a complete characterization of the galah property for Henson directed graphs, homogeneous metric spaces and homogeneous ultrametric spaces, thereby answering the second question asked by Sullivan and Winkel. The third part contains several additional results about the finite sunflower property, including a strengthening of recent results about indivisibility for some classes of undirected graphs obtained by Guingona et al..

An $n$-partite graph is a graph such that every vertex has a color in $\{1,\ldots,n\}$ and every two vertices of the same color are not adjacent. We study the model comparisons of the theories of $n$-partite graph and $K_{\overline{m}}$-free $n$-partite graph, where $K_{\overline{m}}$ is a complete graph of a given size. The model companion of the theory of $n$-partite graph is simple and has IP. The model companion of the theory of $K_{\overline{m}}$-free $n$-partite graph has $\operatorname{TP}_2$, $\operatorname{SOP}_3$ and $\operatorname{NSOP}_4$ if $n > 2$. Forking independence coincides with dividing independence in this theory.