arXiv++ Combinatorics

Motivated by an application in community detection, we consider an \ER random graph conditioned on the rare event that all connected components are fully connected. Such graphs can be considered as partitions of vertices into cliques. Hence, this conditional distribution defines a distribution over partitions. We show that a popular community detection method is equivalent to Bayesian inference with this distribution as prior over the community partitions. Using tools from analytic combinatorics, we prove limit theorems for several graph observables in this conditional distribution: the number of cliques; the number of edges; and the degree distribution. We consider several regimes of the connection probability $p$ as the number of vertices $n$ diverges. For $p=\tfrac{1}{2}$, the conditioning yields the uniform distribution over set partitions, which is well-studied, but has not been studied as a graph distribution before. For $p<\tfrac{1}{2}$, we show that the number of cliques is of the order $n/\sqrt{\log n}$, while for $p>\tfrac{1}{2}$, we prove that the graph consists of a single clique with high probability. This shows that there is a phase transition at $p=\tfrac{1}{2}$. We additionally study the near-critical regime $p_n\downarrow\tfrac{1}{2}$, as well as the sparse regime $p_n\downarrow0$. Finally, we discuss the implications of these results for community detection.

In this paper we study $d$-dependent random graphs -- introduced by Brody and Sanchez -- which are the family of random graph distributions where each edge is present with probability $p$, and each edge is independent of all but at most $d$ other edges. For this random graph model, we analyze degree sequences, jumbledness, connectivity, and subgraph containment. Our results mirror those of the classical Erdős--Rényi random graph, which are recovered by specializing our problem to $d=0$, although we show that in many regards our setting is appreciably more nuanced. We survey what is known for this model and conclude with a variety of open questions.

Motivated by the community detection problem in Bayesian inference, as well as the recent explosion of interest in spin glasses from statistical physics, we study the classical Glauber dynamics for sampling from Ising models with sparse random interactions. It is now well-known that when the interaction matrix has spectral diameter less than $1$, Glauber dynamics mixes in $O(n\log n)$ steps. Unfortunately, such criteria fail dramatically for interactions supported on arguably the most well-studied sparse random graph: the Erdős--Rényi random graph $G(n,d/n)$, due to the presence of almost linearly many outlier eigenvalues of unbounded magnitude. We prove that for the \emph{Viana--Bray spin glass}, where the interactions are supported on $G(n,d/n)$ and randomly assigned $\pmβ$, Glauber dynamics mixes in $n^{1+o(1)}$ time with high probability as long as $β\le O(1/\sqrt{d})$, independent of $n$. We further extend our results to random graphs drawn according to the $2$-community stochastic block model, as well as when the interactions are given by a "centered" version of the adjacency matrix. The latter setting is particularly relevant for the inference problem in community detection. Indeed, we use this to show that Glauber dynamics succeeds at recovering communities in the stochastic block model in a companion paper [LMR+24]. The primary technical ingredient in our proof is showing that with high probability, a sparse random graph can be decomposed into two parts -- a \emph{bulk} which behaves like a graph with bounded maximum degree and a well-behaved spectrum, and a \emph{near-forest} with favorable pseudorandom properties. We then use this decomposition to design a localization procedure that interpolates to simpler Ising models supported only on the near-forest, and then execute a pathwise analysis to establish a modified log-Sobolev inequality.

We consider the question of how many edge-disjoint near-maximal cliques may be found in the dense Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$. Recently Acan and Kahn showed that the largest such family contains only $O(n^2/(\log{n})^3)$ cliques, with high probability, which disproved a conjecture of Alon and Spencer. We prove the corresponding lower bound, $Ω(n^2/(\log{n})^3)$, by considering a random graph process which sequentially selects and deletes near-maximal cliques. To analyse this process we use the Differential Equation Method. We also give a new proof of the upper bound $O(n^2/(\log{n})^3)$ and discuss the problem of the precise size of the largest such clique packing.

In their seminal paper introducing the theory of random graphs, Erdős and Rényi considered the evolution of the structure of a random subgraph of $K_n$ as the density increases from $0$ to $1$, identifying two key points in this evolution -- the \emph{percolation threshold}, where the order of the largest component seemingly jumps from logarithmic to linear in size, and the \emph{connectivity threshold}, where the subgraph becomes connected. Similar phenomena have been observed in many other random graph models, and in particular, works of Ajtai, Komlós and Szemerédi and of Spencer and Erdős determine corresponding thresholds for random subgraphs of the hypercube. We study similar questions on the \emph{permutahedron}. The permutahedron, like the hypercube, has many different equivalent representations, and arises as a natural object of study in many areas of combinatorics. In particular, as a highly-symmetric simple polytope, like the $n$-simplex and $n$-cube, this percolation model naturally generalises the Erdős-Rényi random graph and the percolated hypercube. We determine the percolation threshold and the connectivity threshold for random subgraphs of the permutahedron. Along the way we develop a novel graph exploration technique which can be used to find exponentially large clusters after percolation in high-dimensional geometric graphs and we initiate the study of the isoperimetric properties of the permutahedron.

We consider random simple temporal graphs in which every edge of the complete graph $K_n$ appears once within the time interval [0,1] independently and uniformly at random. Our main result is a sharp threshold on the size of any maximum $δ$-clique (namely a clique with edges appearing at most $δ$ apart within [0,1]) in random instances of this model, for any constant~$δ$. In particular, using the probabilistic method, we prove that the size of a maximum $δ$-clique is approximately $\frac{2\log{n}}{\log{\frac{1}δ}}$ with high probability (whp). What seems surprising is that, even though the random simple temporal graph contains $Θ(n^2)$ overlapping $δ$-windows, which (when viewed separately) correspond to different random instances of the Erdos-Renyi random graphs model, the size of the maximum $δ$-clique in the former model and the maximum clique size of the latter are approximately the same. Furthermore, we show that the minimum interval containing a $δ$-clique is $δ-o(δ)$ whp. We use this result to show that any polynomial time algorithm for $δ$-TEMPORAL CLIQUE is unlikely to have very large probability of success.

Let $N_{\triangle}(G)$ be the number of triangles in a graph $G$. In [14] and [25] (respectively) the following bounds were proved on the lower tail behaviour of triangle counts in the dense Erdős-Rényi random graphs $G_m\sim G(n,m)$: \[ \mathbb{P}\big(N_{\triangle}(G_m) \, < \, (1-δ)\mathbb{E}[N_{\triangle}(G_m)]\big) \,=\, \exp\left(-Θ\left(δ^2n^3\right)\right) \qquad \text{if $n^{-3/2}\ll δ\ll n^{-1}$} \] and \[ \mathbb{P}\big(N_{\triangle}(G_m) \, < \, (1-δ)\mathbb{E}[N_{\triangle}(G_m)]\big) \,=\, \exp\left(-Θ(δ^{2/3}n^2) \right) \qquad \text{if $n^{-3/4} \ll δ\ll 1$.} \] Neeman, Radin and Sadun [25] also conjectured that the probability should be of the form $\exp\left(-Θ\left(δ^2n^3\right)\right)$ in the "missing interval" $n^{-1}\ll δ\ll n^{-3/4}$. We prove this conjecture. As part of our proof we also prove that some random graph statistics, related to degrees and codegrees, are normally distributed with high probability.

In this paper we explore the connection between the ranks of the magnitude homology groups of a graph and the structure of its subgraphs. To this end, we introduce variants of magnitude homology called eulerian magnitude homology and discriminant magnitude homology. Leveraging the combinatorics of the differential in magnitude homology, we illustrate a close relationship between the ranks of the eulerian magnitude homology groups on the first diagonal and counts of subgraphs which fall in specific classes. We leverage these tools to study limiting behavior of the eulerian magnitude homology groups for Erdos-Renyi random graphs and random geometric graphs, producing for both models a vanishing threshold for the eulerian magnitude homology groups on the first diagonal. This in turn provides a characterization of the generators for the corresponding magnitude homology groups. Finally, we develop an explicit asymptotic estimate the expected rank of eulerian magnitude homology along the first diagonal for these random graph models.

In 1981, Karp and Sipser proved a law of large numbers for the matching number of a sparse Erdős-Rényi random graph, in an influential paper pioneering the so-called differential equation method for analysis of random graph processes. Strengthening this classical result, and answering a question of Aronson, Frieze and Pittel, we prove a central limit theorem in the same setting: the fluctuations in the matching number of a sparse random graph are asymptotically Gaussian. Our new contribution is to prove this central limit theorem in the subcritical and critical regimes, according to a celebrated algorithmic phase transition first observed by Karp and Sipser. Indeed, in the supercritical regime, a central limit theorem has recently been proved in the PhD thesis of Kreačić, using a stochastic generalisation of the differential equation method (comparing the so-called Karp-Sipser process to a system of stochastic differential equations). Our proof builds on these methods, and introduces new techniques to handle certain degeneracies present in the subcritical and critical cases. Curiously, our new techniques lead to a non-constructive result: we are able to characterise the fluctuations of the matching number around its mean, despite these fluctuations being much smaller than the error terms in our best estimates of the mean. We also prove a central limit theorem for the rank of the adjacency matrix of a sparse random graph.

As a first step towards a conjecture of Kahle and Newman, we prove that if $T_n$ is a random $2$-dimensional determinantal hypertree on $n$ vertices, then \[\frac{\dim H_1(T_n,\mathbb{F}_2)}{n^2}\] converges to zero in probability. Confirming a conjecture of Linial and Peled, we also prove the analogous statement for the $1$-out $2$-complex. Our proof relies on the large deviation principle for the Erdős-Rényi random graph by Chatterjee and Varadhan.

We study the typical structure of a sparse Erdős--Rényi random graph conditioned on the lower tail subgraph count event. We show that in certain regimes, a typical graph sampled from the conditional distribution resembles the entropy minimizer of the mean field approximation in the sense of both subgraph counts and cut norm. The main ingredients are an adaptation of an entropy increment scheme of Kozma and Samotij, and a new stability for the solution of the associated entropy variational problem. The proof can be interpreted as a structural application of the new probabilistic hypergraph container lemma for sparser than average sets, and suggests a more general framework for establishing such typical behavior statements.

We study the typical structure and the number of triangle-free graphs with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges where $m$ is large enough so that a typical triangle-free graph has a cut containing nearly all of its edges, but may not be bipartite. Erdős, Kleitman, and Rothschild showed that almost every triangle-free graph is bipartite. Osthus, Prömel, and Taraz later showed that for $m \ge (1+ε)\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$, almost every triangle-free graph on $n$ vertices and $m$ edges is bipartite. Here we give a precise characterization of the distribution of edges within each part of the max cut of a uniformly chosen triangle-free graph $G$ on $n$ vertices and $m$ edges, for a larger range of densities with $m=Θ(n^{3/2} \sqrt{\log n})$. Using this characterization, we describe the evolution of the structure of typical triangle-free graphs as the density changes. We show that as the number of edges decreases below $\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$, the following structural changes occur in $G$: -Isolated edges, then trees, then more complex subgraphs emerge as `defect edges', edges within parts of a max cut of $G$. The distribution of defect edges is first that of independent Erdős-Rényi random graphs, then that of independent exponential random graphs, conditioned on a small maximum degree and no triangles. -There is a sharp threshold for $3$-colorability at $m \sim \frac{\sqrt{2}}{4} n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$ and a sharp threshold between $4$-colorability and unbounded chromatic number at $m\sim\frac{1}{4}n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$. -Giant components emerge in the defect edges at $m\sim\frac{1}{4} n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n}$. We use these results to prove asymptotic formulas for the number of triangle-free graphs at these densities. We likewise prove analogous results for the random graph $G(n,p)$ conditioned on triangle-freeness.

A statistical-mechanical study of the effect of constraint relaxation on the minimum vertex cover problem in Erdős-Rényi random graphs is presented. Using a penalty-method formulation for constraint relaxation, typical properties of solutions, including infeasible solutions that violate the constraints, are analyzed by means of the replica method and cavity method. The problem involves a competition between reducing the number of vertices to be covered and satisfying the edge constraints. The analysis under the replica-symmetric (RS) ansatz clarifies that the competition leads to degeneracies in the vertex and edge states, which determine the quantitative properties of the system, such as the cover and penalty ratios. A precise analysis of these effects improves the accuracy of RS approximation for the minimum cover ratio in the replica symmetry breaking (RSB) region. Furthermore, the analysis based on the RS cavity method indicates that the RS/RSB boundary of the ground states with respect to the mean degree of the graphs is expanded, and the critical temperature is lowered by constraint relaxation.

The notion of spectrum for first-order properties introduced by J. Spencer for Erdos-Renyi random graph is considered in relation to random uniform hypergraphs. In this work we study the set of limit points of the spectrum for first-order formulae with bounded quantifier depth and obtain bounds for its maximum value. Moreover, we prove zero-one k-laws for the random uniform hypergraph and improve the bounds for the maximum value of the spectrum for first-order formulae with bounded quantifier depth. We obtain that the maximum value of the spectrum belongs to some two-element set.

The asymptotic behavior of the Jaccard index in $G(n,p)$, the classical Erdös-Rényi random graphs model, is studied in this paper, as $n$ goes to infinity. We first derive the asymptotic distribution of the Jaccard index of any pair of distinct vertices, as well as the first two moments of this index. Then the average of the Jaccard indices over all vertex pairs in $G(n,p)$ is shown to be asymptotically normal under an additional mild condition that $np\to\infty$ and $n^2(1-p)\to\infty$.

We determine the distribution of the sandpile group (also known as the Jacobian) of the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,q)$ along with its canonical duality pairing as $n$ tends to infinity, fully resolving a conjecture from 2015 due to Clancy, Leake, and Payne and generalizing the result by Wood on the groups. In particular, we show that a finite abelian $p$-group $G$ equipped with a perfect symmetric pairing $δ$ appears as the Sylow $p$-part of the sandpile group and its pairing with frequency inversely proportional to $|G||\mathrm{Aut}(G,δ)|$, where $\mathrm{Aut}(G,δ)$ is the set of automorphisms of $G$ preserving the pairing $δ$. While this distribution is related to the Cohen-Lenstra distribution, the two distributions are not the same on account of the additional algebraic data of the pairing. The proof utilizes the moment method: we first compute a complete set of moments for our random variable (the average number of epimorphisms from our random object to a fixed object in the category of interest) and then show the moments determine the distribution. To obtain the moments, we prove a universality result for the moments of cokernels of random symmetric integral matrices whose dual groups are equipped with symmetric pairings that is strong enough to handle both the dependence in the diagonal entries and the additional data of the pairing. We then apply results due to Sawin and Wood to show that these moments determine a unique distribution.

We consider the problem of finding a large clique in an Erdős--Rényi random graph where we are allowed unbounded computational time but can only query a limited number of edges. Recall that the largest clique in $G \sim G(n,1/2)$ has size roughly $2\log_{2} n$. Let $α_{\star}(δ,\ell)$ be the supremum over $α$ such that there exists an algorithm that makes $n^δ$ queries in total to the adjacency matrix of $G$, in a constant $\ell$ number of rounds, and outputs a clique of size $α\log_{2} n$ with high probability. We give improved upper bounds on $α_{\star}(δ,\ell)$ for every $δ\in [1,2)$ and $\ell \geq 3$. We also study analogous questions for finding subgraphs with density at least $η$ for a given $η$, and prove corresponding impossibility results.

Topological indices play a significant role in mathematical chemistry. Given a graph $\mathcal{G}$ with vertex set $\mathcal{V}=\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ and edge set $\mathcal{E}$, let $d_i$ be the degree of node $i$. The degree-based topological index is defined as $\mathcal{I}_n=$ $\sum_{\{i,j\}\in \mathcal{E}}f(d_i,d_j)$, where $f(x,y)$ is a symmetric function. In this paper, we investigate the asymptotic distribution of the degree-based topological indices of a heterogeneous Erdős-Rényi random graph. We show that after suitably centered and scaled, the topological indices converges in distribution to the standard normal distribution. Interestingly, we find that the general Randić index with $f(x,y)=(xy)^τ$ for a constant $τ$ exhibits a phase change at $τ=-\frac{1}{2}$.

The $m$-neighbor complex of a graph is the simplicial complex in which faces are sets of vertices with at least $m$ common neighbors. We consider these complexes for Erdos-Renyi random graphs and find that for certain explicit families of parameters the resulting complexes are with high probability $(t-1)$-dimensional with all $(t-2)$-faces and each $(t-1)$-face present with a fixed probability. Unlike the Linial-Meshulam measure on the same complexes there can be correlations between pairs of $(t-1)$-faces but we conjecture that the two measures converge in total variation for certain parameter sequences.

We investigate the number of maximal cliques, i.e., cliques that are not contained in any larger clique, in three network models: Erdős-Rényi random graphs, inhomogeneous random graphs (also called Chung-Lu graphs), and geometric inhomogeneous random graphs. For sparse and not-too-dense Erdős-Rényi graphs, we give linear and polynomial upper bounds on the number of maximal cliques. For the dense regime, we give super-polynomial and even exponential lower bounds. Although (geometric) inhomogeneous random graphs are sparse, we give super-polynomial lower bounds for these models. This comes from the fact that these graphs have a power-law degree distribution, which leads to a dense subgraph in which we find many maximal cliques. These lower bounds seem to contradict previous empirical evidence that (geometric) inhomogeneous random graphs have only few maximal cliques. We resolve this contradiction by providing experiments indicating that, even for large networks, the linear lower-order terms dominate, before the super-polynomial asymptotic behavior kicks in only for networks of extreme size.