arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given graphs $G$ and $H$, $G$ is $H$-saturated if $H$ is not a subgraph of $G$, but for all $e \notin E(G)$, $H$ appears as a subgraph of $G + e$. While for every $n \ge |V(H)|$, there exists an $n$-vertex graph that is $H$-saturated, the same does not hold for induced subgraphs. That is, there exist graphs $H$ and values of $n \ge |V(H)|$ for which every $n$-vertex graph $G$ either contains $H$ as an induced subgraph, or there exists $e \notin E(G)$ such that $G + e$ does not contain $H$ as an induced subgraph. To circumvent this, Martin and Smith make use of trigraphs when introducing the concept of induced saturation and the induced saturation number of graphs. This allows for edges that can be included or excluded when searching for an induced copy of H, and the induced saturation number is the minimum number of such edges that are required. In this paper, we show that the induced saturation number of many common graphs is zero. Consequently, this yields graphs, instead of trigraphs, that are H-induced-saturated. We introduce a new parameter for such graphs, indsat*(n;H), which is the minimum number of edges in an H-induced-saturated graph on n vertices. We provide bounds on indsat*(n;H) for many graphs. In particular, we determine indsat*(n;paw) completely, and indsat*(n;$K_{1,3}$) for infinitely many n.

A graph $H^{\prime}$ is $(H, G)$-saturated if it is $G$-free and the addition of any edge of $H$ not in $H^{\prime}$ creates a copy of $G$. The saturation number $sat(H, G)$ is the minimum number of edges in a $(H, G)$-saturated graph. We investigate bounds on the saturation number of trees $T$ in the $n$-dimensional hypercube $Q_n$. We first present a general lower bound on the saturation number based on the minimum degree of non-leaves. From there, we suggest two general methods for constructing $T$-saturated subgraphs of $Q_n$, and prove nontrivial upper bounds for specific types of trees, including paths, generalized stars, and certain caterpillars under a restriction on minimum degree with respect to diameter.

A game starts with the empty graph on $n$ vertices, and two player alternate adding edges to the graph. Only moves which do not create a triangle are valid. The game ends when a maximal triangle-free graph is reached. The goal of one player is to end the game as soon as possible, while the other player is trying to prolong the game. With optimal play, the length of the game (number of edges played) is called the $K_3$ game saturation number. In this paper we prove an upper bound for this number.

A degree monotone path in a graph $G$ is a path $P$ such that the sequence of degrees of the vertices in the order in which they appear on $P$ is monotonic. The length of the longest degree monotone path in $G$ is denoted by $mp(G)$. This parameter, inspired by the well-known Erdos-Szekeres theorem, has been studied by the authors in two earlier papers. Here we consider a saturation problem for the parameter $mp(G)$. We call $G$ saturated if, for every edge $e$ added to $G$, $mp(G+e) >mp(G)$, and we define $h(n,k)$ to be the least possible number of edges in a saturated graph $G$ on $n$ vertices with $mp(G) < k$, while $mp(G+e) \geq k$ for every new edge $e$. We obtain linear lower and upper bounds for $h(n,k)$, we determine exactly the values of $h(n,k)$ for $k=3$ and $4$, and we present constructions of saturated graphs.

We study analogues of $\mathcal{F}$-saturation games, first introduced by Furedi, Reimer and Seress in 1991, and named as such by West. We examine analogous games on directed graphs, and show tight results on the walk-avoiding game. We also examine an intermediate game played on undirected graphs, such that there exists an orientation avoiding a given family of directed graphs, and show bounds on the score. This last game is shown to be equivalent to a recent game studied by Hefetz, Krivelevich, Naor and Stojakovic, and we give new bounds for biased versions of this game.

Given graphs $H$ and $F$, a subgraph $G\subseteq H$ is an $F$-saturated subgraph of $H$ if $F\nsubseteq G$, but $F\subseteq G+e$ for all $e\in E(H)\setminus E(G)$. The saturation number of $F$ in $H$, denoted $\text{sat}(H,F)$, is the minimum number of edges in an $F$-saturated subgraph of $H$. In this paper we study saturation numbers of tripartite graphs in tripartite graphs. For $\ell\ge 1$ and $n_1$, $n_2$, and $n_3$ sufficiently large, we determine $\text{sat}(K_{n_1,n_2,n_3},K_{\ell,\ell,\ell})$ and $\text{sat}(K_{n_1,n_2,n_3},K_{\ell,\ell,\ell-1})$ exactly and $\text{sat}(K_{n_1,n_2,n_3},K_{\ell,\ell,\ell-2})$ within an additive constant. We also include general constructions of $K_{\ell,m,p}$-saturated subgraphs of $K_{n_1,n_2,n_3}$ with few edges for $\ell\ge m\ge p>0$.

Let $Q_d$ denote the hypercube of dimension $d$. Given $d\geq m$, a spanning subgraph $G$ of $Q_d$ is said to be $(Q_d,Q_m)$-saturated if it does not contain $Q_m$ as a subgraph but adding any edge of $E(Q_d)\setminus E(G)$ creates a copy of $Q_m$ in $G$. Answering a question of Johnson and Pinto, we show that for every fixed $m\geq2$ the minimum number of edges in a $(Q_d,Q_m)$-saturated graph is $Θ(2^d)$. We also study weak saturation, which is a form of bootstrap percolation. A spanning subgraph of $Q_d$ is said to be weakly $(Q_d,Q_m)$-saturated if the edges of $E(Q_d)\setminus E(G)$ can be added to $G$ one at a time so that each added edge creates a new copy of $Q_m$. Answering another question of Johnson and Pinto, we determine the minimum number of edges in a weakly $(Q_d,Q_m)$-saturated graph for all $d\geq m\geq1$. More generally, we determine the minimum number of edges in a subgraph of the $d$-dimensional grid $P_k^d$ which is weakly saturated with respect to `axis aligned' copies of a smaller grid $P_r^m$. We also study weak saturation of cycles in the grid.

Let $G$ be a fixed graph and let ${\mathcal F}$ be a family of graphs. A subgraph $J$ of $G$ is ${\mathcal F}$-saturated if no member of ${\mathcal F}$ is a subgraph of $J$, but for any edge $e$ in $E(G)-E(J)$, some element of ${\mathcal F}$ is a subgraph of $J+e$. We let $\text{ex}({\mathcal F},G)$ and $\text{sat}({\mathcal F},G)$ denote the maximum and minimum size of an ${\mathcal F}$-saturated subgraph of $G$, respectively. If no element of ${\mathcal F}$ is a subgraph of $G$, then $\text{sat}({\mathcal F},G) = \text{ex}({\mathcal F}, G) = |E(G)|$. In this paper, for $k\ge 3$ and $n\ge 100$ we determine $\text{sat}(K_3,K_k^n)$, where $K_k^n$ is the complete balanced $k$-partite graph with partite sets of size $n$. We also give several families of constructions of $K_t$-saturated subgraphs of $K_k^n$ for $t\ge 4$. Our results and constructions provide an informative contrast to recent results on the edge-density version of $\text{ex}(K_t,K_k^n)$ from [A. Bondy, J. Shen, S. Thomassé, and C. Thomassen, Density conditions for triangles in multipartite graphs, Combinatorica 26 (2006), 121--131] and [F. Pfender, Complete subgraphs in multipartite graphs, Combinatorica 32 (2012), no. 4, 483--495].

A graph $G = (V,E)$ is said to be saturated with respect to a monotone increasing graph property ${\mathcal P}$, if $G \notin {\mathcal P}$ but $G \cup \{e\} \in {\mathcal P}$ for every $e \in \binom{V}{2} \setminus E$. The saturation game $(n, {\mathcal P})$ is played as follows. Two players, called Mini and Max, progressively build a graph $G \subseteq K_n$, which does not satisfy ${\mathcal P}$. Starting with the empty graph on $n$ vertices, the two players take turns adding edges $e \in \binom{V(K_n)}{2} \setminus E(G)$, for which $G \cup \{e\} \notin {\mathcal P}$, until no such edge exists (i.e. until $G$ becomes ${\mathcal P}$-saturated), at which point the game is over. Max's goal is to maximize the length of the game, whereas Mini aims to minimize it. The score of the game, denoted by $s(n, {\mathcal P})$, is the number of edges in $G$ at the end of the game, assuming both players follow their optimal strategies. We prove lower and upper bounds on the score of games in which the property the players need to avoid is being $k$-connected, having chromatic number at least $k$, and admitting a matching of a given size. In doing so we demonstrate that the score of certain games can be as large as the Turán number or as low as the saturation number of the respective graph property. We also demonstrate that the score might strongly depend on the identity of the first player to move.

Given a family ${\mathcal F}$ and a host graph $H$, a graph $G\subseteq H$ is ${\mathcal F}$-saturated relative to $H$ if no subgraph of $G$ lies in ${\mathcal F}$ but adding any edge from $E(H)-E(G)$ to $G$ creates such a subgraph. In the ${\mathcal F}$-saturation game on $H$, players Max and Min alternately add edges of $H$ to $G$, avoiding subgraphs in ${\mathcal F}$, until $G$ becomes ${\mathcal F}$-saturated relative to $H$. They aim to maximize or minimize the length of the game, respectively; $\textrm{sat}_g({\mathcal F};H)$ denotes the length under optimal play (when Max starts). Let ${\mathcal O}$ denote the family of all odd cycles and ${\mathcal T}$ the family of $n$-vertex trees, and write $F$ for ${\mathcal F}$ when ${\mathcal F}=\{F\}$. Our results include $\textrm{sat}_g({\mathcal O};K_{2k})=k^2$, $\textrm{sat}_g({\mathcal T};K_n)=\binom{n-2}{2}+1$ for $n\ge6$, $\textrm{sat}_g(K_{1,3};K_n)=2\lfloor n/2 \rfloor$ for $n\ge8$, $\textrm{sat}_g(K_{1,r+1};K_n)=\frac{rn}{2}-\frac{r^2}{8}+O(1)$, and $|\textrm{sat}_g(P_4;K_n)-(4n-1)/5|\le 1$. We also determine $\textrm{sat}_g(P_4;K_{m,n})$; with $m\ge n$, it is $n$ when $n$ is even, $m$ when $n$ is odd and $m$ is even, and $m+\lfloor n/2 \rfloor$ when $mn$ is odd. Finally, we prove the lower bound $\textrm{sat}_g(C_4;K_{n,n})\ge\frac{1}{10.4}n^{13/12}-O(n^{35/36})$. The results are very similar when Min plays first, except for the $P_4$-saturation game on $K_{m,n}$.

The saturation number of a graph $G$ is the cardinality of any smallest maximal matching of $G$, and it is denoted by $s(G)$. Fullerene graphs are cubic planar graphs with exactly twelve 5-faces; all the other faces are hexagons. They are used to capture the structure of carbon molecules. Here we show that the saturation number of fullerenes on $n$ vertices is essentially $n/3$.

An $n$-by-$n$ bipartite graph is $H$-saturated if the addition of any missing edge between its two parts creates a new copy of $H$. In 1964, Erdős, Hajnal and Moon made a conjecture on the minimum number of edges in a $K_{s,s}$-saturated bipartite graph. This conjecture was proved independently by Wessel and Bollobás in a more general, but ordered, setting: they showed that the minimum number of edges in a $K_{(s,t)}$-saturated bipartite graph is $n^2-(n-s+1)(n-t+1)$, where $K_{(s,t)}$ is the "ordered" complete bipartite graph with $s$ vertices in the first color class and $t$ vertices in the second. However, the very natural question of determining the minimum number of edges in the unordered $K_{s,t}$-saturated case remained unsolved. This problem was considered recently by Moshkovitz and Shapira who also conjectured what its answer should be. In this short paper we give an asymptotically tight bound on the minimum number of edges in a $K_{s,t}$-saturated bipartite graph, which is only smaller by an additive constant than the conjecture of Moshkovitz and Shapira. We also prove their conjecture for $K_{2,3}$-saturation, which was the first open case.

Describing minimal generating set of a toric ideal is a well-studied and difficult problem. In 1980 White conjectured that the toric ideal associated to a matroid is equal to the ideal generated by quadratic binomials corresponding to symmetric exchanges. We prove White's conjecture up to saturation, that is that the saturations of both ideals are equal. In the language of algebraic geometry this means that both ideals define the same projective scheme. Additionally we prove the full conjecture for strongly base orderable matroids.

We consider the following combinatorial game: two players, Fast and Slow, claim $k$-element subsets of $[n]=\{1,2,...,n\}$ alternately, one at each turn, such that both players are allowed to pick sets that intersect all previously claimed subsets. The game ends when there does not exist any unclaimed $k$-subset that meets all already claimed sets. The score of the game is the number of sets claimed by the two players, the aim of Fast is to keep the score as low as possible, while the aim of Slow is to postpone the game's end as long as possible. The game saturation number is the score of the game when both players play according to an optimal strategy. To be precise we have to distinguish two cases depending on which player takes the first move. Let $gsat_F(\mathbb{I}_{n,k})$ and $gsat_S(\mathbb{I}_{n,k})$ denote the score of the saturation game when both players play according to an optimal strategy and the game starts with Fast's or Slow's move, respectively. We prove that $Ω_k(n^{k/3-5}) \le gsat_F(\mathbb{I}_{n,k}),gsat_S(\mathbb{I}_{n,k}) \le O_k(n^{k-\sqrt{k}/2})$ holds.

The saturation theorem of [Knutson-Tao '99] concerns the nonvanishing of Littlewood-Richardson coefficients. In combination with work of [Klyachko '98], it implies [Horn '62]'s conjecture about eigenvalues of sums of Hermitian matrices. This eigenvalue problem has a generalization [Friedland '00] to majorized sums of Hermitian matrices. We further illustrate the common features between these two eigenvalue problems and their connection to Schubert calculus of Grassmannians. Our main result gives a Schubert calculus interpretation of Friedland's problem, via equivariant cohomology of Grassmannians. In particular, we prove a saturation theorem for this setting. Our arguments employ the aformentioned work together with [Thomas-Yong '12].

Let W_n(p,q) denote the minimum number of edges in an n x n bipartite graph G on vertex sets X,Y that satisfies the following condition; one can add the edges between X and Y that do not belong to G one after the other so that whenever a new edge is added, a new copy of K_{p,q} is created. The problem of bounding W_n(p,q), and its natural hypergraph generalization, was introduced by Balogh, Bollobás, Morris and Riordan. Their main result, specialized to graphs, used algebraic methods to determine W_n(1,q). Our main results in this paper give exact bounds for W_n(p,q), its hypergraph analogue, as well as for a new variant of Bollobás's Two Families theorem. In particular, we completely determine W_n(p,q), showing that if 1 <= p <= q <= n then W_n(p,q) = n^2 - (n-p+1)^2 + (q-p)^2. Our proof applies a reduction to a multi-partite version of the Two Families theorem obtained by Alon. While the reduction is combinatorial, the main idea behind it is algebraic.

We present an unexpected application of tropical convexity to the determination of invariants for linear systems of differential equations. We show that the classical Gérard-Levelt lattice saturation procedure can be geometrically understood in terms of a projection on the tropical linear space attached to a subset of the local affine Bruhat-Tits building, that we call the Gérard-Levelt membrane. This provides a way to compute the true Poincaré rank, but also the Katz rank of a meromorphic connection without having to perform gauge transforms nor ramifications of the variable. We finally present an efficient algorithm to compute this tropical projection map, generalising Ardila's method for Bergman fans to the case of the tight-span of a valuated matroid.

In this paper, we discuss a generalization of the notion of saturation in graphs in order to deal with induced structures. In particular, we define ${\rm indsat}(n,H)$, which is the fewest number of gray edges in a trigraph so that no realization of that trigraph has an induced copy of $H$, but changing any white or black edge to gray results in some realization that does have an induced copy of $H$. We give some general and basic results and then prove that ${\rm indsat}(n,P_4)=\lceil (n+1)/3\rceil$ for $n\geq 4$ where $P_4$ is the path on 4 vertices. We also show how induced saturation in this setting extends to a natural notion of saturation in the context of general Boolean formulas.

We show the expected order of RNA saturated secondary structures of size $n$ is $\log_4n(1+O(\frac{\log_2n}{n}))$, if we select the saturated secondary structure uniformly at random. Furthermore, the order of saturated secondary structures is sharply concentrated around its mean. As a consequence saturated structures and structures in the traditional model behave the same with respect to the expected order. Thus we may conclude that the traditional model has already drawn the right picture and conclusions inferred from it with respect to the order (the overall shape) of a structure remain valid even if enforcing saturation (at least in expectation).

In recent years several classical results in extremal graph theory have been improved in a uniform way and their proofs have been simplified and streamlined. These results include a new Erdős-Stone-Bollobás theorem, several stability theorems, several saturation results and bounds for the number of graphs with large forbidden subgraphs. Another recent trend is the expansion of spectral extremal graph theory, in which extremal properties of graphs are studied by means of eigenvalues of various matrices. One particular achievement in this area is the casting of the central results above in spectral terms, often with additional enhancement. In addition, new, specific spectral results were found that have no conventional analogs. All of the above material is scattered throughout various journals, and since it may be of some interest, the purpose of this survey is to present the best of these results in a uniform, structured setting, together with some discussions of the underpinning ideas.