arXiv++ Combinatorics

One of the great pleasures of working with Imre Leader is to experience his infectious delight on encountering a compelling combinatorial problem. This collection of open problems in combinatorics has been put together by a subset of his former PhD students and students-of-students for the occasion of his 60th birthday. All of the contributors have been influenced (directly or indirectly) by Imre: his personality, enthusiasm and his approach to mathematics. The problems included cover many of the areas of combinatorial mathematics that Imre is most associated with: including extremal problems on graphs, set systems and permutations, and Ramsey theory. This is a personal selection of problems which we find intriguing and deserving of being better known. It is not intended to be systematic, or to consist of the most significant or difficult questions in any area. Rather, our main aim is to celebrate Imre and his mathematics and to hope that these problems will make him smile. We also hope this collection will be a useful resource for researchers in combinatorics and will stimulate some enjoyable collaborations and beautiful mathematics.

We study sunflowers within the context of finitely generated substructures of ultrahomogeneous structures. In particular, we look at bounds on how large a set system is needed to guarantee the existence of sunflowers of a given size. We show that if we fix the size of the sunflower, the function which takes the size of the substructures in our set system and outputs the size of a set system needed to guarantee a sunflower of the desired size can grow arbitrarily slowly.

Model theory, machine learning, and combinatorics each have generalizations of VC-dimension for fuzzy and real-valued versions of set systems. These different dimensions define a unique notion of a VC-class for both fuzzy sets and real-valued functions. We study these VC-classes, obtaining generalizations of certain combinatorial results from the discrete case. These include appropriate generalizations of $\varepsilon$-nets, the fractional Helly property and the $(p,q)$-theorem. We then apply these results to continuous logic. We prove that NIP for metric structures is equivalent to an appropriate generalization of honest definitions, which we use to study externally definable predicates and the Shelah expansion. We then examine distal metric structures, providing several equivalent characterizations, in terms of indiscernible sequences, distal types, strong honest definitions, and distal cell decompositions.

We investigate the connections between clusters and least common ancestors (LCAs) in directed acyclic graphs (DAGs). We focus on the class of DAGs having unique least common ancestors for certain subsets of their minimal elements since these are of interest, particularly as models of phylogenetic networks. Here, we use the close connection between the canonical k-ary transit function and the closure function on a set system to show that pre-k-ary clustering systems are exactly those that derive from a class of DAGs with unique LCAs. Moreover, we show that k-ary T-systems and k-weak hierarchies are associated with DAGs that satisfy stronger conditions on the existence of unique LCAs for sets of size at most k.

Let $h(n)$ be the minimum integer such that every complete $n$-vertex simple topological graph contains an edge that crosses at most $h(n)$ other edges. In 2009, Kynčl and Valtr showed that $h(n) = O(n^2/\log^{1/4} n)$, and in the other direction, gave constructions showing that $h(n) = Ω(n^{3/2})$. In this paper, we prove that $h(n) = O(n^{7/4})$. Along the way, we establish a new variant of Chazelle and Welzl's matching theorem for set systems with bounded VC-dimension, which we believe to be of independent interest.

Several algebraic properties of a binomial edge ideal $J_G$ can be interpreted in terms of combinatorial properties of its associated graph $G$. In particular, the so-called cut sets of a graph $G$, special sets of vertices that disconnect $G$ in a minimal way, play an important role since they are in bijection with the minimal prime ideals of $J_G$. In this paper we establish the first graph-theoretical characterization of binomial edge ideals $J_G$ satisfying Serre's condition $(S_2)$ by proving that this is equivalent to having $G$ accessible, which means that $J_G$ is unmixed and the cut sets of $G$ form an accessible set system. The proof relies on the combinatorial structure of the Stanley-Reisner simplicial complex of a multigraded generic initial ideal of $J_G$, whose facets can be described in terms of cut sets. Another key step in the proof consists in proving the equivalence between accessibility and strong accessibility for the collection of cut sets of $G$ with $J_G$ unmixed. This result, interesting on its own, provides the first relevant class of set systems for which the previous two notions are equivalent.

We revisit the Kahn-Kalai conjecture, recently proved in striking fashion by Park and Pham, and present a slightly reformulated simple proof which has a few advantages: (1) it works for non-uniform product measures, (2) it gives near-optimal bounds even for sampling probabilities close to 1, (3) it gives a clean bound of $p_c \leq 4q_c \log_2 (7\ell)$ for every $\ell$-bounded set system, $\ell\geq 1$.

We present representative sets-style statements for linear delta-matroids, which are set systems that generalize matroids, with important connections to matching theory and graph embeddings. Furthermore, our proof uses a new approach of sieving polynomial families, which generalizes the linear algebra approach of the representative sets lemma to a setting of bounded-degree polynomials. The representative sets statements for linear delta-matroids then follow by analyzing the Pfaffian of the skew-symmetric matrix representing the delta-matroid. Applying the same framework to the determinant instead of the Pfaffian recovers the representative sets lemma for linear matroids. Altogether, this significantly extends the toolbox available for kernelization. As an application, we show an exact sparsification result for Mader networks: Let $G=(V,E)$ be a graph and $\mathcal{T}$ a partition of a set of terminals $T \subseteq V(G)$, $|T|=k$. A $\mathcal{T}$-path in $G$ is a path with endpoints in distinct parts of $\mathcal{T}$ and internal vertices disjoint from $T$. In polynomial time, we can derive a graph $G'=(V',E')$ with $T \subseteq V(G')$, such that for every subset $S \subseteq T$ there is a packing of $\mathcal{T}$-paths with endpoints $S$ in $G$ if and only if there is one in $G'$, and $|V(G')|=O(k^3)$. This generalizes the (undirected version of the) cut-covering lemma, which corresponds to the case that $\mathcal{T}$ contains only two blocks. To prove the Mader network sparsification result, we furthermore define the class of Mader delta-matroids, and show that they have linear representations. This should be of independent interest.

Let $\mbox{$\cal F$}\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ be a fixed family of subsets. Let $D(\mbox{$\cal F$})$ stand for the following set of Hamming distances: $$ D(\mbox{$\cal F$}):=\{d_H(F,G):~ F, G\in \mbox{$\cal F$},\ F\neq G\}. $$ $\mbox{$\cal F$}$ is said to be a Hamming symmetric family, if $d\in D(\mbox{$\cal F$})$ implies $n-d\in D(\mbox{$\cal F$})$ for each $d\in D(\mbox{$\cal F$})$. We give sharp upper bounds for the size of Hamming symmetric families. Our proof is based on the linear algebra bound method.

A recent line of work on VC set systems in minor-free (undirected) graphs, starting from Li and Parter, who constructed a new VC set system for planar graphs, has given surprising algorithmic results. In this work, we initialize a more systematic study of VC set systems for minor-free graphs and their applications in both undirected graphs and directed graphs (a.k.a digraphs). More precisely: - We propose a new variant of Li-Parter set system for undirected graphs. - We extend our set system to $K_h$-minor-free digraphs and show that its VC dimension is $O(h^2)$. - We show that the system of directed balls in minor-free digraphs has VC dimension at most $h-1$. - On the negative side, we show that VC set system constructed from shortest path trees of planar digraphs does not have a bounded VC dimension. The highlight of our work is the results for digraphs, as we are not aware of known algorithmic work on constructing and exploiting VC set systems for digraphs.

There is interesting internal structure in the nullspaces of graph and hypergraph adjacency matrices, especially for trees, bipartite graphs, and related combinatorial classes. The zero loci of nullvectors, i.e., their zero coordinates' indices, encode information about matchings, coverings, and edges' influence on rank. This set system is the lattice of flats of a ``kernel matroid'', a subsystem of which are the ``stalled'' sets closed under skew zero forcing (SZF), a graph percolation/infection model known to have connections with rank and nullity. For a wide variety of graphs, the lattice of SZF-closed sets is also a matroid, a fact which can be used to obtain a polynomial-time algorithm for computing the skew zero forcing number. This contrasts with the general case, where we show that the corresponding decision problem is NP-hard. We also define skew zero forcing for hypergraphs, and show that, for linear hypertrees, the poset of SZF-closed sets is dual to the lattice of ideals of the hypergraph's nullvariety; while, for complete hypergraphs, the SZF-closed sets and the zero loci of nullvectors are more loosely related.

Consider a hypergraph (=set system) $\mathbb{H}$ whose $h$ hyperedges are subsets of a set with w elements. We show that the $R$ minimal hitting sets of $\mathbb{H}$ can be enumerated in polynomial total time $O(Rh^2 w^2)$.

The determinant lower bound of Lovasz, Spencer, and Vesztergombi [European Journal of Combinatorics, 1986] is a powerful general way to prove lower bounds on the hereditary discrepancy of a set system. In their paper, Lovasz, Spencer, and Vesztergombi asked if hereditary discrepancy can also be bounded from above by a function of the hereditary discrepancy. This was answered in the negative by Hoffman, and the largest known multiplicative gap between the two quantities for a set system of $m$ substes of a universe of size $n$ is on the order of $\max\{\log n, \sqrt{\log m}\}$. On the other hand, building on work of Matoušek [Proceedings of the AMS, 2013], recently Jiang and Reis [SOSA, 2022] showed that this gap is always bounded up to constants by $\sqrt{\log(m)\log(n)}$. This is tight when $m$ is polynomial in $n$, but leaves open what happens for large $m$. We show that the bound of Jiang and Reis is tight for nearly the entire range of $m$. Our proof relies on a technique of amplifying discrepancy via taking Kronecker products, and on discrepancy lower bounds for a set system derived from the discrete Haar basis.

In a recent breakthrough, Gilmer proved the union closed conjecture up to a constant factor. Using Gilmer's method and additional ideas, Chase and Lovett proved an optimal result for almost union-closed set systems. Here that result is extended to higher order unions.

A combinatorial property that characterizes Cohen-Macaulay binomial edge ideals has long been elusive. A recent conjecture ties the Cohen-Macaulayness of a binomial edge ideal $J_G$ to special disconnecting sets of vertices of its underlying graph $G$, called \textit{cut sets}. More precisely, the conjecture states that $J_G$ is Cohen-Macaulay if and only if $J_G$ is unmixed and the collection of the cut sets of $G$ is an accessible set system. In this paper we prove the conjecture theoretically for all graphs with up to $12$ vertices and develop an algorithm that allows to computationally check the conjecture for all graphs with up to $15$ vertices and all blocks with whiskers where the block has at most $11$ vertices. This significantly extends previous computational results.

Well-graded families, extremal systems and maximum systems (the last two in the sense of VC-theory and Sauer-Shelah lemma on VC-dimension) are three important classes of set systems. This paper aims to study the notion of duality in the context of these classes of set systems and then use the obtained results for studying graphs. More specifically, we are concerned with the characterization of the finite set systems which themselves and their dual systems are both well-graded, extremal or maximum. On the way to this goal, and maybe also of independent interest, we study the structure of the well-graded families with the property that the size of the system is not much bigger than the size of its essential domain, that is, the set of elements of the domain which are shattered by the system as single element subsets. As another target of the paper, we use the above results to characterize graphs whose set systems of open or closed neighbourhoods, cliques or independent sets are well-graded, extremal or maximum. We clarify the relation of such graphs to the celebrated half-graphs. Through the paper, we frequently relate our investigations to the VC-dimension of the systems. Also we use one-inclusion graphs associated to set systems as an important technical tool.

For integers $k\geq 1$ and $n\geq 2k+1$, the Kneser graph $K(n,k)$ has as vertices all $k$-element subsets of an $n$-element ground set, and an edge between any two disjoint sets. It has been conjectured since the 1970s that all Kneser graphs admit a Hamilton cycle, with one notable exception, namely the Petersen graph $K(5,2)$. This problem received considerable attention in the literature, including a recent solution for the sparsest case $n=2k+1$. The main contribution of this paper is to prove the conjecture in full generality. We also extend this Hamiltonicity result to all connected generalized Johnson graphs (except the Petersen graph). The generalized Johnson graph $J(n,k,s)$ has as vertices all $k$-element subsets of an $n$-element ground set, and an edge between any two sets whose intersection has size exactly $s$. Clearly, we have $K(n,k)=J(n,k,0)$, i.e., generalized Johnson graph include Kneser graphs as a special case. Our results imply that all known natural families of vertex-transitive graphs defined by intersecting set systems have a Hamilton cycle, which settles an interesting special case of Lovász' conjecture on Hamilton cycles in vertex-transitive graphs from 1970. Our main technical innovation is to study cycles in Kneser graphs by a kinetic system of multiple gliders that move at different speeds and that interact over time, reminiscent of the gliders in Conway's Game of Life, and to analyze this system combinatorially and via linear algebra.

A family $\mathcal{F}\subset 2^G$ of subsets of an abelian group $G$ is a Sidon system if the sumsets $A+B$ with $A,B\in \mathcal{F}$ are pairwise distinct. Cilleruelo, Serra and the author previously proved that the maximum size $F_k(n)$ of a Sidon system consisting of $k$-subsets of the first $n$ positive integers satisfies $C_k n^{k-1}\leq F_k(n) \leq \binom{n-1}{k-1}+n-k$ for some constant $C_k$ only depending on $k$. We close the gap by proving an essentially tight structural result that in particular implies $F_k(n)\geq (1-o(1))\binom{n}{k-1}$. We also use this to establish a result about the size of the largest Sidon system in the binomial random family $\binom{[n]}{k}_p$. Extensions to $h$-fold sumsets for any fixed $h\geq 3$ are also obtained.

A set system is called union closed if for any two sets in the set system their union is also in the set system. Gilmer recently proved that in any union closed set system some element belongs to at least a $0.01$ fraction of sets, and conjectured that his technique can be pushed to the constant $\frac{3-\sqrt{5}}{2}$. We verify his conjecture; show that it extends to approximate union closed set systems, where for nearly all pairs of sets their union belong to the set system; and show that for such set systems this bound is optimal.

Given a set system $(E, \mathcal{P})$ with $ρ\in [0, 1]^E$ and $π\in [0,1]^{ \mathcal{P}}$, our goal is to find a probability distribution for a random set $S \subseteq E$ such that $\operatorname{Pr}[e \in S] = ρ_e$ for all $e \in E$ and $\operatorname{Pr}[P \cap S \neq \emptyset] \geq π_P$ for all $P \in \mathcal{P}$. We extend the results of Dahan, Amin, and Jaillet (MOR 2022) who studied this problem motivated by a security game in a directed acyclic graph (DAG). We focus on the setting where $π$ is of the affine form $π_P = 1 - \sum_{e \in P} μ_e$ for $μ\in [0, 1]^E$. A necessary condition for the existence of the desired distribution is that $\sum_{e \in P} ρ_e \geq π_P$ for all $P \in \mathcal{P}$. We show that this condition is sufficient if and only if $\mathcal{P}$ has the weak max-flow/min-cut property. We further provide an efficient combinatorial algorithm for computing the corresponding distribution in the special case where $(E, \mathcal{P})$ is an abstract network. As a consequence, equilibria for the security game by Dahan et al. can be efficiently computed in a wide variety of settings (including arbitrary digraphs). As a subroutine of our algorithm, we provide a combinatorial algorithm for computing shortest paths in abstract networks, partially answering an open question by McCormick (SODA 1996). We further show that a conservation law proposed by Dahan et al. for the requirement vector $π$ in DAGs can be reduced to the setting of affine requirements described above.