arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study how the ranks of factors in a positive semidefinite slack factorization constrain its size. We bound the number of low-rank vertex factors in any fixed factorization, and use this to determine the asymptotic order of the minimum factorization size under any fixed bound on vertex-factor ranks: $Θ(n\log n)$ for permutahedra $Π_n$ and $Θ(\log N)$ for regular $N$-gons. In the rank-one case this gives the order of the minimum dimension of a space of real functions on the vertices in which every facet slack is a sum of squares, with no symmetry or degree restriction. For unrestricted lifts, the bound gives $\mathrm{xc}_{\mathrm{PSD}}(Π_n)\ge n+\log_3 n-O(1)$, and shows that a permutahedron factorization of linear size would need vertex factors of rank $Ω(\log n)$ at all but a vanishing fraction of vertices. We also prove that every polytope of real positive semidefinite rank at most four has at most twelve vertices, and construct explicit size-four lifts for every square-symmetric octagon, so eight is attained. The upper bound combines a count of the polygon corners reached by curves of rank-one factors with incidence constraints on factor ranks. Whether eight is the maximum remains open.

Lonely Runner Conjecture, proposed by Jörg M. Wills and so nomenclatured by Luis Goddyn, has been an object of interest since it was first conceived in 1967 : Given positive integers $k$ and $n_1,n_2,\ldots,n_k$ there exists a positive real number $t$ such that the distance of $t\cdot n_j$ to the nearest integer is at least $\frac{1}{k+1}$, $\forall~~1\leq j\leq k$. In a recent article Beck, Hosten and Schymura described the Lonely Runner polyhedron and provided a polyhedral approach to identifying families of lonely runner instances. We revisit the Lonely Runner polyhedron and highlight some new families of instances satisfying the conjecture. In addition, we relax the sufficiency of existence of an integer point in the Lonely Runner polyhedron to prove the conjecture. Specifically, we propose that it suffices to show the existence of a lattice point of certain superlattices of the integer lattice in the Lonely Runner polyhedron.