arXiv++ Combinatorics

We exhibit two finite orthogonality hypergraphs that admit faithful orthogonal representations by rays in complex three-dimensional space but admit none in real three-dimensional space. Thus, although each orthogonality diagram is unchanged, its coordinatizability in dimension three depends on whether the scalar field is complex or real. The first hypergraph has 20 vertices and 12 contexts. The second hypergraph adds one vertex and two contexts. Phase-adjusted realification also gives explicit faithful orthogonal representations of both hypergraphs in real six-dimensional space.

We establish a strict logical separation between two distinct phenomena in orthogonality hypergraphs: chromatic completeness, the possibility of assigning a single globally consistent nondegenerate spectrum to all contexts, and geometric coordinatizability, the existence of a faithful orthogonal representation by rays. A strong chromatic number larger than the Hilbert-space dimension obstructs only the former. It does not, by itself, obstruct the existence of a faithful orthogonal representation. We make this separation explicit by comparing two three-dimensional examples with the same strong chromatic number. A completed 25-ray version of the Yu-Oh configuration has strong chromatic number four and nevertheless possesses an explicit faithful orthogonal representation in R^3. Conversely, Greechie's G_{32} hypergraph also has strong chromatic number four, and has a separating and unital set of two-valued states, but we give an elementary algebraic proof that it admits no faithful orthogonal representation in C^3. The obstruction in G_{32} is therefore not chromatic but projective-geometric: the incidence relations force two distinct atoms to collapse onto the same ray.