arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study a notion of VC-dimension for subsets of groups, defining this for a set $A$ to be the VC-dimension of the family $\{ (xA) \cap A : x \in A\cdot A^{-1} \}$. We show that if a finite subset $A$ of an abelian group has bounded VC-dimension, then the convolution $1_A*1_{-A}$ is Bohr uniformly continuous, in a quantitatively strong sense. This generalises and strengthens a version of the stable arithmetic regularity lemma of Terry and Wolf in various ways. In particular, it directly implies that the Polynomial Bogolyubov--Ruzsa Conjecture -- a strong version of the Polynomial Freiman--Ruzsa Conjecture -- holds for sets with bounded VC-dimension. We also prove some results in the non-abelian setting. In some sense, this gives a structure theorem for translation-closed set systems with bounded (classical) VC-dimension: if a VC-bounded family of subsets of an abelian group is closed under translation, then each member has a simple description in terms of Bohr sets, up to a small error.

In this paper, we introduce a notion of quantum discrepancy, a non-commutative version of combinatorial discrepancy which is defined for projection systems, i.e. finite sets of orthogonal projections, as non-commutative counterparts of set systems. We show that besides its natural algebraic formulation, quantum discrepancy, when restricted to set systems, has a probabilistic interpretation in terms of determinantal processes. Determinantal processes are a family of point processes with a rich algebraic structure. A common feature of this family is the local repulsive behavior of points. Alishahi and Zamani (2015) exploit this repelling property to construct low-discrepancy point configurations on the sphere. We give an upper bound for quantum discrepancy in terms of $N$, the dimension of the space, and $M$, the size of the projection system, which is tight in a wide range of parameters $N$ and $M$. Then we investigate the relation of these two kinds of discrepancies, i.e. combinatorial and quantum, when restricted to set systems, and bound them in terms of each other.

Kneser's 1955 conjecture -- proven by Lovász in 1978 -- asserts that in any partition of the $k$-subsets of $\{1, 2, \dots, n\}$ into $n-2k-3$ parts, one part contains two disjoint sets. Schrijver showed that one can restrict to significantly fewer $k$-sets and still observe the same intersection pattern. Alon, Frankl, and Lovász proved a different generalization of Kneser's conjecture for $r$ pairwise disjoint sets. Dolnikov generalized Lovász' result to arbitrary set systems, while Kříž did the same for the $r$-fold extension of Kneser's conjecture. Here we prove a common generalization of all of these results. Moreover, we prove additional strengthenings by determining the chromatic number of certain sparse stable Kneser hypergraphs, and further develop a general approach to establishing lower bounds for chromatic numbers of hypergraphs using a combination of methods from equivariant topology and intersection results for convex hulls of points in Euclidean space.

The Vapnik-Chervonenkis dimension (in short, VC-dimension) of a graph is defined as the VC-dimension of the set system induced by the neighborhoods of its vertices. We show that every $n$-vertex graph with bounded VC-dimension contains a clique or an independent set of size at least $e^{(\log n)^{1 - o(1)}}$. The dependence on the VC-dimension is hidden in the $o(1)$ term. This improves the general lower bound, $e^{c\sqrt{\log n}}$, due to Erdos and Hajnal, which is valid in the class of graphs satisfying any fixed nontrivial hereditary property. Our result is almost optimal and nearly matches the celebrated Erdos-Hajnal conjecture, according to which one can always find a clique or an independent set of size at least $e^{Ω(\log n)}$. Our results partially explain why most geometric intersection graphs arising in discrete and computational geometry have exceptionally favorable Ramsey-type properties. Our main tool is a partitioning result found by Lovász-Szegedy and Alon-Fischer-Newman, which is called the "ultra-strong regularity lemma" for graphs with bounded VC-dimension. We extend this lemma to $k$-uniform hypergraphs, and prove that the number of parts in the partition can be taken to be $(1/\varepsilon)^{O(d)}$, improving the original bound of $(1/\varepsilon)^{O(d^2)}$ in the graph setting. We show that this bound is tight up to an absolute constant factor in the exponent. Moreover, we give an $O(n^k)$-time algorithm for finding a partition meeting the requirements. Finally, we establish tight bounds on Ramsey-Turán numbers for graphs with bounded VC-dimension.

We say that a set system $\mathcal{F}\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ shatters a given set $S\subseteq [n]$ if $2^S= \{F~\cap~S:~F~\in~\mathcal{F}\}$. The Sauer-Shelah lemma states that in general, a set system $\mathcal{F}$ shatters at least $|\mathcal{F}|$ sets. Here we concentrate on the case of equality. A set system is called \emph{shattering-extremal} if it shatters exactly $|\mathcal{F}|$ sets. A conjecture of Rónyai and the second author and of Litman and Moran states that if a family is shattering-extremal then one can add a set to it and the resulting family is still shattering-extremal. Here we prove this conjecture for a class of set systems defined from Sperner families.

A pair $(\mathcal{A},\mathcal{B})$ of families of subsets of an $n$-element set is called cancellative if whenever $A,A'\in\mathcal{A}$ and $B\in\mathcal{B}$ satisfy $A\cup B=A'\cup B$, then $A=A'$, and whenever $A\in\mathcal{A}$ and $B,B'\in\mathcal{B}$ satisfy $A\cup B=A\cup B'$, then $B=B'$. It is known that there exist cancellative pairs with $|\mathcal{A}||\mathcal{B}|$ about $2.25^n$, whereas the best known upper bound on this quantity is $2.3264^n$. In this paper we improve this upper bound to $2.2682^n$. Our result also improves the best known upper bound for Simonyi's sandglass conjecture for set systems.

A fundamental theorem of matroid theory establishes that a transversal matroid is representable over fields of any characteristic. It was proved in 1970 by Piff and Welsh: their proof is elegant and concise and, moveover, constructive. However it is far from being algorithmic, in terms of suggesting a step-by-step procedure for deriving a collection of vectors over a given base field representing the transversal matroid induced by a given set system. In this note we recast Piff and Welsh's proof in algorithmic form.

Submodular function minimization (SFM) is a fundamental and efficiently solvable problem class in combinatorial optimization with a multitude of applications in various fields. Surprisingly, there is only very little known about constraint types under which SFM remains efficiently solvable. The arguably most relevant non-trivial constraint class for which polynomial SFM algorithms are known are parity constraints, i.e., optimizing only over sets of odd (or even) cardinality. Parity constraints capture classical combinatorial optimization problems like the odd-cut problem, and they are a key tool in a recent technique to efficiently solve integer programs with a constraint matrix whose subdeterminants are bounded by two in absolute value. We show that efficient SFM is possible even for a significantly larger class than parity constraints, by introducing a new approach that combines techniques from Combinatorial Optimization, Combinatorics, and Number Theory. In particular, we can show that efficient SFM is possible over all sets (of any given lattice) of cardinality r mod m, as long as m is a constant prime power. This covers generalizations of the odd-cut problem with open complexity status, and with relevance in the context of integer programming with higher subdeterminants. To obtain our results, we establish a connection between the correctness of a natural algorithm, and the inexistence of set systems with specific combinatorial properties. We introduce a general technique to disprove the existence of such set systems, which allows for obtaining extensions of our results beyond the above-mentioned setting. These extensions settle two open questions raised by Geelen and Kapadia [Combinatorica, 2017] in the context of computing the girth and cogirth of certain types of binary matroids.

In this paper, we provide a common generalization to the well-known Erdős-Ko-Rado Theorem, Frankl-Wilson Theorem, Alon-Babai-Suzuki Theorem, and Snevily Theorem on set systems with $\mathcal{L}$-intersections. As a consequence, we derive a result which strengthens substantially the well-known theorem on set systems with $k$-wise $\mathcal{L}$-intersections by F$\ddot{u}$redi and Sudakov [J. Combin. Theory, Ser. A (2004) 105: 143-159]. We will also derive similar results on $\mathcal{L}$-intersecting families of subspaces of an $n$-dimensional vector space over a finite field $\mathbb{F}_{q}$, where $q$ is a prime power.

The problem of bounding the size of a set system under various intersection restrictions has a central place in extremal combinatorics. We investigate the maximum number of disjoint pairs a set system can have in this setting. In particular, we show that for any pair of set systems $(\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{B})$ which avoid a cross-intersection of size $t$, the number of disjoint pairs $(A, B)$ with $A \in \mathcal{A}$ and $B \in \mathcal{B}$ is at most $\sum_{k=0}^{t-1}\binom{n}{k}2^{n-k}$. This implies an asymptotically best possible upper bound on the number of disjoint pairs in a single $t$-avoiding family $\mathcal{F} \subset \mathcal{P}[n]$. We also study this problem when $\mathcal{A}$, $\mathcal{B} \subset [n]^{(r)}$ are both $r$-uniform, and show that it is closely related to the problem of determining the maximum of the product $|\mathcal{A}||\mathcal{B}|$ when $\mathcal{A}$ and $\mathcal{B}$ avoid a cross-intersection of size $t$, and $n \ge n_0(r, t)$.

We prove that for every class of graphs $\mathcal{C}$ which is nowhere dense, as defined by Nesetril and Ossona de Mendez, and for every first order formula $φ(\bar x,\bar y)$, whenever one draws a graph $G\in \mathcal{C}$ and a subset of its nodes $A$, the number of subsets of $A^{|\bar y|}$ which are of the form $\{\bar v\in A^{|\bar y|}\, \colon\, G\modelsφ(\bar u,\bar v)\}$ for some valuation $\bar u$ of $\bar x$ in $G$ is bounded by $\mathcal{O}(|A|^{|\bar x|+ε})$, for every $ε>0$. This provides optimal bounds on the VC-density of first-order definable set systems in nowhere dense graph classes. We also give two new proofs of upper bounds on quantities in nowhere dense classes which are relevant for their logical treatment. Firstly, we provide a new proof of the fact that nowhere dense classes are uniformly quasi-wide, implying explicit, polynomial upper bounds on the functions relating the two notions. Secondly, we give a new combinatorial proof of the result of Adler and Adler stating that every nowhere dense class of graphs is stable. In contrast to the previous proofs of the above results, our proofs are completely finitistic and constructive, and yield explicit and computable upper bounds on quantities related to uniform quasi-wideness (margins) and stability (ladder indices).

We explore a general method based on trees of elementary submodels in order to present highly simplified proofs to numerous results in infinite combinatorics. While countable elementary submodels have been employed in such settings already, we significantly broaden this framework by developing the corresponding technique for countably closed models of size continuum. The applications range from various theorems on paradoxical decompositions of the plane, to coloring sparse set systems, results on graph chromatic number and constructions from point-set topology. Our main purpose is to demonstrate the ease and wide applicability of this method in a form accessible to anyone with a basic background in set theory and logic.

Given a graph $G$ whose edges are perfectly reliable and whose nodes each operate independently with probability $p\in[0,1],$ the node reliability of $G$ is the probability that at least one node is operational and that the operational nodes can all communicate in the subgraph that they induce. We study analytic properties of the node reliability on the interval $[0,1]$ including monotonicity, concavity, and fixed points. Our results show a stark contrast between this model of network robustness and models that arise from coherent set systems (including all-terminal, two-terminal and K-terminal reliability).

We consider union-closed set systems with infinite breadth, focusing on three particular configurations ${\mathcal T}_{\rm max}(E)$, ${\mathcal T}_{\rm min}(E)$ and ${\mathcal T}_{\rm ort}(E)$. We show that these three configurations are not isolated examples; in any given union-closed set system of infinite breadth, at least one of these three configurations will occur as a subprojection. This characterizes those union-closed set systems which have infinite breadth, and is the first general structural result for such set systems.

We study how a single value of the shatter function of a set system restricts its asymptotic growth. Along the way, we refute a conjecture of Bondy and Hajnal which generalizes Sauer's Lemma.

Combinatorial discrepancy is a complexity measure of a collection of sets which quantifies how well the sets in the collection can be simultaneously balanced. More precisely, we are given an n-point set $P$, and a collection $\mathcal{F} = \{F_1, ..., F_m\}$ of subsets of $P$, and our goal is color $P$ with two colors, red and blue, so that the maximum over the $F_i$ of the absolute difference between the number of red elements and the number of blue elements (the discrepancy) is minimized. Combinatorial discrepancy has many applications in mathematics and computer science, including constructions of uniformly distributed point sets, and lower bounds for data structures and private data analysis algorithms. We investigate the combinatorial discrepancy of geometrically defined systems, in which $P$ is an n-point set in $d$-dimensional space ,and $\mathcal{F}$ is the collection of subsets of $P$ induced by dilations and translations of a fixed convex polytope $B$. Such set systems include systems of sets induced by axis-aligned boxes, whose discrepancy is the subject of the well known Tusnady problem. We prove new discrepancy upper and lower bounds for such set systems by extending the approach based on factorization norms previously used by the author and Matousek. We improve the best known upper bound for the Tusnady problem by a logarithmic factor, using a result of Banaszczyk on signed series of vectors. We extend this improvement to any arbitrary convex polytope $B$ by using a decomposition due to Matousek. Using Fourier analytic techniques, we also prove a nearly matching discrepancy lower bound for sets induced by any fixed bounded polytope $B$ satisfying a certain technical condition. We also outline applications of our results to geometric discrepancy, data structure lower bounds, and differential privacy.

A subfamily $\{F_1,F_2,\dots,F_{|P|}\}\subseteq {\cal F}$ of sets is a copy of a poset $P$ in ${\cal F}$ if there exists a bijection $φ:P\rightarrow \{F_1,F_2,\dots,F_{|P|}\}$ such that whenever $x \le_P x'$ holds, then so does $φ(x)\subseteq φ(x')$. For a family ${\cal F}$ of sets, let $c(P,{\cal F})$ denote the number of copies of $P$ in ${\cal F}$, and we say that ${\cal F}$ is $P$-free if $c(P,{\cal F})=0$ holds. For any two posets $P,Q$ let us denote by $La(n,P,Q)$ the maximum number of copies of $Q$ over all $P$-free families ${\cal F} \subseteq 2^{[n]}$, i.e. $\max\{c(Q,{\cal F}): {\cal F} \subseteq 2^{[n]}, c(P,{\cal F})=0 \}$. This generalizes the well-studied parameter $La(n,P)=La(n,P,P_1)$ where $P_1$ is the one element poset. The quantity $La(n,P)$ has been determined (precisely or asymptotically) for many posets $P$, and in all known cases an asymptotically best construction can be obtained by taking as many middle levels as possible without creating a copy of $P$. In this paper we consider the first instances of the problem of determining $La(n,P,Q)$. We find its value when $P$ and $Q$ are small posets, like chains, forks, the $N$ poset and diamonds. Already these special cases show that the extremal families are completely different from those in the original $P$-free cases: sometimes not middle or consecutive levels maximize $La(n,P,Q)$ and sometimes no asymptotically extremal family is the union of levels. Finally, we determine the maximum number of copies of complete multi-level posets in $k$-Sperner families. The main tools for this are the profile polytope method and two extremal set system problems that are of independent interest: we maximize the number of $r$-tuples $A_1,A_2,\dots, A_r \in {\cal A}$ over all antichains ${\cal A}\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ such that (i) $\cap_{i=1}^rA_i=\emptyset$, (ii) $\cap_{i=1}^rA_i=\emptyset$ and $\cup_{i=1}^rA_i=[n]$.

Let $K=\{k_1,k_2,\ldots,k_r\}$ and $L=\{l_1,l_2,\ldots,l_s\}$ be disjoint subsets of $\{0,1,\ldots,p-1\}$, where $p$ is a prime and $A=\{A_1,A_2,\ldots,A_m\}$ be a family of subsets of $[n]$ such that $|A_i|\pmod{p}\in K$ for all $A_i\in A$ and $|A_i\cap A_j|\pmod{p}\in L$ for $i\ne j$. In 1991, Alon, Babai and Suzuki conjectured that if $n\geq s+\max_{1\leq i\leq r} k_i$, then $|A|\leq {n\choose s}+{n\choose s-1}+\cdots+{n\choose s-r+1}$. In 2000, Qian and Ray-Chaudhuri proved the conjecture under the condition $n\geq 2s-r$. In 2015, Hwang and Kim verified the conjecture of Alon, Babai and Suzuki. In this paper, we will prove that if $n\geq 2s-2r+1$ or $n\geq s+\max_{1\leq i\leq r}k_i$, then \[ |A|\leq{n-1\choose s}+{n-1\choose s-1}+\cdots+{n-1\choose s-2r+1}. \] This result strengthens the upper bound of Alon, Babai and Suzuki's conjecture when $n\geq 2s-2$.

A well-known theorem of Spencer shows that any set system with $n$ sets over $n$ elements admits a coloring of discrepancy $O(\sqrt{n})$. While the original proof was non-constructive, recent progress brought polynomial time algorithms by Bansal, Lovett and Meka, and Rothvoss. All those algorithms are randomized, even though Bansal's algorithm admitted a complicated derandomization. We propose an elegant deterministic polynomial time algorithm that is inspired by Lovett-Meka as well as the Multiplicative Weight Update method. The algorithm iteratively updates a fractional coloring while controlling the exponential weights that are assigned to the set constraints. A conjecture by Meka suggests that Spencer's bound can be generalized to symmetric matrices. We prove that $n \times n$ matrices that are block diagonal with block size $q$ admit a coloring of discrepancy $O(\sqrt{n} \cdot \sqrt{\log(q)})$. Bansal, Dadush and Garg recently gave a randomized algorithm to find a vector $x$ with entries in $\lbrace{-1,1\rbrace}$ with $\|Ax\|_{\infty} \leq O(\sqrt{\log n})$ in polynomial time, where $A$ is any matrix whose columns have length at most 1. We show that our method can be used to deterministically obtain such a vector.

A great variety of fundamental optimization and counting problems arising in computer science, mathematics and physics can be reduced to one of the following computational tasks involving polynomials and set systems: given an $m$-variate real polynomial $g$ and a family of subsets $B$ of $[m]$, (1) find $S\in B$ such that the monomial in $g$ corresponding to $S$ has the largest coefficient in $g$, or (2) compute the sum of coefficients of monomials in $g$ corresponding to all the sets in $B$. Special cases of these problems, such as computing permanents, sampling from DPPs and maximizing subdeterminants have been topics of recent interest in theoretical computer science. In this paper we present a general convex programming framework geared to solve both of these problems. We show that roughly, when $g$ is a real stable polynomial with non-negative coefficients and $B$ is a matroid, the integrality gap of our relaxation is finite and depends only on $m$ (and not on the coefficients of g). Prior to our work, such results were known only in sporadic cases that relied on the structure of $g$ and $B$; it was not even clear if one could formulate a convex relaxation that has a finite integrality gap beyond these special cases. Two notable examples are a result by Gurvits on the van der Waerden conjecture for real stable $g$ when $B$ is a single element and a result by Nikolov and Singh for multilinear real stable polynomials when $B$ is a partition matroid. Our work, which encapsulates most interesting cases of $g$ and $B$, benefits from both - we were inspired by the latter in deriving the right convex programming relaxation and the former in establishing the integrality gap. However, proving our results requires significant extensions of both; in that process we come up with new notions and connections between stable polynomials and matroids which should be of independent interest.