arXiv++ Combinatorics

For $n\ge6$, $m=\binom n2$, let the complete-graph incidence family on $K_n$ have the vertices of $K_n$ as columns, its edges as rows, and the incidence graph as one-edge graph. The universal cell bound of Löfberg and Qi gives $z_2(m,n)\le Z(n):=\lfloor n(n-1)(n+2)/4\rfloor$. We implement the nested one-factorization construction of that family and determine exactly what it certifies. For $n=2q$ with $q$ an odd prime, $q\ge5$, the construction has no hole and the cross-factor transfer equations apply verbatim, giving $z_2=z_{SL}=z_{RL}=Z(n)$; $n=6$ is settled by a separate cyclic witness. For odd $n=2p+1$ the near-perfect one-factorization yields Hamilton paths closed into odd cycles, and the transfer argument breaks: that scheme certifies only $R(G_p)\le Z(n)$. The orders $n=7,8,9,12,13,16,17,18,20,21$ are settled by explicit configurations of a different shape, each attaining the cell bound and satisfying $(\mathrm{RW}3^+)$, obtained from a larger configuration by deleting vertex stars and repairing the restricted grid. At each of these orders $z_2=z_{SL}=z_{RL}=Z(n)$; all remaining orders are conjectural. The first settled order $n=7$ is the only one whose grid has a hole, grounded by a zero-companion rule. Machine-readable configurations and a certificate checker accompany the paper.

We introduce the \emph{second order Zarankiewicz number} $z_2(m,n)$ for irreducible doubly simple biquadratic forms with $|E_1|=z(m,n)$, together with the intermediate recursive-line and signed parameters $z_{RL}(m,n)$ and $z_{SL}(m,n)$. They satisfy the unconditional hierarchy \[ \operatorname{BSR}(m,n) \ge z_2(m,n) \ge z_{SL}(m,n) \ge z_{RL}(m,n) \ge z_{wL}(m,n) \ge z(m,n), \] where $z_{RL}$ is defined by the strengthened recursive rectangle criterion $(RW3^+)$ together with the conditions $(S)$ and $C_4$-freeness of $G_1$, and $z_{SL}$ is defined by the signed criterion $(RW3^\pm)$. We show that $(RW3^+)$ is sound and strictly weaker than the literal weak cross-cell test $(W3)$ on the weak-admissible class, and that $(RW3^\pm)$ is likewise sound. At the smallest four-column cases we obtain \[ z_2(5,4)=z_{SL}(5,4)=z_{RL}(5,4)=13>12=z_{wL}(5,4), \] and \[ z_2(6,4)=z_{SL}(6,4)=z_{RL}(6,4)=16>14=z_{wL}(6,4). \] In three columns this yields \[ z_2(m,3)=z_{RL}(m,3)=2m \qquad \text{for all } m\ge 3, \] with strict separation from $z_{wL}(m,3)$ for every $m\ge10$, and exact gap $\lfloor(m-3)/3\rfloor$ for $m\ge16$. Further finite computations give $z_{RL}(5,5)=17$, $z_{RL}(7,4)=19$, and $z_{RL}(7,7)\ge32>28=z_{wL}(7,7)$. Along $N=2p$ with $p$ an odd prime, we obtain the cubic asymptotic separation \[ z_2\!\left(\binom{N}{2},N\right)-z_{wL}\!\left(\binom{N}{2},N\right)\ge \left(\frac{1}{16}-o(1)\right)N^3. \] For the exceptional incidence case $p=3$ we prove $z_{SL}(15,6)=z_2(15,6)=60$. Concurrent work of Chen and Chen, using the recursive-line definition introduced here, incorporates the finite recursive-line values of this manuscript and establishes further exact four-column values together with an eventual formula for all $m\ge15$. The conjectural equality $z_2=z_{RL}$ is supported by the exact two-column, three-column, four-column, and odd-prime incidence families.