arXiv++ Combinatorics

We introduce a new type of positional games, played on a vertex set of a graph. Given a graph $G$, two players claim vertices of $G$, where the outcome of the game is determined by the subgraphs of $G$ induced by the vertices claimed by each player (or by one of them). We study classical positional games such as Maker-Breaker, Avoider-Enforcer, Waiter-Client and Client-Waiter games, where the board of the game is the vertex set of the binomial random graph $G\sim G(n,p)$. Under these settings, we consider those games where the target sets are the vertex sets of all graphs containing a copy of a fixed graph $H$, called $H$-games, and focus on those cases where $H$ is a clique or a cycle. We show that, similarly to the edge version of $H$-games, there is a strong connection between the threshold probability for these games and the one for the corresponding vertex Ramsey property (that is, the property that every $r$-vertex-coloring of $G(n,p)$ spans a monochromatic copy of $H$). Another similarity to the edge version of these games we demonstrate, is that the games in which $H$ is a triangle or a forest present a different behavior compared to the general case.

We prove that a formula predicted on the basis of non-rigorous physics arguments [Zdeborova and Krzakala: Phys. Rev. E (2007)] provides a lower bound on the chromatic number of sparse random graphs. The proof is based on the interpolation method from mathematical physics. In the case of random regular graphs the lower bound can be expressed algebraically, while in the case of the binomial random we obtain a variational formula. As an application we calculate improved explicit lower bounds on the chromatic number of random graphs for small (average) degrees. Additionally, show how asymptotic formulas for large degrees that were previously obtained by lengthy and complicated combinatorial arguments can be re-derived easily from these new results.

We consider random graphs with a given degree sequence and show, under weak technical conditions, asymptotic normality of the number of components isomorphic to a given tree, first for the random multigraph given by the configuration model and then, by a conditioning argument, for the simple uniform random graph with the given degree sequence. Such conditioning is standard for convergence in probability, but much less straightforward for convergence in distribution as here. The proof uses the method of moments, and is based on a new estimate of mixed cumulants in a case of weakly dependent variables. The result on small components is applied to give a new proof of a recent result by Barbour and Röllin on asymptotic normality of the size of the giant component in the random multigraph; moreover, we extend this to the random simple graph.

In a seminal paper on finding large matchings in sparse random graphs, Karp and Sipser proposed two algorithms for this task. The second algorithm has been intensely studied, but due to technical difficulties, the first algorithm has received less attention. Empirical results suggest that the first algorithm is superior. In this paper we analyze an adapted version of the first algorithm, the Reduce-Construct algorithm. We show that the Reduce-Construct algorithm finds a maximum matching in random $k=O(1)$-regular graphs in linear time in expectation, as opposed to $O(n^{3/2})$ time for the worst-case.

The upper tail problem for the largest eigenvalue of the Erdős--Rényi random graph $\mathcal{G}_{n,p}$ is to estimate the probability that the largest eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of $\mathcal{G}_{n,p}$ exceeds its typical value by a factor of $1+δ$. In this note we show that for $δ>0$ fixed, and $p \rightarrow 0$ such that $n^{\frac{1}{2}} p \rightarrow \infty$, the upper tail probability for the largest eigenvalue of $\mathcal{G}_{n,p}$ is $$\exp\left[-(1+o(1)) \min\left\{\tfrac{(1+δ)^2}{2}, δ(1+δ) \right\} n^{2}p^{2}\log (1/p)\right].$$ In the same regime of $p$, we show that the second largest eigenvalue $λ_2( \mathcal G_{n,p})$ of the adjacency matrix of $\mathcal{G}_{n,p}$ satisfies $$\mathbb P(λ_2(\mathcal G_{n,p})\ge δnp) = \exp\left[-(1+o(1)) \tfrac{1}{2} δ^2n^2p^2 \log (1/p) \right],$$ where $δ=δ_n < 1$ can depend on $n$ such that $δn^{\frac{1}{2}} p \rightarrow \infty$, which covers deviations of $λ_2(\mathcal G_{n,p})$ between $n^{\frac{1}{2}}$ and $np$. Our arguments build on recent results on the large deviations of the largest eigenvalue and related non-linear functions of the adjacency matrix in terms of natural mean-field entropic variational problems.

In this paper, we prove that for every positive $\varepsilon$, there exists an $α\in(1/(k-1),1/(k-1)+\varepsilon)$ such that the binomial random graph $G(n,n^{-α})$ does not obey 0-1 law w.r.t. first order sentences with k variables. In contrast, for every $α\in(0,1/(k-1)]$, $G(n,n^{-α})$ obeys 0-1 law w.r.t. this logic.

Binary classification problems can be naturally modeled as bipartite graphs, where we attempt to classify right nodes based on their left adjacencies. We consider the case of labeled bipartite graphs in which some labels and edges are not trustworthy. Our goal is to reduce noise by identifying and fixing these labels and edges. We first propose a geometric technique for generating random graph instances with untrustworthy labels and analyze the resulting graph properties. We focus on generating graphs which reflect real-world data, where degree and label frequencies follow power law distributions. We review several algorithms for the problem of detection and correction, proposing novel extensions and making observations specific to the bipartite case. These algorithms range from math programming algorithms to discrete combinatorial algorithms to Bayesian approximation algorithms to machine learning algorithms. We compare the performance of all these algorithms using several metrics and, based on our observations, identify the relative strengths and weaknesses of each individual algorithm.

We count orientations of $G(n,p)$ avoiding certain classes of oriented graphs. In particular, we study $T_r(n,p)$, the number of orientations of the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ in which every copy of $K_r$ is transitive, and $S_r(n,p)$, the number of orientations of $G(n,p)$ containing no strongly connected copy of $K_r$. We give the correct order of growth of $\log T_r(n,p)$ and $\log S_r(n,p)$ up to polylogarithmic factors; for orientations with no cyclic triangle, this significantly improves a result of Allen, Kohayakawa, Mota and Parente. We also discuss the problem for a single forbidden oriented graph, and state a number of open problems and conjectures.

The emerging theory of graph limits exhibits an analytic perspective on graphs, showing that many important concepts and tools in graph theory and its applications can be described more naturally (and sometimes proved more easily) in analytic language. We extend the theory of graph limits to the ordered setting, presenting a limit object for dense vertex-ordered graphs, which we call an orderon. As a special case, this yields limit objects for matrices whose rows and columns are ordered, and for dynamic graphs that expand (via vertex insertions) over time. Along the way, we devise an ordered locality-preserving variant of the cut distance between ordered graphs, showing that two graphs are close with respect to this distance if and only if they are similar in terms of their ordered subgraph frequencies. We show that the space of orderons is compact with respect to this distance notion, which is key to a successful analysis of combinatorial objects through their limits. We derive several applications of the ordered limit theory in extremal combinatorics, sampling, and property testing in ordered graphs. In particular, we prove a new ordered analogue of the well-known result by Alon and Stav [RS\&A'08] on the furthest graph from a hereditary property; this is the first known result of this type in the ordered setting. Unlike the unordered regime, here the random graph model $G(n, p)$ with an ordering over the vertices is not always asymptotically the furthest from the property for some $p$. However, using our ordered limit theory, we show that random graphs generated by a stochastic block model, where the blocks are consecutive in the vertex ordering, are (approximately) the furthest. Additionally, we describe an alternative analytic proof of the ordered graph removal lemma [Alon et al., FOCS'17].

Pósa's theorem states that any graph $G$ whose degree sequence $d_1 \le \ldots \le d_n$ satisfies $d_i \ge i+1$ for all $i < n/2$ has a Hamilton cycle. This degree condition is best possible. We show that a similar result holds for suitable subgraphs $G$ of random graphs, i.e. we prove a `resilience version' of Pósa's theorem: if $pn \ge C \log n$ and the $i$-th vertex degree (ordered increasingly) of $G \subseteq G_{n,p}$ is at least $(i+o(n))p$ for all $i<n/2$, then $G$ has a Hamilton cycle. This is essentially best possible and strengthens a resilience version of Dirac's theorem obtained by Lee and Sudakov. Chvátal's theorem generalises Pósa's theorem and characterises all degree sequences which ensure the existence of a Hamilton cycle. We show that a natural guess for a resilience version of Chvátal's theorem fails to be true. We formulate a conjecture which would repair this guess, and show that the corresponding degree conditions ensure the existence of a perfect matching in any subgraph of $G_{n,p}$ which satisfies these conditions. This provides an asymptotic characterisation of all degree sequences which resiliently guarantee the existence of a perfect matching.

The triangle packing number $ν(G)$ of a graph $G$ is the maximum size of a set of edge-disjoint triangles in $G$. Tuza conjectured that in any graph $G$ there exists a set of at most $2ν(G)$ edges intersecting every triangle in $G$. We show that Tuza's conjecture holds in the random graph $G=G(n,m)$, when $m \le 0.2403n^{3/2}$ or $m\ge 2.1243n^{3/2}$. This is done by analyzing a greedy algorithm for finding large triangle packings in random graphs.

In this article, we derive two spectral gap bounds for the reduced Laplacian of a general simplicial complex. Our two bounds are proven by comparing a simplicial complex in two different ways with a larger complex and with the corresponding clique complex respectively. Both of these bounds generalize the result of Aharoni et al. (2005) \cite{ABM} which is valid only for clique complexes. As an application, we investigate the thresholds for vanishing of cohomology of the neighborhood complex of the Erdös-Rényi random graph. We improve the upper bound derived in Kahle (2007) \cite{kahle} by a logarithmic factor using our spectral gap bounds and we also improve the lower bound via finer probabilistic estimates than those in Kahle (2007) \cite{kahle}.

In the binomial random graph $\mathcal{G}(n,p)$, when $p$ changes from $(1-\varepsilon)/n$ (subcritical case) to $1/n$ and then to $(1+\varepsilon)/n$ (supercritical case) for $\varepsilon>0$, with high probability the order of the largest component increases smoothly from $O(\varepsilon^{-2}\log(\varepsilon^3 n))$ to $Θ(n^{2/3})$ and then to $(1 \pm o(1)) 2 \varepsilon n$. As a natural generalisation of random graphs and connectedness, we consider the binomial random $k$-uniform hypergraph $\mathcal{H}^k(n,p)$ (where each $k$-tuple of vertices is present as a hyperedge with probability $p$ independently) and the following notion of high-order connectedness. Given an integer $1 \leq j \leq k-1$, two sets of $j$ vertices are called \emph{$j$-connected} if there is a walk of hyperedges between them such that any two consecutive hyperedges intersect in at least $j$ vertices. A $j$-connected component is a maximal collection of pairwise $j$-connected $j$-tuples of vertices. Recently, the threshold for the appearance of the giant $j$-connected component in $\mathcal{H}^k(n,p)$ and its order were determined. In this article, we take a closer look at the subcritical random hypergraph. We determine the structure, order, and size of the largest $j$-connected components, with the help of a certain class of `hypertrees' and related objects. In our proofs, we combine various probabilistic and enumerative techniques, such as generating functions and couplings with branching processes. Our study will pave the way to establishing a symmetry between the subcritical random hypergraph and the hypergraph obtained from the supercritical random hypergraph by deleting its giant $j$-connected component.

We show that the probability that a random graph $G\sim G(n,p)$ contains no Hamilton cycle is $(1+o(1))Pr(δ(G) < 2)$ for all values of $p = p(n)$. We also prove an analogous result for perfect matchings.

The global structure of the minimal spanning tree (MST) is expected to be universal for a large class of underlying random discrete structures. However, very little is known about the intrinsic geometry of MSTs of most standard models, and so far the scaling limit of the MST viewed as a metric measure space has only been identified in the case of the complete graph [5]. In this work, we show that the MST constructed by assigning i.i.d. continuous edge-weights to either the random (simple) $3$-regular graph or the $3$-regular configuration model on $n$ vertices, endowed with the tree distance scaled by $n^{-1/3}$ and the uniform probability measure on the vertices, converges in distribution with respect to Gromov-Hausdorff-Prokhorov topology to a random compact metric measure space. Further, this limiting space has the same law as the scaling limit of the MST of the complete graph identified in [5] up to a scaling factor of $6^{1/3}$. Our proof relies on a novel argument that proceeds via a comparison between a $3$-regular configuration model and the largest component in the critical Erdős-Rényi random graph. The techniques of this paper can be used to establish the scaling limit of the MST in the setting of general random graphs with given degree sequences provided two additional technical conditions are verified.

For each $Δ>0$, we prove that there exists some $C=C(Δ)$ for which the binomial random graph $G(n,C\log n/n)$ almost surely contains a copy of every tree with $n$ vertices and maximum degree at most $Δ$. In doing so, we confirm a conjecture by Kahn.

A uniform attachment graph (with parameter $k$), denoted $G_{n,k}$ in the paper, is a random graph on the vertex set $[n]$, where each vertex $v$ makes $k$ selections from $[v-1]$ uniformly and independently, and these selections determine the edge set. We study several aspects of this graph. Our motivation comes from two similarly constructed, well-studied random graphs: $k$-out graphs and preferential attachment graphs. In this paper, we find the asymptotic distribution of its minimum degree and connectivity, and study the expansion properties of $G_{n,k}$ to show that the conductance of $G_{n,k}$ is of order $(\log n)^{-1}$. We also study the bootstrap percolation on $G_{n,k}$, where, each vertex is either initially infected with probability $p$, independently of others, or gets infected later as a result of having $r$ infected neighbors at some point. We show that, for $2\le r\le k-1$, if $p\ll (\log n)^{-r/(r-1)}$, then, with probability approaching 1, the process ends before all vertices get infected. On the other hand, if $p\ge ω(\log n)^{-r/(r-1)}$, where $ω$ is a certain very slowly growing function, then all the vertices get infected with probability approaching 1.

For any fixed simple graph $H=(V,E)$ and any fixed $u>0$, we establish the leading order of the exponential rate function for the probability that the number of copies of $H$ in the Erdős--Rényi graph $G(n,p)$ exceeds its expectation by a factor $1+u$, assuming $n^{-κ(H)}\ll p\ll1$, with $κ(H) = 1/(2Δ)$, where $Δ\ge 1$ is the maximum degree of $H$. This improves on a previous result of Chatterjee and the second author, who obtained $κ(H)=c/(Δ|E|)$ for a constant $c>0$. Moreover, for the case of cycle counts we can take $κ$ as large as $1/2$. We additionally obtain the sharp upper tail for Schatten norms of the adjacency matrix, as well as the sharp lower tail for counts of graphs for which Sidorenko's conjecture holds. As a key step, we establish quantitative versions of Szemerédi's regularity lemma and the counting lemma, suitable for the analysis of random graphs in the large deviations regime.

Given a fixed graph H, what is the (exponentially small) probability that the number X_H of copies of H in the binomial random graph G_{n,p} is at least twice its mean? Studied intensively since the mid 1990s, this so-called infamous upper tail problem remains a challenging testbed for concentration inequalities. In 2011 DeMarco and Kahn formulated an intriguing conjecture about the exponential rate of decay of \Pr(X_H \ge (1+ε) \E X_H) for fixed ε>0. We show that this upper tail conjecture is false, by exhibiting an infinite family of graphs violating the conjectured bound.

We consider three different models of sparse random graphs:~undirected and directed Erdős-Rényi graphs, and random bipartite graph with an equal number of left and right vertices. For such graphs we show that if the edge connectivity probability $p \in (0,1)$ satisfies $n p \ge \log n + k(n)$ with $k(n) \to \infty$ as $n \to \infty$, then the adjacency matrix is invertible with probability approaching one (here $n$ is the number of vertices in the two former cases and the number of left and right vertices in the latter case). If $np \le \log n -k(n)$ then these matrices are invertible with probability approaching zero, as $n \to \infty$. In the intermediate region, when $np=\log n + k(n)$, for a bounded sequence $k(n) \in \mathbb{R}$, the event $Ω_0$ that the adjacency matrix has a zero row or a column and its complement both have non-vanishing probability. For such choices of $p$ our results show that conditioned on the event $Ω_0^c$ the matrices are again invertible with probability tending to one. This shows that the primary reason for the non-invertibility of such matrices is the existence of a zero row or a column. The bounds on the probability of the invertibility of these matrices are a consequence of quantitative lower bounds on their smallest singular values. Combining this with an upper bound on the largest singular value of the centered version of these matrices we show that the (modified) condition number is $O(n^{1+o(1)})$ on the event that there is no zero row or column, with large probability. This matches with von Neumann's prediction about the condition number of random matrices up to a factor of $n^{o(1)}$, for the entire range of $p$.