arXiv++ Combinatorics

We survey the impact of Lieb's influential paper "Proofs of some conjectures on permanents" [J. Math. Mech. 16 1966, 127-134], which introduced the famous permanental dominance conjecture. This conjecture has defied all attacks for over half a century, although a number of related conjectures have recently been resolved.

Cauchy's determinant formula (1841) involving $\det ((1-u_i v_j)^{-1})$ is a fundamental result in symmetric function theory. It has been extended in several directions, including a determinantal extension by Frobenius [J. reine angew. Math. 1882] involving a sum of two geometric series in $u_i v_j$. This theme also resurfaced in a matrix analysis setting in a paper by Horn [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 1969] - where the computations are attributed to Loewner - and in recent works by Belton-Guillot-Khare-Putinar [Adv. Math. 2016] and Khare-Tao [Amer. J. Math. 2021]. These formulas were recently unified and extended in [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2022] to arbitrary power series, with commuting/bosonic variables $u_i, v_j$. In this note we formulate analogous permanent identities, and in fact, explain how all of these results are a special case of a more general identity, for any character - in fact, any complex class function - of any finite group that acts on the bosonic variables $u_i$ and on the $v_j$ via signed permutations. (We explain why larger linear groups do not work, via a - perhaps novel - "symmetric function" characterization of signed permutation matrices that holds over any integral domain.) We then provide fermionic analogues of these formulas, as well as of the closely related Cauchy product identities.

Given a directed graph, we show how to efficiently find a shortest (directed, simple) cycle on an even number of vertices. As far as we know, no polynomial-time algorithm was previously known for this problem. In fact, finding any even cycle in a directed graph in polynomial time was open for more than two decades until Robertson, Seymour, and Thomas (Ann. of Math. (2) 1999) and, independently, McCuaig (Electron. J. Combin. 2004; announced jointly at STOC 1997) gave an efficiently testable structural characterisation of even-cycle-free directed graphs. Methodologically, our algorithm relies on algebraic fingerprinting and randomized polynomial identity testing over a finite field, and uses a generating polynomial implicit in Vazirani and Yannakakis ( Discrete Appl. Math. 1989) that enumerates weighted cycle covers as a difference of a permanent and a determinant polynomial. The need to work with the permanent is where our main technical contribution occurs. We design a family of finite commutative rings of characteristic 4 that simultaneously (i) give a nondegenerate representation for the generating polynomial identity via the permanent and the determinant, (ii) support efficient permanent computations, and (iii) enable emulation of finite-field arithmetic in characteristic 2. Here our work is foreshadowed by that of Björklund and Husfeldt (SIAM J. Comput. 2019), who used a considerably less efficient ring design to obtain a polynomial-time algorithm for the shortest two disjoint paths problem. Building on work of Gilbert and Tarjan (Numer. Math. 1978) as well as Alon and Yuster (J. ACM 2013), we also show how ideas from the nested dissection technique for solving linear equation systems leads to faster algorithm designs when we have control on the separator structure of the input graph; for example, this happens when the input has bounded genus.

In this paper, we confirm six conjectures on the exact values of some permanents, relating them to the Genocchi numbers of the first and second kinds as well as the Euler numbers. For example, we prove that $$\mathrm{per}\left[\left\lfloor\frac{2j-k}{n}\right\rfloor\right]_{1\le j,k\le n}=2(2^{n+1}-1)B_{n+1},$$ where $B_0,B_1,B_2,\ldots$ are the Bernoulli numbers. We also show that $$ \mathrm{per}\left[\mathrm{sgn}\left(\cosπ\frac{i+j}{n+1}\right)\right]_{1\le i,j\le n}=\begin{cases} -\sum_{k=0}^m\binom{m}{k}E_{2k+1}&\quad\text{if}\ n=2m+1,\\ \sum_{k=0}^m\binom{m}{k}E_{2k}&\quad\text{if}\ n=2m, \end{cases} $$ where $\mathrm{sgn}(x)$ is the sign function, and $E_0,E_1,E_2,\ldots$ are the Euler (zigzag) numbers. In the course of linking the evaluation of these permanents to the aforementioned combinatorial sequences, the classical permutation statistic -- the excedance number, together with several kinds of its variants, plays a central role. Our approach features recurrence relations, bijections, as well as certain elementary operations on matrices that preserve their permanents. Moreover, our proof of the second permanent identity leads to a proof of Bala's conjectural continued fraction formula, and an unexpected permutation interpretation for the $γ$-coefficients of the $2$-Eulerian polynomials.

We view the determinant and permanent as functions on directed weighted graphs and introduce their analogues for the undirected graphs. We prove that the task of computing the undirected determinants as well as permanents for planar graphs, whose vertices have degree at most 4, is \#P-complete. In the case of planar graphs whose vertices have degree at most 3, the computation of the undirected determinant remains \#P-complete while the permanent can be reduced to the FKT algorithm, and therefore is polynomial. The undirected permanent is a Holant problem and its complexity can be deduced from the existing literature. The concept of the undirected determinant is new. Its introduction is motivated by the formal resemblance to the directed determinant, a property that may inspire generalizations of some of the many algorithms which compute the latter. For a sizable class of planar 3-regular graphs, we are able to compute the undirected determinant in polynomial time.

We prove an identity relating the permanent of a rank $2$ matrix and the determinants of its Hadamard powers. When viewed in the right way, the resulting formula looks strikingly similar to an identity of Carlitz and Levine, suggesting the possibility that these are actually special cases of some more general identity (or class of identities) connecting permanents and determinants. The proof combines some basic facts from the theory of symmetric functions with an application of a famous theorem of Binet and Cauchy in linear algebra.

The problem of computing the permanent of a matrix has attracted interest since the work of Ryser(1963) and Valiant(1979). On the other hand, trellises were extensively studied in coding theory since the 1960s. In this work, we establish a connection between the two domains. We introduce the canonical trellis $T_n$ that represents all permutations, and show that the permanent of a $n$ by $n$ matrix $A$ can be computed as a flow on this trellis. Under certain normalization, the trellis-based method invokes slightly less operations than best known exact methods. Moreover, if $A$ has structure, then $T_n$ becomes amenable to vertex merging, thereby significantly reducing its complexity. - Repeated rows: Suppose $A$ has only $t<n$ distinct rows. The best known method to compute $per(A)$, due to Clifford and Clifford (2020), has complexity $O(n^{t+1})$. Merging vertices in $T_n$, we obtain a reduced trellis that has complexity $O(n^t)$. - Order statistics: Using trellises, we compute the joint distribution of $t$ order statistics of $n$ independent, but not identically distributed, random variables in time $O(n^{t+1})$. Previously, polynomial-time methods were known only when the variables are drawn from two non-identical distributions. - Sparse matrices: Suppose each entry in $A$ is nonzero with probability $d/n$ with $d$ is constant. We show that $T_n$ can be pruned to exponentially fewer vertices, resulting in complexity $O(φ^n)$ with $φ<2$. - TSP: Intersecting $T_n$ with another trellis that represents walks, we obtain a trellis that represents circular permutations. Using the latter trellis to solve the traveling salesperson problem recovers the well-known Held-Karp algorithm. Notably, in all cases, the reduced trellis are obtained using known techniques in trellis theory. We expect other trellis-theoretic results to apply to other structured matrices.

By considering the tiling of an $N$-board (a linear array of $N$ square cells of unit width) with new types of tile that we refer to as combs, we give a combinatorial interpretation of the product of two consecutive generalized Fibonacci numbers $s_n$ (where $s_{n}=\sum_{i=1}^q v_i s_{n-m_i}$, $s_0=1$, $s_{n<0}=0$, where $v_i$ and $m_i$ are positive integers and $m_1<\cdots<m_q$) each raised to an arbitrary non-negative integer power. A $(w,g;m)$-comb is a tile composed of $m$ rectangular sub-tiles of dimensions $w\times1$ separated by gaps of width $g$. The interpretation is used to give combinatorial proof of new convolution-type identities relating $s_n^2$ for the cases $q=2$, $v_i=1$, $m_1=M$, $m_2=m+1$ for $M=0,m$ to the permanent of a (0,1) Toeplitz matrix with 3 nonzero diagonals which are $-2$, $M-1$, and $m$ above the leading diagonal. When $m=1$ these identities reduce to ones connecting the Padovan and Narayana's cows numbers.

We show that the permanent of a matrix can be written as the expectation value of a function of random variables each with zero mean and unit variance. This result is used to show that Glynn's theorem and a simplified MacMahon theorem extend from a common probabilistic interpretation of the permanent. Combining the methods in these two proofs, we prove a new result that relates the permanent of a matrix to the expectation value of a product of hyperbolic trigonometric functions, or, equivalently, the partition function of a spin system. We conclude by discussing how the main theorem can be generalized and how the techniques used to prove it can be applied to more general problems in combinatorics.

We demonstrate how by using a reinforcement learning algorithm, the deep cross-entropy method, one can find explicit constructions and counterexamples to several open conjectures in extremal combinatorics and graph theory. Amongst the conjectures we refute are a question of Brualdi and Cao about maximizing permanents of pattern avoiding matrices, and several problems related to the adjacency and distance eigenvalues of graphs.

Computing the distribution of permanents of random matrices has been an outstanding open problem for several decades. In quantum computing, "anti-concentration" of this distribution is an unproven input for the proof of hardness of the task of boson-sampling. We study permanents of random i.i.d. complex Gaussian matrices, and more broadly, submatrices of random unitary matrices. Using a hybrid representation-theoretic and combinatorial approach, we prove strong lower bounds for all moments of the permanent distribution. We provide substantial evidence that our bounds are close to being tight and constitute accurate estimates for the moments. Let $U(d)^{k\times k}$ be the distribution of $k\times k$ submatrices of $d\times d$ random unitary matrices, and $G^{k\times k}$ be the distribution of $k\times k$ complex Gaussian matrices. (1) Using the Schur-Weyl duality (or the Howe duality), we prove an expansion formula for the $2t$-th moment of $|Perm(M)|$ when $M$ is drawn from $U(d)^{k\times k}$ or $G^{k\times k}$. (2) We prove a surprising size-moment duality: the $2t$-th moment of the permanent of random $k\times k$ matrices is equal to the $2k$-th moment of the permanent of $t\times t$ matrices. (3) We design an algorithm to exactly compute high moments of the permanent of small matrices. (4) We prove lower bounds for arbitrary moments of permanents of matrices drawn from $G^{ k\times k}$ or $U(k)$, and conjecture that our lower bounds are close to saturation up to a small multiplicative error. (5) Assuming our conjectures, we use the large deviation theory to compute the tail of the distribution of log-permanent of Gaussian matrices for the first time. (6) We argue that it is unlikely that the permanent distribution can be uniquely determined from the integer moments and one may need to supplement the moment calculations with extra assumptions to prove the anti-concentration conjecture.

We prove that the maximum determinant of an $n \times n $ matrix, with entries in $\{0,1\}$ and at most $n+k$ non-zero entries, is at most $2^{k/3}$, which is best possible when $k$ is a multiple of 3. This result solves a conjecture of Bruhn and Rautenbach. We also obtain an upper bound on the number of perfect matchings in $C_4$-free bipartite graphs based on the number of edges, which, in the sparse case, improves on the classical Bregman's inequality for permanents. This bound is tight, as equality is achieved by the graph formed by vertex disjoint union of 6-vertex cycles.

By definition, a rigid graph in $\mathbb{R}^d$ (or on a sphere) has a finite number of embeddings up to rigid motions for a given set of edge length constraints. These embeddings are related to the real solutions of an algebraic system. Naturally, the complex solutions of such systems extend the notion of rigidity to $\mathbb{C}^d$. A major open problem has been to obtain tight upper bounds on the number of embeddings in $\mathbb{C}^d$, for a given number $|V|$ of vertices, which obviously also bound their number in $\mathbb{R}^d$. Moreover, in most known cases, the maximal numbers of embeddings in $\mathbb{C}^d$ and $\mathbb{R}^d$ coincide. For decades, only the trivial bound of $O(2^{d\cdot |V|})$ was known on the number of embeddings.Recently, matrix permanent bounds have led to a small improvement for $d\geq 5$. This work improves upon the existing upper bounds for the number of embeddings in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and $S^d$, by exploiting outdegree-constrained orientations on a graphical construction, where the proof iteratively eliminates vertices or vertex paths. For the most important cases of $d=2$ and $d=3$, the new bounds are $O(3.7764^{|V|})$ and $O(6.8399^{|V|})$, respectively. In general, the recent asymptotic bound mentioned above is improved by a factor of $1/ \sqrt{2}$. Besides being the first substantial improvement upon a long-standing upper bound, our method is essentially the first general approach relying on combinatorial arguments rather than algebraic root counts.

Let $M_{n}$ denote a random symmetric $n\times n$ matrix, whose entries on and above the diagonal are i.i.d. Rademacher random variables (taking values $\pm 1$ with probability $1/2$ each). Resolving a conjecture of Vu, we prove that the permanent of $M_{n}$ has magnitude $n^{n/2+o(n)}$ with probability $1-o(1)$. Our result can also be extended to more general models of random matrices.

We prove two "master" convolution theorems for multivariate determinantal polynomials. The methods used include basic properties of what we call a "minor-orthogonal" ensemble as well as properties of the mixed discriminant of matrices. We also give applications, including a rederivation of a result of Barvinok on computing the permanent of a low rank matrix and a polynomial convolution corresponding to the unitarily invariant addition of generalized singular values.

Let $P$ be a poset, $inc(P)$ its incomparability graph, and $X_{inc(P)}$ the corresponding chromatic symmetric function, as defined by Stanley in {\em Adv. Math.}, {\bf 111} (1995) pp.~166--194. Certain conditions on $P$ imply that the expansions of $X_{inc(P)}$ in standard symmetric function bases yield coefficients which have simple combinatorial interpretations. By expressing these coefficients as character evaluations, we extend several of these interpretations to {\em all} posets $P$. Consequences include new combinatorial interpretations of the permanent and other immanants of totally nonnegative matrices, and of the sum of elementary coefficients in the Shareshian-Wachs chromatic quasisymmetric function $X_{inc(P),q}$ when $P$ is a unit interval order.

Given as input two $n$-element sets $\mathcal A,\mathcal B\subseteq\{0,1\}^d$ with $d=c\log n\leq(\log n)^2/(\log\log n)^4$ and a target $t\in \{0,1,\ldots,d\}$, we show how to count the number of pairs $(x,y)\in \mathcal A\times \mathcal B$ with integer inner product $\langle x,y \rangle=t$ deterministically, in $n^2/2^{Ω\bigl(\!\sqrt{\log n\log \log n/(c\log^2 c)}\bigr)}$ time. This demonstrates that one can solve this problem in deterministic subquadratic time almost up to $\log^2 n$ dimensions, nearly matching the dimension bound of a subquadratic randomized detection algorithm of Alman and Williams [FOCS 2015]. We also show how to modify their randomized algorithm to count the pairs w.h.p., to obtain a fast randomized algorithm. Our deterministic algorithm builds on a novel technique of reconstructing a function from sum-aggregates by prime residues, which can be seen as an {\em additive} analog of the Chinese Remainder Theorem. As our second contribution, we relate the fine-grained complexity of the task of counting of vector pairs by inner product to the task of computing a zero-one matrix permanent over the integers.

We give a sharp lower bound on the capacity of a real stable polynomial, depending only on the value of its gradient at $x = 1$. This result implies a sharp improvement to a similar inequality proved by Linial-Samorodnitsky-Wigderson in 2000, which was crucial to the analysis of their permanent approximation algorithm. Such inequalities have played an important role in the recent work on operator scaling and its generalizations and applications, and in fact we use our bound to construct a new scaling algorithm for real stable polynomials. In addition, we give a strong improvement on previous lower bounds of the capacity of a non-homogeneous real stable polynomial, depending only on the value of its gradient at $x = 1$. Crucially, this new bound is independent of the degree of the polynomial, and has singly exponential dependence on the number of variables. This compares favorably to the bounds used recently in the fantastic work of Karlin-Klein-Oveis Gharan to give an improved approximation factor for metric TSP, where this dependence is doubly exponential. Such bounds were conjectured to exist by the authors, and thus our new bound should imply further improvement to the approximation factor for metric TSP. The new technique we develop to prove this bound is productization, which says that any real stable polynomial can be approximated at any point in the positive orthant by a product of linear forms. Beyond the results of this paper, our main hope is that this new technique will allow us to avoid "frightening technicalities", in the words of Laurent and Schrijver, that often accompany combinatorial lower bounds.

Let $\mathbb Z/d\mathbb Z \wr \mathfrak S_n$ denote the wreath product of the cyclic group $\mathbb Z/d\mathbb Z$ with the symmetric group $\mathfrak S_n$. We define generating functions for monomial (induced one-dimensional) characters of $\mathbb Z/d\mathbb Z \wr \mathfrak S_n$ and express these in terms of determinants and permanents. This extends work of Littlewood ({\em The Theory of Group Characters and Representations of Groups}, 1940) and Merris and Watkins ({\em Linear Algebra Appl.}, {\bf 64}, 1985) on generating functions for the monomial characters of $\mathfrak S_n$.

Rigid graph theory is an active area with many open problems, especially regarding embeddings in $\mathbb{R}^d$ or other manifolds, and tight upper bounds on their number for a given number of vertices. Our premise is to relate the number of embeddings to that of solutions of a well-constrained algebraic system and exploit progress in the latter domain. In particular, the system's complex solutions naturally extend the notion of real embeddings, thus allowing us to employ bounds on complex roots. We focus on multihomogeneous B{é}zout (m-B{é}zout) bounds of algebraic systems since they are fast to compute and rather tight for systems exhibiting structure as in our case. We introduce two methods to relate such bounds to combinatorial properties of minimally rigid graphs in $\mathbb{C}^d$ and $S^d$. The first relates the number of graph orientations to the m-Bézout bound, while the second leverages a matrix permanent formulation. Using these approaches we improve the best known asymptotic upper bounds for planar graphs in dimension~3, and all minimally rigid graphs in dimension $d\geq 5$, both in the Euclidean and spherical case. Our computations indicate that m-Bézout bounds are tight for embeddings of planar graphs in $S^2$ and $\mathbb{C}^3$. We exploit Bernstein's second theorem on the exactness of mixed volume, and relate it to the m-B{é}zout bound by analyzing the associated Newton polytopes. We reduce the number of checks required to verify exactness by an exponential factor, and conjecture further that it suffices to check a linear instead of an exponential number of cases overall.