arXiv++ Combinatorics

Kostochka and Thomason independently showed that any graph with average degree $Ω(r\sqrt{\log r})$ contains a $K_r$ minor. In particular, any graph with chromatic number $Ω(r\sqrt{\log r})$ contains a $K_r$ minor, a partial result towards Hadwiger's famous conjecture. In this paper, we investigate analogues of these results in the directed setting. There are several ways to define a minor in a digraph. One natural way is as follows. A strong $\overrightarrow{K}_r$ minor is a digraph whose vertex set is partitioned into $r$ parts such that each part induces a strongly-connected subdigraph, and there is at least one edge in each direction between any two distinct parts. We investigate bounds on the dichromatic number and minimum out-degree of a digraph that force the existence of strong $\overrightarrow{K}_r$ minors as subdigraphs. In particular, we show that any tournament with dichromatic number at least $2r$ contains a strong $\overrightarrow{K}_r$ minor, and any tournament with minimum out-degree $Ω(r\sqrt{\log r})$ also contains a strong $\overrightarrow{K}_r$ minor. The latter result is tight up to the implied constant, and may be viewed as a strong-minor analogue to the classical result of Kostochka and Thomason. Lastly, we show that there is no function $f: \mathbb{N} \rightarrow \mathbb{N}$ such that any digraph with minimum out-degree at least $f(r)$ contains a strong $\overrightarrow{K}_r$ minor, but such a function exists when considering dichromatic number.

In this short note we prove that every tournament contains the $k$-th power of a directed path of linear length. This improves upon recent results of Yuster and of Girão. We also give a complete solution for this problem when $k=2$, showing that there is always a square of a directed path of length $\lceil 2n/3 \rceil-1$, which is best possible.

A square of a path on $k$ vertices is a directed path $x_1\ldots x_k$, where $x_i$ is directed to $x_{i+2}$, for every $i\in \{1,\ldots, k-1\}$. Recently, Yuster showed that any tournament on $n$ vertices contains a square of a path of length at least $n^{0.295}$. In this short note, we improve this bound. More precisely, we show that for every $\varepsilon>0$, there exists $c_{\varepsilon}>0$ such that any tournament on $n$ vertices contains a square of a path on at least $c_{\varepsilon}n^{1-\varepsilon}$ vertices.

A shortcut of a directed path $v_1 v_2 \cdots v_n$ is an edge $v_iv_j$ with $j > i+1$. If $j = i+2$ the shortcut is called a hop. If all hops are present, the path is called hop complete, so the path and its hops form a square of a path. We prove that every tournament with $n \ge 4$ vertices has a Hamiltonian path with at least $(4n-10)/7$ hops, and has a hop complete path of order at least $n^{0.295}$. A spanning binary tree of a tournament is a spanning shortcut tree if for every vertex of the tree, all its left descendants are in-neighbors and all its right descendants are out-neighbors. It is well-known that every tournament contains a spanning shortcut tree. The number of shortcuts of a shortcut tree is the number of shortcuts of its unique induced Hamiltonian path. Let $t(n)$ denote the largest integer such that every tournament with $n$ vertices has a spanning shortcut tree with at least $t(n)$ shortcuts. We almost determine the asymptotic growth of $t(n)$ as it is proved that $Θ(n\log^2n) \ge t(n)-\frac{1}{2}\binom{n}{2} \ge Θ(n \log n)$.

In this paper, we discover all the triangle-free graphs that are competition graphs of multipartite tournaments.

A tournament is an orientation of a graph. Each edge represents a match, directed towards the winner. The score sequence lists the number of wins by each team. Landau (1953) characterized score sequences of the complete graph. Moon (1963) showed that the same conditions are necessary and sufficient for mean score sequences of random tournaments. We present short and natural proofs of these results that work for any graph using zonotopes from convex geometry. A zonotope is a linear image of a cube. Moon's Theorem follows by identifying elements of the cube with distributions and the linear map as the expectation operator. Our proof of Landau's Theorem combines zonotopal tilings with the theory of mixed subdivisions. We also show that any mean score sequence can be realized by a tournament that is random within a subforest, and deterministic otherwise.

A tournament on 8 or more vertices may be intrinsically linked as a directed graph. We begin the classification of intrinsically linked tournaments by examining their score sequences. While many distinct tournaments may have the same score sequence, there exist score sequences $S$ such that any tournament with score sequence $S$ has an embedding with no nonsplit consistently oriented link. We call such score sequences $\textit{linkless}$, and we show that the vast majority of score sequences for 8 vertex tournaments are linkless. We also extend these results to $n$ vertex tournaments and are able to classify many longer score sequences as well. We show that for any $n$, there exist at least $O(n)$ linkless score sequences, but we conjecture that the fraction of score sequences of length $n$ that are linkless goes to 0 as $n$ becomes large.

In this paper, we use the theory of Riordan matrices to introduce the notion of an oriented Riordan graph. The oriented Riordan graphs are a far-reaching generalization of the well known and well studied Toeplitz oriented graphs and tournament. The main focus in this paper is the study of structural properties of the oriented Riordan graphs which includes a fundamental decomposition theorem and fractal property. Finally, we introduce the generalization of the oriented Riordan graph who is called a $p$-Riordan graph.

We investigate bounds on the dichromatic number of digraphs which avoid a fixed digraph as a topological minor. For a digraph $F$, denote by $\text{mader}_{\vecχ}(F)$ the smallest integer $k$ such that every $k$-dichromatic digraph contains a subdivision of $F$. As our first main result, we prove that if $F$ is an orientation of a cycle then $\text{mader}_{\vecχ}(F)=v(F)$. This settles a conjecture of Aboulker, Cohen, Havet, Lochet, Moura and Thomassé. We also extend this result to the more general class of orientations of cactus graphs, and to bioriented forests. Our second main result is that $\text{mader}_{\vecχ}(F)=4$ for every tournament $F$ of order $4$. This is an extension of the classical result by Dirac that $4$-chromatic graphs contain a $K_4$-subdivision to directed graphs.

We show that performing just one round of the Sherali-Adams hierarchy gives an easy 7/3-approximation algorithm for the Feedback Vertex Set (FVST) problem in tournaments. This matches the best deterministic approximation algorithm for FVST due to Mnich, Williams, and Végh, and is a significant simplification and runtime improvement of their approach.

The orientation completion problem for a fixed class of oriented graphs asks whether a given partially oriented graph can be completed to an oriented graph in the class. Orientation completion problems have been studied recently for several classes of oriented graphs, yielding both polynomial time solutions and NP-completeness results. Local tournaments are a well-structured class of oriented graphs that generalize tournaments and their underlying graphs are intimately related to proper circular-arc graphs. Proper interval graphs are precisely those which can be oriented as acyclic local tournaments. It has been proved that the orientation completion problems for local tournaments and acyclic local tournaments are both polynomial time solvable. In this paper we identify the obstructions for acyclic local tournament orientation completions. These are in a sense minimal partially oriented graphs that cannot be completed to acyclic local tournaments. Our description of the obstructions imply that they can be recognized in polynomial time. In a companion paper we will determine all obstructions for local tournament orientation completions.

We study the asymptotic behavior of the maximum number of directed cycles of a given length in a tournament: let $c(\ell)$ be the limit of the ratio of the maximum number of cycles of length $\ell$ in an $n$-vertex tournament and the expected number of cycles of length $\ell$ in the random $n$-vertex tournament, when $n$ tends to infinity. It is well-known that $c(3)=1$ and $c(4)=4/3$. We show that $c(\ell)=1$ if and only if $\ell$ is not divisible by four, which settles a conjecture of Bartley and Day. If $\ell$ is divisible by four, we show that $1+2\cdot\left(2/π\right)^{\ell}\le c(\ell)\le 1+\left(2/π+o(1)\right)^{\ell}$ and determine the value $c(\ell)$ exactly for $\ell = 8$. We also give a full description of the asymptotic structure of tournaments with the maximum number of cycles of length $\ell$ when $\ell$ is not divisible by four or $\ell\in\{4,8\}$.

In a graph, a watchman's walk is a minimum closed dominating walk. Given a graph $G$ and a single watchman, the length of a watchman's walk in $G$ (the watchman number) is denoted by $w(G)$ and the typical goals of the watchman's walk problem is to determine $w(G)$ and find a watchman's walk in $G$. In this paper, we extend the watchman's walk problem to directed graphs. In a directed graph, we say that the watchman can only move to and see the vertices that are adjacent to him relative to outgoing arcs. That is, a watchman's walk is oriented and domination occurs in the direction of the arcs. The directed graphs this paper focuses on are families of tournaments and orientations of complete multipartite graphs. We give bounds on the watchman number and discuss its relationship to variants of the domination number.

It is proved that with finitely many possible exceptions, each cyclotomic scheme over finite field is determined up to isomorphism by the tensor of 2-dimensional intersection numbers; for infinitely many schemes, this result cannot be improved. As a consequence, the Weisfeiler-Leman dimension of a Paley graph or tournament is at most 3 with possible exception of several small graphs.

We say that a digraph $D$ is competitive if any pair of vertices has a common out-neighbor in $D$ and that a graph $G$ is competitively orientable if there exists a competitive orientation of $G$. The notion of competitive digraphs arose while studying digraph whose competition graphs are complete. We derive some useful properties of competitively orientable graphs and show that a complete graph of order $n$ is competitively orientable if and only if $n \geq 7$. Then we completely characterize a competitively orientable complete multipartite graph in terms of the sizes of its partite sets. Moreover, we present a way to build a competitive multipartite tournament in each of competitively orientable cases.

For a tournament $H$ with $h$ vertices, its typical density is $h!2^{-\binom{h}{2}}/aut(H)$, i.e. this is the expected density of $H$ in a random tournament. A family ${\mathcal F}$ of $h$-vertex tournaments is {\em dominant} if for all sufficiently large $n$, there exists an $n$-vertex tournament $G$ such that the density of each element of ${\mathcal F}$ in $G$ is larger than its typical density by a constant factor. Characterizing all dominant families is challenging already for small $h$. Here we characterize several large dominant families for every $h$. In particular, we prove the following for all $h$ sufficiently large: (i) For all tournaments $H^*$ with at least $5\log h$ vertices, the family of all $h$-vertex tournaments that contain $H^*$ as a subgraph is dominant. (ii) The family of all $h$-vertex tournaments whose minimum feedback arc set size is at most $\frac{1}{2}\binom{h}{2}-h^{3/2}\sqrt{\ln h}$ is dominant. For small $h$, we construct a dominant family of $6$ (i.e. $50\%$ of the) tournaments on $5$ vertices and dominant families of size larger than $40\%$ for $h=6,7,8,9$. For all $h$, we provide an explicit construction of a dominant family which is conjectured to obtain an absolute constant fraction of the tournaments on $h$ vertices. Some additional intriguing open problems are presented.

We investigate the \emph{last passage percolation} problem on transitive tournaments, in the case when the edge weights are independent Bernoulli random variables. Given a transitive tournament on $n$ nodes with random weights on its edges, the last passage percolation problem seeks to find the weight $X_n$ of the heaviest path, where the weight of a path is the sum of the weights on its edges. We give a recurrence relation and use it to obtain a (bivariate) generating function for the probability generating function of $X_n$. This also gives exact combinatorial expressions for $\mathbb{E}[X_n]$, which was stated as an open problem by Yuster [\emph{Disc. Appl. Math.}, 2017]. We further determine scaling constants in the limit laws for $X_n$. Define $β_{tr}(p) := \lim_{n\to \infty} \frac{\mathbb{E}[X_n]}{n-1}$. Using singularity analysis, we show \[ β_{tr}(p) = \left(\sum_{n\geq 1}(1-p)^{n\choose 2}\right)^{-1}. \] In particular, $β_{tr}(0.5) = \left(\sum_{n\geq 1} 2^{-{n\choose 2}}\right)^{-1} = 0.60914971106...$. This settles the question of determining the value of $β_{tr}(0.5)$, initiated by Yuster. $β_{tr}(p)$ is also the limiting value in the strong law of large numbers for $X_n$, given by Foss, Martin, and Schmidt [\emph{Ann. Appl. Probab.}, 2014]. We also derive the scaling constants in the functional central limit theorem for $X_n$ proved by Foss et al.

A fundamental property of choice functions is stability, which, loosely speaking, prescribes that choice sets are invariant under adding and removing unchosen alternatives. We provide several structural insights that improve our understanding of stable choice functions. In particular, (i) we show that every stable choice function is generated by a unique simple choice function, which never excludes more than one alternative, (ii) we completely characterize which simple choice functions give rise to stable choice functions, and (iii) we prove a strong relationship between stability and a new property of tournament solutions called local reversal symmetry. Based on these findings, we provide the first concrete tournament---consisting of 24 alternatives---in which the tournament equilibrium set fails to be stable. Furthermore, we prove that there is no more discriminating stable tournament solution than the bipartisan set and that the bipartisan set is the unique most discriminating tournament solution which satisfies standard properties proposed in the literature.

Given a tournament $T$, a module of $T$ is a subset $X$ of $V(T)$ such that for $x, y\in X$ and $v\in V(T)\setminus X$, $(x,v)\in A(T)$ if and only if $(y,v)\in A(T)$. The trivial modules of $T$ are $\emptyset$, $\{u\}$ $(u\in V(T))$ and $V(T)$. The tournament $T$ is indecomposable if all its modules are trivial; otherwise it is decomposable. The decomposability index of $T$, denoted by $δ(T)$, is the smallest number of arcs of $T$ that must be reversed to make $T$ indecomposable. The first author conjectured that for $n \geq 5$, we have $δ(n) = \left\lceil \frac{n+1}{4} \right\rceil$, where $δ(n)$ is the maximum of $δ(T)$ over the tournaments $T$ with $n$ vertices. In this paper we prove this conjecture by introducing the co-modular index of a tournament $T$, denoted by $Δ(T)$, as the largest number of disjoint co-modules of $T$, where a co-module of $T$ is a subset $M$ of $V(T)$ such that $M$ or $V(T) \setminus M$ is a nontrivial module of $T$. We prove that for $n \geq 3$, we have $Δ(n) = \left\lceil \frac{n+1}{2} \right\rceil$, where $Δ(n)$ is the maximum of $Δ(T)$ over the tournaments $T$ with $n$ vertices. Our main result is the following close relationship between the above two indices: for every tournament $T$ with at least $5$ vertices, we have $δ(T) = \left\lceil \frac{Δ(T)}{2} \right\rceil$. As a consequence, we obtain $δ(n) = \left\lceil \frac{Δ(n)}{2} \right\rceil = \left\lceil \frac{n+1}{4} \right\rceil$ for $n \geq 5$, and we answer some further related questions.

In the homomorphism order of digraphs, a duality pair is an ordered pair of digraphs $(G,H)$ such that for any digraph, $D$, $G\to D$ if and only if $D\not\to H$. The directed path on $k+1$ vertices together with the transitive tournament on $k$ vertices is a classic example of a duality pair. This relation between paths and tournaments implies that a graph is $k$-colourable if and only if it admits an orientation with no directed path on more than $k$-vertices. In this work, for every undirected cycle $C$ we find an orientation $C_D$ and an oriented path $P_C$, such that $(P_C,C_D)$ is a duality pair. As a consequence we obtain that there is a finite set, $F_C$, such that an undirected graph is homomorphic to $C$, if and only if it admits an $F_C$-free orientation. As a byproduct of the proposed duality pairs, we show that if $T$ is a tree of height at most $3$, one can choose a dual of $T$ of linear size with respect to the size of $T$.