arXiv++ Combinatorics

We give a quantitative combinatorial characterization of size-oblivious one-sided testability in the dense graph model, resolving a question of Alon, Fischer, Newman, and Shapira. For hereditary graph properties, we prove that one-sided testability is quantitatively equivalent to the existence of suitable hypergraph containers, a central and widely used tool in modern combinatorics. Combining this equivalence with the Alon-Shapira notion of semi-hereditariness yields a quantitative characterization of arbitrary graph properties. The correspondence is effective in both directions and provides explicit translations between tester complexity and container parameters. Our proof is regularity-free and extends uniformly to every fixed finite relational signature of bounded arity, including digraphs, coloured graphs, and hypergraphs. As applications, we obtain quantitative closure results for partition properties and testers for properties defined by the existence of a linearly large induced substructure.

The spectral sensitivity $λ(f)$ of a Boolean function is the largest eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of its sensitivity graph. It lower-bounds every standard measure of query complexity, and Aaronson, Ben-David, Kothari, Rao and Tal, who introduced it, asked whether block sensitivity is at most quadratic in it: is $bs(f)=O(λ(f)^{2})$? We show that it is not. We construct a total Boolean function on $2017584$ variables with $bs(f)\ge 14011$ and $λ(f)\le 89.0162$, so that $bs(f)\geλ(f)^{2.127}$, and hence by composition a family with $λ(f_n)\to\infty$ and $bs(f_n)=Ω(λ(f_n)^{2.127})$. The function is the indicator of a union of $k$ subcubes indexed by the vertices of a doubly regular tournament, and the freedom left in the construction is fixed by the Lovász local lemma. The main result has been formally verified in Lean. We also give numerical evidence that a member of the same family on $1255$ variables reaches an exponent near $2.20$, and exhibit a member on $30$ variables whose exponent already exceeds $2$ and whose spectral sensitivity can be computed exactly.

A connected graph G is said to be a bisplit graph if the vertex set of G can be partitioned into a stable set and a complete bipartite graph. We establish the following dichotomy with chordality being the parameter; for chordal bisplit graphs, Hamiltonian cycle (HCYCLE) and Hamiltonian path (HPATH) problems are polynomial-time solvable, and for chordal bipartite bisplit graphs, HCYCLE (HPATH) is NP-complete. We further strengthen the result of [1] and show that HCYCLE (HPATH) is polynomial-time solvable on P5-free chordal bipartite graphs (bipartite chain graphs) and NP-complete on P10-free chordal bipartite graphs. By using our polynomial results on HCYCLE (HPATH) as a framework, we solve many variants and generalizations of HCYCLE (HPATH), which are also reported in this paper.

The Kemeny rule aggregates rankings by minimizing their total Kendall-tau distance from an aggregate order. We prove that Kemeny Score is NP-complete for exactly three unweighted rankings, even when every candidate pair is split $2$-to-$1$. On the same profiles, the winner, unique-winner, and possible- and necessary-precedence problems are $Θ_2^p$-complete, while recognizing a Kemeny-optimal or uniquely Kemeny-optimal aggregate is coNP-complete. The hard instances induce tournaments of majority dimension exactly $3$. The reduction also determines the exact maximum-cut value from the optimal Kemeny score and recovers a maximum cut from any Kemeny-optimal aggregate. For every fixed $q\geq3$ and $\lceil q/2\rceil\leq s\leq q$, minimum pairwise support $s$ yields a sharp dichotomy: the score problem is NP-complete, the winner and precedence problems are $Θ_2^p$-complete, and the recognition problems are coNP-complete when $3s\leq2q$; for $3s>2q$, the majority tournament is transitive and its unique topological order is the unique Kemeny-optimal aggregate. Exact support $s$ suffices in the hard case when $s>q/2$, and supports in ${s,s+1}$ suffice when $s=q/2$. These results give complete fixed-profile-size classifications and transfer to Slater orders, permutation medians, and maximum-likelihood central rankings in the Mallows model. Finally, a six-copy construction proves NP-completeness of both Kemeny Score and Kendall--Tau Center for three pairwise-equidistant rankings that still split every pair $2$-to-$1$. For $N$ output candidates, their common distance is $\frac23\binom N2$, the largest possible for an equidistant triple. The construction gives affine formulas for both optimal values, characterizes all Kemeny-optimal output orders, and shows that the output has a unique Kemeny-optimal order and a unique center exactly when the input has a unique Kemeny-optimal order.

Graph $k$-coloring is one of the classic NP-complete problems. Previous work has studied its average time complexity, defined to be the average runtime of computing a $k$-coloring over the set of all $k$-colorable graphs on $n$ vertices. A highly influential result of Dyer-Frieze from 1989 gave an algorithm with $O(n^2)$ average runtime for constant $k$. This quadratic runtime appeared natural (and possibly even optimal) since almost all $k$-colorable graphs have $Θ(n^2)$ edges, so one needs at least this time in order to read the (entire) input. However, this was later improved by Kučera in 1995 to average runtime $O(n^2/k)$ for every $k \leq n^{c}$ where $c \in (0, 1)$. Nevertheless, in the most interesting case of $k = O(1)$, the best-known bound remained quadratic in $n$. The true average complexity of the $k$-coloring problem has remained elusive for the last three decades. We break the longstanding quadratic barrier. Our main result in this paper shows that the exact average-case complexity of this fundamental problem is $Θ(nk)$ for every $k \leq n^{c'}$ and some $c' \in (0, 1)$. For $k = O(1)$, this reveals the average sublinear nature of $k$-colorability: the average-case complexity is linear in $n$, and thus sublinear in the size of the input. We further show that our $Θ(nk)$ average runtime is optimal, since a simple bound proves that every algorithm that correctly $k$-colors all $k$-colorable graphs requires $Ω(n k)$ average runtime. Our proofs draw on ideas from sublinear and local algorithms and also yield a local computation algorithm (LCA) for $k$-coloring with average-case probe complexity $\text{poly}(k)$. A key new ingredient in our algorithm is a method for certifying the unique colorability of random subgraphs, using tools from the theory of graph regularity.

It is shown that the $\mathsf{OR}$-rank (covering rank) of the $2^n \times 2^n$ unique disjointness matrix is $n^{O(1)}(3/2)^n$, hence the known lower bound $1.5^n$ turns out to be essentially tight. By the way, an upper bound $1.89^n$ is obtained for the $\mathsf{SUM}$-rank (partition rank) of this matrix.

For integers $k\le n$, let $L_{k,n}$ be the set of words over $[n]$ of length at most $k$ in which no symbol is repeated. We present a nondeterministic finite automaton (NFA) of size $3.918^k n^{O(1)}$, improving on the $4^{k+o(k)}n^{O(1)}$ construction of Ben-Basat, Gabizon, and Zehavi. Our proof organizes several classical ingredients---product automata, hashing, and coefficient estimates---into a gadget-amplification framework: We take the product of many copies of a small local NFA gadget, whose language is a subset of $L_{r,c}$, and hash the $k$ input symbols to copies and local colors. The hash family guarantees that, for every repetition-free input, some hash sends at most $r$ symbols to each copy such that the resulting projection in every copy is accepted by the local gadget. Taking the nondeterministic union of the corresponding product NFAs yields a global NFA. Amplifying a $200$-state gadget for $L_{6,11}$ obtained from the small Witt design $S(4,5,11)$, this framework gives a $3.967^k n^{O(1)}$-size NFA. We then introduce the compose-and-compress technique, which deletes the expensive middle layers of these products and replaces paths across the deleted bands with sound one-symbol shortcut transitions. We apply it twice, once for enhancing the amplification framework and again for the local gadget, obtaining the stated result.

Finding a set of vertices in a graph with no edges between them, INDSET, is a well-known NP-complete problem. The queen graph of a chessboard is constructed by taking vertices as the tiles of the chessboard and drawing edges between two tiles if a queen can move from one to the other. We call INDQUEENS the independent set problem on a queen graph where the chessboard is a polyomino. We prove that INDQUEENS on polyominoes is NP-complete, proving a conjecture of Langlois-Rémillard--Müßig--Roldán. As our reduction is parsimonious, we can further prove that it is #P-complete. We furthermore prove that INDROOKS on polyominoes is #P-complete, despite being solvable in polynomial time.

A quasi-tree of a connected ribbon graph is a spanning ribbon subgraph with exactly one boundary component; quasi-trees play the role of spanning trees in the topological graph theory of embedded graphs. We prove that counting them is #P-complete under polynomial-time Turing reductions, already for bouquets. The proof identifies every nonempty framed chord diagram, up to natural identifications, with a 4-regular map equipped with a distinguished A-trail, in such a way that quasi-trees correspond to A-trails, whose counting is #P-complete by a theorem of Ge and Štefankovič. Through the framed Cohn-Lempel equality the count is also an interlace-polynomial evaluation - $q(H;2,1)$, the number of full-rank induced subgraphs of the looped circle graph $H$ of the diagram - placing it on the line $y=1$ left open in the complexity classification of Bläser and Hoffmann; a cloning argument then makes every fixed rational point of that line, other than the trivial $(1,1)$, #P-hard on looped circle graphs, even when a framed chord representation is supplied. On the tractable side, the same GF(2) model yields short proofs of the known determinantal cases: for orientable ribbon graphs the count is a determinant, essentially the Matrix-Quasi-tree Theorem of Merino, Moffatt and Noble, proved here via Bouchet's principal unimodularity, and for bouquets with exactly one non-orientable loop it is a sum of two orientable determinants, equivalent by a rank-one determinant identity to the determinant formula of Deng, Jin and Yan.

The recent breakthrough work of Chatterjee, Ghosh, Gurjar, Raj and Thierauf [CGGRT26] gives the first deterministic NC algorithm for the bipartite matching problem. They show how to detect as well as find perfect matchings in bipartite graphs in NC. In this note we present an arguably simpler-to-state variation of the NC detection criterion of [CGGRT26], with improved parameters.

We study the class $\#\mathsf{L}$ of functions counting accepting paths of non-deterministic log-space Turing machines and construct methods to prove containment in $\#\mathsf{L}$. We prove that a large number of classical combinatorial and number theoretic functions belong to this class: classical functions from enumerative combinatorics (multinomial coefficients, Catalan numbers, linear extensions of trees, Stirling numbers, etc), algebraic combinatorics (number of standard Young tableaux, etc), discrete geometry, number theoretic functions, representation theoretic multiplicities in a large class of cases. We show that $\mathrm{GL}_2$-plethysm coefficients of bounded length outer partition can be counted by log$^2$-space polytime verifiers. We pose numerous questions and conjectures on $\#\mathsf{L}$ containment and its generalizations, that suggest venues for conditionally disproving $\#\mathsf{P}$-completeness. While studying which combinatorial functions are in $\#\mathsf{P}$ provides a formal way of (dis)proving the existence of combinatorial interpretations, the lower class $\#\mathsf{L}$ serves as an analogue for functions computable in polynomial time.

For an explicitly represented finite empirical model, deciding whether the contextual fraction is strictly below one is NP-complete, while the standard exact linear program has one column for every global assignment. We identify a permutation-transport class in which this global problem collapses to a fixed-point calculation. Let a connected permutation gain graph act on a finite state set $O$, let $H \leq{ \rm Sym}(O)$ be its holonomy subgroup, let $F = {\rm Fix}(H)$, and let $p$ be an $H$-invariant root distribution. For the induced empirical model, \[ {\rm NCF}(e)=p(F),\qquad {\rm CF}(e)=1-p(F). \] Consequently, compatibility, $F$, and ${\rm CF}(e)$ are computable in $O(|O|(|V|+|E|))$ arithmetic and table operations. For every finite simple $2$-edge-connected graph, any deterministic exact algorithm in the explicit permutation-table query model requires at least $(|O|-1)|E|$ probes in the worst case, making the dependence on the input tables optimal up to constant factors. With a fixed spanning tree, chord insertions and deletions require $O(|O|)$ worst-case time, or time proportional to the moved-set representation, while compatibility and contextual-fraction queries take $O(1)$ time. Finally, for common-marginal realizable binary constraint languages, the support threshold ${\rm CF} < 1$ is polynomial-time equivalent to the associated finite-domain constraint-satisfaction problem and therefore inherits the Bulatov--Zhuk dichotomy. The results identify a query-optimal and dynamically maintainable tractability island inside the general contextual-fraction problem.

Let $\mathcal F$ be a graph class that is closed under topological minors and 1-sums, has decidable membership, contains a triangle, and is not the class of all graphs. Recently, Lee, Liu, and Tsai [ICALP 2026] showed that the edge-decomposition problem into $k \geq 3$ elements of $\mathcal F$ is NP-hard. In particular, their general hardness reduction covers a long-standing problem on outerthickness (when $\mathcal F$ is the class of outerplanar graphs). On the other hand, it is well known that decomposing a graph into forests is polynomial-time solvable, as implied by work of Edmonds [J. Res. Natl. Bur. Stand. B. 1965]. In this paper, we take a first step toward determining the complexity of edge-decomposition problems into just two graphs (the case $k=2$). We consider the simplest possible graph class $\mathcal F$ satisfying the criteria above: the triangular forests, that is, graphs in which every 2-connected component is a triangle. We prove that determining whether a graph can be edge-decomposed into two triangular forests is NP-complete.

We study tropical circuits with scalar multiplication gates, that is, algebraic circuits whose gates implement $\max$, $+$, or multiplication with a positive constant. For such circuits, we prove exponential size lower bounds for computing maximum weight directed spanning trees and maximum weight bipartite perfect matchings. As a corollary, we obtain an exponential size separation between monotone and non-monotone maxout neural networks, which generalize the popularly used ReLU neural networks. One conclusion from this is that neural network models with enforced convexity constraints, such as input-convex neural networks (ICNNs), sometimes need to be exponentially larger than their unrestricted counterparts in order to express the same functions.

A $4$-uniform $2$-cycle in a $4$-uniform hypergraph of length $t$ is a cyclic ordering of $2t$ vertices $v_1v_2\cdots v_{2t}v_1$ such that $v_{2i+1}v_{2i+2}v_{2i+3}v_{2i+4}$ are edges for $0\le i\le t-1$ while the addition is modulo $2t$. For every $γ>0$ and large $n$, we characterize the $n$-vertex $4$-uniform hypergraphs such that every triple of vertices is contained in at least $(1/3+γ)n$ edges and admits a Hamilton $2$-cycle. Up to the error term $γn$, the assumption on the minimum codegree is best possible and verifies a conjecture of Garbe and Mycroft. As a consequence, this gives a polynomial-time algorithm that decides whether an $n$-vertex $4$-uniform hypergraph with minimum codegree $(1/3+γ)n$ contains a Hamilton $2$-cycle. This stands as a steep contrast to the graph case where such a hardness gap has size $o(n)$.

We study the computational complexity of problems that ask if a given graph admits an edge-coloring that does not contain an edge-colored clique from some fixed finite family. We show that every such problem is poly-time equivalent to a Constraint Satisfaction Problem, yielding a P vs. NP-complete dichotomy. Our main contribution lies in the reduction from the CSP to the coloring problem where we apply methods from Ramsey theory and a novel notion of cut-homotopy.

Given a nonnegative matrix $X$, a factorization rank $r$ and a real parameter $p$, entrywise power matrix factorization (EPMF) looks for a low-rank matrix $X_r$ such that $X = |X_r|^{\circ p}$ (exact case) or $X \approx |X_r|^{\circ p}$ (approximate case), where $(\cdot)^{\circ p}$ denotes the component-wise exponent. EPMF includes the modulus model ($p=1$) and component-wise square factorization ($p=2$) as special cases, the latter being closely related to the square root rank. We analyze the computational complexity of the exact decision problem and the Frobenius-norm approximation problem, and establish a complete complexity landscape. In the exact case, we show that EPMF is equivalent to the combinatorial problem of flipping the signs of the entries of a given matrix $X$ to obtain a rank-$r$ matrix, which we refer to as the signing problem. We first show that the signing problem, and hence exact EPMF, is strongly NP-hard, improving a weak NP-hardness result for the square-root-rank of Fawzi et al. (Math. Prog., 2015). We then show that the signing problem can be solved in polynomial-time when $r$ is fixed. Moreover, when the rank $r$ is part of the input, we show that for generic matrices the algorithm is fixed-parameter tractable (FPT) in the parameter $r$; in fact, the running time is linear in the input size $X$. In the approximate case using the Frobenius norm as an error measure, we show that EPMF is NP-hard, already when $r=2$, the smallest nontrivial case.

The Chromatic Sum problem asks, given a graph $G$ and an integer $k$, whether $G$ admits a colouring $c$ with sum $\sum_{v\in V}c(v) \leq k$. We study the complexity of Chromatic Sum on graph classes defined by some set of forbidden graphs. First, we show that three known frameworks fully classify the complexity of Chromatic Sum on $HH$-minor-free graphs and $HH$-topological-minor-free graphs for any set of graphs $HH$, and on $HH$-subgraph-free graphs for any finite set of graphs $HH$. To show this, we prove a new NP-completeness result for Chromatic Sum on certain subdivisions of planar subcubic graphs. Next, we consider other containment relations. We formalise a novel framework of problems that are NP-complete for planar graphs as well as for graphs of bounded independence number. For every problem in this framework, we obtain an almost complete complexity classification on $H$-induced-minor-free graphs, $H$-induced-topological-minor-free graphs, and $H$-free graphs for every graph $H$. We show that Chromatic Sum belongs to this framework, as do several other problems. We also define a more fine-grained framework for the induced subgraph relation. We apply this to obtain a complete complexity classification for Chromatic Sum on $H$-free graphs, as well as for several other problems. We justify the choice of this framework by proving that Chromatic Sum is NP-complete for graphs of clique-width at most $3$. This result complements a known polynomial-time result for graphs of clique-width at most $2$.

We study the computational complexity of several counting problems on graphs. Each of these problems consists of counting orderings of the vertices or edges with adjacency constraints. We show $\#P$-completeness for all of them via a common new technique. Given a counting function $C$ of interest, we define a parameterized family of instances $G_q$, where the parameter $q$ controls the amplification of a simple gadget. After multiplying by an explicit factor $f(q)$, we show that the values of $f(q) \cdot C(G_q)$, for positive integers $q$, agree with a rational function in $q$ whose numerator and denominator can be interpolated in polynomial time. We then recover a $\#P$-hard function by evaluating this rational function symbolically at a limiting value $L \in \mathbb{Q} \cup \{\infty, -\infty\}$. With this methodology, we show $\#P$-completeness for the following counting problems: (a) successive vertex orderings of bipartite graphs, (b) st-numberings of graphs, (c) shellings of bipartite graphs, (d) linear extensions of N-free posets of height $3$, and (e) linear extensions of posets of height $2$. Result (d) settles a conjecture of Felsner and Manneville (2015). Although result (e) was first proved by Dittmer and Pak (2018), we include an alternative proof, using our technique, that does not rely on the result of Brightwell and Winkler (1991) about the hardness of counting linear extensions for general posets.

The KKL Theorem, a seminal result in boolean function analysis, characterizes the structure of low-influence (non-expanding) functions on the hypercube. While recent years have seen breakthrough results across a variety of areas relying on analogs of the KKL Theorem beyond the cube (e.g., on product spaces, Grassmann graphs), further progress has been inhibited by our poor understanding of the phenomenon across more general domains. Motivated in this context, Bafna, Hopkins, Kaufman, and Lovett (STOC 2022) and Gur, Lifshitz, and Liu (STOC 2022) proved a generalized KKL-type Theorem for spectral high dimensional expanders (HDX). Their results, however, remain highly restricted due to strong quantitative expansion requirements on the underlying complex. In this work, we introduce a simple local-to-global method for analyzing low influence functions on simplicial complexes. Using this method we prove a local-to-global KKL-type Theorem: any simplicial complex whose links satisfy a KKL-Theorem also satisfies such a result globally. Building on Gotlib and Kaufman (RANDOM 2023), we also prove a weaker dimension-dependent KKL-type Theorem for simplicial complexes with any non-trivial (two-sided) expansion. As concrete applications of our framework, we give the first characterization of non-expanding functions on `combinatorial' HDX such as dense clique complexes and a corresponding Kruskal-Katona Theorem, as well as a small-set expansion theorem for the Ramanujan Complexes of Lubotzky, Samuels, and Vishne (EJC '05).