arXiv++ Combinatorics

Löfberg and Qi introduced the second order Zarankiewicz number \(z_2\), the recursive-line Zarankiewicz number \(z_{RL}\), and the signed Zarankiewicz number \(z_{SL}\) for doubly simple biquadratic forms. It was shown that \[ z_2(m,n)\ge z_{SL}(m,n)\ge z_{RL}(m,n) \] for all \(m\) and \(n\). However, there was no evidence that there exist particular \(m\) and \(n\) such that \(z_{SL}(m,n)>z_{RL}(m,n)\). The motivation for introducing \(z_{SL}\) was as follows: during the study of the exceptional case \(m=15\), \(n=6\), Löfberg and Qi showed that \[ z_2(15,6)=z_{SL}(15,6)=60, \] but the exact value of \(z_{RL}(15,6)\) was unknown then. In this paper we show that \[ z_{RL}(15,6)=60. \] This eliminates the motivation for introducing \(z_{SL}\). Whether \(z_{SL}(m,n)=z_{RL}(m,n)\) in general remains an open problem. Recently, Lebedev presented an explicit construction separating the augmented Zarankiewicz number \(z_A\) from the limited augmented Zarankiewicz number \(z_L\) at \(m=n=1893\). We hope that the separation problem for \(z_{SL}\) and \(z_{RL}\) can also be solved. We also present the exact values of \(z_{RL}(m,6)\) for \(6\le m\le 16\).

The recursive-line Zarankiewicz number maximizes the number of squares in a structured irreducible sum-of-squares representation encoded by an augmentation of an extremal $C_4$-free bipartite graph. We determine its four-column behavior under the strengthened recursive definition in the manuscript of Löfberg and Qi dated 9 September 2026. Combining AI-assisted discovery with exact certificate verification and finite exclusion computations, we determine eighteen of the nineteen values for $2\le m\le20$ and isolate the only unresolved case to $37\le\zr(14,4)\le38$. More significantly, we prove the first eventual exact formula in the four-column setting: \[ \zr(m,4)=\floor{\frac{5m+6}{2}}\qquad(m\ge15). \] The upper bound follows from the classical identity $z(m,4)=m+6$ and a sharp cell count. For the matching lower bound, we construct a two-row extension chain from an explicit $20\times4$ seed and derive the odd orders by a fixed deletion. Analytic propagation, together with two independently audited symbolic certificate tables, proves the construction for arbitrary chain length rather than merely for a finite computational range. Thus every extremal configuration has no holes when $m$ is even and exactly one hole when $m$ is odd, and the same exact formula holds for the second-order number $z_2(m,4)$.