arXiv++ Combinatorics

The aim of this paper is to present new upper bounds for the distance between a properly normalized permanent of a rectangular complex matrix and the product of the arithmetic means of the entries of its columns. It turns out that the bounds improve on those from earlier work. Our proofs are based on some new identities for the above-mentioned differences and also for related expressions for matrices over a rational associative commutative unital algebra. Some of our identities are generalizations of results in Dougall (Proceedings of the Edinburgh Mathematical Society, 24, 61-77, 1905). Second order results are also included.

A great variety of fundamental optimization and counting problems arising in computer science, mathematics and physics can be reduced to one of the following computational tasks involving polynomials and set systems: given an $m$-variate real polynomial $g$ and a family of subsets $B$ of $[m]$, (1) find $S\in B$ such that the monomial in $g$ corresponding to $S$ has the largest coefficient in $g$, or (2) compute the sum of coefficients of monomials in $g$ corresponding to all the sets in $B$. Special cases of these problems, such as computing permanents, sampling from DPPs and maximizing subdeterminants have been topics of recent interest in theoretical computer science. In this paper we present a general convex programming framework geared to solve both of these problems. We show that roughly, when $g$ is a real stable polynomial with non-negative coefficients and $B$ is a matroid, the integrality gap of our relaxation is finite and depends only on $m$ (and not on the coefficients of g). Prior to our work, such results were known only in sporadic cases that relied on the structure of $g$ and $B$; it was not even clear if one could formulate a convex relaxation that has a finite integrality gap beyond these special cases. Two notable examples are a result by Gurvits on the van der Waerden conjecture for real stable $g$ when $B$ is a single element and a result by Nikolov and Singh for multilinear real stable polynomials when $B$ is a partition matroid. Our work, which encapsulates most interesting cases of $g$ and $B$, benefits from both - we were inspired by the latter in deriving the right convex programming relaxation and the former in establishing the integrality gap. However, proving our results requires significant extensions of both; in that process we come up with new notions and connections between stable polynomials and matroids which should be of independent interest.

In this paper, we derive simple closed-form expressions for the $n$-queens problem and three related problems in terms of permanents of $(0,1)$ matrices. These formulas are the first of their kind. Moreover, they provide the first method for solving these problems with polynomial space that has a nontrivial time complexity bound. We then show how a closed-form for the number of Latin squares of order $n$ follows from our method. Finally, we prove lower bounds. In particular, we show that the permanent of Schur's complex valued matrix is a lower bound for the toroidal semi-queens problem, or equivalently, the number of transversals in a cyclic Latin square.

We study the problem of allocating $m$ items to $n$ agents subject to maximizing the Nash social welfare (NSW) objective. We write a novel convex programming relaxation for this problem, and we show that a simple randomized rounding algorithm gives a $1/e$ approximation factor of the objective. Our main technical contribution is an extension of Gurvits's lower bound on the coefficient of the square-free monomial of a degree $m$-homogeneous stable polynomial on $m$ variables to all homogeneous polynomials. We use this extension to analyze the expected welfare of the allocation returned by our randomized rounding algorithm.

Let $A=(a_{ij})$ be an $n$-by-$n$ matrix. For any real number $μ$, we define the polynomial $$P_μ(A)=\sum_{σ\in S_n} a_{1σ(1)}\cdots a_{nσ(n)}\,μ^{\ell(σ)}\; ,$$ as the $μ$-permanent of $A$, where $\ell(σ)$ is the number of inversions of the permutation $σ$ in the symmetric group $S_n$. In this note, motivated by this notion, we discuss a new graph labeling for trees whose matrices satisfy certain $μ$-permanental identities. We relate the number of labelings of a path with a known integer sequence. Several examples are provided.

We review and update on a few conjectures concerning matrix permanent that are easily stated, understood, and accessible to general math audience. They are: Soules permanent-on-top conjecture${}^\dagger$, Lieb permanent dominance conjecture, Bapat and Sunder conjecture${}^\dagger$ on Hadamard product and diagonal entries, Chollet conjecture on Hadamard product, Marcus conjecture on permanent of permanents, and several other conjectures. Some of these conjectures are recently settled; some are still open. We also raise a few new questions for future study. (${}^\dagger$conjectures have been recently settled negatively.)

Previously, the graph permanent was introduced as a single-valued invariant for graphs $G$ with $|E(G)| = k(|V(G)|-1)$ for some $k \in \mathbb{Z}_{>0}$. Herein, we construct the extended graph permanent, an infinite sequence for all graphs. We prove that, like the graph permanent, the extended graph permanent is invariant under the graph operations that are known to preserve the period. Further, the original construction and extension arise from permanents of matrices, but we construct a novel graph polynomial such that the sequence can be generated from the point count of this polynomial, as a residue over prime-order finite fields.

We consider two ensembles of nxn matrices. The first is the set of all nxn matrices with entries zeroes and ones such that all column sums and all row sums equal r, uniformly weighted. The second is the set of nxn matrices with zero and one entries where the probability that any given entry is one is r/n, the probabilities of the set of individual entries being i.i.d.'s. Calling the two expectation values E and EB respectively, we develop a formal relation E(perm(A)) = EB(perm (A)) x exp{sum Ti}. We also use a well-known approximating ensemble to E, E1. We prove using E or E1 one obtains the same value of Ti for i < 21. (THE PUBLISHED VERSION OF THIS PAPER ONLY OBTAINS RESULTS FOR i < 8. We go beyond the results of the published version by taking much more advantage of recent work of Pernici and of Wanless on i-matchings on regular bipartite graphs.)These terms Ti, i < 21, have amazing properties. We conjecture that these properties hold also for all i.

We prove a stability version of a general result that bounds the permanent of a matrix in terms of its operator norm. More specifically, suppose $A$ is an $n \times n$ matrix over $\mathbb{C}$ (resp. $\mathbb{R}$), and let $\mathcal{P}$ denote the set of $n \times n$ matrices over $\mathbb{C}$ (resp. $\mathbb{R}$) that can be written as a permutation matrix times a unitary diagonal matrix. Then it is known that the permanent of $A$ satisfies $|\text{perm}(A)| \leq \Vert A \Vert_{2} ^n$ with equality iff $A/ \Vert A \Vert_{2} \in \mathcal{P}$ (where $\Vert A \Vert_2$ is the operator $2$-norm of $A$). We show a stability version of this result asserting that unless $A$ is very close (in a particular sense) to one of these extremal matrices, its permanent is exponentially smaller (as a function of $n$) than $\Vert A \Vert_2 ^n$. In particular, for any fixed $α, β> 0$, we show that $|\text{perm}(A)|$ is exponentially smaller than $\Vert A \Vert_2 ^n$ unless all but at most $αn$ rows contain entries of modulus at least $\Vert A \Vert_2 (1 - β)$.

We investigate the tropical analogues of totally positive and totally nonnegative matrices. These arise when considering the images by the nonarchimedean valuation of the corresponding classes of matrices over a real nonarchimedean valued field, like the field of real Puiseux series. We show that the nonarchimedean valuation sends the totally positive matrices precisely to the Monge matrices. This leads to explicit polyhedral representations of the tropical analogues of totally positive and totally nonnegative matrices. We also show that tropical totally nonnegative matrices with a finite permanent can be factorized in terms of elementary matrices. We finally determine the eigenvalues of tropical totally nonnegative matrices, and relate them with the eigenvalues of totally nonnegative matrices over nonarchimedean fields.

Continuing the computations of the previous paper,[1], we calculate another approximation to the expectation value of the product of two permanents in the ensemble of 0-1 n x n matrices with like row and column sums equal r uniformly weighted. Here we consider the Bernoulli random matrix ensemble where each entry independently has a probability p=r/n of being one, otherwise zero. We denote the expectations of the approximation ensemble of [1] by E, and the expectations of the present approximation ensemble, the Bernoulli random matrix ensemble, by E*. One has for these lim_{r to infinity}( lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E(perm_m(A))) -lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E*(perm_m(A))) ) = 0 and lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E(perm_m(A)perm_m'(A))) = lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E(perm_m(A))) + lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E(perm_m'(A))) Here and in all such formulas the subscripts m,m' are assumed proportional to n. It seems likely to us that lim_{r to infinity}( lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E*(perm_m(A)perm_m'(A))) - lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E*(perm_m(A))) + - lim_{n to infinity} (1/n) ln(E*(perm_m'(A))) ) = 0 We believe: "E gives us the `correct' expectations in these equations, and E* is only `correct' in the r to infinity limit."

We study the combinatorics of tropical hyperplane arrangements, and their relationship to (classical) hyperplane face monoids. We show that the refinement operation on the faces of a tropical hyperplane arrangement, introduced by Ardila and Develin in their definition of a tropical oriented matroid, induces an action of the hyperplane face monoid of the classical braid arrangement on the arrangement, and hence on a number of interesting related structures. Along the way, we introduce a new characterization of the types (in the sense of Develin and Sturmfels) of points with respect to a tropical hyperplane arrangement, in terms of partial bijections which attain permanents of submatrices of a matrix which naturally encodes the arrangement.

Björklund and Husfeldt developed a randomized polynomial time algorithm to solve the shortest two disjoint paths problem. Their algorithm is based on computation of permanents modulo 4 and the isolation lemma. In this paper, we consider the following generalization of the shortest two disjoint paths problem, and develop a similar algebraic algorithm. The shortest perfect $(A+B)$-path packing problem is: given an undirected graph $G$ and two disjoint node subsets $A,B$ with even cardinalities, find a shortest $|A|/2+|B|/2$ disjoint paths whose ends are both in $A$ or both in $B$. Besides its NP-hardness, we prove that this problem can be solved in randomized polynomial time if $|A|+|B|$ is fixed. Our algorithm basically follows the framework of Björklund and Husfeldt but uses a new technique: computation of hafnian modulo $2^k$ combined with Gallai's reduction from $T$-paths to matchings. We also generalize our technique for solving other path packing problems, and discuss its limitation.

We prove that the logarithm of the permanent of an nxn real matrix A and the logarithm of the hafnian of a 2nx2n real symmetric matrix A can be approximated within an additive error 1 > epsilon > 0 by a polynomial p in the entries of A of degree O(ln n - ln epsilon) provided the entries a_ij of A satisfy delta < a_ij < 1 for an arbitrarily small delta > 0, fixed in advance. Moreover, the polynomial p can be computed in n^{O(ln n - ln epsilon)} time. We also improve bounds for approximating ln per A, ln haf A and logarithms of multi-dimensional permanents for complex matrices and tensors A.

We prove that in the geometric complexity theory program the vanishing of rectangular Kronecker coefficients cannot be used to prove superpolynomial determinantal complexity lower bounds for the permanent polynomial. Moreover, we prove the positivity of rectangular Kronecker coefficients for a large class of partitions where the side lengths of the rectangle are at least quadratic in the length of the partition. We also compare rectangular Kronecker coefficients with their corresponding plethysm coefficients, which leads to a new lower bound for rectangular Kronecker coefficients. Moreover, we prove that the saturation of the rectangular Kronecker semigroup is trivial, we show that the rectangular Kronecker positivity stretching factor is 2 for a long first row, and we completely classify the positivity of rectangular limit Kronecker coefficients that were introduced by Manivel in 2011.

The principal permanent rank characteristic sequence is a binary sequence $r_0 r_1 \ldots r_n$ where $r_k = 1$ if there exists a principal square submatrix of size $k$ with nonzero permanent and $r_k = 0$ otherwise, and $r_0 = 1$ if there is a zero diagonal entry. A characterization is provided for all principal permanent rank sequences obtainable by the family of nonnegative matrices as well as the family of nonnegative symmetric matrices. Constructions for all realizable sequences are provided. Results for skew-symmetric matrices are also included.

A total weighting of a graph $G$ is a mapping $f$ which assigns to each element $z \in V(G) \cup E(G)$ a real number $f(z)$ as its weight. The vertex sum of $v$ with respect to $f$ is $φ_f(v)=\sum_{e \in E(v)}f(e)+f(v)$. A total weighting is proper if $φ_f(u) \ne φ_f(v)$ for any edge $uv$ of $G$. A $(k,k')$-list assignment is a mapping $L$ which assigns to each vertex $v$ a set $L(v)$ of $k$ permissible weights, and assigns to each edge $e$ a set $L(e)$ of $k'$ permissible weights. We say $G$ is $(k,k')$-choosable if for any $(k,k')$-list assignment $L$, there is a proper total weighting $f$ of $G$ with $f(z) \in L(z)$ for each $z \in V(G) \cup E(G)$. It was conjectured in [T. Wong and X. Zhu, Total weight choosability of graphs, J. Graph Theory 66 (2011), 198-212] that every graph is $(2,2)$-choosable and every graph with no isolated edge is $(1,3)$-choosable. A promising tool in the study of these conjectures is Combinatorial Nullstellensatz. This approach leads to conjectures on the permanent indices of matrices $A_G$ and $B_G$ associated to a graph $G$. In this paper, we establish a method that reduces the study of permanent of matrices associated to a graph $G$ to the study of permanent of matrices associated to induced subgraphs of $G$. Using this reduction method, we show that if $G$ is a subcubic graph, or a $2$-tree, or a Halin graph, or a grid, then $A_G$ has permanent index $1$. As a consequence, these graphs are $(2,2)$-choosable. \end{abstract} {\small \noindent{{\bf Key words: } Permanent index, matrix, total weighting}

From a transfer formula in multivariate finite operator calculus, comes an expansion for the determinant similar to Ryser's formula for the permanent. Although this one contains many more terms than the usual determinant formula. To prove it, we consider the poset of ordered partitions, properties of the permutahedron, and some good old fashioned combinatorial techniques.

We give a sharp lower bound on the number of matchings of a given size in a bipartite graph. When specialized to regular bipartite graphs, our results imply Friedland's Lower Matching Conjecture and Schrijver's theorem proven by Gurvits and Csikvari. Indeed, our work extends the recent work of Csikvari done for regular and bi-regular bipartite graphs. Moreover, our lower bounds are order optimal as they are attained for a sequence of $2$-lifts of the original graph as well as for random $n$-lifts of the original graph when $n$ tends to infinity. We then extend our results to permanents and subpermanents sums. For permanents, we are able to recover the lower bound of Schrijver recently proved by Gurvits using stable polynomials. Our proof is algorithmic and borrows ideas from the theory of local weak convergence of graphs, statistical physics and covers of graphs. We provide new lower bounds for subpermanents sums and obtain new results on the number of matching in random $n$-lifts with some implications for the matching measure and the spectral measure of random $n$-lifts as well as for the spectral measure of infinite trees.

This article, showing that almost all objects in the title are asymmetric, is re-typed from a manuscript I wrote somewhere around 1980 (after the papers of Bang and Friedland on the permanent conjecture but before those of Egorychev and Falikman). I am not sure of the exact date. The manuscript had been lost, but surfaced among my papers recently. I am grateful to Laci Babai and Ian Wanless who have encouraged me to make this document public, and to Ian for spotting a couple of typos. In the section on Latin squares, Ian objects to my use of the term "cell"; this might be more reasonably called a "triple" (since it specifies a row, column and symbol), but I have decided to keep the terminology I originally used. The result for Latin squares is in B. D. McKay and I. M. Wanless, On the number of Latin squares, Annals of Combinatorics 9 (2005), 335-344 (arXiv 0909.2101), while the result for Steiner triple systems is in L. Babai, Almost all Steiner triple systems are asymmetric, Annals of Discrete Mathematics 7 (1980), 37-39.