arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given a family $\mathcal{F}$ of bipartite graphs, the {\it Zarankiewicz number} $z(m,n,\mathcal{F})$ is the maximum number of edges in an $m$ by $n$ bipartite graph $G$ that does not contain any member of $\mathcal{F}$ as a subgraph (such $G$ is called {\it $\mathcal{F}$-free}). For $1\leq β<α<2$, a family $\mathcal{F}$ of bipartite graphs is $(α,β)$-{\it smooth} if for some $ρ>0$ and every $m\leq n$, $z(m,n,\mathcal{F})=ρm n^{α-1}+O(n^β)$. Motivated by their work on a conjecture of Erdős and Simonovits on compactness and a classic result of Andrásfai, Erdős and Sós, in \cite{AKSV} Allen, Keevash, Sudakov and Verstraëte proved that for any $(α,β)$-smooth family $\mathcal{F}$, there exists $k_0$ such that for all odd $k\geq k_0$ and sufficiently large $n$, any $n$-vertex $\mathcal{F}\cup\{C_k\}$-free graph with minimum degree at least $ρ(\frac{2n}{5}+o(n))^{α-1}$ is bipartite. In this paper, we strengthen their result by showing that for every real $δ>0$, there exists $k_0$ such that for all odd $k\geq k_0$ and sufficiently large $n$, any $n$-vertex $\mathcal{F}\cup\{C_k\}$-free graph with minimum degree at least $δn^{α-1}$ is bipartite. Furthermore, our result holds under a more relaxed notion of smoothness, which include the families $\mathcal{F}$ consisting of the single graph $K_{s,t}$ when $t\gg s$. We also prove an analogous result for $C_{2\ell}$-free graphs for every $\ell\geq 2$, which complements a result of Keevash, Sudakov and Verstraëte in \cite{KSV}.

We obtain some new upper bounds on the maximum number $f(n)$ of edges in $n$-vertex graphs without containing cycles of length four. This leads to an asymptotically optimal bound on $f(n)$ for a broad range of integers $n$ as well as a disproof of a conjecture of Erdős from 1970s which asserts that $f(n)=\frac12 n^{3/2}+\frac14 n+o(n)$.

For positive integers $n>d\geq k$, let $φ(n,d,k)$ denote the least integer $φ$ such that every $n$-vertex graph with at least $φ$ vertices of degree at least $d$ contains a path on $k+1$ vertices. Many years ago, Erdős, Faudree, Schelp and Simonovits proposed the study of the function $φ(n,d,k)$, and conjectured that for any positive integers $n>d\geq k$, it holds that $φ(n,d,k)\leq \lfloor\frac{k-1}{2}\rfloor\lfloor\frac{n}{d+1}\rfloor+ε$, where $ε=1$ if $k$ is odd and $ε=2$ otherwise. In this paper we determine the values of the function $φ(n,d,k)$ exactly. This confirms the above conjecture of Erdős et al. for all positive integers $k\neq 4$ and in a corrected form for the case $k=4$. Our proof utilizes, among others, a lemma of Erdős et al. \cite{EFSS89}, a theorem of Jackson \cite{J81}, and a (slight) extension of a very recent theorem of Kostochka, Luo and Zirlin \cite{KLZ}, where the latter two results concern maximum cycles in bipartite graphs. Moreover, we construct examples to provide answers to two closely related questions raised by Erdős et al.

Given integers $m$ and $f$, let $S_n(m,f)$ consist of all integers $e$ such that every $n$-vertex graph with $e$ edges contains an $m$-vertex induced subgraph with $f$ edges, and let $σ(m,f)=\limsup_{n\rightarrow\infty} |S_n(m,f)|/\binom{n}{2}$. As a natural extension of an extremal problem of Erdős, this was investigated by Erdős, Füredi, Rothschild and Sós twenty years ago. Their main result indicates that integers in $S_n(m,f)$ are rare for most pairs $(m,f)$, though they also found infinitely many pairs $(m,f)$ whose $σ(m,f)$ is a fixed positive constant. Here we aim to provide some improvements on this study. Our first result shows that $σ(m,f)\leq \frac12$ holds for all but finitely many pairs $(m,f)$ and the constant $\frac12$ cannot be improved. This answers a question of Erdős et. al. Our second result considers infinitely many pairs $(m,f)$ of special forms, whose exact values of $σ(m,f)$ were conjectured by Erdős et. al. We partially solve this conjecture (only leaving two open cases) by making progress on some constructions which are related to number theory. Our proofs are based on the research of Erdős et. al and involve different arguments in number theory. We also discuss some related problems.

Resolving a conjecture of Bollobás and Erdős, Gyárfás proved that every graph $G$ of chromatic number $k+1\geq 3$ contains cycles of $\lfloor\frac{k}{2}\rfloor$ distinct odd lengths. We strengthen this prominent result by showing that such $G$ contains cycles of $\lfloor\frac{k}{2}\rfloor$ consecutive odd lengths. Along the way, combining extremal and structural tools, we prove a stronger statement that every graph of chromatic number $k+1\geq 7$ contains $k$ cycles of consecutive lengths, except that some block is $K_{k+1}$. As corollaries, this confirms a conjecture of Verstraëte and answers a question of Moore and West.

Aharoni and Howard, and, independently, Huang, Loh, and Sudakov proposed the following rainbow version of Erdős matching conjecture: For positive integers $n,k,m$ with $n\ge km$, if each of the families $F_1,\ldots, F_m\subseteq {[n]\choose k}$ has size more than $\max\{\binom{n}{k} - \binom{n-m+1}{k}, \binom{km-1}{k}\}$, then there exist pairwise disjoint subsets $e_1,\dots, e_m$ such that $e_i\in F_i$ for all $i\in [m]$. We prove that there exists an absolute constant $n_0$ such that this rainbow version holds for $k=3$ and $n\geq n_0$. We convert this rainbow matching problem to a matching problem on a special hypergraph $H$. We then combine several existing techniques on matchings in uniform hypergraphs: find an absorbing matching $M$ in $H$; use a randomization process of Alon et al. to find an almost regular subgraph of $H-V(M)$; and find an almost perfect matching in $H-V(M)$. To complete the process, we also need to prove a new result on matchings in 3-uniform hypergraphs, which can be viewed as a stability version of a result of Łuczak and Mieczkowska and might be of independent interest.

Akin to the Erdős-Rademacher problem, Linial and Morgenstern made the following conjecture in tournaments: for any $d\in (0,1]$, among all $n$-vertex tournaments with $d\binom{n}{3}$ many 3-cycles, the number of 4-cycles is asymptotically minimized by a special random blow-up of a transitive tournament. Recently, Chan, Grzesik, Král' and Noel introduced spectrum analysis of adjacency matrices of tournaments in this study, and confirmed this for $d\geq 1/36$. In this paper, we investigate the analogous problem of minimizing the number of cycles of a given length. We prove that for integers $\ell\not\equiv 2\mod 4$, there exists some constant $c_\ell>0$ such that if $d\geq 1-c_\ell$, then the number of $\ell$-cycles is also asymptotically minimized by the same family of extremal examples for $4$-cycles. In doing so, we answer a question of Linial and Morgenstern about minimizing the $q$-norm of a probabilistic vector with given $p$-norm for any integers $q>p>1$. For integers $\ell\equiv 2\mod 4$, however the same phenomena do not hold for $\ell$-cycles, for which we can construct an explicit family of tournaments containing fewer $\ell$-cycles for any given number of $3$-cycles. We conclude by proposing two conjectures on the minimization problem for general cycles in tournaments.

Combining Pósa's rotation lemma with a technique of Kopylov in a novel approach, we prove a generalization of the Erdős-Gallai theorems on cycles and paths. This implies a clique version of the Erdős-Gallai stability theorems and also provides alternative proofs for some recent results.

We consider the problem of maximizing the number of induced copies of an oriented star $S_{k,\ell}$ in digraphs of given size, where the center of the star has out-degree $k$ and in-degree $\ell$. The case $k\ell=0$ was solved by Huang. Here, we asymptotically solve it for all other oriented stars with at least seven vertices.

A conjecture of Chung and Graham states that every $K_4$-free graph on $n$ vertices contains a vertex set of size $\lfloor n/2 \rfloor$ that spans at most $n^2/18$ edges. We make the first step toward this conjecture by showing that it holds for all regular graphs.

We prove a conjecture of Boros, Caro, Füredi and Yuster on the maximum number of edges in a 2-connected graph without repeated cycle lengths, which is a restricted version of a longstanding problem of Erdős. Our proof together with the matched lower bound construction of Boros, Caro, Füredi and Yuster show that this problem can be conceptually reduced to the seminal problem of finding the maximum Sidon sequences in number theory.

We show that for every rational number $r \in (1,2)$ of the form $2 - a/b$, where $a, b \in \mathbb{N}^+$ satisfy $\lfloor b/a \rfloor^3 \le a \le b / (\lfloor b/a \rfloor +1) + 1$, there exists a graph $F_r$ such that the Turán number $\operatorname{ex}(n, F_r) = Θ(n^r)$. Our result in particular generates infinitely many new Turán exponents. As a byproduct, we formulate a framework that is taking shape in recent work on the Bukh--Conlon conjecture.

A well-known result of Verstraëte \cite{V00} shows that for each integer $k\geq 2$ every graph $G$ with average degree at least $8k$ contains cycles of $k$ consecutive even lengths, the shortest of which is at most twice the radius of $G$. We establish two extensions of Verstraëte's result for linear cycles in linear $r$-uniform hypergraphs. We show that for any fixed integers $r\geq 3,k\geq 2$, there exist constants $c_1=c_1(r)$ and $c_2=c_2(r,k)$, such that every linear $r$-uniform hypergraph $G$ with average degree $d(G)\geq c_1 k$ contains linear cycles of $k$ consecutive even lengths, the shortest of which is at most $2\lceil \frac{ \log n}{\log (d(G)/k)-c_2}\rceil$. In particular, as an immediate corollary, we retrieve the current best known upper bound on the linear Turán number of $C^r_{2k}$ with improved coefficients. Furthermore, we show that for any fixed integers $r\geq 3,k\geq 2$, there exist constants $c_3=c_3(r)$ and $c_4=c_4(r)$ such that every $n$-vertex linear $r$-uniform graph with average degree $d(G)\geq c_3k$, contains linear cycles of $k$ consecutive lengths, the shortest of which has length at most $6\lceil \frac{\log n}{\log (d(G)/k)-c_4} \rceil +6$. Both the degree condition and the shortest length among the cycles guaranteed are best possible up to a constant factor.

Extremal problems on the $4$-cycle $C_4$ played a heuristic important role in the development of extremal graph theory. A fundamental theorem of Füredi states that the Turán number $ex(q^2+q+1, C_4)\leq \frac12 q(q+1)^2$ holds for every $q\geq 14$, which matches with the classic construction of Erdős-R{é}nyi-Sós and Brown from finite geometry for prime powers $q$. Very recently, we obtained the first stability result on Füredi's theorem, by showing that for large even $q$, every $(q^2+q+1)$-vertex $C_4$-free graph with more than $\frac12 q(q+1)^2-0.2q$ edges must be a spanning subgraph of a unique polarity graph. Using new technical ideas in graph theory and finite geometry, we strengthen this by showing that the same conclusion remains true if the number of edges is lowered to $\frac12 q(q+1)^2-\frac12 q+o(q)$. Among other applications, this gives an immediate improvement on the upper bound of $ex(n,C_4)$ for infinitely many integers $n$. A longstanding conjecture of Erdős and Simonovits states that every $n$-vertex graph with $ex(n,C_4)+1$ edges contains at least $(1+o(1))\sqrt{n}$ 4-cycles. We proved an exact result and confirmed Erdős-Simonovits conjecture for infinitely many integers $n$. As the second main result of this paper, we further characterize all extremal graphs for which achieve the $\ell$th least number of copies of $C_4$ for any fixed positive integer $\ell$. This can be extended to more general settings and provides enhancements on the understanding of the supersaturation problem of $C_4$.

For integers $n\ge 0$, an iterated triangulation $Tr(n)$ is defined recursively as follows: $Tr(0)$ is the plane triangulation on three vertices and, for $n\ge 1$, $Tr(n)$ is the plane triangulation obtained from the plane triangulation $Tr(n-1)$ by, for each inner face $F$ of $Tr(n-1)$, adding inside $F$ a new vertex and three edges joining this new vertex to the three vertices incident with $F$. In this paper, we show that there exists a 2-edge-coloring of $Tr(n)$ such that $Tr(n)$ contains no monochromatic copy of the cycle $C_k$ for any $k\ge 5$. As a consequence, the answer to one of two questions asked by Axenovich, Schade, Thomassen and Ueckerdt is negative. We also determine the radius two graphs $H$ for which there exists $n$ such that every 2-edge-coloring of $Tr(n)$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H$, extending a result of the above authors for radius two trees.

Gallai asked in 1984 if any $k$-critical graph on $n$ vertices contains at least $n$ distinct $(k-1)$-critical subgraphs. The answer is trivial for $k\leq 3$. Improving a result of Stiebitz, Abbott and Zhou proved in 1995 that for all $k\geq 4$, such graph contains $Ω(n^{1/(k-1)})$ distinct $(k-1)$-critical subgraphs. Since then no progress had been made until very recently, Hare resolved the case $k=4$ by showing that any $4$-critical graph on $n$ vertices contains at least $(8n-29)/3$ odd cycles. In this paper, we mainly focus on 4-critical graphs and develop some novel tools for counting cycles of specified parity. Our main result shows that any $4$-critical graph on $n$ vertices contains $Ω(n^2)$ odd cycles, which is tight up to a constant factor by infinite many graphs. As a crucial step, we prove the same bound for 3-connected non-bipartite graphs, which may be of independent interest. Using the tools, we also give a very short proof for the case $k=4$. Moreover, we improve the longstanding lower bound of Abbott and Zhou to $Ω(n^{1/(k-2)})$ for the general case $k\geq 5$. We will also discuss some related problems on $k$-critical graphs in the final section.

Answering a question of Häggkvist and Scott, Verstraëte proved that every sufficiently large graph with average degree at least $k^2+19k+10$ contains $k$ vertex-disjoint cycles of consecutive even lengths. He further conjectured that the same holds for every graph $G$ with average degree at least $k^2+3k+2$. In this paper we prove this conjecture for $k\geq 19$ when $G$ is sufficiently large. We also show that for any $ε>0$ and large $k\geq k_ε$, average degree at least $k^2+3k-2+ε$ suffices, which is asymptotically tight for infinitely many graphs.

In this paper, we prove a tight minimum degree condition in general graphs for the existence of paths between two given endpoints, whose lengths form a long arithmetic progression with common difference one or two. This allows us to obtain a number of exact and optimal results on cycle lengths in graphs of given minimum degree, connectivity or chromatic number. More precisely, we prove the following statements by a unified approach. (1) Every graph $G$ with minimum degree at least $k+1$ contains cycles of all even lengths modulo $k$; in addition, if $G$ is 2-connected and non-bipartite, then it contains cycles of all lengths modulo $k$. (2) For all $k\geq 3$, every $k$-connected graph contains a cycle of length zero modulo $k$. (3) Every 3-connected non-bipartite graph with minimum degree at least $k+1$ contains $k$ cycles of consecutive lengths. (4) Every graph with chromatic number at least $k+2$ contains $k$ cycles of consecutive lengths. The first statement is a conjecture of Thomassen, the second is a conjecture of Dean, the third is a tight answer to a question of Bondy and Vince, and the fourth is a conjecture of Sudakov and Verstraëte. All of the above results are best possible.

Twenty years ago Bondy and Vince conjectured that for any nonnegative integer $k$, except finitely many counterexamples, every graph with $k$ vertices of degree less than three contains two cycles whose lengths differ by one or two. The case $k\leq 2$ was proved by Bondy and Vince, which resolved an earlier conjecture of Erdős et. al.. In this paper we confirm this conjecture for all $k$.

A long-standing conjecture of Erdős and Simonovits asserts that for every rational number $r\in (1,2)$ there exists a bipartite graph $H$ such that $\ex(n,H)=Θ(n^r)$. So far this conjecture is known to be true only for rationals of form $1+1/k$ and $2-1/k$, for integers $k\geq 2$. In this paper we add a new form of rationals for which the conjecture is true; $2-2/(2k+1)$, for $k\geq 2$. This in its turn also gives an affirmative answer to a question of Pinchasi and Sharir on cube-like graphs. Recently, a version of Erdős and Simonovits's conjecture where one replaces a single graph by a family, was confirmed by Bukh and Conlon. They proposed a construction of bipartite graphs which should satisfy Erdős and Simonovits's conjecture. Our result can also be viewed as a first step towards verifying Bukh and Conlon's conjecture. We also prove the an upper bound on the Turán's number of $θ$-graphs in an asymmetric setting and employ this result to obtain yet another new rational exponent for Turán exponents; $r=7/5$.