arXiv++ Combinatorics

A tournament is an oriented complete graph. The problem of ranking tournaments was firstly investigated by P. Erdős and J. W. Moon. By probabilistic methods, the existence of "unrankable" tournaments was proved. On the other hand, they also mentioned the problem of explicit constructions. However, there seems to be only a few of explicit constructions of such tournaments. In this note, we give a construction of many such tournaments by using skew Hadamard difference sets which have been investigated in combinatorial design theory.

Let $F_k$ be the set of graphs on $k$ vertices. For a graph $G$, a $k$-decomposition is a set of induced subgraphs of $G$, each isomorphic to an element of $F_k$, such that each pair of vertices of $G$ is in exactly one element of the set. A fundamental result of Wilson is that for all $n=|V(G)|$ sufficiently large, $G$ has a $k$-decomposition if and only if $G$ is $k$-divisible. Let ${\bf v} \in {\mathbb R}^{|F_k|}$ be indexed by $F_k$. For a $k$-decomposition $L$ of $G$, let $ν_{\bf v}(L) = \sum_{F \in F_k} {\bf v}_F d_{L,F}$ where $d_{L,F}$ is the fraction of elements of $L$ isomorphic to $F$. Let $ν_{\bf v}(G) = \max_{L} ν_{\bf v}(L)$ and $ν_{\bf v}(n)=\min\{ν_{\bf v}(G):|V(G)|=n\}$. It is not difficult to prove that the sequence $ν_{\bf v}(n)$ has a limit so let $ν_{\bf v} = \lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} ν_{\bf v}(n)$. Replacing $k$-decompositions with their fractional relaxations, one obtains the (polynomial time computable) fractional analogue $ν_{\bf v}^*(G)$ and corresponding fractional values $ν^*_{\bf v}(n)$ and $ν^*_{\bf v}$. Our first main result is that for each ${\bf v} \in {\mathbb R}^{|F_k|}$ $$ ν_{\bf v} = ν^*_{\bf v}\;. $$ Further, there is a polynomial time algorithm that produces a decomposition $L$ of a $k$-decomposable graph such that $ν_{\bf v}(L) \ge ν_{\bf v} - o_n(1)$. A similar result holds when $F_k$ is the family of all tournaments on $k$ vertices and when $F_k$ is the family of all edge-colorings of $K_k$. We use these results to obtain new and improved bounds on several decomposition results. For example, we prove that every $n$-vertex tournament which is $3$-divisible has a triangle decomposition in which the number of directed triangles is less than $0.0222n^2(1+o(1))$ and that every $5$-decomposable $n$-vertex graph has a $5$-decomposition in which the fraction of cycles of length $5$ is $o_n(1)$.

Linial and Morgenstern conjectured that, among all $n$-vertex tournaments with $d\binom{n}{3}$ cycles of length three, the number of cycles of length four is asymptotically minimized by a random blow-up of a transitive tournament with all but one part of equal size and one smaller part. We prove the conjecture for $d\ge 1/36$ by analyzing the possible spectrum of adjacency matrices of tournaments. We also demonstrate that the family of extremal examples is broader than expected and give its full description for $d\ge 1/16$.

We give a new theorem describing a relation between the quasi-random property of regular tournaments and their spectra. This provides many solutions to a constructing problem mentioned by Erdős and Moon (1965) and Spencer (1985).

Single-elimination tournaments are the standard paradigm both for the main tennis professional associations. Schedules are generated by allocating first seeded and then unseeded players with seeds prevented from encountering each other early in the competition. Besides, the distribution of pairings in the first round between unseeded players and seeds for a yearly season may be strongly unbalanced. This provides often a great disadvantage to some "unlucky" unseeded players in terms of money prizes. Also, a fair distribution of matches during a season would benefit from limiting in first rounds the presence of Head-to-Head (H2H) matches between players that met in the recent past. We propose a tournament generation approach in order to reduce in the first round "unlucky" pairings and replay of H2H matches. The approach consists in a clustering optimization problem inducing a consequent draw within each cluster. A Non-Linear Mathematical Programming (NLMP) model is proposed for the clustering problem so as to reach a fair schedule. The solution reached by a commercial NLMP solver on the model is compared to the one reached by a faster hybrid algorithm based on multi-start local search. The approach is successfully tested on historical records from the recent Grand Slams tournaments.

A directed graph $G$ is $\textit{intrinsically linked}$ if every embedding of that graph contains a non-split link $L$, where each component of $L$ is a consistently oriented cycle in $G$. A $\textit{tournament}$ is a directed graph where each pair of vertices is connected by exactly one directed edge. We consider intrinsic linking and knotting in tournaments, and study the minimum number of vertices required for a tournament to have various intrinsic linking or knotting properties. We produce the following bounds: intrinsically linked ($n=8$), intrinsically knotted ($9 \leq n \leq 12$), intrinsically 3-linked ($10 \leq n \leq 23$), intrinsically 4-linked ($12 \leq n \leq 66$), intrinsically 5-linked ($15 \leq n \leq 154$), intrinsically $m$-linked ($3m \leq n \leq 8(2m-3)^2$), intrinsically linked with knotted components ($9 \leq n \leq 107$), and the disjoint linking property ($12 \leq n \leq 14$). We also introduce the $\textit{consistency gap}$, which measures the difference in the order of a graph required for intrinsic $n$-linking in tournaments versus undirected graphs. We conjecture the consistency gap to be non-decreasing in $n$, and provide an upper bound at each $n$.

The Rényi $α$-entropy $H_α$ of complete antisymmetric directed graphs (i.e., tournaments) is explored. We optimize $H_α$ when $α= 2$ and $3$, and find that as $α$ increases $H_α$'s sensitivity to what we refer to as `regularity' increases as well. A regular tournament on $n$ vertices is one with each vertex having out-degree $\frac{n-1}{2}$, but there is a lot of diversity in terms of structure among the regular tournaments; for example, a regular tournament may be such that each vertex's out-set induces a regular tournament (a doubly-regular tournament) or a transitive tournament (a rotational tournament). As $α$ increases, on the set of regular tournaments, $H_α$ has maximum value on doubly regular tournaments and minimum value on rotational tournaments. The more `regular', the higher the entropy. We show, however, that $H_2$ and $H_3$ are maximized, among all tournaments on any number of vertices by any regular tournament. We also provide a calculation that is equivalent to the von Neumann entropy, but may be applied to any directed or undirected graph and shows that the von Neumann entropy is a measure of how quickly a random walk on the graph or directed graph settles.

Decomposing a digraph into subdigraphs with a fixed structure or property is a classical problem in graph theory and a useful tool in a number of applications of networks and communication. A digraph is strongly connected if it contains a directed path from each vertex to all others. In this paper we consider multipartite tournaments, and we study the existence of a partition of a multipartite tournament with $c$ partite sets into strongly connected $c$-tournaments. This is a continuation of the study started in 1999 by Volkmann of the existence of strongly connected subtournaments in multipartite tournaments.

A digraph is {\it $n$-unavoidable} if it is contained in every tournament of order $n$. We first prove that every arborescence of order $n$ with $k$ leaves is $(n+k-1)$-unavoidable. We then prove that every oriented tree of order $n$ ($n\geq 2$) with $k$ leaves is $(\frac{3}{2}n+\frac{3}{2}k -2)$-unavoidable and $(\frac{9}{2}n -\frac{5}{2}k -\frac{9}{2})$-unavoidable, and thus $(\frac{21}{8} n- \frac{47}{16})$-unavoidable. Finally, we prove that every oriented tree of order $n$ with $k$ leaves is $(n+ 144k^2 - 280k + 124)$-unavoidable.

Competition graphs were created in connected to a biological model as a means of reflecting the competition relations among the predators in the food webs and determining the smallest dimension of ecological phase space. In 2011, Factor and Merz introduced the (1,2)-step competition graph of a digraph. Given a digraph $D=(V,A)$, the (1,2)-step competition graph of $D$, denoted $C_{1,2}(D)$, is a graph on $V(D)$ where $xy\in E(C_{1,2}(D))$ if and only if there exists a vertex $z\neq x,y$ such that either $d_{D-y}(x,z)=1$ and $d_{D-x}(y,z)\leq 2$ or $d_{D-x}(y,z)=1$ and $d_{D-y}(x,z)\leq 2$. They also characterized the (1,2)-step competition graphs of tournaments and extended some results to the $(i,j)$-step competition graphs of tournaments. In this paper, the definition of the (1,2)-step competition graph of a digraph is generalized to the one of a hypertournament and the $(1,2)$-step competition graph of a $k$-hypertournament is characterized. Also, the results are extended to the $(i,j)$-step competition graph of a $k$-hypertournament.

Sullivan stated the conjectures: (1) every oriented graph $D$ has a vertex $x$ such that $d^{++}(x)\geq d^{-}(x)$; (2) every oriented graph $D$ has a vertex $x$ such that $d^{++}(x)+d^{+}(x)\geq 2d^{-}(x)$. In this paper, we prove that these conjectures hold for local tournaments. In particular, for a local tournament $D$, we prove that $D$ has at least two vertices satisfying $(1)$ if $D$ has no vertex of in-degree zero. And, for a local tournament $D$, we prove that either there exist two vertices satisfying $(2)$ or there exists a vertex $v$ satisfying $d^{++}(v)+d^{+}(v)\geq 2d^{-}(v)+2$ if $D$ has no vertex of in-degree zero.

On being told that a piece of work he thought was his discovery had duplicated an earlier mathematician's work, Larry Shepp once replied "Yes, but when {\em I} discovered it, it {\em stayed} discovered". In this spirit we give discussion and probabilistic proofs of two related known results (Moon 1963, Joe 1988) on random tournaments which seem surprisingly unknown to modern probabilists. In particular our proof of Moon's theorem on mean score sequences seems more constructive than previous proofs. This provides a comparatively concrete introduction to a longstanding mystery, the lack of a canonical construction for a joint distribution in the representation theorem for convex order.

For an oriented graph $G$, let $f(G)$ denote the maximum chromatic number of an acyclic subgraph of $G$. Let $f(n)$ be the smallest integer such that every oriented graph $G$ with chromatic number larger than $f(n)$ has $f(G) > n$. Let $g(n)$ be the smallest integer such that every tournament $G$ with more than $g(n)$ vertices has $f(G) > n$. It is straightforward that $Ω(n) \le g(n) \le f(n) \le n^2$. This paper provides the first nontrivial lower and upper bounds for $g(n)$. In particular, it is proved that $\frac{1}{4}n^{8/7} \le g(n) \le n^2-(2-\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}})n+2$. It is also shown that $f(2)=3$, i.e. every orientation of a $4$-chromatic graph has a $3$-chromatic acyclic subgraph. Finally, it is shown that a random tournament $G$ with $n$ vertices has $f(G) = Θ(\frac{n}{\log n})$ whp.

We propose a new arrangement problem on directed graphs, Maximum Directed Linear Arrangement (MaxDLA). This is a directed variant of a similar problem for undirected graphs, in which however one seeks maximum and not minimum; this problem known as the Minimum Linear Arrangement Problem (MinLA) has been much studied in the literature. We establish a number of theorems illustrating the behavior and complexity of MaxDLA. First, we relate MaxDLA to Maximum Directed Cut (MaxDiCut) by proving that every simple digraph $D$ on $n$ vertices satisfies $\frac{n}{2}$$maxDiCut(D) \leq MaxDLA(D) \leq (n-1)MaxDiCut(D)$. Next, we prove that MaxDiCut is NP-Hard for planar digraphs (even with the added restriction of maximum degree 15); it follows from the above bounds that MaxDLA is also NP-Hard for planar digraphs. In contrast, Hadlock (1975) and Dorfman and Orlova (1972) showed that the undirected Maximum Cut problem is solvable in polynomial time on planar graphs. On the positive side, we present a polynomial-time algorithm for solving MaxDLA on orientations of trees with degree bounded by a constant, which translates to a polynomial-time algorithm for solving MinLA on the complements of those trees. This pairs with results by Goldberg and Klipker (1976), Shiloach (1979) and Chung (1984) solving MinLA in polynomial time on trees. Finally, analogues of Harper's famous isoperimetric inequality for the hypercube, in the setting of MaxDLA, are shown for tournaments, orientations of graphs with degree at most two, and transitive acyclic digraphs.

We consider real orthogonal $n\times n$ matrices whose diagonal entries are zero and off-diagonal entries nonzero, which we refer to as $\mathrm{OMZD}(n)$. We show that there exists an $\mathrm{OMZD}(n)$ if and only if $n\neq 1,\ 3$, and that a symmetric $\mathrm{OMZD}(n)$ exists if and only if $n$ is even and $n\neq 4$. We also give a construction of $\mathrm{OMZD}(n)$ obtained from doubly regular tournaments. Finally, we apply our results to determine the minimum number of distinct eigenvalues of matrices associated with some families of graphs, and consider the related notion of orthogonal matrices with partially-zero diagonal.

Let $D$ be an arc-colored digraph. The arc number $a(D)$ of $D$ is defined as the number of arcs of $D$. The color number $c(D)$ of $D$ is defined as the number of colors assigned to the arcs of $D$. A rainbow triangle in $D$ is a directed triangle in which every pair of arcs have distinct colors. Let $f(D)$ be the smallest integer such that if $c(D)\geq f(D)$, then $D$ contains a rainbow triangle. In this paper we obtain $f(\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n})$ and $f(T_n)$, where $\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n}$ is a complete digraph of order $n$ and $T_n$ is a strongly connected tournament of order $n$. Moreover we characterize the arc-colored complete digraph $\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n}$ with $c(\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n})=f(\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n})-1$ and containing no rainbow triangles. We also prove that an arc-colored digraph $D$ on $n$ vertices contains a rainbow triangle when $a(D)+c(D)\geq a(\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n})+f(\overleftrightarrow{K}_{n})$, which is a directed extension of the undirected case.

In this paper, we completely characterize the niche graphs of bipartite tournaments and find their interesting properties.

We prove that, with high probability, in every $2$-edge-colouring of the random tournament on $n$ vertices there is a monochromatic copy of every oriented tree of order $O (n / \sqrt{\log n})$. This generalises a result of the first, third and forth authors who proved the same statement for paths, and is tight up to a constant factor.

We study the problem of extending partial isomorphisms for hypertournaments, which are relational structures generalizing tournaments. This is a generalized version of an old question of Herwig and Lascar. We show that the generalized problem has a negative answer, and we provide a positive answer in a special case. As a corollary, we show that the extension property holds for tournaments in case the partial isomorphisms have pairwise disjoint ranges and pairwise disjoint domains.

A vertex in a directed graph is said to have a large second neighborhood if it has at least as many second out-neighbors as out-neighbors. The Second Neighborhood Conjecture, first stated by Seymour, asserts that there is a vertex having a large second neighborhood in every oriented graph (a directed graph without loops or digons). We prove that oriented graphs whose missing edges can be partitioned into a (possibly empty) matching and a (possibly empty) star satisfy this conjecture. This generalizes a result of Fidler and Yuster. An implication of our result is that every oriented graph without a sink and whose missing edges form a (possibly empty) matching has at least two vertices with large second neighborhoods. This is a strengthening of a theorem of Havet and Thomasse, who showed that the same holds for tournaments without a sink. Moreover, we also show that the conjecture is true for oriented graphs whose vertex set can be partitioned into an independent set and a 2-degenerate graph.