arXiv++ Combinatorics

Standard phylogenetic reconstruction techniques often yield unrooted phylogenetic networks; these are subsequently rooted to infer evolutionary history. A common problem in this process is to determine the structural classes to which the resulting network will belong. In this paper, we investigate unrooted networks in which the choice of any root results in a valid rooted phylogenetic network, a property we define as {\em robustly orientable}. We then establish a strict structural condition for this class, specifically, that an unrooted network is robustly orientable if and only if it contains no sink components. We also show that if an unrooted network is level-$2$ or less, or if it is tree-based, then it is robustly orientable. Furthermore, we define an unrooted network to be {\em robustly class $\mathcal C$} if the choice of any root results in a network belonging to class $\mathcal C$. We demonstrate that an unrooted network is robustly tree-child or robustly stack-free if and only if it is level-$1$ or less. Finally, we show that a phylogenetic network is robustly normal if and only if it is a phylogenetic tree.

Snir and Yuster [Discrete Appl. Math. 347 (2026) 160--171] asked for the least number $h(k)$ such that $k$ unrooted binary phylogenetic trees on the same $h(k)$ leaves always share a common quartet. We give a new upper bound for the $k$-tree version of the Maximum Agreement Subtree problem, namely an upper bound for the number of leaves, on which $k$ unrooted binary phylogenetic trees always share a common induced binary subtree on $n$ leaves, which is a four-times iterated exponential function. For $h(k)$, this implies a four-times iterated exponential upper bound. We also set an exponential lower bound for $h(k)$.

Phylogenetic networks are used to represent the evolutionary history of species. Due to biological interpretations and computational advantages, researchers have focused on restricted classes of phylogenetic networks, such as tree-child, orchard, and tree-based. These classes capture different notions of tree-likeness: tree-child networks require every internal vertex to have a taxon reachable by a tree path, orchard networks are trees with horizontal arcs (for modelling histories rife with horizontal gene transfers), and tree-based networks are trees with additional (not-necessarily horizontal) arcs. A natural question to ask is ``how far is a given network from belonging to a particular class?'' This motivates the study of proximity measures, which measure the minimum number of graph modifications required to transform a network into one belonging to a particular class. In this paper, we consider three proximity measures based on leaf addition, valid arc deletion, and arc deletion. We study pairwise comparability of the proximity measures, prove complexity results, and derive extremal bounds for the classes of tree, tree-child, orchard, and tree-based networks.

Phylogenetic trees are rooted trees with branch lengths that record genetic divergence or elapsed time, and quantifying differences between them is central to a wide range of evolutionary and epidemiological analyses. Graph-polynomial encodings of rooted trees provide an accurate, interpretable, and computationally efficient way to compare tree shapes, but existing polynomial encodings must be paired with auxiliary structures to study rooted trees with branch lengths. We introduce a bivariate polynomial encoding that incorporates branch lengths directly into a recursive computation from the leaf vertices to the root vertex of a tree. We prove that, for rooted trees with branch lengths and no vertices of degree two, which include all standard phylogenetic trees, two trees have the same polynomial if and only if their underlying unlabeled trees are isomorphic and the branch lengths of corresponding edges are equal. We apply the polynomial encoding to three published HIV-1 phylogenies sampled in different epidemiological settings and show that it accurately separates the three datasets based on their tree topologies and branch lengths, outperforming previous polynomial-based approaches for analyzing rooted trees with branch lengths.

We introduce a new family of balance indices for phylogenetic networks: the $H_α$ indices, where $α$ is a positive real number. This family includes the $B_2$ index as a special case ($α= 1$) and provides a natural extension of the Sackin index to phylogenetic networks. We show that the $H_α$ indices share many structural properties with the $B_2$ index, most notably a "grafting property" that makes it possible to express the $H_α$ index of a network in terms of the $H_α$ indices of its biconnected components. These properties allow us to identify networks that minimize / maximize $H_α$ for various classes of phylogenetic networks, and to study its distribution for several models of random trees and networks (in particular, Galton-Watson trees and binary Markov branching trees, with a focus on the Yule and PDA models). Finally, we show how local limits can be used to analyze the asymptotic behavior of $H_α$ for large trees and networks, and we obtain general results for the moments of $H_α$ for a broad class of random phylogenetic networks known as blowups of Galton-Watson trees.

Encoding phylogenetic networks by suitable substructures is a central problem in phylogenetic combinatorics. We study encodings based on least common ancestor (LCA) constraints. For a directed acyclic graph (DAG) $G$ with leaf set $X$, we consider the relation on pairs of leaves in which $(ab,xy)$ records that the LCAs of $a,b$ and $x,y$ are well-defined and that the former is a descendant of the latter. We first identify precisely which part of $G$ is determined by this relation. To this end, we compare the canonical DAG constructed from the LCA relation with the 2-regularization of $G$, obtained by removing all vertices that are not LCAs of one or two leaves and then deleting shortcut edges. We prove that these two DAGs are isomorphic. Hence the obstruction to encoding a graph by its LCA relation is exactly the information lost under 2-regularization. This yields a general reconstruction principle, which we apply to several natural classes of phylogenetic networks. In particular, we show that shortcut-free 2-LCA-relevant DAGs, phylogenetic trees, regular level-1 networks, regular networks with binary clustering systems, regular networks whose clustering systems are closed weak hierarchies, strong-phylogenetic normal networks, separated phylogenetic normal networks, and binary normal networks are encoded by their LCA relations. We also introduce a sparse triple-like restriction consisting only of comparisons of the form $(ab,ac)$, where $a,b,c\in X$ are pairwise distinct. For graphs with the 2-LCA property, we show that this sparse relation, together with the leaf set, determines the full LCA relation after a natural closure operation. Consequently, several of the above classes can be reconstructed, up to isomorphism, from the sparse relation in polynomial time.

In this note, we show that, for all $n\ge 2$, the number of distinct rooted binary phylogenetic $X$-trees displayed by a binary tree-child network $\mathcal{N}$ on $X$ with $n$ leaves is at most $2^{n-1}-1$ and that this upper bound is sharp. Furthermore, if $\mathcal{N}$ displays exactly $2^{n-1}-1$ such trees, then exactly one rooted binary phylogenetic $X$-tree is displayed twice, and this tree can be canonically found by iteratively replacing a reticulated cherry with a cherry.

Let $d_r(n)$ be the maximum, over all binary phylogenetic trees with $n$ leaves, of the minimum number of $r$-state characters required to define the tree. Semple and Steel proved that $d_r(n)\geq\lceil(n-3)/(r-1)\rceil$, and Bordewich and Semple proved that equality holds for each fixed $r$ and all sufficiently large $n$. We study the corresponding threshold $n_r$, the least $N$ for which equality holds for every $n\geq N$. The Bordewich--Semple construction yields an explicit polynomial upper bound of order $O(r^5)$ for this threshold. We prove the near-linear estimate \[ 3r+1\leq n_r\leq \ceil{64(r-1)\log_2(r+1)}+3\qquad(r\geq4). \] The proof constructs, for every binary phylogenetic tree with $m=n-3$ internal edges, a linked quartet certificate whose conflict graph has maximum degree at most $16\lceil\log_2(m+2)\rceil+4$. Equitable coloring then packs the certificate into exactly $\lceil m/(r-1)\rceil$ $r$-state characters once $m\geq\lceil64(r-1)\log_2(r+1)\rceil$. We also include the lower bound $n_r\geq3r+1$, obtained from the snowflake obstruction, and state the natural conjecture that this lower bound is the exact threshold for all $r\geq4$. The conjectural endpoint is consistent with the known small-state thresholds: $n_4=13$ and $n_5=16$, while the cases $r=2,3$ are also explicitly classified.

We study the enumeration of spinal tree-child phylogenetic networks, a rigid family of tree-child networks in which all internal vertices lie on a single root--to--leaf path. We provide two complementary combinatorial frameworks. First, we introduce a word model: unlabeled spinal networks correspond to a suitable class of restricted words with fixed multiplicities, taken modulo a simple relabeling equivalence, which yields an explicit closed enumeration. Second, we develop a symbolic-method approach based on a marked version of trees that admits a clean recursive specification; its boxed-product translation leads to a solvable bivariate generating function and a direct derivation of the coefficients.

Tree-child networks are an important class of phylogenetic network used to model reticulate evolutionary processes. These networks have attracted increasing attention from researchers with interests in both combinatorics and algorithms. A fundamental open problem posed by Pons and Batle asks whether the number $TC_{n,k}$ of bicombining tree-child networks with $n$ leaves and $k$ reticulation nodes equals the number of certain constrained words, now called Pons-Batle words. In this paper, we confirm the conjecture for tree-child networks with a bounded number of reticulation nodes. Our approach is combinatorial and analytic. We introduce families of Young tableaux with walls and holes and construct explicit bijections with Pons-Batle words, yielding a direct combinatorial explanation of the identities. These tableaux encode structural features of the underlying networks, including the placement of reticulation nodes. By projecting them to decorated Dyck paths, we obtain algebraic generating functions with differential operators encoding step weights, leading to explicit recurrence relations and closed-form formulas for $TC_{n,k}$. Beyond finite verification for moderate $k$, the framework reveals an underlying probabilistic structure. For $k=1$, natural structural parameters, such as the position and value of distinguished cells, converge, after rescaling, to $\mathrm{Beta}(2,1)$, $\mathrm{Beta}(1,2)$, and Uniform (i.e., $\mathrm{Beta}(1,1)$) distributions. These limit laws arise from a coalescence of singularities at the dominant square-root singularity, producing a non-analytic transition in the local expansion. Overall, our results provide both combinatorial insight and a unified analytic perspective on the asymptotic behavior of tree-child networks, showing how algebraic generating functions with interacting singularities systematically produce Beta limit laws.

In evolutionary biology, phylogenetic networks are now widely used to represent the historical relationships between species and population, when this history includes reticulation events such as hybridization, gene flow and admixture between populations. Semidirected phylogenetic networks are appropriate models when the direction of some edges and the root position are not identifiable from data. Comparing semidirected networks is important in many applications. For rooted and directed networks, a $μ$-representation was originally introduced to distinguish tree-child networks, and has since been extended in two different directions: to the larger class of orchard directed networks by adding an extra component that counts paths to reticulations; and to semidirected networks, through an edge-based variant. However, the latter does not provide a distance between semidirected and orchard networks. We introduce here a new edge-based $μ$-representation capable of distinguishing distinct orchard binary semidirected networks. For this class, we provide a reconstruction algorithm and therefore obtain a true distance that is computable in polynomial time.

Scaffolds are the one-dimensional skeleta of high-dimensional flag simplicial complexes of nonpositive curvature. They generalize the phylogenetic trees of Trop G(2,n) to arbitrary $k$, drawing together SL(k)-web bases, affine buildings, the combinatorics of the positive tropical Grassmannian and low-dimensional topology. We prove that scaffolds model points in all tropical Grassmannians via a $k$-point distance function. In this paper, we study in detail CAT(0) planar graphs, which are positive scaffolds for the tropical Grassmannian of three-planes. CAT(0) planar graphs are directed versions of the diskoids of Fontaine-Kamnitzer-Kuperberg, planar dual to SL(3)-webs. Our main result is the construction of a unique representation of any given integer positive tropical Plucker vector by a normal CAT(0) planar graph. We show that any normal CAT(0) planar graph embeds into the tropical linear space as a Lam-Postnikov membrane, and embeds into the Keel-Tevelev membrane within the affine building. We show that Early's planar basis expansion can be computed directly from the strand combinatorics of the dual web, and connect this expansion to Petersen-Pylyavskyy-Speyer's noncrossing tableaux, explored further in our companion paper.

Nested (or reconciled) phylogenetic trees model co-evolutionary systems in which one evolutionary history is embedded within another. We introduce a geometric framework for such systems by defining $σ$-space, a moduli space of fully nested ultrametric phylogenetic trees with a fixed leaf map. Generalizing the $τ$-space of Gavryushkin and Drummond, $σ$-space is constructed as a cubical complex parametrised by nested ranked tree topologies and inter-event time coordinates of the combined host and parasite speciation events. We characterise admissible orderings via binary \textit{nesting sequences} and organise them into a natural poset. We show that $σ$-space is contractible and satisfies Gromov's cube condition, and is therefore CAT(0). In particular, it admits unique geodesics and well-defined Fréchet means. We further describe its geometric structure, including boundary strata corresponding to cospeciation events, and relate it to products of ultrametric tree spaces via natural forgetful maps.

The class of terminal planar networks was recently introduced from a biological perspective in relation to the visualization of phylogenetic networks, and its connection to upward planar networks has been established. We provide a Kuratowski-type theorem that characterizes terminal planar networks by a finite set of forbidden structures, defined via six families of 0/1-labeled graphs. Another characterization based on planarity of supergraphs yields linear-time algorithms for testing terminal planarity and for computing such planar drawings. We describe an application that is potentially relevant in broader, non-phylogenetic settings. We also discuss a connection of our main result to an open problem on the forbidden structures of single-source upward planar networks.

A directed phylogenetic network is tree-child if every non-leaf vertex has a child that is not a reticulation. As a class of directed phylogenetic networks, tree-child networks are very useful from a computational perspective. For example, several computationally difficult problems in phylogenetics become tractable when restricted to tree-child networks. At the same time, the class itself is rich enough to contain quite complex networks. Furthermore, checking whether a directed network is tree-child can be done in polynomial time. In this paper, we seek a class of undirected phylogenetic networks that is rich and computationally useful in a similar way to the class tree-child directed networks. A natural class to consider for this role is the class of tree-child-orientable networks which contains all those undirected phylogenetic networks whose edges can be oriented to create a tree-child network. However, we show here that recognizing such networks is NP-hard, even for binary networks, and as such this class is inappropriate for this role. Towards finding a class of undirected networks that fills a similar role to directed tree-child networks, we propose new classes called $q$-cuttable networks, for any integer $q\geq 1$. We show that these classes have many of the desirable properties, similar to tree-child networks in the rooted case, including being recognizable in polynomial time, for all $q\geq 1$. Towards showing the computational usefulness of the class, we show that the NP-hard problem Tree Containment is polynomial-time solvable when restricted to $q$-cuttable networks with $q\geq 3$.

The asymmetric tropical distance is a distance measure on the tropical torus $\mathbb{R}^n/\mathbb{R}\mathbf{1}$ and in particular on the Bergman fan $B(K_N) \subseteq \mathbb{R}^{\binom{N}{2}}/\mathbb{R}\mathbf{1}$ of the complete graphical matroid. In this paper, we define and analyse a clustering algorithm for equidistant phylogenetic trees based on this distance, using the correspondence between $B(K_N)$ and the space of equidistant trees with $N$ leaves.

It follows from a classical result of Jordan that every tree with maximum degree at most $r$ containing a vertex set labeled by $[n]$, has a single-edge cut which separates two subsets $A,B \subset [n]$ for which $\min\{|A|,|B|\} \ge (n-1)/r$. Motivated by the tree dissimilarity problem in phylogenetics, we consider the case of separating vertex sets of {\em several} trees: Given $k$ trees with maximum degree at most $r$, containing a common vertex set labeled by $[n]$, we ask for a single-edge cut in each tree which maximizes $min\{|A|,|B|\}$ where $A,B \subset [n]$ are separated by the corresponding cut at each tree. Denoting this maximum by $f(r,k,n)$ and considering the limit $f(r,k) = \lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} f(r,k,n)/n$ (which is shown to always exist) we determine that $f(r,2)=\frac{1}{2r}$ and determine that $f(3,3)=\frac{2}{27}$, which is already quite intricate. The case $r=3$ is especially interesting in phylogenetics and our result implies that any two (three) binary phylogenetic trees over $n$ taxa have a split at each tree which separates two taxa sets of order at least $n/6$ (resp. $2n/27$), and these bounds are asymptotically tight.

The maximum agreement forest (MAF) problem in phylogenetics takes as input a set t >=2 of binary phylogenetic trees T on the same set of taxa X. It asks for a partition X into the smallest number of blocks such that the subtrees induced by these blocks are disjoint and have common topology across all the trees in T. We produce a modified version of the well-known chain reduction rule in order to prove the existence of a kernel of size O( t * r * k ) where k is the natural parameter (the number of blocks) and r=min{max{k,3},t+1}}. We prove this bound for both the unrooted and rooted version of the problem, and demonstrate that the bound r, the length to which common chains are truncated, is tight. Our results constitute the first kernels for MAF in the t > 2 regime.

We explicitly describe the tropicalization of a type C cluster variety by identifying it with the space of axially symmetric phylogenetic trees. We also study the signed tropicalizations of this cluster variety, realizing them as subfans of the tropicalization that are dual to either associahedra or cyclohedra.

This paper studies the enumeration of seven subclasses of level-$2$ phylogenetic networks under various planarity and structural constraints, including terminal planar, tree-child, and galled networks. We derive their exponential generating functions, recurrence relations, and asymptotic formulas. Specifically, we show that the number of networks of size $n$ in each class follows: \[ N_n \sim c \cdot n^{n-1} \cdot γ^n, \] where $c$ is a class-specific constant and $γ$ is the corresponding growth rate. Our results reveal that being terminal planar can significantly reduce the growth rate of general level-2 networks, but has only a minor effect on the growth rates of tree-child and galled level-2 networks. Notably, the growth rate of 3.83 for level-$2$ terminal planar galled tree-child networks is remarkably close to the rate of 2.94 for level-$1$ networks.