arXiv++ Combinatorics

Andrews-Dyson-Hickerson, Cohen build a striking relation between q-hypergeometric series, real quadratic fields, and Maass forms. Thanks to the works of Lewis-Zagier and Zwegers we have a complete understanding on the part of these relations pertaining to Maass forms and false-indefinite theta functions. In particular, we can systematically distinguish and study the class of false-indefinite theta functions related to Maass forms. A crucial component here is the framework of mock Maass theta functions built by Zwegers in analogy with his earlier work on indefinite theta functions and their application to Ramanujan's mock theta functions. Given this understanding, a natural question is to what extent one can utilize modular properties to investigate the asymptotic behavior of the associated Fourier coefficients, especially in view of their relevance to combinatorial objects. In this paper, we develop the relevant methods to study such a question and show that quite detailed results can be obtained on the asymptotic development, which also enable Hardy-Ramanujan-Rademacher type exact formulas under the right conditions. We develop these techniques by concentrating on a concrete example involving partitions with parts separated by parity and derive an asymptotic expansion that includes all the exponentially growing terms.

Let $S_r(p,q)$ be the $r$-associated Stirling numbers of the second kind, the number of ways to partition a set of size $p$ into $q$ subsets of size at least $r$. For $r=1$, these are the standard Stirling numbers of the second kind, and for $r=2$, these are also known as the Ward Numbers. This paper concerns asymptotic expansions of these Stirling numbers; such expansions have been known for many years. However, while uniform convergence of these expansions was conjectured in Hennecart's 1994 paper, it has not been fully proved. A recent paper (Connamacher and Dobrosotskaya, 2020) went a long way, by proving uniform convergence on a large set. In this paper we build on that paper and prove convergence "everywhere."

We derive the asymptotic expansion (asymptotics with an arbitrary number of error terms) of k-regular graphs by applying the Laplace method on a recent exact formula from Caizergues and de Panafieu (2023). We also deduce the asymptotic expansion of connected k-regular graphs using standard techniques for divergent series developed by Wright (1970) and Bender (1975), and quantify its closeness to the asymptotic expansion of k-regular graphs.

This article addresses a combinatorial problem with applications to algebraic geometry. To a convex lattice polytope $P$ and each of its integer dilations $kP$ one may associate the barycenter of its lattice points. This sequence of $k$-quantized barycenters converge to the (classical) barycenter of the polytope considered as a convex body. A basic question arises: is there a complete asymptotic expansion for this sequence? If so, what are its terms? This article initiates the study of this question. First, we establish the existence of such an expansion as well as determine the first two terms. Second, for Delzant lattice polytopes we use toric algebra to determine all terms using mixed volumes of virtual rooftop polytopes, or alternatively in terms of higher Donaldson--Futaki invariants. Third, for reflexive polytopes we show the quantized barycenters are colinear to first order, and actually colinear in the case of polygons. The proofs use Ehrhart theory, convexity arguments, and toric algebra. As applications we derive the complete asymptotic expansion of the Fujita--Odaka stability thresholds $δ_k$ on arbitrary polarizations on (possibly singular) toric varieties. In fact, we show they are rational functions of $k$ for sufficiently large $k$. This gives the first general result on Tian's stabilization problem for $δ_k$-invariants for (possibly singular) toric Fanos: $δ_k$ stabilize in $k$ if and only if they are all equal to $1$, and when smooth if and only if asymptotically Chow semistable. We also relate the asymptotic expansions to higher Donaldson--Futaki invariants of test configurations motivated by Ehrhart theory, and unify in passing previous results of Donaldson, Ono, Futaki, and Rubinstein--Tian--Zhang.

The critical beta-splitting tree, introduced by Aldous, is a Markov branching phylogenetic tree. Aldous and Pittel recently proved, amongst other results, a central limit theorem for the height of a random leaf. We give an alternative proof, via contraction methods for random recursive structures. These methods were developed by Neininger and Rüschendorf, motivated by Pittel's article "Normal convergence problem? Two moments and a recurrence may be the clues." Aldous and Pittel estimated the leading order terms in the first two moments. More recently, Aldous and Janson obtained an asymptotic expansion for the average height. We show that a central limit theorem follows, and bound the distance to normality. Our results also apply to the continuous version of the model, in which branching times are exponential.

In the asymptotic analysis of regular sequences as defined by Allouche and Shallit, it is usually advisable to study their summatory function because the original sequence has a too fluctuating behaviour. It might be that the process of taking the summatory function has to be repeated if the sequence is fluctuating too much. In this paper we show that for all regular sequences except for some degenerate cases, repeating this process finitely many times leads to a ``nice'' asymptotic expansion containing periodic fluctuations whose Fourier coefficients can be computed using the results on the asymptotics of the summatory function of regular sequences by the first two authors of this paper. In a recent paper, Hwang, Janson, and Tsai perform a thorough investigation of divide-and-conquer recurrences. These can be seen as $2$-regular sequences. By considering them as the summatory function of their forward difference, the results on the asymptotics of the summatory function of regular sequences become applicable. We thoroughly investigate the case of a polynomial toll function.

We give a new combinatorial proof of Parraud's formula for the asymptotic expansion in powers of $1/N^2$ for the expected trace of polynomials of several independent $N \times N$ GUE matrices, which expresses the result using a mixture of free difference quotients, introducing new freely independent semicircular variables, and integration with respect to parameters. Our approach streamlines the statement of the formula while clarifying its relationship to the combinatorial genus expansion.

We study the structure of the asymptotic expansion of the probability that a combinatorial object is connected. We show that the coefficients appearing in those asymptotics are integers and can be interpreted as the counting sequences of other derivative combinatorial classes. The general result applies to rapidly growing combinatorial structures, which we call gargantuan, that also admit a sequence decomposition. The result is then applied to several models of graphs, of surfaces (square-tiled surfaces, combinatorial maps), and to geometric models of higher dimension (constellations, graph encoded manifolds). The corresponding derivative combinatorial classes are irreducible (multi)tournaments, indecomposable (multi)permutations and indecomposable perfect (multi)matchings.

The m-thick part of the modular surface X is the smallest compact subsurface of X with horocycle boundary containing all the closed geodesics which wind around the cusp at most m times. The m-thick parts form a compact exhaustion of X. We are interested in the geodesics that lie in the m-thick part (so called m low-lying geodesics). We produce a complete asymptotic expansion for the number of m low-lying geodesics of length equal to 2n in the modular surface. In particular, we obtain the asymptotic growth rate of the m low-lying geodesics in terms of their word length using the natural generators of the modular group. After establishing a correspondence between this counting problem and the problem of counting necklaces with n beads, we perform a careful singularity analysis on the associated generating function of the sequence.

In this work, we study the concept of self-overlapping permutations, which is related to the larger study of consecutive patterns in permutations. We show that this concept admits a simple and clear geometrical meaning, and prove that a permutation can be represented as a sequence of non-self-overlapping ones. The above structural decomposition allows us to obtain equations for the corresponding generating functions, as well as the complete asymptotic expansions for the probability that a large random permutation is (non-)self-overlapping. In particular, we show that almost all permutations are non-self-overlapping, and that the corresponding asymptotic expansion has the self-reference property: the involved coefficients count non-self-overlapping permutations once again. We also establish complete asymptotic expansions of the distributions of very tight non-self-overlapping patterns, and discuss the similarities of the non-self-overlapping permutations to other permutation building blocks, such as indecomposable and simple permutations, as well as their associated asymptotics.

We propose a new method for obtaining complete asymptotic expansions in a systematic manner, which is suitable for counting sequences of various graph families in dense regime. The core idea is to encode the two-dimensional array of expansion coefficients into a special bivariate generating function, which we call a coefficient generating function. We show that coefficient generating functions possess certain general properties that make it possible to express asymptotics in a short closed form. Also, in most scenarios, we indicate a combinatorial meaning of the involved coefficients. Applications of our method include asymptotics of connected graphs, irreducible tournaments, strongly connected digraphs, 2-SAT formulae and contradictory strongly connected implication digraphs. Moreover, due to its flexibility, the method allows to treat a wide range of structural variations, including fixing the numbers of connected, irreducible, strongly connected and contradictory components, as well as source-like, sink-like and isolated ones, or adding weights and marking variables.

An Eulerian orientation is an orientation of the edges of a graph such that every vertex is balanced: its in-degree equals its out-degree. Counting Eulerian orientations corresponds to the crucial partition function in so-called ``ice-type models'' in statistical physics and is known to be hard for general graphs. For all graphs with good expansion properties and degrees larger than $\log^{8} n$, we derive an asymptotic expansion for this count that approximates it to precision $O(n^{-c})$ for arbitrary large $c$, where $n$ is the number of vertices. The proof relies on a new tail bound for the cumulant expansion of the Laplace transform, which is of independent interest.

In the context of lattice walk enumeration in cones, we consider the number of walks in the quarter plane with fixed starting and ending points, prescribed step-set and given length. After renormalization, this number may be interpreted as a discrete heat kernel in the quadrant. We propose a new method to compute complete asymptotic expansions of these numbers of walks as their length tends to infinity, based on two main ingredients: explicit expressions for the underlying generating functions in terms of elliptic Jacobi theta functions along with a duality known as Jacobi transformation. This duality allows us to pass from a classical Taylor expansion of the series to an expansion at the critical point of the model. We work through two examples. First, we present our approach on the well-known Kreweras model, which is algebraic, and show how to obtain a complete asymptotic expansion in this case. We then consider a more generic (so-called infinite group) model, and find the associated complete asymptotic expansion. In this second case, we prove the existence of logarithmic terms in the asymptotic expansion, and we relate the coefficients appearing in the expansion to polyharmonic functions. To our knowledge, this is the first time that logarithmic terms have been observed in the asymptotics of a class of lattice walks confined to a quadrant.

Enumeration of walks with small steps in the quadrant has been a topic of great interest in combinatorics over the last few years. In this article, it is shown how to compute exact asymptotics of the number of such walks with fixed start- and endpoints for orbit-summable models with finite group, up to arbitrary precision. The resulting representation greatly resembles one conjectured by Chapon, Fusy and Raschel for walks starting from the origin (AofA 2020), differing only in terms appearing due to the periodicity of the model. We will see that the dependency on start- and endpoint is given by discrete polyharmonic functions, which are solutions of $\triangle^n v=0$ for a discretisation $\triangle$ of a Laplace-Beltrami operator. They can be decomposed into a sum of products of lower order polyharmonic functions of either the start- or the endpoint only, which leads to a partial extension of a recent theorem by Denisov and Wachtel (Ann. Prob. 43.3).

Without using the classification of finite simple groups, we show that the probability that two random elements of $S_n$ generate a primitive group smaller than $A_n$ is at most $\exp(-c(n \log n)^{1/2})$. As a corollary we get Dixon's asymptotic expansion \[ 1 - 1/n - 1/n^2 - 4/n^3 - 23/n^4 - \cdots \] for the probability that two random elements of $S_n$ (or $A_n$) generate a subgroup containing $A_n$.

For a partition $λ\vdash n$, we let $\operatorname{pd}(λ)$, the parity difference of $λ$, be the number of odd parts of $λ$ minus the number of even parts of $λ$. We prove for $c_0\in\mathbb{R}$ an asymptotic expansion for the number of partitions of $n$ into distinct parts with normalised parity difference $n^{- 1/4}\operatorname{pd}(λ)$ greater than $c_0$ as $n\to \infty$. As a corollary, we find the distribution of the parity differences and parity biases for partitions of $n$ into distinct parts. We also establish analogous results for generalised parity differences modulo $N$.

Recently it has been shown that the $α$-Sun density $h(x)$ [{\it J. Math. Anal. Appl.}, {\bf 527} (2023), p. 127371] which interpolates between the Fr{é}chet density and that of the positive, stable distributions whose density is given by a Fox $H$-function, has a Mellin transform involving an infinite product of ratios of Incomplete Beta functions. We develop systematic, but asymptotic, approximations for such products and consequently for the behaviour of the density as $ x\to 0+$ which complement the recent exact form for this by Simon [{\it Electron. Commun. Probab.}, {\bf 28} (2023) p. 1 - 13]. The systematic expansion is an example of a Power Product Expansion, and in our case we derive bounds and estimates which show that this expansion is not convergent and thus only yields an asymptotic expansion.

Generalized digamma functions $ψ_k(x)$, studied by Ramanujan, Deninger, Dilcher, Kanemitsu, Ishibashi etc., appear as the Laurent series coefficients of the zeta function associated to an indefinite quadratic form. In this paper, a modular relation of the form $F_k(α)=F_k(1/α)$ containing infinite series of $ψ_k(x)$, or, equivalently, between the generalized Stieltjes constants $γ_k(x)$, is obtained for any $k\in\mathbb{N}$. When $k=0$, it reduces to a famous transformation given on page $220$ of Ramanujan's Lost Notebook. For $k=1$, an integral containing Riemann's $Ξ$-function, and corresponding to the aforementioned modular relation, is also obtained along with its asymptotic expansions as $α\to0$ and $α\to\infty$. Carlitz-type and Guinand-type finite modular relations involving $ψ_j^{(m)}(x), 0\leq j\leq k, m\in\mathbb{N}\cup\{0\},$ are also derived, thereby extending previous results on the digamma function $ψ(x)$. The extension of Guinand's result for $ψ_j^{(m)}(x), m\geq2,$ involves an interesting combinatorial sum $h(r)$ over integer partitions of $2r$ into exactly $r$ parts. This sum plays a crucial role in an inversion formula needed for this extension. This formula has connection with the inversion formula for the inverse of a triangular Toeplitz matrix. The modular relation for $ψ_j'(x)$ is subtle and requires delicate analysis.

We study the distribution of the length of longest monotone subsequences in random (fixed-point free) involutions of $n$ integers as $n$ grows large, establishing asymptotic expansions in powers of $n^{-1/6}$ in the general case and in powers of $n^{-1/3}$ in the fixed-point free cases. Whilst the limit laws were shown by Baik and Rains to be one of the Tracy-Widom distributions $F_β$ for $β=1$ or $β=4$, we find explicit analytic expressions of the first few expansion terms as linear combinations of higher order derivatives of $F_β$ with rational polynomial coefficients. Our derivation is based on a concept of generalized analytic de-Poissonization and is subject to the validity of certain hypotheses for which we provide compelling (computational) evidence. In a preparatory step expansions of the hard-to-soft edge transition laws of L$β$E are studied, which are lifted into expansions of the generalized Poissonized length distributions for large intensities. (This paper continues our work arXiv:2301.02022, which established similar results in the case of general permutations and $β=2$.)

We study the distribution of the length of longest increasing subsequences in random permutations of $n$ integers as $n$ grows large and establish an asymptotic expansion in powers of $n^{-1/3}$. Whilst the limit law was already shown by Baik, Deift and Johansson to be the GUE Tracy-Widom distribution $F$, we find explicit analytic expressions of the first few finite-size correction terms as linear combinations of higher order derivatives of $F$ with rational polynomial coefficients. Our proof replaces Johansson's de-Poissonization, which is based on monotonicity as a Tauberian condition, by analytic de-Poissonization of Jacquet and Szpankowski, which is based on growth conditions in the complex plane; it is subject to a tameness hypothesis concerning complex zeros of the analytically continued Poissonized length distribution. In a preparatory step an expansion of the hard-to-soft edge transition law of LUE is studied, which is lifted into an expansion of the Poissonized length distribution for large intensities. Finally, expansions of Stirling-type approximations and of the expected value and variance of the length distribution are given.