arXiv++ Combinatorics

This exposition contains a short and streamlined proof of the recent result of Kwan, Letzter, Sudakov and Tran that every triangle-free graph with minimum degree $d$ contains an induced bipartite subgraph with average degree $Ω(\ln d/\ln\ln d)$.

The first author together with Jenssen, Perkins and Roberts (2017) recently showed how local properties of the hard-core model on triangle-free graphs guarantee the existence of large independent sets, of size matching the best-known asymptotics due to Shearer (1983). The present work strengthens this in two ways: first, by guaranteeing stronger graph structure in terms of colourings through applications of the Lovász local lemma; and second, by extending beyond triangle-free graphs in terms of local sparsity, treating for example graphs of bounded local edge density, of bounded local Hall ratio, and of bounded clique number. This generalises and improves upon much other earlier work, including that of Shearer (1995), Alon (1996) and Alon, Krivelevich and Sudakov (1999), and more recent results of Molloy (2019), Bernshteyn (2019) and Achlioptas, Iliopoulos and Sinclair (2019). Our results derive from a common framework built around the hard-core model. It pivots on a property we call local occupancy, giving a clean separation between the methods for deriving graph structure with probabilistic information and verifying the requisite probabilistic information itself.

The Maximum Weight Independent Set Problem (WIS) is a well-known NP-hard problem. A popular way to study WIS is to detect graph classes for which WIS can be solved in polynomial time, with particular reference to hereditary graph classes, i.e., defined by a hereditary graph property or equivalently by forbidding one or more induced subgraphs. Given two graphs $G$ and $H$, $G+H$ denotes the disjoint union of $G$ and $H$. This manuscript shows that (i) WIS can be solved for ($P_4+P_4$, Triangle)-free graphs in polynomial time, where a $P_4$ is an induced path of four vertices and a Triangle is a cycle of three vertices, and that in particular it turns out that (ii) for every ($P_4+P_4$, Triangle)-free graph $G$ there is a family ${\cal S}$ of subsets of $V(G)$ inducing (complete) bipartite subgraphs of $G$, which contains polynomially many members and can be computed in polynomial time, such that every maximal independent set of $G$ is contained in some member of ${\cal S}$. These results seem to be harmonic with respect to other polynomial results for WIS on certain [subclasses of] $S_{i,j,k}$-free graphs and to other structure results on [subclasses of] Triangle-free graphs.

An orientation of a graph is semi-transitive if it is acyclic, and for any directed path $v_0\rightarrow v_1\rightarrow \cdots\rightarrow v_k$ either there is no arc between $v_0$ and $v_k$, or $v_i\rightarrow v_j$ is an arc for all $0\leq i<j\leq k$. An undirected graph is semi-transitive if it admits a semi-transitive orientation. Semi-transitive graphs generalize several important classes of graphs and they are precisely the class of word-representable graphs studied extensively in the literature. Determining if a triangle-free graph is semi-transitive is an NP-hard problem. The existence of non-semi-transitive triangle-free graphs was established via Erdős' theorem by Halldórsson and the authors in 2011. However, no explicit examples of such graphs were known until recent work of the first author and Saito who have shown computationally that a certain subgraph on 16 vertices of the triangle-free Kneser graph $K(8,3)$ is not semi-transitive, and have raised the question on the existence of smaller triangle-free non-semi-transitive graphs. In this paper we prove that the smallest triangle-free 4-chromatic graph on 11 vertices (the Grötzsch graph) and the smallest triangle-free 4-chromatic 4-regular graph on 12 vertices (the Chvátal graph) are not semi-transitive. Hence, the Grötzsch graph is the smallest triangle-free non-semi-transitive graph. We also prove the existence of semi-transitive graphs of girth 4 with chromatic number 4 including a small one (the circulant graph $C(13;1,5)$ on 13 vertices) and dense ones (Toft's graphs). Finally, we show that each $4$-regular circulant graph (possibly containing triangles) is semi-transitive.

We propose the total staggered quantum walk model and the total tessellation cover of a graph. This model uses the concept of total tessellation cover to describe the motion of the walker who is allowed to hop both to vertices and edges of the graph, in contrast with previous models in which the walker hops either to vertices or edges. We establish bounds on $T_t(G)$, which is the smallest number of tessellations required in a total tessellation cover of $G$. We highlight two of these lower bounds $T_t(G) \geq ω(G)$ and $T_t(G)\geq is(G)+1$, where $ω(G)$ is the size of a maximum clique and $is(G)$ is the number of edges of a maximum induced star subgraph. Using these bounds, we define the good total tessellable graphs with either $T_t(G)=ω(G)$ or $T_t(G)=is(G)+1$. The $k$-total tessellability problem aims to decide whether a given graph $G$ has $T_t(G) \leq k$. We show that $k$-total tessellability is in $\mathcal{P}$ for good total tessellable graphs. We establish the $\mathcal{NP}$-completeness of the following problems when restricted to the following classes: ($is(G)+1$)-total tessellability for graphs with $ω(G) = 2$; $ω(G)$-total tessellability for graphs $G$ with $is(G)+1 = 3$; $k$-total tessellability for graphs $G$ with $\max\{ω(G), is(G)+1\}$ far from $k$; and $4$-total tessellability for graphs $G$ with $ω(G) = is(G)+1 = 4$. As a consequence, we establish hardness results for bipartite graphs, line graphs of triangle-free graphs, universal graphs, planar graphs, and $(2,1)$-chordal graphs.

Let $G$ be a finite, connected graph. The average distance of a vertex $v$ of $G$ is the arithmetic mean of the distances from $v$ to all other vertices of $G$. The remoteness $ρ(G)$ and the proximity $π(G)$ of $G$ are the maximum and the minimum of the average distances of the vertices of $G$. In this paper, we present a sharp upper bound on the remoteness of a triangle-free graph of given order and minimum degree, and a corresponding bound on the proximity, which is sharp apart from an additive constant. We also present upper bounds on the remoteness and proximity of $C_4$-free graphs of given order and minimum degree, and we demonstrate that these are close to being best possible.

Given positive integers $n\ge s$, we let ${\mathrm{ex}}(n,s)$ denote the maximum number of edges in a triangle-free graph $G$ on $n$ vertices with $α(G)\le s$. In the early sixties Andrásfai conjectured that for $n/3<s<n/2$ the function ${\mathrm{ex}}(n, s)$ is piecewise quadratic with critical values at $s/n={k}/({3k-1})$. We confirm that this is indeed the case whenever $s/n$ is slightly larger than a critical value, thus determining ${\mathrm{ex}}(n,s)$ for all $n$ and $s$ such that $s/n\in [{k}/({3k-1}), {k}/({3k-1})+γ_k]$, where $γ_k=Θ(k^{-6})$.

One of the oldest results in modern graph theory, due to Mantel, asserts that every triangle-free graphs on $n$ vertices has at most $\lfloor n^2/4\rfloor$ edges. About half a century later Andrásfai studied dense triangle-free graphs and proved that the largest triangle-free graphs on $n$ vertices without independent sets of size $αn$, where $2/5\le α< 1/2$, are blow-ups of the pentagon. More than 50 further years have elapsed since Andrásfai's work. In this article we make the next step towards understanding the structure of dense triangle-free graphs without large independent sets. Notably, we determine the maximum size of triangle-free graphs~$G$ on $n$ vertices with $α(G)\ge 3n/8$ and state a conjecture on the structure of the densest triangle-free graphs $G$ with $α(G) > n/3$. We remark that the case $α(G) \le n/3$ behaves differently, but due to the work of Brandt this situation is fairly well understood.

Motivated by a recent conjecture of the first author, we prove that every properly coloured triangle-free graph of chromatic number $χ$ contains a rainbow independent set of size $\lceil\frac12χ\rceil$. This is sharp up to a factor $2$. This result and its short proof have implications for the related notion of chromatic discrepancy. Drawing inspiration from both structural and extremal graph theory, we conjecture that every triangle-free graph of chromatic number $χ$ contains an induced cycle of length $Ω(χ\logχ)$ as $χ\to\infty$. Even if one only demands an induced path of length $Ω(χ\logχ)$, the conclusion would be sharp up to a constant multiple. We prove it for regular girth $5$ graphs and for girth $21$ graphs. As a common strengthening of the induced paths form of this conjecture and of Johansson's theorem (1996), we posit the existence of some $c >0$ such that for every forest $H$ on $D$ vertices, every triangle-free and induced $H$-free graph has chromatic number at most $c D/\log D$. We prove this assertion with `triangle-free' replaced by `regular girth $5$'.

Every $n$-vertex planar triangle-free graph with maximum degree at most $3$ has an independent set of size at least $\frac{3}{8}n$. This was first conjectured by Albertson, Bollobás and Tucker, and was later proved by Heckman and Thomas. Fraughnaugh and Locke conjectured that the planarity requirement could be relaxed into just forbidding a few specific nonplanar subgraphs: They described a family $\mathcal{F}$ of six nonplanar graphs (each of order at most $22$) and conjectured that every $n$-vertex triangle-free graph with maximum degree at most $3$ having no subgraph isomorphic to a member of $\mathcal{F}$ has an independent set of size at least $\frac{3}{8}n$. In this paper, we prove this conjecture. As a corollary, we obtain that every $2$-connected $n$-vertex triangle-free graph with maximum degree at most $3$ has an independent set of size at least $\frac{3}{8}n$, with the exception of the six graphs in $\mathcal{F}$. This confirms a conjecture made independently by Bajnok and Brinkmann, and by Fraughnaugh and Locke.

The niche graph of a digraph $D$ has $V(D)$ as the vertex set and an edge $uv$ if and only if $(u,w) \in A(D)$ and $(v,w) \in A(D)$, or $(w,u) \in A(D)$ and $(w,v) \in A(D)$ for some $w \in V(D)$. The notion of niche graph was introduced by Cable et al. (1989) as a variant of competition graph. If a graph is the niche graph of a digraph $D$, it is said to be niche-realizable through $D$. If a graph $G$ is niche-realizable through a $k$-partite tournament for an integer $k \ge 2$, then we say that the pair $(G, k)$ is niche-realizable. Bowser et al. (1999) studied the graphs that are niche-realizable through a tournament and Eoh et al. (2018) studied niche-realizable pairs $(G, k)$ for $k=2$. In this paper, we study niche-realizable pairs $(G, k)$ when $G$ is a graph and $k$ is an integer at least $3$ to extend their work. We show that the niche graph of a $k$-partite tournament has at most three components if $k \ge 3$ and is connected if $k \ge 4$. Then we find all the niche-realizable pairs $(G, k)$ when $G$ is a disconnected graph, when $G$ is a complete graph, and when $G$ is a connected triangle-free graph.

One powerful method for upper-bounding the largest independent set in a graph is the Hoffman bound, which gives an upper bound on the largest independent set of a graph in terms of its eigenvalues. It is easily seen that the Hoffman bound is sharp on the tensor power of a graph whenever it is sharp for the original graph. In this paper, we introduce the related problem of upper-bounding independent sets in tensor powers of hypergraphs. We show that many of the prominent open problems in extremal combinatorics, such as the Turán problem for (hyper-)graphs, can be encoded as special cases of this problem. We also give a new generalization of the Hoffman bound for hypergraphs which is sharp for the tensor power of a hypergraph whenever it is sharp for the original hypergraph. As an application of our Hoffman bound, we make progress on the problem of Frankl on families of sets without extended triangles from 1990. We show that if $\frac{1}{2}n\le2k\le\frac{2}{3}n,$ then the extremal family is the star, i.e. the family of all sets that contains a given element. This covers the entire range in which the star is extremal. As another application, we provide spectral proofs for Mantel's theorem on triangle-free graphs and for Frankl-Tokushige theorem on $k$-wise intersecting families.

For a graph $G$, let $a(G)$ denote the maximum size of a subset of vertices that induces a forest. We prove the following. 1. Let $G$ be a graph of order $n$, maximum degree $Δ>0$ and maximum clique size $ω$. Then \[ a(G) \geq \frac{6n}{2Δ+ ω+2}. \] This bound is sharp for cliques. 2. Let $G=(V,E)$ be a triangle-free graph and let $d(v)$ denote the degree of $v \in V$. Then \[ a(G) \geq \sum_{v \in V} \min\left(1, \frac{3}{d(v)+2} \right). \] As a corollary we have that a triangle-free graph $G$ of order $n$, with $m$ edges and average degree $d \geq 2$ satisfies \[ a(G) \geq \frac{3n}{d+2}. \] This improves the lower bound $n - \frac{m}{4}$ of Alon-Mubayi-Thomas for graphs of average degree greater than $4$. Furthermore it improves the lower bound $\frac{20n - 5m - 5}{19}$ of Shi-Xu for (connected) graphs of average degree at least $\frac{9}{2}$.

Let G be a simple connected plane graph and let C_1 and C_2 be cycles in G bounding distinct faces f_1 and f_2. For a positive integer l, let r(l) denote the number of integers n such that -l<=n<=l, n is divisible by 3, and n has the same parity as l; in particular, r(4)=1. Let r_{f_1,f_2}(G) be the product of r(|f|) over all faces f of G distinct from f_1 and f_2, and let q(G)=1+sum_{f:|f|\neq 4} |f|, where the sum is over all faces f of G. We give an algorithm with time complexity O(r_{f_1,f_2}(G)q(G)|G|) which, given a 3-coloring psi of C_1 and C_2, either finds an extension of psi to a 3-coloring of G, or correctly decides no such extension exists. The algorithm is based on a min-max theorem for a variant of integer 2- commodity flows, and consequently in the negative case produces an obstruction to the existence of the extension. As a corollary, we show that every triangle-free graph drawn in the torus with edge-width at least 21 is 3-colorable.

A graph is \emph{well-dominated} if all of its minimal dominating sets have the same cardinality. We prove that at least one of the factors is well-dominated if the Cartesian product of two graphs is well-dominated. In addition, we show that the Cartesian product of two connected, triangle-free graphs is well-dominated if and only if both graphs are complete graphs of order $2$. Under the assumption that at least one of the connected graphs $G$ or $H$ has no isolatable vertices, we prove that the direct product of $G$ and $H$ is well-dominated if and only if either $G=H=K_3$ or $G=K_2$ and $H$ is either the $4$-cycle or the corona of a connected graph. Furthermore, we show that the disjunctive product of two connected graphs is well-dominated if and only if one of the factors is a complete graph and the other factor has domination number at most $2$.

Let $G$ be a connected finite graph with vertex set $V(G)$. The eccentricity $e(v)$ of a vertex $v$ is the distance from $v$ to a vertex farthest from $v$. The average eccentricity of $G$ is defined as $\frac{1}{|V(G)|}\sum_{v \in V(G)}e(v)$. We show that the average eccentricity of a connected graph of order $n$, minimum degree $δ$ and maximum degree $Δ$ does not exceed $\frac{9}{4} \frac{n-Δ-1}{δ+1} \big( 1 + \frac{Δ-δ}{3n} \big) + 7$, and this bound is sharp apart from an additive constant. We give improved bounds for triangle-free graphs and for graphs not containing a $4$-cycles.

Let $γ_g(G)$ and $γ_{tg}(G)$ be the game domination number and the total game domination number of a graph $G$, respectively. Then $G$ is $γ_g$-perfect (resp. $γ_{tg}$-perfect), if every induced subgraph $F$ of $G$ satisfies $γ_g(F)=γ(F)$ (resp. $γ_{tg}(F)=γ_t(F)$). A recursive characterization of $γ_g$-perfect graphs is derived. The characterization yields a polynomial recognition algorithm for $γ_g$-perfect graphs. It is proved that every minimally $γ_g$-imperfect graph has domination number $2$. All minimally $γ_g$-imperfect triangle-free graphs are determined. It is also proved that $γ_{tg}$-perfect graphs are precisely $\overline{2P_3}$-free cographs.

The celebrated Hadwiger's conjecture states that if a graph contains no $K_{t+1}$ minor then it is $t$-colourable. If true, it would in particular imply that every $n$-vertex $K_{t+1}$-minor-free graph has an independent set of size at least $n/t$. In 1982, Duchet and Meyniel proved that this bound holds within a factor $2$. Their bound has been improved; most notably in an absolute factor by Fox, which was later improved by Balogh and Kostochka. Here we consider the same question for triangle-free graphs. By the results of Shearer and Kostochka and Thomason, it follows that any triangle-free graph with no $K_t$ minor has an independent set of size $Ω(\tfrac{\sqrt{\log{t}}}{t}n)$. We show that a much larger independent set exists; for all sufficiently large $t$ every triangle-free graph on $n$ vertices with no $K_t$-minor has an independent set of size $ \tfrac{n}{t^{1-\varepsilon}}$. This answers a question of Sergey Norin.

We explore connections between the phenomenon of correlation decay and the location of Lee-Yang and Fisher zeros for various spin systems. In particular we show that, in many instances, proofs showing that weak spatial mixing on the Bethe lattice (infinite $Δ$-regular tree) implies strong spatial mixing on all graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ can be lifted to the complex plane, establishing the absence of zeros of the associated partition function in a complex neighborhood of the region in parameter space corresponding to strong spatial mixing. This allows us to give unified proofs of several recent results of this kind, including the resolution by Peters and Regts of the Sokal conjecture for the partition function of the hard core lattice gas. It also allows us to prove new results on the location of Lee-Yang zeros of the anti-ferromagnetic Ising model. We show further that our methods extend to the case when weak spatial mixing on the Bethe lattice is not known to be equivalent to strong spatial mixing on all graphs. In particular, we show that results on strong spatial mixing in the anti-ferromagnetic Potts model can be lifted to the complex plane to give new zero-freeness results for the associated partition function. This extension allows us to give the first deterministic FPTAS for counting the number of $q$-colorings of a graph of maximum degree $Δ$ provided only that $q\ge 2Δ$. This matches the natural bound for randomized algorithms obtained by a straightforward application of Markov chain Monte Carlo. We also give an improved version of this result for triangle-free graphs.

Let $x_1, \ldots, x_n \in \mathbb{R}^d$ be unit vectors such that among any three there is an orthogonal pair. How large can $n$ be as a function of $d$, and how large can the length of $x_1 + \ldots + x_n$ be? The answers to these two celebrated questions, asked by Erdős and Lovász, are closely related to orthonormal representations of triangle-free graphs, in particular to their Lovász $\vartheta$-function and minimum semidefinite rank. In this paper, we study these parameters for general $H$-free graphs. In particular, we show that for certain bipartite graphs $H$, there is a connection between the Turán number of $H$ and the maximum of $\vartheta \left( \overline{G} \right)$ over all $H$-free graphs $G$.