arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given a graph $H$, the Ramsey number $r(H)$ is the smallest natural number $N$ such that any two-colouring of the edges of $K_N$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H$. The existence of these numbers has been known since 1930 but their quantitative behaviour is still not well understood. Even so, there has been a great deal of recent progress on the study of Ramsey numbers and their variants, spurred on by the many advances across extremal combinatorics. In this survey, we will describe some of this progress.

An edge (vertex) coloured graph is rainbow-connected if there is a rainbow path between any two vertices, i.e. a path all of whose edges (internal vertices) carry distinct colours. Rainbow edge (vertex) connectivity of a graph $G$ is the smallest number of colours needed for a rainbow edge (vertex) colouring of $G$. In this paper we propose a very simple approach to studying rainbow connectivity in graphs. Using this idea, we give a unified proof of several known results, as well as some new ones.

Given a family $\mathcal{F}$ of subsets of $[n]$, we say two sets $A, B \in \mathcal{F}$ are comparable if $A \subset B$ or $B \subset A$. Sperner's celebrated theorem gives the size of the largest family without any comparable pairs. This result was later generalised by Kleitman, who gave the minimum number of comparable pairs appearing in families of a given size. In this paper we study a complementary problem posed by Erdős and Daykin and Frankl in the early '80s. They asked for the maximum number of comparable pairs that can appear in a family of $m$ subsets of $[n]$, a quantity we denote by $c(n,m)$. We first resolve an old conjecture of Alon and Frankl, showing that $c(n,m) = o(m^2)$ when $m = n^{ω(1)} 2^{n/2}$. We also obtain more accurate bounds for $c(n,m)$ for sparse and dense families, characterise the extremal constructions for certain values of $m$, and sharpen some other known results.

Given a labeled graph $H$ with vertex set $\{1, 2,\ldots,n\}$, the ordered Ramsey number $r_<(H)$ is the minimum $N$ such that every two-coloring of the edges of the complete graph on $\{1, 2, \ldots,N\}$ contains a copy of $H$ with vertices appearing in the same order as in $H$. The ordered Ramsey number of a labeled graph $H$ is at least the Ramsey number $r(H)$ and the two coincide for complete graphs. However, we prove that even for matchings there are labelings where the ordered Ramsey number is superpolynomial in the number of vertices. Among other results, we also prove a general upper bound on ordered Ramsey numbers which implies that there exists a constant $c$ such that $r_<(H) \leq r(H)^{c \log^2 n}$ for any labeled graph $H$ on vertex set $\{1,2, \dots, n\}$.

A graph is Hamiltonian if it contains a cycle passing through every vertex exactly once. A celebrated theorem of Dirac from 1952 asserts that every graph on $n\ge 3$ vertices with minimum degree at least $n/2$ is Hamiltonian. We refer to such graphs as Dirac graphs. In this paper we obtain the following strengthening of this result. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, an {\em incompatibility system} $\mathcal{F}$ over $G$ is a family $\mathcal{F}=\{F_v\}_{v\in V}$ such that for every $v\in V$, the set $F_v$ is a set of unordered pairs $F_v \subseteq \{\{e,e'\}: e\ne e'\in E, e\cap e'=\{v\}\}$. An incompatibility system is {\em $Δ$-bounded} if for every vertex $v$ and an edge $e$ incident to $v$, there are at most $Δ$ pairs in $F_v$ containing $e$. We say that a cycle $C$ in $G$ is {\em compatible} with $\mathcal{F}$ if every pair of incident edges $e,e'$ of $C$ satisfies $\{e,e'\} \notin F_v$, where $v=e\cap e'$. This notion is partly motivated by a concept of transition systems defined by Kotzig in 1968, and can be viewed as a quantitative measure of robustness of graph properties. We prove that there is a constant $μ>0$ such that for every $μn$-bounded incompatibility system $\mathcal{F}$ over a Dirac graph $G$, there exists a Hamilton cycle compatible with $\mathcal{F}$. This settles in a very strong form, a conjecture of Häggkvist from 1988.

A graph is Hamiltonian if it contains a cycle passing through every vertex. One of the cornerstone results in the theory of random graphs asserts that for edge probability $p \gg \frac{\log n}{n}$, the random graph $G(n,p)$ is asymptotically almost surely Hamiltonian. We obtain the following strengthening of this result. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, an {\em incompatibility system} $\mathcal{F}$ over $G$ is a family $\mathcal{F}=\{F_v\}_{v\in V}$ where for every $v\in V$, the set $F_v$ is a set of unordered pairs $F_v \subseteq \{\{e,e'\}: e\ne e'\in E, e\cap e'=\{v\}\}$. An incompatibility system is {\em $Δ$-bounded} if for every vertex $v$ and an edge $e$ incident to $v$, there are at most $Δ$ pairs in $F_v$ containing $e$. We say that a cycle $C$ in $G$ is {\em compatible} with $\mathcal{F}$ if every pair of incident edges $e,e'$ of $C$ satisfies $\{e,e'\} \notin F_v$. This notion is partly motivated by a concept of transition systems defined by Kotzig in 1968, and can be used as a quantitative measure of robustness of graph properties. We prove that there is a constant $μ>0$ such that the random graph $G=G(n,p)$ with $p(n) \gg \frac{\log n}{n}$ is asymptotically almost surely such that for any $μnp$-bounded incompatibility system $\mathcal{F}$ over $G$, there is a Hamilton cycle in $G$ compatible with $\mathcal{F}$. We also prove that for larger edge probabilities $p(n)\gg \frac{\log^8n}{n}$, the parameter $μ$ can be taken to be any constant smaller than $1-\frac{1}{\sqrt 2}$. These results imply in particular that typically in $G(n,p)$ for $p \gg \frac{\log n}{n}$, for any edge-coloring in which each color appears at most $μnp$ times at each vertex, there exists a properly colored Hamilton cycle.

For a given graph $G$ of minimum degree at least $k$, let $G_p$ denote the random spanning subgraph of $G$ obtained by retaining each edge independently with probability $p=p(k)$. We prove that if $p \ge \frac{\log k + \log \log k + ω_k(1)}{k}$, where $ω_k(1)$ is any function tending to infinity with $k$, then $G_p$ asymptotically almost surely contains a cycle of length at least $k+1$. When we take $G$ to be the complete graph on $k+1$ vertices, our theorem coincides with the classic result on the threshold probability for the existence of a Hamilton cycle in the binomial random graph.

A classic theorem in combinatorial design theory is Fisher's inequality, which states that a family $\mathcal F$ of subsets of $[n]$ with all pairwise intersections of size $λ$ can have at most $n$ non-empty sets. One may weaken the condition by requiring that for every set in $\mathcal F$, all but at most $k$ of its pairwise intersections have size $λ$. We call such families $k$-almost $λ$-Fisher. Vu was the first to study the maximum size of such families, proving that for $k=1$ the largest family has $2n-2$ sets, and characterising when equality is attained. We substantially refine his result, showing how the size of the maximum family depends on $λ$. In particular we prove that for small $λ$ one essentially recovers Fisher's bound. We also solve the next open case of $k=2$ and obtain the first non-trivial upper bound for general $k$.

We consider problems about packing and counting Hamilton $\ell$-cycles in hypergraphs of large minimum degree. Given a hypergraph $\mathcal H$, for a $d$-subset $A\subseteq V(\mathcal H)$, we denote by $d_{\mathcal H}(A)$ the number of distinct \emph{edges} $f\in E(\mathcal H)$ for which $A\subseteq f$, and set $δ_d(\mathcal H)$ to be the minimum $d_{\mathcal H}(A)$ over all $A\subseteq V(\mathcal H)$ of size $d$. We show that if a $k$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices $\mathcal H$ satisfies $δ_{k-1}(\mathcal H)\geq αn$ for some $α>1/2$, then for every $\ell<k/2$ $\mathcal H$ contains $(1-o(1))^n\cdot n!\cdot \left(\fracα{\ell!(k-2\ell)!}\right)^{\frac{n}{k-\ell}}$ Hamilton $\ell$-cycles. The exponent above is easily seen to be optimal. In addition, we show that if $δ_{k-1}(\mathcal H)\geq αn$ for $α>1/2$, then $\mathcal H$ contains $f(α)n$ edge-disjoint Hamilton $\ell$-cycles for an explicit function $f(α)>0$. For the case where every $(k-1)$-tuple $X\subset V({\mathcal H})$ satisfies $d_{\mathcal H}(X)\in (α\pm o(1))n$, we show that $\mathcal H$ contains edge-disjoint Haimlton $\ell$-cycles which cover all but $o\left(|E(\mathcal H)|\right)$ edges of $\mathcal H$. As a tool we prove the following result which might be of independent interest: For a bipartite graph $G$ with both parts of size $n$, with minimum degree at least $δn$, where $δ>1/2$, and for $p=ω(\log n/n)$ the following holds. If $G$ contains an $r$-factor for $r=Θ(n)$, then by retaining edges of $G$ with probability $p$ independently at random, w.h.p the resulting graph contains a $(1-o(1))rp$-factor.

One of the most classical results in Ramsey theory is the theorem of Erdős and Szekeres from 1935, which says that every sequence of more than $k^2$ numbers contains a monotone subsequence of length $k+1$. We address the following natural question motivated by this result: Given integers $k$ and $n$ with $n \geq k^2+1$, how many monotone subsequences of length $k+1$ must every sequence of $n$ numbers contain? We answer this question precisely for all sufficiently large $k$ and $n \leq k^2 + c k^{3/2} / \log k$, where $c$ is some absolute positive constant.

The Hales--Jewett theorem is one of the pillars of Ramsey theory, from which many other results follow. A celebrated theorem of Shelah says that Hales--Jewett numbers are primitive recursive. A key tool used in his proof, now known as the cube lemma, has become famous in its own right. In its simplest form, this lemma says that if we color the edges of the Cartesian product $K_n \times K_n$ in $r$ colors then, for $n$ sufficiently large, there is a rectangle with both pairs of opposite edges receiving the same color. Shelah's proof shows that $n = r^{\binom{r+1}{2}} + 1$ suffices. More than twenty years ago, Graham, Rothschild and Spencer asked whether this bound can be improved to a polynomial in $r$. We show that this is not possible by providing a superpolynomial lower bound in $r$. We also discuss a number of related problems.

A classical theorem of Ghouila-Houri from 1960 asserts that every directed graph on $n$ vertices with minimum out-degree and in-degree at least $n/2$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. In this paper we extend this theorem to a random directed graph ${\mathcal D}(n,p)$, that is, a directed graph in which every ordered pair $(u,v)$ becomes an arc with probability $p$ independently of all other pairs. Motivated by the study of resilience of properties of random graphs, we prove that if $p \gg \log n/\sqrt{n}$, then a.a.s. every subdigraph of ${\mathcal D}(n,p)$ with minimum out-degree and in-degree at least $(1/2 + o(1)) n p$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. The constant $1/2$ is asymptotically best possible. Our result also strengthens classical results about the existence of directed Hamilton cycles in random directed graphs.

More than twenty years ago Erdős conjectured~\cite{E1} that a triangle-free graph $G$ of chromatic number $k \geq k_0(\varepsilon)$ contains cycles of at least $k^{2 - \varepsilon}$ different lengths as $k \rightarrow \infty$. In this paper, we prove the stronger fact that every triangle-free graph $G$ of chromatic number $k \geq k_0(\varepsilon)$ contains cycles of $(\frac{1}{64} - \varepsilon)k^2 \log k$ consecutive lengths, and a cycle of length at least $(\tfrac{1}{4} - \varepsilon)k^2 \log k$. As there exist triangle-free graphs of chromatic number $k$ with at most roughly $4k^2 \log k$ vertices for large $k$, theses results are tight up to a constant factor. We also give new lower bounds on the circumference and the number of different cycle lengths for $k$-chromatic graphs in other monotone classes, in particular, for $K_r$-free graphs and graphs without odd cycles $C_{2s+1}$.

Over 50 years ago, Erdős and Gallai conjectured that the edges of every graph on $n$ vertices can be decomposed into $O(n)$ cycles and edges. Among other results, Conlon, Fox and Sudakov recently proved that this holds for the random graph $G(n,p)$ with probability approaching 1 as $n\rightarrow\infty$. In this paper we show that for most edge probabilities $G(n,p)$ can be decomposed into a union of $\frac{n}{4}+\frac{np}{2}+o(n)$ cycles and edges whp. This result is asymptotically tight.

Fix positive integers $p$ and $q$ with $2 \leq q \leq {p \choose 2}$. An edge-coloring of the complete graph $K_n$ is said to be a $(p, q)$-coloring if every $K_p$ receives at least $q$ different colors. The function $f(n, p, q)$ is the minimum number of colors that are needed for $K_n$ to have a $(p,q)$-coloring. This function was introduced by Erdős and Shelah about 40 years ago, but Erdős and Gyárfás were the first to study the function in a systematic way. They proved that $f(n, p, p)$ is polynomial in $n$ and asked to determine the maximum $q$, depending on $p$, for which $f(n,p,q)$ is subpolynomial in $n$. We prove that the answer is $p-1$.

An $n$-by-$n$ bipartite graph is $H$-saturated if the addition of any missing edge between its two parts creates a new copy of $H$. In 1964, Erdős, Hajnal and Moon made a conjecture on the minimum number of edges in a $K_{s,s}$-saturated bipartite graph. This conjecture was proved independently by Wessel and Bollobás in a more general, but ordered, setting: they showed that the minimum number of edges in a $K_{(s,t)}$-saturated bipartite graph is $n^2-(n-s+1)(n-t+1)$, where $K_{(s,t)}$ is the "ordered" complete bipartite graph with $s$ vertices in the first color class and $t$ vertices in the second. However, the very natural question of determining the minimum number of edges in the unordered $K_{s,t}$-saturated case remained unsolved. This problem was considered recently by Moshkovitz and Shapira who also conjectured what its answer should be. In this short paper we give an asymptotically tight bound on the minimum number of edges in a $K_{s,t}$-saturated bipartite graph, which is only smaller by an additive constant than the conjecture of Moshkovitz and Shapira. We also prove their conjecture for $K_{2,3}$-saturation, which was the first open case.

In this note, we answer the following question of Foucaud, Krivelevich and Perarnau. What is the size of the largest $K_{r,s}$-free subgraph one can guarantee in every graph $G$ with $m$ edges? We also discuss the analogous problem for hypergraphs.

The celebrated Erdős-Ko-Rado theorem shows that for $n \ge 2k$ the largest intersecting $k$-uniform set family on $[n]$ has size $\binom{n-1}{k-1}$. It is natural to ask how far from intersecting larger set families must be. Katona, Katona and Katona introduced the notion of most probably intersecting families, which maximise the probability of random subfamilies being intersecting. We study the most probably intersecting problem for $k$-uniform set families. We provide a rough structural characterisation of the most probably intersecting families and, for families of particular sizes, show that the initial segment of the lexicographic order is optimal.

Let $i_t(G)$ be the number of independent sets of size $t$ in a graph $G$. Engbers and Galvin asked how large $i_t(G)$ could be in graphs with minimum degree at least $δ$. They further conjectured that when $n\geq 2δ$ and $t\geq 3$, $i_t(G)$ is maximized by the complete bipartite graph $K_{δ, n-δ}$. This conjecture has drawn the attention of many researchers recently. In this short note, we prove this conjecture.

In the 1960s, Erdős and Gallai conjectured that the edge set of every graph on n vertices can be partitioned into O(n) cycles and edges. They observed that one can easily get an O(n log n) upper bound by repeatedly removing the edges of the longest cycle. We make the first progress on this problem, showing that O(n log log n) cycles and edges suffice. We also prove the Erdős-Gallai conjecture for random graphs and for graphs with linear minimum degree.